Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9801056

Comments on Unruh's Paper

Henry Pierce Stapp

Published Jan 23, 1998• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Unruh has commented upon my recent proof that certain predictions of quantum theory are incompatible with the assertion that no influence of any kind acts backward in time in any Lorentz frame. Unruh fails to make a necessary distinction between statements that assert the existence of values, and statements that assert the existence merely of correlations between possible values. Consequently his argument fails to show that my proof involves a tacit or hidden reality assumption that is alien to quantum theory.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/9801056

Related papers

Comment on Unruh's Paper

Henry Pierce Stapp

William Unruh has commented on my recent proof of the incompatibility of certain predictions of quantum theory with the idea that no influence of any kind can act backward in time in any Lorentz frame.He argues that my proof contains, contrary to my explicit claim, a tacit reality assumption that conflicts with the ideas quantum theory.I show here that Unruh's argument fails to draw a necessary distinction between statements that make an assertion about actual values and statements that make an assertion about correlations between possible values, and that consequently his argument fails demonstrate the occurrence in my proof of any reality assumption that is alien to the principles of quantum theory.

•Jan 23, 1998•1 citation

Comment on “Nonlocality, counterfactuals, and quantum mechanics”

Henry Pierce Stapp

A recent proof [H. P. Stapp, Am. J. Phys. 65, 300 (1997)], formulated in the symbolic language of modal logic, claims to show that contemporary quantum theory, viewed as a set of rules that allow us to calculate statistical predictions among certain kinds of observations, cannot be imbedded in any rational framework that conforms to the principles that (1) the experimenters' choices of which experiments they will perform can be considered to be free choices, (2) outcomes of measurements are unique, and (3) the free choices just mentioned have no backward-in-time effects of any kind. This claim is similar to Bell's theorem, but much stronger, because no reality assumption alien to quantum philosophy is used. The paper being commented on [W. Unruh, Phys. Rev. A 59, 126 (1999)] argues that some such reality assumption has been ``smuggled'' in. That argument is examined here and shown, I believe, to be defective.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1999•11 citations

Reply to Unruh

Henry Pierce Stapp

William Unruh has suggested (quant-ph/9710032) that a certain counterfactual statement in my recent nonlocality proof should be re-interpreted in a way that would block the proof. I give reason's why that statement should not be re-interpreted.

arXiv:quant-ph/9712043•Dec 19, 1997•7 citations

Reply to Unruh

Henry Pierce Stapp

William Unruh has suggested (quant-ph/9710032) that a certain counterfactual statement in my recent nonlocality proof should be re-interpreted in a way that would block the proof. I give reason's why that statement should not be re-interpreted.

•Dec 19, 1997•3 citations

Reply to Unruh

Henry Pierce Stapp

certain counterfactual statement in my recent nonlocality proof should be re-interpreted in a way that would block the proof.I give reason's why that statement should not be re-interpreted.

•Dec 16, 2009•0 citations

Reply to Unruh

Stapp, Henry P.

certain counterfactual statement in my recent nonlocality proof should be re-interpreted in a way that would block the proof.I give reason's why that statement should not be re-interpreted.

•Dec 19, 1997•0 citations
Unruh has commented upon my recent proof that certain predictions of quantum theory are incompatible with the assertion that no influence of any kind acts backward in time in any Lorentz frame. Unruh fails to make a necessary distinction between statements that assert the existence of values, and statements that assert the existence merely of correlations between possible values. Consequently his argument fails to show that my proof involves a tacit or hidden reality assumption that is alien to quantum theory.
William Unruh has commented on my recent proof of the incompatibility of certain predictions of quantum theory with the idea that no influence of any kind can act backward in time in any Lorentz frame.He argues that my proof contains, contrary to my explicit claim, a tacit reality assumption that conflicts with the ideas quantum theory.I show here that Unruh's argument fails to draw a necessary distinction between statements that make an assertion about actual values and statements that make an assertion about correlations between possible values, and that consequently his argument fails demonstrate the occurrence in my proof of any reality assumption that is alien to the principles of quantum theory.
A recent proof [H. P. Stapp, Am. J. Phys. 65, 300 (1997)], formulated in the symbolic language of modal logic, claims to show that contemporary quantum theory, viewed as a set of rules that allow us to calculate statistical predictions among certain kinds of observations, cannot be imbedded in any rational framework that conforms to the principles that (1) the experimenters' choices of which experiments they will perform can be considered to be free choices, (2) outcomes of measurements are unique, and (3) the free choices just mentioned have no backward-in-time effects of any kind. This claim is similar to Bell's theorem, but much stronger, because no reality assumption alien to quantum philosophy is used. The paper being commented on [W. Unruh, Phys. Rev. A 59, 126 (1999)] argues that some such reality assumption has been ``smuggled'' in. That argument is examined here and shown, I believe, to be defective.