Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9612015 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

Quantum weight enumerators

Eric M. Rains

Published Jul 1, 1998• 139 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent paper, Shor and Laflamme (see Phys. Rev. Lett., vol.78, p.1600-2, 1997) defined two "weight enumerators" for quantum error-correcting codes, connected by a MacWilliams transform, and used them to give a linear programming bound for quantum codes. We introduce two new enumerators which, while much less powerful at producing bounds, are useful tools nonetheless. The new enumerators are connected by a much simpler duality transform, clarifying the duality between Shor and Laflamme's enumerators. We also use the new enumerators to give a simpler condition for a quantum code to have specified minimum distance, and to extend the enumerator theory to codes with block size greater than 2.

DOI
10.1109/18.681316

Related papers

Quantum shadow enumerators

Eric M. Rains

In a previous paper, Shor and Laflamme (see Phys. Rev. Lett., vol.78, p.1600-02, 1997) define two "weight enumerators" for quantum error-correcting codes, connected by a MacWilliams (1977) transform, and use them to give a linear-programming bound for quantum codes. We extend their work by introducing another enumerator, based on the classical theory of shadow codes, that tightens their bounds significantly. In particular, nearly all of the codes known to be optimal among additive quantum codes (codes derived from orthogonal geometry) can be shown to be optimal among all quantum codes. We also use the shadow machinery to extend a bound on additive codes to general codes, obtaining as a consequence that any code of length, can correct at most [(n+1)/6] errors.

arXiv:quant-ph/9611001•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jan 1, 1999•115 citations

MacWilliams Identities for Intrinsic Quantum Codes

Eric Kubischta, Ian Teixeira

This paper develops a MacWilliams-type enumerator theory and semidefinite programming bounds for intrinsic quantum codes. An intrinsic code is a subspace $\mathcal{C}\subset V$ of a finite-dimensional unitary representation $V$ of a group $G$, with errors organized into the isotypic components of $\mathscr{L}(V)$ under conjugation. The Knill-Laflamme conditions persist under every $G$-equivariant realization of $V$, aallowing intrinsic bounds to apply across diverse physical encodings. Without a group action, we first construct projector and twirl quadratic enumerators for an arbitrary orthogonal decomposition of $\mathscr{L}(V)$, analogous respectively to the $A$ and $B$ enumerators of Shor-Laflamme theory. These enumerators satisfy positivity, normalization, and Knill-Laflamme inequalities, but the two superoperator families need not span the same space and therefore admit no canonical duality. A group action places their generalized versions in the same equivariant intertwiner algebra, and the change of basis between them defines the intrinsic MacWilliams transform. When the conjugation representation has multiplicities, this algebra is noncommutative and the enumerators are matrix-valued; positivity and detection are encoded by Loewner-order constraints, making the natural programming bound a semidefinite program. The multiplicity-free specialization recovers the known scalar MacWilliams transform and linear-programming framework. For symmetric powers, intrinsic depth equals ordinary qudit distance, yielding extremality certificates for permutation-invariant qudit codes. Finally, for the $27$-dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(3)$ representation $V=(2,2)$, an exact dual certificate proves the sharp bound $K\leq5$ for codes detecting the full adjoint isotypic component. An explicit $5$-dimensional code attains the bound and, under the canonical embedding, gives a four-qutrit distance-$2$ code.

quant-pharXiv:2604.16023•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Apr 20, 2026•6 citations

Complete Weight Distributions and MacWilliams Identities for Asymmetric Quantum Codes

Chuangqiang Hu, Shudi Yang, Stephen S.‐T. Yau

In 1997, Shor and Laflamme defined the weight enumerators for quantum error-correcting codes and derived a MacWilliams identity. We extend their work by introducing our double weight enumerators and complete weight enumerators for qubit codes and then investigate the MacWilliams identities for these enumerators. Based on the generalized MacWilliams identities, we solve an open problem, namely, the Singleton-type bound for asymmetric quantum codes (AQCs). Besides, the Hamming-type and the first linear-programming-type bounds for the AQCs are deduced similarly.

arXiv:1810.11969•IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2019•7 citations

Linear Programming Bounds for Entanglement-Assisted Quantum Error-Correcting Codes by Split Weight Enumerators

Ching–Yi Lai, Alexei Ashikhmin

Linear programming approaches have been applied to derive upper bounds on the size of classical and quantum codes. In this paper, we derive similar results for general quantum codes with entanglement assistance by considering a type of split weight enumerator. After deriving the MacWilliams identities for these enumerators, we are able to prove algebraic linear programming bounds, such as the Singleton bound, the Hamming bound, and the first linear programming bound. Our Singleton bound and Hamming bound are more general than the previous bounds for entanglement-assisted quantum stabilizer codes. In addition, we show that the first linear programming bound improves the Hamming bound when the relative distance is sufficiently large. On the other hand, we obtain additional constraints on the size of Pauli subgroups for quantum codes, which allow us to improve the linear programming bounds on the minimum distance of quantum codes of small length. In particular, we show that there is no [[27, 15, 5]] or [[28, 14, 6]] stabilizer code. We also discuss the existence of some entanglement-assisted quantum stabilizer codes with maximal entanglement. As a result, the upper and lower bounds on the minimum distance of maximal-entanglement quantum stabilizer codes with length up to 20 are significantly improved.

