There seems to be general agreement amongst researchers investigating detailed structures in the brain that concepts like mind and consciousness will ultimately have their explanation in terms of classical physics with quantum mechanics playing no role at these higher levels. However classical physics excludes the observer, whereas the higher level activities of the brain involve the observer in the form of a subject in a very fundamental way. In quantum theory the observer plays a crucial role and there are general arguments which suggest that quantum theory will play a key role at this level. In this paper I will discuss the reasons for adopting such a position. I will discuss Bohr’s contribution to the mind/matter debate, a contribution which depends on the recognition that there is an element of wholeness in quantum processes that leads to general problems concerning the separation of subject from object. I will show how the work I did with Bohm led to similar conclusions, albeit from a very different point of view. Our view suggests that physical processes contain an organic element that is based on the notion of active information. I also present some more general ideas which replace the Cartesian order by a more subtle order, the implicate order which I feel offers the best possibility of bridging the gap between the basic underlying neurophysics and the top down psychophysics.
Abstract An assessment is made of the role of quantum entanglement in biological neuronal circuitry, in agreement with previous experimental evidence, which indicated that quantum tunneling plays an essential role in the occurrence of the sense of smell. It is here described how that can be physically realistic. Then, it is analyzed how the occurrence of quantum entanglement in multiple scales allows for the occurrence of consciousness in biological systems. We obtain that quantum mechanics (QM) allows for coherence to be maintained in living brains for regions in the scale of the minicollumn, but not much more. The QM waves can then be amplified into classical waves along the brain that transmit information, which existed in the quantum wave at minicollumn scale. For the quantum wave to be able to exist at the minicollumn scale at the temperature of a living brain, several physiological constraints need to occur within the neuronal circuitry. Here, we assess what those constraints are and propose forms for realistically theorizing that those constraints can occur in a living brain at the minicollumn scale. This analysis of the effects of quantum entanglement in biological neuronal circuitry assists in suggesting a new approach to neuronal nets, which we call a multidepth quantum neural net. We then analyze in what way it is likely that in the future a multidepth quantum neural net will be capable of achieving consciousness.
How is mind related to matter? This ancient question in philosophy is rapidly becoming a core problem in science, perhaps the most important of all because it probes the essential nature of man himself. The origin of the problem is a conflict between the mechanical conception of human beings that arises from the precepts of classical physical theory and the very different idea that arises from our intuition: the former reduces each of us to an automaton, while the latter allows our thoughts to guide our actions. The dominant contemporary approaches to the problem attempt to resolve this conflict by clinging to the classical concepts, and trying to explain away our misleading intuition. But a detailed argument given here shows why, in a scientific approach to this problem, it is necessary to use the more basic principles of quantum physics, which bring the observer into the dynamics, rather than to accept classical precepts that are profoundly incorrect precisely at the crucial point of the role of human consciousness in the dynamics of human brains. Adherence to the quantum principles yields a dynamical theory of the mind/brain/body system that is in close accord with our intuitive idea of what we are. In particular, the need for a self-observing quantum system to pose certain questions creates a causal opening that allows mind/brain dynamics to have three distinguishable but interlocked causal processes, one micro-local, one stochastic, and the third experiential. Passing to the classical limit in which the critical difference between zero and the finite actual value of Planck's constant is ignored not only eliminates the chemical processes that are absolutely crucial to the functioning of actual brains, it simultaneously blinds the resulting theoretical construct to the physical fine structure wherein the effect of mind on matter lies: the use of this limit in this context is totally unjustified from a physics perspective.