Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9811071

An Alternative Commutation Relation Between Position and Momentum Operators of Massless Particles

H. Razmi

Published Nov 25, 1998• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It seems that the problem of finding a suitable position operator for photon has been solved in a recently published work which is based on a new commutation relation between position and momentum operators of massless particles[1]. Although the authors of [1] have presented a classical reasoning in favour of the new commutator,here we are going to find this new commutator based on a quantum mechanical argument.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/9811071

Related papers

A Comment on the "Photon position operator with commuting components" by Margaret Hawton

Arkadiusz Jadczyk, Agnieszka Matylda Schlichtinger

We show that the position operator with commuting components proposed by M. Hawton [M. Hawton, Phys. Rev. A {\bf 59}, 954 (1999)] and developed in subsequent papers, including the recent ones, does not have the properties required for a photon position operator. Depending on the exact interpretation of the results it either concerns a triplet of massless spin zero particles rather than the photon, or does not have the required covariance properties under space rotations.

arXiv:2203.14555•Mar 28, 2022•3 citations

The commutation relations

Keith Hannabuss

Abstract Our results so far, in particular Section 3.4, strongly suggest that although it is possible to find formalisms in which either momentum or position are easy to handle, one cannot simultaneously manage both. The underlying reason for this is that the operators P and X do not commute.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 20, 1997•1 citation

LOCALIZATION OF MASSLESS SPINNING PARTICLES AND THE BERRY PHASE

B.-S. Skagerstam

The components of the position operator, at a fixed time, for a massless and spinning particle with given helicity $λ$ described in terms of bosonic degrees of freedom have an anomalous commutator proportional to $λ$. The position operator generates translations in momentum space. We show that a ray-representation for these translations emerges due to the non-commuting components of the position operators and relate this to the Berry-phase for photons. The Tomita-Chiao experiment then gives support for this relativistic and quantum mechanical description of photons in terms of non-commuting position operators.

arXiv:hep-th/9210054•WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 1, 1994•41 citations

Some general commutation rules and identities for three-dimensional quantum-mechanical operators

Edgardo T. García Alvarez, Alejandro D. González

A general proof of several formulas used in three-dimensional quantum problems is presented. By considering the two vector operators A and B having Cartesian components that satisfy the canonical commutation relations—as the position and momentum operators do—we obtain commutation rules and relations for the projection onto each another. All of these rules and relations have symmetry under A↔B exchange. This symmetry suggests, in the particular case of position and momentum operators, a new operator, the projection of r onto p, which seems to be useful in dissipative quantum problems.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1989•0 citations

MOMENTUM OPERATORS IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

A. M. Arthurs

Representation for real functions of quantum mechanical momentum operator obtained by functional integration in phase space

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Aug 1, 1968•9 citations

Zero curvature is a necessary and sufficient condition for a spin-orbital decomposition

Eric Palmerduca, Hong Qin

There has been an extended debate regarding the existence of a spin-orbital decomposition of the angular momentum of photons and other massless particles. It was recently shown that there are both geometric and topological obstructions preventing any such decomposition. Here we show that any geometric connection on a particle's state space induces a splitting of the angular momentum into two operators. These operators are well-defined angular momentum operators if and only if the connection has zero curvature. Massive particles have two canonical curved connections corresponding to boosts and rotations, respectively. These can be uniquely combined to produce a flat connection, and this gives a novel derivation of the Newton-Wigner position operator and the corresponding spin and orbital angular momenta for relativistic massive particles. When the mass is taken to zero, transverse boosts and rotations degenerate, leaving only a single connection for massless particles. This connection produces a commonly proposed splitting of the massless angular momentum into two operators. However, the connection is not flat, explaining why these operators do not satisfy the angular momentum commutation relations and are thus not true spin and orbital angular momentum operators.

arXiv:2505.00178•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jun 6, 2025•3 citations
It seems that the problem of finding a suitable position operator for photon has been solved in a recently published work which is based on a new commutation relation between position and momentum operators of massless particles[1]. Although the authors of [1] have presented a classical reasoning in favour of the new commutator,here we are going to find this new commutator based on a quantum mechanical argument.
The components of the position operator, at a fixed time, for a massless and spinning particle with given helicity λλλ described in terms of bosonic degrees of freedom have an anomalous commutator proportional to λλλ. The position operator generates translations in momentum space. We show that a ray-representation for these translations emerges due to the non-commuting components of the position operators and relate this to the Berry-phase for photons. The Tomita-Chiao experiment then gives support for this relativistic and quantum mechanical description of photons in terms of non-commuting position operators.
A general proof of several formulas used in three-dimensional quantum problems is presented. By considering the two vector operators A and B having Cartesian components that satisfy the canonical commutation relations—as the position and momentum operators do—we obtain commutation rules and relations for the projection onto each another. All of these rules and relations have symmetry under A↔B exchange. This symmetry suggests, in the particular case of position and momentum operators, a new operator, the projection of r onto p, which seems to be useful in dissipative quantum problems.
There has been an extended debate regarding the existence of a spin-orbital decomposition of the angular momentum of photons and other massless particles. It was recently shown that there are both geometric and topological obstructions preventing any such decomposition. Here we show that any geometric connection on a particle's state space induces a splitting of the angular momentum into two operators. These operators are well-defined angular momentum operators if and only if the connection has zero curvature. Massive particles have two canonical curved connections corresponding to boosts and rotations, respectively. These can be uniquely combined to produce a flat connection, and this gives a novel derivation of the Newton-Wigner position operator and the corresponding spin and orbital angular momenta for relativistic massive particles. When the mass is taken to zero, transverse boosts and rotations degenerate, leaving only a single connection for massless particles. This connection produces a commonly proposed splitting of the massless angular momentum into two operators. However, the connection is not flat, explaining why these operators do not satisfy the angular momentum commutation relations and are thus not true spin and orbital angular momentum operators.