Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0611201 · Physical Review A

Power of unentangled measurements on two antiparallel spins

Tamás Vértesi

Published Mar 28, 2007• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a pair of antiparallel spins polarized in a random direction to encode quantum information. We wish to extract as much information as possible on the polarization direction attainable by an unentangled measurement, i.e., by a measurement whose outcomes are associated with product states. We develop analytically the upper bound $0.7935\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\text{bits}$ to the Shannon mutual information obtainable by an unentangled measurement, which is definitely less than the value $0.8664\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\text{bits}$ attained by an entangled measurement. This proves our main result, that not every ensemble of product states can be optimally distinguished by an unentangled measurement, if the measure of distinguishability is defined in the sense of Shannon. We also present results from numerical calculations and discuss briefly the case of parallel spins.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.75.032343

Related papers

Information–disturbance tradeoff in sending direction information via antiparallel quantum spin

ShengLi Zhang, Xu‐Bo Zou, ChuanFeng Li +2 more

For sending unknown direction information, antiparallel spins contains more direction information than parallel spins(Gisin and Popescu, 1999, \textit{Phys. Rev. Lett.} 83, 432).In this paper, the optimal information-disturbance tradeoff bound for antiparallel spins is derived. The quantum measurements which attain the optimal tradeoff bound are obtained. This result can be of practical relevance for posing some general limits on Eve's eavesdropping process. Finally, we also present a comparison between the bound for antiparallel spins and the bound for parallel spins.

arXiv:1106.6170•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 13, 2010•5 citations

DISTINGUISHING UNENTANGLED STATES WITH AN UNENTANGLED MEASUREMENT

William K. Wootters

In a 1991 paper, Asher Peres and the author theoretically analyzed a set of unentangled bipartite quantum states that could apparently be distinguished better by a global measurement than by any sequence of local measurements on the individual subsystems. The present paper returns to the same example, and shows that the best result so far achieved can alternatively be attained by a measurement that, while still global, is "unentangled" in the sense that the operator associated with each measurement outcome is a tensor product.

arXiv:quant-ph/0506149•International Journal of Quantum Information•Feb 1, 2006•33 citations

Distinguishability of tripartite unextendible product basis using local operations and classical communication

Michael Durocher

Quantum states must be distinguished every time information is extracted from a system.Local distinguishability is on par with entanglement as being a defining characteristic of quantum mechanics.In this thesis, I optimize state distiguishability of a tripartite system with different measurement settings.Specifically, I analyze the smallest tripartite Unextendible Product Basis (UPB), known as SHIFTS.This UPB has interesting symmetries and exhibits nonlocality without entanglement.I consider the case in which the parties are restricted to Local Operations and Classical Communication, which makes perfect distinguishability impossible here.My work is an important step towards a full quantitative analysis of local information available in locally indistinguishable sets of states.I discuss my discovery of optimal (maximal mutual information) protocols for partially distinguishing SHIFTS.In particular, I present a protocol which is optimal among all protocols consisting only of projective measurements.I show that a certain type of three-outcome measurement can outperform projective measurements for certain input states probability distributions.I claim that this is not the case for SHIFTS.D Calculation of (H) and Generation of a Corresponding C Programming Language Function 130 D.1 Initialization 130 D.2 Definitions 130 D.2.1 Normalization of a discrete probability distribution 131 D.2.2 Shannon entropy 132 D.2.3 Non-deterministic projective measurements/probabilities 134 D.2.4 Non-deterministic POVM measurements/probabilities 136 vii D.2. 5 Probability distributions normalized weighting D.2.6 States D.2.7 Assumptions D.3 Calculations D.3.1 Initial situation D.3.2 Alice's measurement D.3.3 Bob's measurement D.3.4 Charlie's measurement D.3.5 Shannon entropies IE Discussion of Precision of Numerical Results E.1 Evaluation of (H) E.2 Finding a Global Minimum in One Dimension E.3 Finding a Global Minimum in Multi-dimensions E.4 Precision of Individual Results E.4.1 Protocol 1 E.4.2 Protocol 2 E.4.3 Protocol 3 E.4.4 Protocol 4 and Claim 5.1 E.4.5 Proposition 5.4 E.4.6 Claim 5.5 viii List of Tables 1.1 Four states and corresponding binary representations 3.1 SHIFTS UPB labels 4.1 Bob's prior distribution when Alice measures 0 5.1 Prior distribution leading to superiority of trine over projective measurements B. 1 Output from optimization of an isosceles trifle measurements protocol . . .ix List of Figures 1.1 Decomposition of a choice with three possibilities into two steps 2.1 Pentagonal base pyramid used to construct the PYRAMID UPB 3.1 Bloch circle on the Bloch sphere 3.2 Stern-Gerlach apparatuses implementation of a protocol 3.3 Example of a tree representation of a protocol 3.4 Four transformations of a simplex 4.1 Projective measurement on the Bloch circle 4.2 Measurement tree for Protocol 1 4.3 Measurement tree for Protocol 2 4.4 Bob's Shannon entropy when distinguishing local states 5.1 Bloch circle representation of a general trine measurement 5.2 Optimal projective and equilateral trifle optimal measurements 5.3 Shannon entropy after projective and equilateral trifle measurements .5.4 Isosceles trine measurement representation x

