We derive explicit expressions for the volume elements of both the minimal and maximal monotone metrics over the (n^{2} - 1)-dimensional convex set of n x n density matrices for the cases n = 3 and 4. We make further progress for the specific n = 3 maximal-monotone case, by taking the limit of a certain ratio of integration results, obtained using an orthogonal set of eight coordinates. By doing so, we find remarkably simple marginal probability distributions based on the corresponding volume element, which we then use for thermodynamic purposes. We, thus, find a spin-1 analogue of the Langevin function. In the fully general n = 4 situation, however, we are impeded in making similar progress by the inability to diagonalize a 3 x 3 Hermitian matrix and thereby obtain an orthogonal set of coordinates to use in the requisite integrations.
We derive explicit expressions for the volume elements of both the minimal and maximal monotone metrics over the (n^{2} - 1)-dimensional convex set of n x n density matrices for the cases n = 3 and 4. We make further progress for the specific n = 3 maximal-monotone case, by taking the limit of a certain ratio of integration results, obtained using an orthogonal set of eight coordinates. By doing so, we find remarkably simple marginal probability distributions based on the corresponding volume element, which we then use for thermodynamic purposes. We, thus, find a spin-1 analogue of the Langevin function. In the fully general n = 4 situation, however, we are impeded in making similar progress by the inability to diagonalize a 3 x 3 Hermitian matrix and thereby obtain an orthogonal set of coordinates to use in the requisite integrations.
Among the monotone metrics on the (n^{2} - 1)-dimensional convex set of n x n density matrices, as Petz and Sudar have recently elaborated, there are a minimal (Bures) and a maximal one. We examine the proposition that it is physically meaningful to treat the volume elements of these metrics as densities-of-states for thermodynamic purposes. In the n = 2 (spin-1/2) case, use of the maximal monotone metric, in fact, does lead to the adoption of the Langevin (and not the Brillouin) functions, thus, completely conforming with a recent probabilistic argument of Lavenda. Brody and Hughston also arrived at the Langevin function in an analysis based on the Fubini-Study metric. It is a matter of some interest, however, that in the first (subsequently modified) version of their paper, they had reported a different result, one fully consistent with the alternative use of the minimal monotone metric. In this part I of our investigation, we first study scenarios involving partially entangled spin-1/2 particles (n = 4, 6,...) and then a certain three-level extension of the two-level systems. In part II, we examine, in full generality, and with some limited analytical success, the cases n = 3 and 4.
Among the monotone metrics on the (n^{2} - 1)-dimensional convex set of n x n density matrices, as Petz and Sudar have recently elaborated, there are a minimal (Bures) and a maximal one. We examine the proposition that it is physically meaningful to treat the volume elements of these metrics as densities-of-states for thermodynamic purposes. In the n = 2 (spin-1/2) case, use of the maximal monotone metric, in fact, does lead to the adoption of the Langevin (and not the Brillouin) functions, thus, completely conforming with a recent probabilistic argument of Lavenda. Brody and Hughston also arrived at the Langevin function in an analysis based on the Fubini-Study metric. It is a matter of some interest, however, that in the first (subsequently modified) version of their paper, they had reported a different result, one fully consistent with the alternative use of the minimal monotone metric. In this part I of our investigation, we first study scenarios involving partially entangled spin-1/2 particles (n = 4, 6,...) and then a certain three-level extension of the two-level systems. In part II, we examine, in full generality, and with some limited analytical success, the cases n = 3 and 4.
