Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9804018 · Physical Review Letters

Quantum Limitations on Superluminal Propagation

Yakir Aharonov, Benni Reznik, Ady Stern

Published Sep 14, 1998• 58 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Unstable systems such as media with inverted atomic population have been shown to allow the propagation of analytic wave packets with group velocity faster than that of light, without violating causality. We illuminate the important role played by unstable modes in this propagation and show that the quantum fluctuations of these modes and their unitary time evolution impose severe restrictions on the observation of superluminal phenomena.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.81.2190

Related papers

Superluminal (but causal) propagation of wave packets in transparent media with inverted atomic populations

R. Y. Chiao

The propagation of limited-bandwidth signals, such as Gaussian wave packets, tuned to a transparent spectral region far below the resonance of an inverted two-level atomic medium, can be superluminal, i.e., with phase, group, and energy velocities all exceeding the vacuum speed of light c. Causality is not violated, however. Little distortion and gain can accompany this propagation.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1993•249 citations

Fast light in atomic media

A. M. Akulshin, Russell McLean

Atomic media have played a major role in studies of fast light. One of their attractive features is the ability to manipulate experimental parameters to control the dispersive properties that determine the group velocity of a propagating light pulse. We give an overview of the experimental methods, based on both linear and nonlinear atom-light interaction, that have produced superluminal propagation in atomic media, and discuss some of the significant theoretical contributions to the issues of pulse preservation and reconciling faster-than-light propagation and the principle of causality. The comparison of storage of light, enhanced Kerr nonlinearity and efficient wave mixing processes in slow and fast light atomic media illustrates their common and distinct features.

Journal of Optics•Sep 24, 2010•69 citations

Optical pulse propagation at abnormal group velocities through transparent inverted-population media

Eric L. Bolda, R. Y. Chiao, J. C. Garrison

We show that, in a medium with an inverted population, waves with frequencies outside the gain band will propagate with abnormal (i.e. superluminal or negative) group velocities.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1993•0 citations

Quantum noise and superluminal propagation

Bilha Segev, Peter W. Milonni, J. F. Babb +1 more

Causal ``superluminal'' effects have recently been observed and discussed in various contexts. The question arises whether such effects could be observed with extremely weak pulses, and what would prevent the observation of an ``optical tachyon.'' Aharonov, Reznik, and Stern (ARS) [Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 2190 (1998)] have argued that quantum noise will preclude the observation of a superluminal group velocity when the pulse consists of one or a few photons. In this paper we reconsider this question both in a general framework and in the specific example, suggested by Chiao, Kozhekin, and Kurizki (CKK) [Phys. Rev. 77, 1254 (1996)], of off-resonant, short-pulse propagation in an optical amplifier. We derive in the case of the amplifier a signal-to-noise ratio that is consistent with the general ARS conclusions when we impose their criteria for distinguishing between superluminal propagation and propagation at the speed c. However, results consistent with the semiclassical arguments of CKK are obtained if weaker criteria are imposed, in which case the signal can exceed the noise without being ``exponentially large.'' We show that the quantum fluctuations of the field considered by ARS are closely related to superfluorescence noise. More generally, we consider the implications of unitarity for superluminal propagation and quantum noise and study, in addition to the complete and truncated wave packets considered by ARS, the residual wave packet formed by their difference. This leads to the conclusion that the noise is mostly luminal and delayed with respect to the superluminal signal. In the limit of a very weak incident signal pulse, the superluminal signal will be dominated by the noise part, and the signal-to-noise ratio will therefore be very small.

arXiv:quant-ph/0004047•Physical Review A•Jul 19, 2000•35 citations

Quantum Optical Studies of Tunneling and other Superluminal Phenomena

R. Y. Chiao, Aephraim M. Steinberg

Experiments at Berkeley and elsewhere which show that the process of tunneling is apparently superluminal will be reviewed. Conflicting theories for the tunneling time will be compared with experiment. The tunneling particle in the Berkeley experiments was the photon. The measurement of the tunneling time utilized a two-photon light source (spontaneous parametric down-conversion), a Hong-Ou-Mandel interferometer, and a coincidence counter of photon pairs. The tunnel barrier consisted of a photonic-bandgap medium excited at midgap. We find that the peak of a tunneling single-photon wave packet appeared on the far side of the barrier 1.47 ± 0.21 fs earlier than the peak of a wave packet which traveled an equal distance in air. Group velocities which exceed c can also occur in transparent media with inverted atomic populations. Tachyon-like excitations, i.e., collective normal modes of atoms coupled to electromagnetic radiation which possess tachyon-like dispersion relations, occur in these media. However, relativistic causality is not violated by any of these superluminal phenomena.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1998•18 citations