arXiv:1602.00413•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jun 2, 2017•107 citations

Twisted Fourier Analysis of Quantum Weight Enumerators

Ching-Yi Lai

A unified Fourier framework for quantum weight enumerators of prime-power-dimensional qudits is developed in this paper. We introduce the notions of Weyl power spectrum and Weyl-conjugation autocorrelation for the Weyl-operator quantities nderlying the Shor--Laflamme weight enumerators. Representing these quantities as formal vectors, we show that they form a symplectic Fourier transform pair, from which the quantum MacWilliams identity follows by applying the Hamming-weight functional. This framework extends to a family of twisted Fourier transforms, including the Rains shadow transform. We show that identical-copy Bell sampling corresponds to a twisted autocorrelation related to the shadow enumerator through Weyl translation and Hamming projection. We further prove that all twisted Fourier transforms are Weyl translations of either the ordinary MacWilliams transform or the Rains shadow transform. This two-class reduction implies that the twists yield no additional independent coefficientwise positivity constraints under compatible projections. Nevertheless, the framework leads to refined MacWilliams and shadow identities that retain more Fourier information than ordinary Hamming weight enumerators. We employ these refined identities in linear programming, together with simplex mapping and shadow-coset counting, to exclude surviving candidate weight distributions. These techniques yield tighter bounds for binary and qutrit quantum codes, including nonexistence results for specific code parameters.

quant-pharXiv:2610.37894•Oct 29, 2026•0 citations

Linear Programming Bounds for Approximate Quantum Error Correction Over Arbitrary Quantum Channels

Yingkai Ouyang, Ching–Yi Lai

While quantum weight enumerators establish some of the best upper bounds on the minimum distance of quantum error-correcting codes, these bounds are not optimized to quantify the performance of quantum codes under the effect of arbitrary quantum channels that describe bespoke noise models. Herein, for any Kraus decomposition of any given quantum channel, we introduce corresponding quantum weight enumerators that naturally generalize the Shor-Laflamme quantum weight enumerators. We establish an indirect linear relationship between these generalized quantum weight enumerators by introducing an auxiliary exact weight enumerator that completely quantifies the quantum code’s projector, and is independent of the underlying noise process. By additionally working within the framework of approximate quantum error correction, we establish a general framework for constructing a linear program that is infeasible whenever approximate quantum error correcting codes with corresponding parameters do not exist. Our linear programming framework allows us to establish the non-existence of certain quantum codes that approximately correct amplitude damping errors, and obtain non-trivial upper bounds on the maximum dimension of a broad family of permutation-invariant quantum codes.

