Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9902056

Nonlocality without inequalities using unambiguous discrimination between non-orthogonal states

Adan Cabello, Jose Luis Cereceda

Published Feb 15, 1999• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A nonlocality without inequalities proof for bipartite twolevel pure states using unambiguous discrimination between non-orthogonal states, following the method of Barnett and Chefles (Los Alamos e-print archive, quant-ph/9807090), is provided.Unlike Barnett and Chefles', our proof has Hardy's [Phys.Rev. Lett.71, 1665 (1993)] as a limit.Moreover, this new proof gives a higher probability of contradiction with local realism than Hardy's and Barnett and Chefles'.The maximum effective probability of violation of local realism is 8% for maximally entangled states, and 10% for entangled but not maximally entangled states.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/9902056

Related papers

Nonlocality without inequalities has not been proved for maximally entangled states

Adán Cabello

Two approaches to extend Hardy's proof of nonlocality without inequalities to maximally entangled states of bipartite two-level systems are shown to fail. On one hand, it is shown that the proof of Wu and co-workers [Phys. Rev. A 53, R1927 (1996)] uses an effective state which is not maximally entangled. On the other hand, it is demonstrated that Hardy's proof cannot be generalized by the replacement of one of the four von Neumann measurements involved in the original proof by a generalized measurement to unambiguously discriminate between nonorthogonal states.

arXiv:quant-ph/9911023•Physical Review A•Jan 18, 2000•8 citations

Chain of Hardy-type local reality constraints for n qubits

Sibasish Ghosh A, Shasanka Mohan Roy

Nonlocality without inequality is an elegant argument introduced by Hardy for two qubit systems, and later generalised to n qubits, to establish contradiction of quantum theory with local realism. Interestingly, for n = 2 this argument is actually a corollary of Bell-type inequalities, viz., the CH–Hardy inequality involving Bell correlations, but for n greater than two it involves n-particle probabilities more general than Bell-correlations. In this paper, we first derive a chain of completely new local realistic inequalities involving joint probabilities for n qubits and then associated with each such inequality, we provide a new Hardy-type local reality constraint without inequalities. Quantum mechanical maximal violations of the chain of inequalities and of the associated constraints are also studied by deriving appropriate Cirel'son-type theorems. These results involving joint probabilities more general than Bell correlations are expected to provide a new systematic tool to investigate entanglement.

arXiv:1007.4649•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2010•4 citations

Ladder proof of nonlocality without inequalities and without probabilities

Adán Cabello

The ladder proof of nonlocality without inequalities for two spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ particles proposed by Hardy [in New Developments on Fundamental Problems in Quantum Physics, edited by M. Ferrero and A. van der Merwe (Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1997)] and Hardy and co-workers [Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 2755 (1997)] works only for nonmaximally entangled states and goes through for 50% of pairs at the most. A similar ladder proof for two spin-$1$ particles in a maximally entangled state is presented. In its simplest form, the proof goes through for 17% of pairs. An extended version works for 100% of pairs. The proof can be extended to any maximally entangled state of two spin-$s$ particles (with $s>~1)$.

arXiv:quant-ph/9712055•Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1998•20 citations

Nonlocality without inequalities for almost all entangled states for two particles

Sheldon Goldstein

We provide a streamlined proof of Hardy's theorem, that almost every entangled state for a pair of quantum particles admits a ``proof of nonlocality'' without inequalities. Moreover, our analysis covers a larger class of observables. Thus we also strengthen Hardy's assertion that the argument fails for maximally entangled states, such as the singlet state. At the same time, we formulate the argument in such a manner that the relations which must be satisfied for local hidden variables are entirely deterministic, making no reference whatsoever to probability, let alone probablistic inequalities.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 28, 1994•128 citations

sComment on 'Local-realism violations in two-particle interferometry'

Jose Luis Cereceda

In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 53, R1927 (1996)] Wu et al. give a proof of nonlocality for the maximally entangled state of two particles without using inequalities. Here we point out that in order for their argument to go through it is necessary to consider a minimum total of six dimensions in Hilbert space. Indeed, the above argument is found to fail whenever the dimensionality of the product Hilbert space is reduced to four. The explanation for this failure is provided by the fact according to which no direct contradiction between the quantum-mechanical and locally realistic predictions can arise for any fraction of an ensemble of 2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2 systems configured in the maximally entangled state.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1997•3 citations

Towards an equivalence between maximal entanglement and maximal quantum nonlocality