Atomic coherence effects which produce superluminal (but causal) propagation of wavepackets

R. Y. Chiao

Analytic, limited-bandwidth signals, e.g. Gaussian wavepackets, whose frequencies lie in a transparent spectral window far below the resonance of an amplifying atomic medium, can propagate with phase, group, energy and 'signal' velocities (as defined by Sommerfeld and Brillouin) all exceeding the vacuum speed of light c. This 'superluminal' propagation may occur without significant distortion or gain. The front velocity, however, is not superluminal, and therefore Einstein causality is not violated. Applications will be discussed, including the possibility of using superluminal atomic coherence in condensed matter (e.g. macroscopic mass currents in superfluid helium which arise from vortex motions) for efficient gravitational antennae.

Quantum Optics Journal of the European Optical Society Part B•Aug 1, 1994•18 citations
Unstable systems such as media with inverted atomic population have been shown to allow the propagation of analytic wave packets with group velocity faster than that of light, without violating causality. We illuminate the important role played by unstable modes in this propagation and show that the quantum fluctuations of these modes and their unitary time evolution impose severe restrictions on the observation of superluminal phenomena.
Atomic media have played a major role in studies of fast light. One of their attractive features is the ability to manipulate experimental parameters to control the dispersive properties that determine the group velocity of a propagating light pulse. We give an overview of the experimental methods, based on both linear and nonlinear atom-light interaction, that have produced superluminal propagation in atomic media, and discuss some of the significant theoretical contributions to the issues of pulse preservation and reconciling faster-than-light propagation and the principle of causality. The comparison of storage of light, enhanced Kerr nonlinearity and efficient wave mixing processes in slow and fast light atomic media illustrates their common and distinct features.
Causal ``superluminal'' effects have recently been observed and discussed in various contexts. The question arises whether such effects could be observed with extremely weak pulses, and what would prevent the observation of an ``optical tachyon.'' Aharonov, Reznik, and Stern (ARS) [Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 2190 (1998)] have argued that quantum noise will preclude the observation of a superluminal group velocity when the pulse consists of one or a few photons. In this paper we reconsider this question both in a general framework and in the specific example, suggested by Chiao, Kozhekin, and Kurizki (CKK) [Phys. Rev. 77, 1254 (1996)], of off-resonant, short-pulse propagation in an optical amplifier. We derive in the case of the amplifier a signal-to-noise ratio that is consistent with the general ARS conclusions when we impose their criteria for distinguishing between superluminal propagation and propagation at the speed c. However, results consistent with the semiclassical arguments of CKK are obtained if weaker criteria are imposed, in which case the signal can exceed the noise without being ``exponentially large.'' We show that the quantum fluctuations of the field considered by ARS are closely related to superfluorescence noise. More generally, we consider the implications of unitarity for superluminal propagation and quantum noise and study, in addition to the complete and truncated wave packets considered by ARS, the residual wave packet formed by their difference. This leads to the conclusion that the noise is mostly luminal and delayed with respect to the superluminal signal. In the limit of a very weak incident signal pulse, the superluminal signal will be dominated by the noise part, and the signal-to-noise ratio will therefore be very small.
Experiments at Berkeley and elsewhere which show that the process of tunneling is apparently superluminal will be reviewed. Conflicting theories for the tunneling time will be compared with experiment. The tunneling particle in the Berkeley experiments was the photon. The measurement of the tunneling time utilized a two-photon light source (spontaneous parametric down-conversion), a Hong-Ou-Mandel interferometer, and a coincidence counter of photon pairs. The tunnel barrier consisted of a photonic-bandgap medium excited at midgap. We find that the peak of a tunneling single-photon wave packet appeared on the far side of the barrier 1.47 ± 0.21 fs earlier than the peak of a wave packet which traveled an equal distance in air. Group velocities which exceed c can also occur in transparent media with inverted atomic populations. Tachyon-like excitations, i.e., collective normal modes of atoms coupled to electromagnetic radiation which possess tachyon-like dispersion relations, occur in these media. However, relativistic causality is not violated by any of these superluminal phenomena.
Analytic, limited-bandwidth signals, e.g. Gaussian wavepackets, whose frequencies lie in a transparent spectral window far below the resonance of an amplifying atomic medium, can propagate with phase, group, energy and 'signal' velocities (as defined by Sommerfeld and Brillouin) all exceeding the vacuum speed of light c. This 'superluminal' propagation may occur without significant distortion or gain. The front velocity, however, is not superluminal, and therefore Einstein causality is not violated. Applications will be discussed, including the possibility of using superluminal atomic coherence in condensed matter (e.g. macroscopic mass currents in superfluid helium which arise from vortex motions) for efficient gravitational antennae.