We report the results of certain integrations of quantum-theoretic interest, relying, in this regard, upon recently developed parametrizations of Boya et al (1998 Preprint quant-ph/9810084) of the n × n density matrices, in terms of squared components of the unit ( n - 1)-sphere and the n × n unitary matrices. Firstly, we express the normalized volume elements of the Bures (minimal monotone) metric for n = 2 and 3, thereby obtaining `Bures prior probability distributions' over the two- and three-state systems. Then, as a first step in extending these results to n >3, we determine that the `Hall normalization constant' ( C n ) for the marginal Bures prior probablity distribution over the ( n - 1)-dimensional simplex of the n eigenvalues of the n × n density matrices is, for n = 4, equal to 71 680/ 2 . Since we also find that C 3 = 35/ , it follows that C 4 is simply equal to 2 11 C 3 / . ( C 2 itself is known to equal 2/ .) The constant C 5 is also found. It too is associated with a remarkably simple decomposition, involving the product of the eight consecutive prime numbers from 3 to 23. We also preliminarily investigate several cases n >5, with the use of quasi-Monte Carlo integration. We hope that the various analyses reported will prove useful in deriving a general formula (which evidence suggests will involve the Bernoulli numbers) for the Hall normalization constant for arbitrary n . This would have diverse applications, including quantum inference and universal quantum coding.
We demonstrate --- using the case of the two-dimensional quantum systems --- that the "natural measure on the space of density matrices describing N-dimensional quantum systems" proposed by Zyczkowski et al (quant-ph/9804024) does not belong to the class of normalized volume elements of monotone metrics on the quantum systems. Such metrics possess the statistically important property of being decreasing under stochastic mappings (coarse-grainings). We do note that the proposed measure (and certain evident variations upon it) exhibit quite specific monotonicity properties, but not of the form required for membership in the class.
We extend to additional probability measures and scenarios, certain of the recent results of Krattenthaler and Slater (quant-ph/9612043), whose original motivation was to obtain quantum analogs of seminal work on universal data compression of Clarke and Barron. KS obtained explicit formulas for the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the 2^m x 2^m density matrices derived by averaging the m-fold tensor products with themselves of the 2 x 2 density matrices. The weighting was done with respect to a one-parameter (u) family of probability distributions, all the members of which are spherically-symmetric (SU(2)-invariant) over the ``Bloch sphere'' of two-level quantum systems. For u = 1/2, one obtains the normalized volume element of the minimal monotone (Bures) metric. In this paper, analyses parallel to those of KS are conducted, based on an alternative "natural" measure on the density matrices recently proposed by Zyczkowski, Horodecki, Sanpera, and Lewenstein (quant-ph/9804024). The approaches of KS and that based on ZHSL are found to yield [1 + m/2] identical SU(2) x S_{m}-invariant eigenspaces (but not coincident eigenvalues for m > 3). Companion results, based on the SU(3) form of the ZHSL measure, are obtained for the twofold and threefold tensor products of the 3 x 3 density matrices. We find a rather remarkable limiting procedure (selection rule) for recovering from these analyses, the (permutationally-symmetrized) multiplets of SU(3) constructed from two or three particles. We also analyze the scenarios (all for m = 2) N = 2 x 3, N= 2 x 3 x 2, N= 3 x 2 x 2 and N = 4 and, in addition, generalize the ZHSL measure, so that it incorporates a family of (symmetric) Dirichlet distributions (rather than simply the uniform distribution), defined on the (N-1)-dimensional simplex of eigenvalues.
We apply and extend recent results of Krattenthaler and Slater (quant-ph/9612043), who sought quantum analogs of seminal work on universal data compression of Clarke and Barron. KS obtained explicit formulas for the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the 2^m x 2^m density matrices gotten by averaging the m-fold tensor products with themselves of the 2 x 2 density matrices. The weighting was done with respect to a one-parameter family of probability distributions, all the members of which are spherically-symmetric over the "Bloch sphere" of two-level quantum systems. This family includes the normalized volume element of the minimal monotone (Bures) metric. In this letter, we conduct parallel analyses (for m =2,3,4), based on a natural measure on the density matrices recently proposed by Zyczkowski, Horodecki, Sanpera and Lewenstein (quant-ph/9804024) and find interesting similarities and differences with the findings of KS. In addition, we are able to obtain exact analogous results, based on the measure of ZHSL, for the twofold tensor products of the 3 x 3 density matrices.