Victoria Lipińska, Florian J. Curchod, Alejandro Máttar +1 more

While all bipartite pure entangled states are known to generate correlations violating a Bell inequality, and are therefore nonlocal, the quantitative relation between pure state entanglement and nonlocality is poorly understood. In fact, some Bell inequalities are maximally violated by non-maximally entangled states and this phenomenon is also observed for other operational measures of nonlocality. In this work, we study a recently proposed measure of nonlocality defined as the probability that a pure state displays nonlocal correlations when subjected to random measurements. We first prove that this measure satisfies some natural properties for an operational measure of nonlocality. Then, we show that for pure states of two qubits the measure is monotonic with entanglement for all correlation two-outcome Bell inequalities: for all these inequalities, the more the state is entangled, the larger the probability to violate them when random measurements are performed. Finally, we extend our results to the multipartite setting.

arXiv:1802.09982•New Journal of Physics•Jun 4, 2018•27 citations
A nonlocality without inequalities proof for bipartite twolevel pure states using unambiguous discrimination between non-orthogonal states, following the method of Barnett and Chefles (Los Alamos e-print archive, quant-ph/9807090), is provided.Unlike Barnett and Chefles', our proof has Hardy's [Phys.Rev. Lett.71, 1665 (1993)] as a limit.Moreover, this new proof gives a higher probability of contradiction with local realism than Hardy's and Barnett and Chefles'.The maximum effective probability of violation of local realism is 8% for maximally entangled states, and 10% for entangled but not maximally entangled states.
Two approaches to extend Hardy's proof of nonlocality without inequalities to maximally entangled states of bipartite two-level systems are shown to fail. On one hand, it is shown that the proof of Wu and co-workers [Phys. Rev. A 53, R1927 (1996)] uses an effective state which is not maximally entangled. On the other hand, it is demonstrated that Hardy's proof cannot be generalized by the replacement of one of the four von Neumann measurements involved in the original proof by a generalized measurement to unambiguously discriminate between nonorthogonal states.
Nonlocality without inequality is an elegant argument introduced by Hardy for two qubit systems, and later generalised to n qubits, to establish contradiction of quantum theory with local realism. Interestingly, for n = 2 this argument is actually a corollary of Bell-type inequalities, viz., the CH–Hardy inequality involving Bell correlations, but for n greater than two it involves n-particle probabilities more general than Bell-correlations. In this paper, we first derive a chain of completely new local realistic inequalities involving joint probabilities for n qubits and then associated with each such inequality, we provide a new Hardy-type local reality constraint without inequalities. Quantum mechanical maximal violations of the chain of inequalities and of the associated constraints are also studied by deriving appropriate Cirel'son-type theorems. These results involving joint probabilities more general than Bell correlations are expected to provide a new systematic tool to investigate entanglement.
The ladder proof of nonlocality without inequalities for two spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ particles proposed by Hardy [in New Developments on Fundamental Problems in Quantum Physics, edited by M. Ferrero and A. van der Merwe (Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1997)] and Hardy and co-workers [Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 2755 (1997)] works only for nonmaximally entangled states and goes through for 50% of pairs at the most. A similar ladder proof for two spin-111 particles in a maximally entangled state is presented. In its simplest form, the proof goes through for 17% of pairs. An extended version works for 100% of pairs. The proof can be extended to any maximally entangled state of two spin-sss particles (with s> 1)s>~1)s> 1).
We provide a streamlined proof of Hardy's theorem, that almost every entangled state for a pair of quantum particles admits a ``proof of nonlocality'' without inequalities. Moreover, our analysis covers a larger class of observables. Thus we also strengthen Hardy's assertion that the argument fails for maximally entangled states, such as the singlet state. At the same time, we formulate the argument in such a manner that the relations which must be satisfied for local hidden variables are entirely deterministic, making no reference whatsoever to probability, let alone probablistic inequalities.
In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 53, R1927 (1996)] Wu et al. give a proof of nonlocality for the maximally entangled state of two particles without using inequalities. Here we point out that in order for their argument to go through it is necessary to consider a minimum total of six dimensions in Hilbert space. Indeed, the above argument is found to fail whenever the dimensionality of the product Hilbert space is reduced to four. The explanation for this failure is provided by the fact according to which no direct contradiction between the quantum-mechanical and locally realistic predictions can arise for any fraction of an ensemble of 2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2 systems configured in the maximally entangled state.
While all bipartite pure entangled states are known to generate correlations violating a Bell inequality, and are therefore nonlocal, the quantitative relation between pure state entanglement and nonlocality is poorly understood. In fact, some Bell inequalities are maximally violated by non-maximally entangled states and this phenomenon is also observed for other operational measures of nonlocality. In this work, we study a recently proposed measure of nonlocality defined as the probability that a pure state displays nonlocal correlations when subjected to random measurements. We first prove that this measure satisfies some natural properties for an operational measure of nonlocality. Then, we show that for pure states of two qubits the measure is monotonic with entanglement for all correlation two-outcome Bell inequalities: for all these inequalities, the more the state is entangled, the larger the probability to violate them when random measurements are performed. Finally, we extend our results to the multipartite setting.