Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9905050 · Physical Review A

Fundamental limit on “interaction-free” measurements

Steven H. Simon, P. M. Platzman

Published Apr 3, 2000• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In ``interaction-free'' measurements, one typically wants to detect the presence of an object without touching it with even a single photon. One often imagines a bomb whose trigger is an extremely sensitive measuring device whose presence we would like to detect without triggering it. We point out that all such measuring devices have a maximum sensitivity set by the uncertainty principle, and thus can only determine whether a measurement is ``interaction-free'' to within a finite minimum resolution. We further discuss exactly what can be achieved with the proposed ``interaction-free'' measurement schemes.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.61.052103

Related papers

Experimental demonstration of interaction-free measurements

Paul G. Kwiat, Harald Weinfurter, Anton Zeilinger

It is now well-understood that the complementary wave- and particle-like natures of quanta enable one to make measurements that are “interaction-free” -- one can determine the presence or absence of an object, even a completely absorbing object, without any photons being absorbed. The first proposal of such a scheme was limited to an efficiency of 50% -- at most half of the measurements could be interaction free [1]. By using an application of the Quantum Zeno effect, one can in fact have the fraction of interaction-free measurements arbitrarily close to one [2].

•Jul 14, 1996•0 citations

Interaction-Free Measurement

Paul G. Kwiat, Harald Weinfurter, Thomas Herzog +2 more

We show that one can ascertain the presence of an object in some sense without interacting with it. One repeatedly, but weakly, tests for the presence of the object, which would inhibit an otherwise coherent evolution of the interrogating photon. The fraction of ``interaction-free'' measurements can be arbitrarily close to 1. Using single photons in a Michelson interferometer, we have performed a preliminary demonstration of some of these ideas.

Physical Review Letters•Jun 12, 1995•581 citations

"Interaction-free" quantum measurements

Andrew G. White, Paul G. Kwiat, Olaf Nairz +2 more

Summary form only given.Using the complementary wave-like and particle-like natures of photons, one can make interaction-free measurements (IFM)-the presence of an object can be determined with no photons being absorbed. By using an application of the quantum Zeno effect (weakly and repeatedly testing for the object's presence so that the otherwise coherent evolution of the interrogating photon is inhibited), we have demonstrated the feasibility of IFMs with an efficiency of >85%, higher than that possible in the original IFM scheme, where, at most, half of the measurements could be interaction free. We also investigate various interaction-free imaging systems, demonstrate imaging with a resolution <5 /spl mu/m, and define the limits to these systems. We also discuss in which sense interaction-free measurements really are not.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 1998•10 citations

'Interaction-free' measurement: possibilities and limitations

Sergey P. Vyatchanin, Farit Ya. Khalili

The so-called 'interaction-free' measurement is a very interesting quantum effect that allows discovering the presence of an opaque object in a given spatial domain, with the probability that the object absorbs a photon being, in principle, as low as desired. This probability is bounded from below only by a value of the order of 1/ωτ, where ω is the frequency of light and τ is the measurement time. This corresponds to the average absorbed energy of the order of /τ. The 'interaction-free' technique can also be used to measure the coordinate of an object but only under the condition that the object is prepared in a special 'discretized' quantum state. Such is, for instance, the state of a ponderomotive meter of electromagnetic energy, which, in principle, enables the interaction-free' measurement of the energy contained in an electromagnetic cavity. Estimations show that with modern experimental equipment and with the help of 'interaction-free' measurement, single atoms can be registered inside optical cavities.

Physics-Uspekhi•Jul 31, 2004•8 citations

Interaction-Free Measurements

Z. Ficek, Mohamed Ridza Wahiddin

The Penrose bomb testing problem I am greatly indebted to Roger Penrose.I have learned very much from his papers, from his exciting books, and from our (too short) conversations.I am most grateful to Roger for developing the idea of Avshalom Elitzur and myself on interaction-free measurements (IFM).The version of IFM Penrose described in his book (1994) is conceptually different from our original proposal, and although it is much more difficult for practical applications it has the advantage of demonstrating even more striking quantum phenomena.So I will start with presenting Pen rose's version of IFM.Suppose we have a pile of bombs equipped with super-sensitive triggers.The good bombs have a tiny mirror which is connected to a detonator such that if any particle (photon) "touches" the mirror, the mirror bounces and the bomb explodes.Some of the bombs are duds in which the mirror is rigidly connected to the massive body of the bomb.Classically, the only way to verify that a bomb is good is to touch the mirror, but then a good bomb will explode.Our task is to test a bomb without exploding it.We are not allowed to make errors in our test, i.e., to say that a bomb is good while it is a dud, but we may sometimes cause an explosion.There cannot be a solution by weighting the bomb, or touching the mirror from the side, or any other similar way: the only observable physical difference between a good bomb and a dud is that the good bomb will explode when a single particle will touch the mirror, and the dud will not.Thus, the solution of this task seems to be logically impossible: the only difference between the bombs is that one explodes and the other does not and we are asked to test a bomb without exploding it.Nevertheless, quantum mechanics provides a solution to the problem in a surprisingly simple way.The method uses the well known Mach-Zehnder interferometer which is shown in Fig. 1.The photons reach the first beam splitter which has transmission coefficient 1/2.The transmitted and reflected parts of their waves are then reflected by two mirrors and finally reunite at another similar beam splitter.Two detectors collect the photons after they pass through the second beam splitter.It is possible to arrange the positions of the beam splitters and the mirrors in such a

•Apr 19, 2016•1 citation

Experimental realization of interaction-free measurements

Harald Weinfurter, Paul G. Kwiat, Thomas Herzog +2 more

Recently, it has been pointed out that it is possible to make a quantum-mechanical interaction-free measurement (IFM), in which the existence of an object in a given region of space may be determined seemingly without interacting with it.1,2 In the embodiment first proposed by Elitzur and Vaidman,3 a standard Michelson interferometer is aligned so that incident single photons (obtained in our experiment by using parametric downconversion; see Fig. 1) must exit by the same port in which they entered, in the absence of any object within the interferometer. The presence of an object (e.g., the mirror leading to detector DB) in one of the arms completely changes the possible outcomes because the constructive interference is interrupted. Now it is possible that the photon will exit from the other exit port, to detector DIfm. By detecting the photon in this case, one can claim with certainty that an object was within the interferometer, even though the photon could not have interacted with it. If the beam splitter has a very low reflectivity, then the fraction of IFMs approaches 1/2.