arXiv:2108.04434•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Mar 25, 2022•7 citations
In a recent paper, Shor and Laflamme (see Phys. Rev. Lett., vol.78, p.1600-2, 1997) defined two "weight enumerators" for quantum error-correcting codes, connected by a MacWilliams transform, and used them to give a linear programming bound for quantum codes. We introduce two new enumerators which, while much less powerful at producing bounds, are useful tools nonetheless. The new enumerators are connected by a much simpler duality transform, clarifying the duality between Shor and Laflamme's enumerators. We also use the new enumerators to give a simpler condition for a quantum code to have specified minimum distance, and to extend the enumerator theory to codes with block size greater than 2.
In a previous paper, Shor and Laflamme (see Phys. Rev. Lett., vol.78, p.1600-02, 1997) define two "weight enumerators" for quantum error-correcting codes, connected by a MacWilliams (1977) transform, and use them to give a linear-programming bound for quantum codes. We extend their work by introducing another enumerator, based on the classical theory of shadow codes, that tightens their bounds significantly. In particular, nearly all of the codes known to be optimal among additive quantum codes (codes derived from orthogonal geometry) can be shown to be optimal among all quantum codes. We also use the shadow machinery to extend a bound on additive codes to general codes, obtaining as a consequence that any code of length, can correct at most [(n+1)/6] errors.
This paper develops a MacWilliams-type enumerator theory and semidefinite programming bounds for intrinsic quantum codes. An intrinsic code is a subspace C⊂V\mathcal{C}\subset VC⊂V of a finite-dimensional unitary representation VVV of a group GGG, with errors organized into the isotypic components of L(V)\mathscr{L}(V)L(V) under conjugation. The Knill-Laflamme conditions persist under every GGG-equivariant realization of VVV, aallowing intrinsic bounds to apply across diverse physical encodings. Without a group action, we first construct projector and twirl quadratic enumerators for an arbitrary orthogonal decomposition of L(V)\mathscr{L}(V)L(V), analogous respectively to the AAA and BBB enumerators of Shor-Laflamme theory. These enumerators satisfy positivity, normalization, and Knill-Laflamme inequalities, but the two superoperator families need not span the same space and therefore admit no canonical duality. A group action places their generalized versions in the same equivariant intertwiner algebra, and the change of basis between them defines the intrinsic MacWilliams transform. When the conjugation representation has multiplicities, this algebra is noncommutative and the enumerators are matrix-valued; positivity and detection are encoded by Loewner-order constraints, making the natural programming bound a semidefinite program. The multiplicity-free specialization recovers the known scalar MacWilliams transform and linear-programming framework. For symmetric powers, intrinsic depth equals ordinary qudit distance, yielding extremality certificates for permutation-invariant qudit codes. Finally, for the 272727-dimensional SU(3)\mathrm{SU}(3)SU(3) representation V=(2,2)V=(2,2)V=(2,2), an exact dual certificate proves the sharp bound K≤5K\leq5K≤5 for codes detecting the full adjoint isotypic component. An explicit 555-dimensional code attains the bound and, under the canonical embedding, gives a four-qutrit distance-222 code.
In 1997, Shor and Laflamme defined the weight enumerators for quantum error-correcting codes and derived a MacWilliams identity. We extend their work by introducing our double weight enumerators and complete weight enumerators for qubit codes and then investigate the MacWilliams identities for these enumerators. Based on the generalized MacWilliams identities, we solve an open problem, namely, the Singleton-type bound for asymmetric quantum codes (AQCs). Besides, the Hamming-type and the first linear-programming-type bounds for the AQCs are deduced similarly.
Linear programming approaches have been applied to derive upper bounds on the size of classical and quantum codes. In this paper, we derive similar results for general quantum codes with entanglement assistance by considering a type of split weight enumerator. After deriving the MacWilliams identities for these enumerators, we are able to prove algebraic linear programming bounds, such as the Singleton bound, the Hamming bound, and the first linear programming bound. Our Singleton bound and Hamming bound are more general than the previous bounds for entanglement-assisted quantum stabilizer codes. In addition, we show that the first linear programming bound improves the Hamming bound when the relative distance is sufficiently large. On the other hand, we obtain additional constraints on the size of Pauli subgroups for quantum codes, which allow us to improve the linear programming bounds on the minimum distance of quantum codes of small length. In particular, we show that there is no [[27, 15, 5]] or [[28, 14, 6]] stabilizer code. We also discuss the existence of some entanglement-assisted quantum stabilizer codes with maximal entanglement. As a result, the upper and lower bounds on the minimum distance of maximal-entanglement quantum stabilizer codes with length up to 20 are significantly improved.
A unified Fourier framework for quantum weight enumerators of prime-power-dimensional qudits is developed in this paper. We introduce the notions of Weyl power spectrum and Weyl-conjugation autocorrelation for the Weyl-operator quantities nderlying the Shor--Laflamme weight enumerators. Representing these quantities as formal vectors, we show that they form a symplectic Fourier transform pair, from which the quantum MacWilliams identity follows by applying the Hamming-weight functional. This framework extends to a family of twisted Fourier transforms, including the Rains shadow transform. We show that identical-copy Bell sampling corresponds to a twisted autocorrelation related to the shadow enumerator through Weyl translation and Hamming projection. We further prove that all twisted Fourier transforms are Weyl translations of either the ordinary MacWilliams transform or the Rains shadow transform. This two-class reduction implies that the twists yield no additional independent coefficientwise positivity constraints under compatible projections. Nevertheless, the framework leads to refined MacWilliams and shadow identities that retain more Fourier information than ordinary Hamming weight enumerators. We employ these refined identities in linear programming, together with simplex mapping and shadow-coset counting, to exclude surviving candidate weight distributions. These techniques yield tighter bounds for binary and qutrit quantum codes, including nonexistence results for specific code parameters.
While quantum weight enumerators establish some of the best upper bounds on the minimum distance of quantum error-correcting codes, these bounds are not optimized to quantify the performance of quantum codes under the effect of arbitrary quantum channels that describe bespoke noise models. Herein, for any Kraus decomposition of any given quantum channel, we introduce corresponding quantum weight enumerators that naturally generalize the Shor-Laflamme quantum weight enumerators. We establish an indirect linear relationship between these generalized quantum weight enumerators by introducing an auxiliary exact weight enumerator that completely quantifies the quantum code’s projector, and is independent of the underlying noise process. By additionally working within the framework of approximate quantum error correction, we establish a general framework for constructing a linear program that is infeasible whenever approximate quantum error correcting codes with corresponding parameters do not exist. Our linear programming framework allows us to establish the non-existence of certain quantum codes that approximately correct amplitude damping errors, and obtain non-trivial upper bounds on the maximum dimension of a broad family of permutation-invariant quantum codes.