Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9508007

Bounds for Approximation in Total Variation Distance by Quantum Circuits

Emanuel H. Knill

Published Aug 8, 1995• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It was recently shown that for reasonable notions of approximation of states and functions by quantum circuits, almost all states and functions are exponentially hard to approximate [Knill 1995]. The bounds obtained are asymptotically tight except for the one based on total variation distance (TVD). TVD is the most relevant metric for the performance of a quantum circuit. In this paper we obtain asymptotically tight bounds for TVD. We show that in a natural sense, almost all states are hard to approximate to within a TVD of 2/e-εeven for exponentially small ε. The quantity 2/e is asymptotically the average distance to the uniform distribution. Almost all states with probability amplitudes concentrated in a small fraction of the space are hard to approximate to within a TVD of 2-ε. These results imply that non-uniform quantum circuit complexity is non-trivial in any reasonable model. They also reinforce the notion that the relative information distance between states (which is based on the difficulty of transforming one state to another) fully reflects the dimensionality of the space of qubits, not the number of qubits.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/9508007

Related papers

Operational Quantum Average-Case Distances

Filip B. Maciejewski, Zbigniew Puchała, Michał Oszmaniec

We introduce distance measures between quantum states, measurements, and channels based on their statistical distinguishability in generic experiments. Specifically, we analyze the average Total Variation Distance (TVD) between output statistics of protocols in which quantum objects are intertwined with random circuits and measured in standard basis. We show that for circuits forming approximate 4-designs, the average TVDs can be approximated by simple explicit functions of the underlying objects – the average-case distances (ACDs). We apply them to analyze the effects of noise in quantum advantage experiments and for efficient discrimination of high-dimensional states and channels without quantum memory. We argue that ACDs are better suited for assessing the quality of NISQ devices than common distance measures such as trace distance or the diamond norm.

arXiv:2112.14283•Quantum•Sep 11, 2023•11 citations

Random Quantum Circuits Beyond Moment Matching

Shih-Han Hung

Random quantum circuits aim to efficiently reproduce the statistical properties of ideal random quantum evolution. One approach is to construct approximate unitary designs, which match the moments of Haar-random unitaries up to a prescribed order with controlled error. We establish quantitative guarantees for how accurately these designs reproduce the distribution of each output probability. We show that, for every strong $\varepsilon$-approximate unitary $k$-design on $n$ qubits, the distribution of each output probability is within $O(k^{-1/2}(1+k/2^n)^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)$ in Kolmogorov distance of the Porter-Thomas distribution, a beta distribution with parameters $1$ and $2^n-1$. This bound is optimal up to constant factors, implying that a substantially better uniform bound requires additional structure. We then show that a mild form of local invariance suffices. We prove that any such design that is invariant under unitary translations acting on a single qubit approximates Porter-Thomas to total variation distance $O(k^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)$. Every strong $\varepsilon$-approximate unitary $k$-design invariant on $\log k+O(1)$ qubits achieves error $2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon)$ in Kolmogorov distance and $2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon\log(2/\varepsilon))$ in total variation distance. These results identify the distributional accuracy guaranteed by moment matching and the structure that improves it. As an application, we show that the Shannon entropy of the output distribution of a strong $\varepsilon$-approximate $k$-design is concentrated around its Haar value $n-Θ(1)$: its mean differs from the Haar mean by $O(k^{-1/4}+\varepsilon^{1/2})$ and its standard deviation is $O(2^{-n/2}+k^{-1/8}+\varepsilon^{1/4})$. Consequently, a trusted device sampling such circuits generates $n-O(1)$ bits of entropy per sample, which makes them useful for random number generation.

quant-pharXiv:2610.02135•Oct 2, 2026•0 citations

On the Hardness of Approximate Quantum Circuit Membership and Optimization

Adam Husted Kjelstrøm, Jaco van de Pol, Andreas Pavlogiannis

Quantum circuit optimization is an indispensable component of the quantum software stack, used to reduce noise, maximize performance, alleviate costs of quantum error correction, or target specific hardware. A related problem is approximate membership: for a fixed set of unitaries $S$, decide whether a given circuit $C$ is within distance $\varepsilon$ of a unitary in $S$ under some metric $m$. Membership is a special case of optimization, where $S$ is a set of unitaries implementable at no cost (e.g., with noise-minimal circuits, or without magic states). Janzing, Wocjan, and Beth (Int. J. Quantum Inf., 2005) showed that, for the operator metric, the case $S=\{I\}$ (approximate identity) is QMA-complete when $C$ is promised to be either close to the identity or far from it. We generalize this setting in three directions: (i) promise-free inputs, (ii) besides $S=\{I\}$, sets $S$ containing only Clifford unitaries, or only generalized permutation matrices (i.e., no superposition), and (iii) the trace-based, spectral, and operator metrics. We show that, in all cases, approximate membership is PP-hard for wide ranges of $\varepsilon$, provided $C$'s gate-set can implement Clifford+T, as the gate-sets of standard hardware do. If $S=\{I\}$, or if $S$ contains only generalized permutation matrices, $I\in S$, and $m$ is a trace-based distance, PP-hardness holds for all non-trivial $\varepsilon$. If $S=\{I\}$ and $m$ is a trace-based distance, PP-hardness holds even for circuits over classical-reversible gate-sets. Our results indicate that approximate membership is harder over promise-free inputs than the QMA-complete promise version, and that this hardness persists across quantum resources (any gates, non-Clifford, superposition) and distance metrics. They directly imply PP-hardness of circuit optimization when minimizing total, non-Clifford, or superposition gate depth or count.