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Spin Flips and Quantum Information for Antiparallel Spins

Nicolas Gisin, Sandu Popescu

We consider two different ways to encode quantum information, by parallel or antiparallel pairs of spins. We find that there is more information in the antiparallel ones. This purely quantum mechanical effect is due to entanglement, not of the states but occurring in the course of the measuring process. We also introduce a range of quantum information processing machines, such as spin flip and anticloning.

arXiv:quant-ph/9901072•Physical Review Letters•Jul 12, 1999•257 citations

Experimental Optimal Orienteering via Parallel and Antiparallel Spins

Jun-Feng Tang, Zhibo Hou, Jiangwei Shang +4 more

Antiparallel spins are superior in orienteering to parallel spins. This intriguing phenomenon is tied to entanglement associated with quantum measurements rather than quantum states. Using photonic systems, we experimentally realize the optimal orienteering protocols based on parallel spins and antiparallel spins, respectively. The optimal entangling measurements for decoding the direction information from parallel spins and antiparallel spins are realized using photonic quantum walks, which is a useful idea that is of wide interest in quantum information processing and foundational studies. Our experiments clearly demonstrate the advantage of antiparallel spins over parallel spins in orienteering. In addition, entangling measurements can extract more information than local measurements even if no entanglement is present in the quantum states.

arXiv:2002.07364•Physical Review Letters•Feb 13, 2020•31 citations

Collective versus local measurements on two parallel or antiparallel spins

Serge Massar

We give a complete analysis of covariant measurements on two spins. We consider the cases of two parallel and two antiparallel spins, and we consider both collective measurements on the two spins and measurements that require only local quantum operations and classical communication (LOCC). In all cases we obtain the optimal measurements for arbitrary fidelities. In particular, we show that if the aim is to determine as accurately as possible the direction in which the spins are pointing, it is best to carry out measurements on antiparallel spins (as already shown by Gisin and Popescu), second best to carry out measurements on parallel spins, and worst to be restricted to LOCC measurements. If the aim is to determine as accurately as possible a direction orthogonal to that in which the spins are pointing, it is best to carry out measurements on parallel spins, whereas measurements on antiparallel spins and LOCC measurements are both less suitable but equivalent.

