Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0703261 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Quantum thermodynamic Carnot and Otto-like cycles for a two-level system

Gian Paolo Beretta

Published Jul 1, 2012• 35 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Within the recent revival of interest in quantum heat engines between two thermal reservoirs whereby the working substance is a two-level system, it has been suggested that the celebrated Carnot heat-to-work conversion efficiency 1 − ( T low / T high ) cannot be reached. Contrary to this suggestion, we show that reaching the Carnot bound not only is not impossible and does not require an infinite number of heat baths and infinitesimal processes, but it is also within reach of the current experimental techniques. It is sufficient to cycle smoothly (slowly) over at least three (in general four) values of the tunable energy level gap Δ of the system, by varying Δ not only along the isoentropics, but also along the isotherms. This is possible by means of the recently suggested maser-laser tandem technique. We base our proof on the general thermodynamic equilibrium properties of a two-level system together with a careful distinction between the Gibbs relation d E = T d S + ( E /Δ) dΔ and the energy balance equation . We derive bounds to the net-work to high-temperature-heat ratio (energy efficiency) for a Carnot cycle and for the "inscribed" Otto-like cycle. By representing these cycles on useful thermodynamic diagrams, we infer and confirm important aspects of the second law of thermodynamics.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/99/20005

Related papers

Efficiency of a quantum Otto heat engine based on a two-level system

Rogério Jorge de Assis

Classical thermodynamics, also called equilibrium thermodynamics, is a theory that deals with macroscopic systems in equilibrium. After its development, other theories emerged to encompass macroscopic out-of-equilibrium systems. Over the past few decades, researchers have developed a new theory to describe also the thermodynamics of microscopic quantum systems, which became known as quantum thermodynamics. An important application of this theory is in the development of heat engines in which the working substance (the substance responsible for transforming heat into work) is a microscopic quantum system. Due to their composition, these devices came to be commonly called quantum heat engines. Notably, recent studies have shown that using an out-of-equilibrium reservoir as a heat source can improve the performance of quantum heat engines, compared to the usual case where the heat source is an equilibrium reservoir (a thermal reservoir). In this context, this thesis presents two studies related to a quantum Otto heat engine whose working substance is a two-level system: in the first study, the engine has a squeezed thermal reservoir as the heat source, while in the second study, the heat source is a reservoir with a negative temperature. Both studies explore the finite-time regime of the expansion and compression stages of the heat engine. The first study shows that the engine efficiency can be greater than the Carnot efficiency in both the quasi-static and finite-time regimes. However, as in the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages degrades the engine efficiency. In its turn, the second study shows that the engine efficiency can surpass the Otto efficiency in the finite-time regime. Here, different from the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages can increase the engine's efficiency. Finally, the present thesis shows an experimental scheme in the nuclear magnetic resonance context able to provide a proof of concept for the engine in the different situations studied.

•Dec 9, 2021•0 citations

Quantum thermodynamic cycles and quantum heat engines

H. T. Quan, Yu-xi Liu, C. P. Sun +1 more

In order to describe quantum heat engines, here we systematically study isothermal and isochoric processes for quantum thermodynamic cycles. Based on these results the quantum versions of both the Carnot heat engine and the Otto heat engine are defined without ambiguities. We also study the properties of quantum Carnot and Otto heat engines in comparison with their classical counterparts. Relations and mappings between these two quantum heat engines are also investigated by considering their respective quantum thermodynamic processes. In addition, we discuss the role of Maxwell's demon in quantum thermodynamic cycles. We find that there is no violation of the second law, even in the existence of such a demon, when the demon is included correctly as part of the working substance of the heat engine.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611275•Physical Review E•Sep 7, 2007•812 citations

Two-level quantum Otto heat engine operating with unit efficiency far from the quasi-static regime under a squeezed reservoir

Rogério J de Assis, José S Sales, Udson C. Mendes +1 more

Abstract Recent theoretical and experimental studies in quantum heat engines show that, in the quasi-static regime, it is possible to have higher efficiency than the limit imposed by Carnot, provided that engineered reservoirs are used. The quasi-static regime, however, is a strong limitation to the operation of heat engines, since an infinitely long time is required to complete a cycle. In this paper we propose a two-level model as the working substance to perform a quantum Otto heat engine surrounded by a cold thermal reservoir and a squeezed hot thermal reservoir. Taking advantage of this model we show a striking achievement, that is to attain unity efficiency even at non-null power.

arXiv:2003.12664•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Dec 2, 2020•24 citations

Comparative study of quantum Otto and Carnot engines powered by a spin working substance

Mahmoud Youssef Abd‐Rabbou, Atta Ur Rahman, Mikhail A. Yurischev +1 more

Quantum Otto and Carnot engines have recently been receiving attention due to their ability to achieve high efficiencies and powers based on the laws of quantum mechanics. This paper discusses the theory, progress, and possible applications of quantum Otto and Carnot engines, such as energy production, cooling, and nanoscale technologies. In particular, we investigate a two-spin Heisenberg system that works as a substance in quantum Otto and Carnot cycles while exposed to an external magnetic field with both Dzyaloshinsky-Moriya and dipole-dipole interactions. The four stages of engine cycles are subject to analysis with respect to the heat exchanges that occur between the hot and cold reservoirs, alongside the work done during each stage. The operating conditions of the heat engine, refrigerator, thermal accelerator, and heater are all achieved. Moreover, our results demonstrate that the laws of thermodynamics are strictly upheld and the Carnot cycle produces more useful work than that of the Otto cycle.