quant-pharXiv:2611.04381•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Quantum circuit debugging and sensitivity analysis via local inversions.

F. A. Calderon-Vargas, Timothy J Proctor, Kenneth Rudinger +1 more

We write a d-layer circuit as:§ We define the i-inverse of the circuit as which we view as a local perturbation of the circuit.§ With the probability distribution over measurement outcomes, ( and is the set of all length-n bitstrings), we assess how such local perturbations affect the circuit outcomes by computing the distance, , between the original and perturbed output distributions.§ We use the total variation distance (TVD) for the distance measure

•Oct 1, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Noise And Measuring Quantum Distance For NISQ Circuits

Sakibul Islam Sazzad, Protik Nag

In this article, we analyzed the performance of several classes of quantum circuits under various errors. We executed NISQ circuits on both noisy simulator and real hardware backend publicly available from IBM Quantum. On simulation, we created noise models with both individual errors and combination of multiple errors to quantify how each type of error impact performance of quantum circuits. We utilized statistical distances such as total variation distance (TVD), Jensen-Shannon divergence (JSD), and Hellinger distance, to measure the deviation of noisy output from ideal output. Finally, we compare the noisy outputs from the simulator and outputs from the real hardware to showcase the gap between simulation and real device experiment. This gap points to the limitation of present noise models failure to exhibit the behavior of real hardware.

•Dec 30, 2022•1 citation

Quantum Noise And Measuring Quantum Distance For NISQ Circuits

Sakibul Islam Sazzad, Protik Nag

In this article, we analyzed the performance of several classes of quantum circuits under various errors. We executed NISQ circuits on both noisy simulator and real hardware backend publicly available from IBM Quantum. On simulation, we created noise models with both individual errors and combination of multiple errors to quantify how each type of error impact performance of quantum circuits. We utilized statistical distances such as total variation distance (TVD), Jensen-Shannon divergence (JSD), and Hellinger distance, to measure the deviation of noisy output from ideal output. Finally, we compare the noisy outputs from the simulator and outputs from the real hardware to showcase the gap between simulation and real device experiment. This gap points to the limitation of present noise models failure to exhibit the behavior of real hardware.