arXiv:quant-ph/0004035•Physical Review A•Sep 19, 2000•55 citations
We consider a pair of antiparallel spins polarized in a random direction to encode quantum information. We wish to extract as much information as possible on the polarization direction attainable by an unentangled measurement, i.e., by a measurement whose outcomes are associated with product states. We develop analytically the upper bound 0.7935bits0.7935\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\text{bits}0.7935bits to the Shannon mutual information obtainable by an unentangled measurement, which is definitely less than the value 0.8664bits0.8664\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\text{bits}0.8664bits attained by an entangled measurement. This proves our main result, that not every ensemble of product states can be optimally distinguished by an unentangled measurement, if the measure of distinguishability is defined in the sense of Shannon. We also present results from numerical calculations and discuss briefly the case of parallel spins.
For sending unknown direction information, antiparallel spins contains more direction information than parallel spins(Gisin and Popescu, 1999, \textit{Phys. Rev. Lett.} 83, 432).In this paper, the optimal information-disturbance tradeoff bound for antiparallel spins is derived. The quantum measurements which attain the optimal tradeoff bound are obtained. This result can be of practical relevance for posing some general limits on Eve's eavesdropping process. Finally, we also present a comparison between the bound for antiparallel spins and the bound for parallel spins.
In a 1991 paper, Asher Peres and the author theoretically analyzed a set of unentangled bipartite quantum states that could apparently be distinguished better by a global measurement than by any sequence of local measurements on the individual subsystems. The present paper returns to the same example, and shows that the best result so far achieved can alternatively be attained by a measurement that, while still global, is "unentangled" in the sense that the operator associated with each measurement outcome is a tensor product.
Quantum states must be distinguished every time information is extracted from a system.Local distinguishability is on par with entanglement as being a defining characteristic of quantum mechanics.In this thesis, I optimize state distiguishability of a tripartite system with different measurement settings.Specifically, I analyze the smallest tripartite Unextendible Product Basis (UPB), known as SHIFTS.This UPB has interesting symmetries and exhibits nonlocality without entanglement.I consider the case in which the parties are restricted to Local Operations and Classical Communication, which makes perfect distinguishability impossible here.My work is an important step towards a full quantitative analysis of local information available in locally indistinguishable sets of states.I discuss my discovery of optimal (maximal mutual information) protocols for partially distinguishing SHIFTS.In particular, I present a protocol which is optimal among all protocols consisting only of projective measurements.I show that a certain type of three-outcome measurement can outperform projective measurements for certain input states probability distributions.I claim that this is not the case for SHIFTS.D Calculation of (H) and Generation of a Corresponding C Programming Language Function 130 D.1 Initialization 130 D.2 Definitions 130 D.2.1 Normalization of a discrete probability distribution 131 D.2.2 Shannon entropy 132 D.2.3 Non-deterministic projective measurements/probabilities 134 D.2.4 Non-deterministic POVM measurements/probabilities 136 vii D.2. 5 Probability distributions normalized weighting D.2.6 States D.2.7 Assumptions D.3 Calculations D.3.1 Initial situation D.3.2 Alice's measurement D.3.3 Bob's measurement D.3.4 Charlie's measurement D.3.5 Shannon entropies IE Discussion of Precision of Numerical Results E.1 Evaluation of (H) E.2 Finding a Global Minimum in One Dimension E.3 Finding a Global Minimum in Multi-dimensions E.4 Precision of Individual Results E.4.1 Protocol 1 E.4.2 Protocol 2 E.4.3 Protocol 3 E.4.4 Protocol 4 and Claim 5.1 E.4.5 Proposition 5.4 E.4.6 Claim 5.5 viii List of Tables 1.1 Four states and corresponding binary representations 3.1 SHIFTS UPB labels 4.1 Bob's prior distribution when Alice measures 0 5.1 Prior distribution leading to superiority of trine over projective measurements B. 1 Output from optimization of an isosceles trifle measurements protocol . . .ix List of Figures 1.1 Decomposition of a choice with three possibilities into two steps 2.1 Pentagonal base pyramid used to construct the PYRAMID UPB 3.1 Bloch circle on the Bloch sphere 3.2 Stern-Gerlach apparatuses implementation of a protocol 3.3 Example of a tree representation of a protocol 3.4 Four transformations of a simplex 4.1 Projective measurement on the Bloch circle 4.2 Measurement tree for Protocol 1 4.3 Measurement tree for Protocol 2 4.4 Bob's Shannon entropy when distinguishing local states 5.1 Bloch circle representation of a general trine measurement 5.2 Optimal projective and equilateral trifle optimal measurements 5.3 Shannon entropy after projective and equilateral trifle measurements .5.4 Isosceles trine measurement representation x
Antiparallel spins are superior in orienteering to parallel spins. This intriguing phenomenon is tied to entanglement associated with quantum measurements rather than quantum states. Using photonic systems, we experimentally realize the optimal orienteering protocols based on parallel spins and antiparallel spins, respectively. The optimal entangling measurements for decoding the direction information from parallel spins and antiparallel spins are realized using photonic quantum walks, which is a useful idea that is of wide interest in quantum information processing and foundational studies. Our experiments clearly demonstrate the advantage of antiparallel spins over parallel spins in orienteering. In addition, entangling measurements can extract more information than local measurements even if no entanglement is present in the quantum states.
We give a complete analysis of covariant measurements on two spins. We consider the cases of two parallel and two antiparallel spins, and we consider both collective measurements on the two spins and measurements that require only local quantum operations and classical communication (LOCC). In all cases we obtain the optimal measurements for arbitrary fidelities. In particular, we show that if the aim is to determine as accurately as possible the direction in which the spins are pointing, it is best to carry out measurements on antiparallel spins (as already shown by Gisin and Popescu), second best to carry out measurements on parallel spins, and worst to be restricted to LOCC measurements. If the aim is to determine as accurately as possible a direction orthogonal to that in which the spins are pointing, it is best to carry out measurements on parallel spins, whereas measurements on antiparallel spins and LOCC measurements are both less suitable but equivalent.