Physical review. E•Sep 7, 2023•34 citations

Efficiency at maximum power of a heat engine working with a two-level atomic system

Rui Wang, Jianhui Wang, Jizhou He +1 more

We consider the finite-time operation of a quantum heat engine whose working substance is composed of a two-level atomic system. The engine cycle, consisting of two quantum adiabatic and two quantum isochoric (constant-frequency) processes and working between two heat reservoirs at temperatures ${T}_{h}$ and ${T}_{c}$$(<$${T}_{h})$, is a quantum version of the classical Otto cycle. By optimizing the power output with respect to two frequencies, we obtain the efficiency at maximum power output (EMP) and analyze numerically the effects of the times taken for two adiabatic and two isochoric processes on the EMP. In the absence of internally dissipative friction, we find that the EMP is bounded from the upper side by a function of the Carnot efficiency ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}$, ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{+}={\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}^{2}/[{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}\ensuremath{-}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})\mathrm{ln}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})]$, with ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}=1\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}/{T}_{h}$. This analytic expression is confirmed by our exact numerical result and is identical to the one derived in an engine model based on a mesoscopic or macroscopic system. If the internal friction is included, we find that the EMP decreases as the friction coefficient increases.

Physical Review E•Apr 23, 2013•77 citations

Efficiency at maximum power of a quantum Otto cycle within finite-time or irreversible thermodynamics

Feilong Wu, Jizhou He, Yongli Ma +1 more

We consider the efficiency at maximum power of a quantum Otto engine, which uses a spin or a harmonic system as its working substance and works between two heat reservoirs at constant temperatures ${T}_{h}$ and ${T}_{c}$ $(<{T}_{h})$. Although the behavior of spin-$1/2$ system differs substantially from that of the harmonic system in that they obey two typical quantum statistics, the efficiencies at maximum power based on these two different kinds of quantum systems are bounded from the upper side by the same expression ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{mp}}\ensuremath{\le}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{+}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}^{2}/[{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}\ensuremath{-}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})ln(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})]$ with ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}=1\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}/{T}_{h}$ as the Carnot efficiency. This expression ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{mp}}$ possesses the same universality of the CA efficiency ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{CA}}=1\ensuremath{-}\sqrt{1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}}$ at small relative temperature difference. Within the context of irreversible thermodynamics, we calculate the Onsager coefficients and show that the value of ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{CA}}$ is indeed the upper bound of EMP for an Otto engine working in the linear-response regime.