•Dec 30, 2022•3 citations
It was recently shown that for reasonable notions of approximation of states and functions by quantum circuits, almost all states and functions are exponentially hard to approximate [Knill 1995]. The bounds obtained are asymptotically tight except for the one based on total variation distance (TVD). TVD is the most relevant metric for the performance of a quantum circuit. In this paper we obtain asymptotically tight bounds for TVD. We show that in a natural sense, almost all states are hard to approximate to within a TVD of 2/e-εeven for exponentially small ε. The quantity 2/e is asymptotically the average distance to the uniform distribution. Almost all states with probability amplitudes concentrated in a small fraction of the space are hard to approximate to within a TVD of 2-ε. These results imply that non-uniform quantum circuit complexity is non-trivial in any reasonable model. They also reinforce the notion that the relative information distance between states (which is based on the difficulty of transforming one state to another) fully reflects the dimensionality of the space of qubits, not the number of qubits.
We introduce distance measures between quantum states, measurements, and channels based on their statistical distinguishability in generic experiments. Specifically, we analyze the average Total Variation Distance (TVD) between output statistics of protocols in which quantum objects are intertwined with random circuits and measured in standard basis. We show that for circuits forming approximate 4-designs, the average TVDs can be approximated by simple explicit functions of the underlying objects – the average-case distances (ACDs). We apply them to analyze the effects of noise in quantum advantage experiments and for efficient discrimination of high-dimensional states and channels without quantum memory. We argue that ACDs are better suited for assessing the quality of NISQ devices than common distance measures such as trace distance or the diamond norm.
Random quantum circuits aim to efficiently reproduce the statistical properties of ideal random quantum evolution. One approach is to construct approximate unitary designs, which match the moments of Haar-random unitaries up to a prescribed order with controlled error. We establish quantitative guarantees for how accurately these designs reproduce the distribution of each output probability. We show that, for every strong ε\varepsilonε-approximate unitary kkk-design on nnn qubits, the distribution of each output probability is within O(k−1/2(1+k/2n)−1/2+ε)O(k^{-1/2}(1+k/2^n)^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)O(k−1/2(1+k/2n)−1/2+ε) in Kolmogorov distance of the Porter-Thomas distribution, a beta distribution with parameters 111 and 2n−12^n-12n−1. This bound is optimal up to constant factors, implying that a substantially better uniform bound requires additional structure. We then show that a mild form of local invariance suffices. We prove that any such design that is invariant under unitary translations acting on a single qubit approximates Porter-Thomas to total variation distance O(k−1/2+ε)O(k^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)O(k−1/2+ε). Every strong ε\varepsilonε-approximate unitary kkk-design invariant on log⁡k+O(1)\log k+O(1)logk+O(1) qubits achieves error 2−Ω(k)+O(ε)2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon)2−Ω(k)+O(ε) in Kolmogorov distance and 2−Ω(k)+O(εlog⁡(2/ε))2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon\log(2/\varepsilon))2−Ω(k)+O(εlog(2/ε)) in total variation distance. These results identify the distributional accuracy guaranteed by moment matching and the structure that improves it. As an application, we show that the Shannon entropy of the output distribution of a strong ε\varepsilonε-approximate kkk-design is concentrated around its Haar value n−Θ(1)n-Θ(1)n−Θ(1): its mean differs from the Haar mean by O(k−1/4+ε1/2)O(k^{-1/4}+\varepsilon^{1/2})O(k−1/4+ε1/2) and its standard deviation is O(2−n/2+k−1/8+ε1/4)O(2^{-n/2}+k^{-1/8}+\varepsilon^{1/4})O(2−n/2+k−1/8+ε1/4). Consequently, a trusted device sampling such circuits generates n−O(1)n-O(1)n−O(1) bits of entropy per sample, which makes them useful for random number generation.
Quantum circuit optimization is an indispensable component of the quantum software stack, used to reduce noise, maximize performance, alleviate costs of quantum error correction, or target specific hardware. A related problem is approximate membership: for a fixed set of unitaries SSS, decide whether a given circuit CCC is within distance ε\varepsilonε of a unitary in SSS under some metric mmm. Membership is a special case of optimization, where SSS is a set of unitaries implementable at no cost (e.g., with noise-minimal circuits, or without magic states). Janzing, Wocjan, and Beth (Int. J. Quantum Inf., 2005) showed that, for the operator metric, the case S={I}S=\{I\}S={I} (approximate identity) is QMA-complete when CCC is promised to be either close to the identity or far from it. We generalize this setting in three directions: (i) promise-free inputs, (ii) besides S={I}S=\{I\}S={I}, sets SSS containing only Clifford unitaries, or only generalized permutation matrices (i.e., no superposition), and (iii) the trace-based, spectral, and operator metrics. We show that, in all cases, approximate membership is PP-hard for wide ranges of ε\varepsilonε, provided CCC's gate-set can implement Clifford+T, as the gate-sets of standard hardware do. If S={I}S=\{I\}S={I}, or if SSS contains only generalized permutation matrices, I∈SI\in SI∈S, and mmm is a trace-based distance, PP-hardness holds for all non-trivial ε\varepsilonε. If S={I}S=\{I\}S={I} and mmm is a trace-based distance, PP-hardness holds even for circuits over classical-reversible gate-sets. Our results indicate that approximate membership is harder over promise-free inputs than the QMA-complete promise version, and that this hardness persists across quantum resources (any gates, non-Clifford, superposition) and distance metrics. They directly imply PP-hardness of circuit optimization when minimizing total, non-Clifford, or superposition gate depth or count.
In this article, we analyzed the performance of several classes of quantum circuits under various errors. We executed NISQ circuits on both noisy simulator and real hardware backend publicly available from IBM Quantum. On simulation, we created noise models with both individual errors and combination of multiple errors to quantify how each type of error impact performance of quantum circuits. We utilized statistical distances such as total variation distance (TVD), Jensen-Shannon divergence (JSD), and Hellinger distance, to measure the deviation of noisy output from ideal output. Finally, we compare the noisy outputs from the simulator and outputs from the real hardware to showcase the gap between simulation and real device experiment. This gap points to the limitation of present noise models failure to exhibit the behavior of real hardware.
In this article, we analyzed the performance of several classes of quantum circuits under various errors. We executed NISQ circuits on both noisy simulator and real hardware backend publicly available from IBM Quantum. On simulation, we created noise models with both individual errors and combination of multiple errors to quantify how each type of error impact performance of quantum circuits. We utilized statistical distances such as total variation distance (TVD), Jensen-Shannon divergence (JSD), and Hellinger distance, to measure the deviation of noisy output from ideal output. Finally, we compare the noisy outputs from the simulator and outputs from the real hardware to showcase the gap between simulation and real device experiment. This gap points to the limitation of present noise models failure to exhibit the behavior of real hardware.