Quantum Electronics and Laser Science Conference•May 22, 1995•8 citations
In interaction-free'' measurements, one typically wants to detect the presence of an object without touching it with even a single photon. One often imagines a bomb whose trigger is an extremely sensitive measuring device whose presence we would like to detect without triggering it. We point out that all such measuring devices have a maximum sensitivity set by the uncertainty principle, and thus can only determine whether a measurement is interaction-free'' to within a finite minimum resolution. We further discuss exactly what can be achieved with the proposed ``interaction-free'' measurement schemes.
It is now well-understood that the complementary wave- and particle-like natures of quanta enable one to make measurements that are “interaction-free” -- one can determine the presence or absence of an object, even a completely absorbing object, without any photons being absorbed. The first proposal of such a scheme was limited to an efficiency of 50% -- at most half of the measurements could be interaction free [1]. By using an application of the Quantum Zeno effect, one can in fact have the fraction of interaction-free measurements arbitrarily close to one [2].
Summary form only given.Using the complementary wave-like and particle-like natures of photons, one can make interaction-free measurements (IFM)-the presence of an object can be determined with no photons being absorbed. By using an application of the quantum Zeno effect (weakly and repeatedly testing for the object's presence so that the otherwise coherent evolution of the interrogating photon is inhibited), we have demonstrated the feasibility of IFMs with an efficiency of >85%, higher than that possible in the original IFM scheme, where, at most, half of the measurements could be interaction free. We also investigate various interaction-free imaging systems, demonstrate imaging with a resolution <5 /spl mu/m, and define the limits to these systems. We also discuss in which sense interaction-free measurements really are not.
The so-called 'interaction-free' measurement is a very interesting quantum effect that allows discovering the presence of an opaque object in a given spatial domain, with the probability that the object absorbs a photon being, in principle, as low as desired. This probability is bounded from below only by a value of the order of 1/ωτ, where ω is the frequency of light and τ is the measurement time. This corresponds to the average absorbed energy of the order of /τ. The 'interaction-free' technique can also be used to measure the coordinate of an object but only under the condition that the object is prepared in a special 'discretized' quantum state. Such is, for instance, the state of a ponderomotive meter of electromagnetic energy, which, in principle, enables the interaction-free' measurement of the energy contained in an electromagnetic cavity. Estimations show that with modern experimental equipment and with the help of 'interaction-free' measurement, single atoms can be registered inside optical cavities.
The Penrose bomb testing problem I am greatly indebted to Roger Penrose.I have learned very much from his papers, from his exciting books, and from our (too short) conversations.I am most grateful to Roger for developing the idea of Avshalom Elitzur and myself on interaction-free measurements (IFM).The version of IFM Penrose described in his book (1994) is conceptually different from our original proposal, and although it is much more difficult for practical applications it has the advantage of demonstrating even more striking quantum phenomena.So I will start with presenting Pen rose's version of IFM.Suppose we have a pile of bombs equipped with super-sensitive triggers.The good bombs have a tiny mirror which is connected to a detonator such that if any particle (photon) "touches" the mirror, the mirror bounces and the bomb explodes.Some of the bombs are duds in which the mirror is rigidly connected to the massive body of the bomb.Classically, the only way to verify that a bomb is good is to touch the mirror, but then a good bomb will explode.Our task is to test a bomb without exploding it.We are not allowed to make errors in our test, i.e., to say that a bomb is good while it is a dud, but we may sometimes cause an explosion.There cannot be a solution by weighting the bomb, or touching the mirror from the side, or any other similar way: the only observable physical difference between a good bomb and a dud is that the good bomb will explode when a single particle will touch the mirror, and the dud will not.Thus, the solution of this task seems to be logically impossible: the only difference between the bombs is that one explodes and the other does not and we are asked to test a bomb without exploding it.Nevertheless, quantum mechanics provides a solution to the problem in a surprisingly simple way.The method uses the well known Mach-Zehnder interferometer which is shown in Fig. 1.The photons reach the first beam splitter which has transmission coefficient 1/2.The transmitted and reflected parts of their waves are then reflected by two mirrors and finally reunite at another similar beam splitter.Two detectors collect the photons after they pass through the second beam splitter.It is possible to arrange the positions of the beam splitters and the mirrors in such a
Recently, it has been pointed out that it is possible to make a quantum-mechanical interaction-free measurement (IFM), in which the existence of an object in a given region of space may be determined seemingly without interacting with it.1,2 In the embodiment first proposed by Elitzur and Vaidman,3 a standard Michelson interferometer is aligned so that incident single photons (obtained in our experiment by using parametric downconversion; see Fig. 1) must exit by the same port in which they entered, in the absence of any object within the interferometer. The presence of an object (e.g., the mirror leading to detector DB) in one of the arms completely changes the possible outcomes because the constructive interference is interrupted. Now it is possible that the photon will exit from the other exit port, to detector DIfm. By detecting the photon in this case, one can claim with certainty that an object was within the interferometer, even though the photon could not have interacted with it. If the beam splitter has a very low reflectivity, then the fraction of IFMs approaches 1/2.