Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0612005

Quantum complimentarity, erasers and photons

Aloysius F. Kracklauer

Published Dec 1, 2006• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Optical experiments designed to explore quantum complementarity are reanalyzed. It is argued that, for each, a classical explanation is not only possible, but more coherent and less contrived. The final conclusion is that these experiments actually constitute support for criticism of the photon paradigm of electric charged particle interaction. They offer little or nothing to say about quantum complementarity once the photon concept is not imposed by mandate.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0612005

Related papers

Phase-selective quantum eraser

Axel Heuer, Gregor Pieplow, R. Menzel

A quantum-eraser experiment with photon pairs coupled via induced coherence is reported, and the complementarity between which-source information and two-photon-interference-fringe visibility is demonstrated.

arXiv:1501.00817•Physical Review A•Jul 2, 2015•5 citations

The Quantum Eraser Does Not Always Erase

António Cardoso, João L. Cordovil, J. R. Croca

In this paper we will first look at a particular quantum eraser setup to show that this type of experiments can be understood in an intuitive manner if we are willing to take a complex nonlinear approach, without the need to invoke Niels Bohr's complementarity or quantum entanglement between two particles. We will then discuss a recent experiment of the same type that does not erase the interference pattern when which-path information is available, and argue that this result is in clear contradiction with the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics but perfectly understandable in the framework of nonlinear quantum physics.

arXiv:1503.07583•Journal of Advanced Physics•Mar 16, 2016•3 citations

Optical Tests of Foundations of Quantum Theory

Yanhua H. Shih

From the point of view of classical theory and our everyday experience, quantum phenomena are surprising and the concepts of quantum mechanics are incomprehensible. Since the beginning of quantum theory scientists questioned its very basic concepts, such as locality, reality, and complementarity, and proposed gedankenexperiments , or thought experiments, to probe its foundations. In the light of new optical technology we have been able to realize some of these experiments. This chapter will focus on three of them: (1) EPR-Bohm-Bell correlation and Bell’s inequality; (2) Scully’s quantum eraser; (3) Popper’s experiment. The results of these experiments are very interesting. On one hand, the experimental observations confirm the predictions of EPR-Bell, Scully, and Popper. On the other hand, the calculations from quantum theory perfectly agree with the experimental data. Moreover, apparently, the experimental observations do not lead to any “violations” of the principles of quantum mechanics. One important conclusion we may draw from these optical tests is that all the observations are the results of multi-photon interference: a group of photons interferes with the group itself at distance. The nonlocal multi-photon interference phenomena may never be understood in classical theory, however, it is legitimate in quantum mechanics. The superposition principle of quantum theory supports the superposition of multi-photon amplitudes, whether the photons are entangled or randomly grouped and despite the distances between these individual photodetection events. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2016•1 citation

Comment on "On Phase Selective Quantum Eraser" (arXiv:1501.00817 [quant-ph])

Luiz Carlos Ryff

In a recent interesting article A. Heuer, G. Pieplow, and R. Menzel discuss a quantum-eraser experiment to investigate the complementarity of wave-like and particle-like behavior of photons. I would like to draw your attention to the fact that the very same experimental setup was suggested in a previous paper, and take advantage of this opportunity to examine some aspects of this controversial subject.

arXiv:1509.04673•Sep 15, 2015•1 citation

What do correlations tell us about photons?

Aloysius F. Kracklauer

Finding a model or paradigm to capture the essence of light, is an enterprise of historic legend. The two main contenders, particle beams and waves have alternated in acceptance, with each ultimately proving unsatisfactory. Currently, the particle variant is predominant, but with strong caveats encompassed in Bohr's Principle of Complementarity. Herein a study of correlated pairs of photons is presented. It reveals additional challenges for the particle paradigm. Finally, it is suggested that as neither of these two paradigms is optimal, the direct-interaction paradigm as originally introduced by Schwarzschild deserves further consideration.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 26, 2007•4 citations