arXiv:1408.5467•Physical Review E•Dec 22, 2014•40 citations
Within the recent revival of interest in quantum heat engines between two thermal reservoirs whereby the working substance is a two-level system, it has been suggested that the celebrated Carnot heat-to-work conversion efficiency 1 − ( T low / T high ) cannot be reached. Contrary to this suggestion, we show that reaching the Carnot bound not only is not impossible and does not require an infinite number of heat baths and infinitesimal processes, but it is also within reach of the current experimental techniques. It is sufficient to cycle smoothly (slowly) over at least three (in general four) values of the tunable energy level gap Δ of the system, by varying Δ not only along the isoentropics, but also along the isotherms. This is possible by means of the recently suggested maser-laser tandem technique. We base our proof on the general thermodynamic equilibrium properties of a two-level system together with a careful distinction between the Gibbs relation d E = T d S + ( E /Δ) dΔ and the energy balance equation . We derive bounds to the net-work to high-temperature-heat ratio (energy efficiency) for a Carnot cycle and for the "inscribed" Otto-like cycle. By representing these cycles on useful thermodynamic diagrams, we infer and confirm important aspects of the second law of thermodynamics.
Classical thermodynamics, also called equilibrium thermodynamics, is a theory that deals with macroscopic systems in equilibrium. After its development, other theories emerged to encompass macroscopic out-of-equilibrium systems. Over the past few decades, researchers have developed a new theory to describe also the thermodynamics of microscopic quantum systems, which became known as quantum thermodynamics. An important application of this theory is in the development of heat engines in which the working substance (the substance responsible for transforming heat into work) is a microscopic quantum system. Due to their composition, these devices came to be commonly called quantum heat engines. Notably, recent studies have shown that using an out-of-equilibrium reservoir as a heat source can improve the performance of quantum heat engines, compared to the usual case where the heat source is an equilibrium reservoir (a thermal reservoir). In this context, this thesis presents two studies related to a quantum Otto heat engine whose working substance is a two-level system: in the first study, the engine has a squeezed thermal reservoir as the heat source, while in the second study, the heat source is a reservoir with a negative temperature. Both studies explore the finite-time regime of the expansion and compression stages of the heat engine. The first study shows that the engine efficiency can be greater than the Carnot efficiency in both the quasi-static and finite-time regimes. However, as in the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages degrades the engine efficiency. In its turn, the second study shows that the engine efficiency can surpass the Otto efficiency in the finite-time regime. Here, different from the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages can increase the engine's efficiency. Finally, the present thesis shows an experimental scheme in the nuclear magnetic resonance context able to provide a proof of concept for the engine in the different situations studied.
In order to describe quantum heat engines, here we systematically study isothermal and isochoric processes for quantum thermodynamic cycles. Based on these results the quantum versions of both the Carnot heat engine and the Otto heat engine are defined without ambiguities. We also study the properties of quantum Carnot and Otto heat engines in comparison with their classical counterparts. Relations and mappings between these two quantum heat engines are also investigated by considering their respective quantum thermodynamic processes. In addition, we discuss the role of Maxwell's demon in quantum thermodynamic cycles. We find that there is no violation of the second law, even in the existence of such a demon, when the demon is included correctly as part of the working substance of the heat engine.
Abstract Recent theoretical and experimental studies in quantum heat engines show that, in the quasi-static regime, it is possible to have higher efficiency than the limit imposed by Carnot, provided that engineered reservoirs are used. The quasi-static regime, however, is a strong limitation to the operation of heat engines, since an infinitely long time is required to complete a cycle. In this paper we propose a two-level model as the working substance to perform a quantum Otto heat engine surrounded by a cold thermal reservoir and a squeezed hot thermal reservoir. Taking advantage of this model we show a striking achievement, that is to attain unity efficiency even at non-null power.
Quantum Otto and Carnot engines have recently been receiving attention due to their ability to achieve high efficiencies and powers based on the laws of quantum mechanics. This paper discusses the theory, progress, and possible applications of quantum Otto and Carnot engines, such as energy production, cooling, and nanoscale technologies. In particular, we investigate a two-spin Heisenberg system that works as a substance in quantum Otto and Carnot cycles while exposed to an external magnetic field with both Dzyaloshinsky-Moriya and dipole-dipole interactions. The four stages of engine cycles are subject to analysis with respect to the heat exchanges that occur between the hot and cold reservoirs, alongside the work done during each stage. The operating conditions of the heat engine, refrigerator, thermal accelerator, and heater are all achieved. Moreover, our results demonstrate that the laws of thermodynamics are strictly upheld and the Carnot cycle produces more useful work than that of the Otto cycle.
We consider the finite-time operation of a quantum heat engine whose working substance is composed of a two-level atomic system. The engine cycle, consisting of two quantum adiabatic and two quantum isochoric (constant-frequency) processes and working between two heat reservoirs at temperatures Th{T}_{h}Th​ and Tc{T}_{c}Tc​(<(<(<Th){T}_{h})Th​), is a quantum version of the classical Otto cycle. By optimizing the power output with respect to two frequencies, we obtain the efficiency at maximum power output (EMP) and analyze numerically the effects of the times taken for two adiabatic and two isochoric processes on the EMP. In the absence of internally dissipative friction, we find that the EMP is bounded from the upper side by a function of the Carnot efficiency ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}$, ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{+}={\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}^{2}/[{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}\ensuremath{-}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})\mathrm{ln}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})]$, with ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}=1\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}/{T}_{h}$. This analytic expression is confirmed by our exact numerical result and is identical to the one derived in an engine model based on a mesoscopic or macroscopic system. If the internal friction is included, we find that the EMP decreases as the friction coefficient increases.
We consider the efficiency at maximum power of a quantum Otto engine, which uses a spin or a harmonic system as its working substance and works between two heat reservoirs at constant temperatures Th{T}_{h}Th​ and Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ (<Th)(<{T}_{h})(<Th​). Although the behavior of spin-1/21/21/2 system differs substantially from that of the harmonic system in that they obey two typical quantum statistics, the efficiencies at maximum power based on these two different kinds of quantum systems are bounded from the upper side by the same expression ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{mp}}\ensuremath{\le}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{+}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}^{2}/[{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}\ensuremath{-}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})ln(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})]$ with ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}=1\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}/{T}_{h}$ as the Carnot efficiency. This expression ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{mp}}$ possesses the same universality of the CA efficiency ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{CA}}=1\ensuremath{-}\sqrt{1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}}$ at small relative temperature difference. Within the context of irreversible thermodynamics, we calculate the Onsager coefficients and show that the value of ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\mathrm{CA}}$ is indeed the upper bound of EMP for an Otto engine working in the linear-response regime.