Three proposed ‘‘quantum erasers’’

Paul G. Kwiat, Aephraim M. Steinberg, R. Y. Chiao

Interaction with a measuring apparatus can cause otherwise interfering paths of a particle to become distinguishable. Under some conditions, however, it is possible to ``erase'' the distinguishability, thereby restoring interference. The concept of a quantum eraser is useful for understanding the role of entanglement in interference. Several attempts to investigate the phenomenon have been made using the correlated photons from spontaneous parametric down-conversion. However, none of the experiments previously performed in connection with quantum erasure has provided an optimal demonstration. We propose three improved down-conversion schemes, each of which satisfies all the criteria for a true quantum eraser. As the proposed schemes are all modifications or combinations of previously completed experiments, they are deemed to be feasible.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1994•95 citations
Optical experiments designed to explore quantum complementarity are reanalyzed. It is argued that, for each, a classical explanation is not only possible, but more coherent and less contrived. The final conclusion is that these experiments actually constitute support for criticism of the photon paradigm of electric charged particle interaction. They offer little or nothing to say about quantum complementarity once the photon concept is not imposed by mandate.
In this paper we will first look at a particular quantum eraser setup to show that this type of experiments can be understood in an intuitive manner if we are willing to take a complex nonlinear approach, without the need to invoke Niels Bohr's complementarity or quantum entanglement between two particles. We will then discuss a recent experiment of the same type that does not erase the interference pattern when which-path information is available, and argue that this result is in clear contradiction with the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics but perfectly understandable in the framework of nonlinear quantum physics.
From the point of view of classical theory and our everyday experience, quantum phenomena are surprising and the concepts of quantum mechanics are incomprehensible. Since the beginning of quantum theory scientists questioned its very basic concepts, such as locality, reality, and complementarity, and proposed gedankenexperiments , or thought experiments, to probe its foundations. In the light of new optical technology we have been able to realize some of these experiments. This chapter will focus on three of them: (1) EPR-Bohm-Bell correlation and Bell’s inequality; (2) Scully’s quantum eraser; (3) Popper’s experiment. The results of these experiments are very interesting. On one hand, the experimental observations confirm the predictions of EPR-Bell, Scully, and Popper. On the other hand, the calculations from quantum theory perfectly agree with the experimental data. Moreover, apparently, the experimental observations do not lead to any “violations” of the principles of quantum mechanics. One important conclusion we may draw from these optical tests is that all the observations are the results of multi-photon interference: a group of photons interferes with the group itself at distance. The nonlocal multi-photon interference phenomena may never be understood in classical theory, however, it is legitimate in quantum mechanics. The superposition principle of quantum theory supports the superposition of multi-photon amplitudes, whether the photons are entangled or randomly grouped and despite the distances between these individual photodetection events. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Finding a model or paradigm to capture the essence of light, is an enterprise of historic legend. The two main contenders, particle beams and waves have alternated in acceptance, with each ultimately proving unsatisfactory. Currently, the particle variant is predominant, but with strong caveats encompassed in Bohr's Principle of Complementarity. Herein a study of correlated pairs of photons is presented. It reveals additional challenges for the particle paradigm. Finally, it is suggested that as neither of these two paradigms is optimal, the direct-interaction paradigm as originally introduced by Schwarzschild deserves further consideration.
Interaction with a measuring apparatus can cause otherwise interfering paths of a particle to become distinguishable. Under some conditions, however, it is possible to ``erase'' the distinguishability, thereby restoring interference. The concept of a quantum eraser is useful for understanding the role of entanglement in interference. Several attempts to investigate the phenomenon have been made using the correlated photons from spontaneous parametric down-conversion. However, none of the experiments previously performed in connection with quantum erasure has provided an optimal demonstration. We propose three improved down-conversion schemes, each of which satisfies all the criteria for a true quantum eraser. As the proposed schemes are all modifications or combinations of previously completed experiments, they are deemed to be feasible.