Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0609226 · Quantum Information and Computation

General classes of impossible operations through the existence of incomparable states

Indrani Chattopadhyay, D. Sarkar

Published May 1, 2007• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this work we show that the most general class of anti-unitary operators are nonphysical in nature through the existence of incomparable pure bipartite entangled states. It is also shown that a large class of inner-product-preserving operations defined only on the three qubits having spin-directions along x,y and z are impossible. If we perform such an operation locally on a particular pure bipartite state then it will exactly transform to another pure bipartite state that is incomparable with the original one. As subcases of the above results we find the nonphysical nature of universal exact flipping operation and existence of universal Hadamard gate. Beyond the information conservation in terms of entanglement, this work shows how an impossible local operation evolve with the joint system in a nonphysical way.

DOI
10.26421/qic7.4-8

Related papers

Impossibility of exact flipping of three arbitrary quantum states via incomparability

Indrani Chattopadhyay, Debasis Sarkar

We present here a scheme that relates seemingly two different kinds of physical impossibilities of quantum information processing. We derive, exact flipping of three arbitrary states not lying in one great circle is not possible with certainty, by using the existence of incomparable states which are not interconvertible deterministically by local operations and classical communications. In contrast, considering the nonexistence of exact universal flipper, the incomparability of a pair of bipartite pure entangled states can be established.

arXiv:quant-ph/0511040•Physical Review A•Apr 21, 2006•12 citations

Entanglement - A Queer In The World Of Quantum : Some Perspectives

Indrani Chattopadhyay

The work is intended to represent some interesting and apparently peculiar features of entangled system in both pure as well as mixed states level. In the pure state level, we are largely concerned about the existence and characteristics of bipartite incomparable pair of states. We have found some schemes for local transformation of one pure bipartite state to another, incomparable in nature, by exploiting free unpreserved entanglement. Also, we observed that different incomparable pair of states in $3\times 3$ may co-operate with each other to cross the barrier of incomparability. Our next goal was to probe critically the roots of the existence of incomparable states. We have succeeded in connecting incomparability with some famous no-go theorems of quantum mechanics. We have established it with no-flipping principle, general anti-unitary operators and lastly with inner product preserving operations. Thus we are able to pose incomparability as a good detector of some non-physical operations. In the next part, we provide a new class of multipartite bound entanglement in mixed state level. The class of states are activable bound entangled. There are exactly four orthogonal activable bound entangled states in any even number of qubit system. They have some interesting features like Bell correlation, permutation symmetry, local Pauli connection, non-compatibility, etc. Apart from those properties, the class of bound entangled states have the remarkable feature of local indistinguishability in quantum systems.

arXiv:0805.2056•May 14, 2008•0 citations

Deterministic Local Conversion of Incomparable States by Collective LOCC

Indrani Chattopadhyay, D. Sarkar

Incomparability of pure bipartite entangled states under deterministic LOCC is a very strange phenomena. We find two possible ways of getting our desired pure entangled state which is incomparable with the given input state, by collective LOCC with certainty. The first one is by providing some pure entanglement through the lower dimensional maximally-entangled states or using further less amount of entanglement and the next one is by collective operation on two pairs which are individually incomparable. It is quite surprising that we are able to achieve maximally entangled states of any Schmidt rank from a finite number of 2x2 pure entangled states only by deterministic LOCC. We provide general theory for the case of 3x3 system of incomparable states by the above processes where incomparability seems to be the most hardest one.

arXiv:quant-ph/0409174•Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2005•7 citations

General entanglement-assisted transformation for bipartite pure quantum states

Wei Song, Yan Hua Huang, Nai-Le Liu +1 more

We introduce the general catalysts for pure entanglement transformations under local operations and classical communications in such a way that we disregard the profit and loss of entanglement of the catalysts per se. As such, the possibilities of pure entanglement transformations are greatly expanded. Remarkably, we find an interesting phenomenon that, in some situations, incomparable pairs ${| ψ> ,| ϕ> \} $ and ${| χ> ,| χ^{\prime}> \} $ can assist each other mutually so as to realize the transformation $| ψ> | χ> \to| ϕ> | χ^{\prime}>$. We also design an efficient algorithm to detect whether a $k\times k$ general catalyst exists for a given entanglement transformation. This algorithm can as well be exploited to witness the existence of standard catalysts.

arXiv:quant-ph/0603085•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 9, 2007•2 citations

Resource Theory of Entanglement with a Unique Multipartite Maximally Entangled State

Patricia Contreras-Tejada, Carlos Palazuelos, Julio I. de Vicente

Entanglement theory is formulated as a quantum resource theory in which the free operations are local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This defines a partial order among bipartite pure states that makes it possible to identify a maximally entangled state, which turns out to be the most relevant state in applications. However, the situation changes drastically in the multipartite regime. Not only do there exist inequivalent forms of entanglement forbidding the existence of a unique maximally entangled state, but recent results have shown that LOCC induces a trivial ordering: almost all pure entangled multipartite states are incomparable (i.e., LOCC transformations among them are almost never possible). In order to cope with this problem we consider alternative resource theories in which we relax the class of LOCC to operations that do not create entanglement. We consider two possible theories depending on whether resources correspond to multipartite entangled or genuinely multipartite entangled (GME) states and we show that they are both nontrivial: no inequivalent forms of entanglement exist in them and they induce a meaningful partial order (i.e., every pure state is transformable to more weakly entangled pure states). Moreover, we prove that the resource theory of GME that we formulate here has a unique maximally entangled state, the generalized GHZ state, which can be transformed to any other state by the allowed free operations.

arXiv:1807.11395•Physical Review Letters•Mar 28, 2019•96 citations

No-masking theorem for observables

Swapnil Bhowmick, Abhay Srivastav, Arun Kumar Pati

The no-masking theorem for quantum information proves that it is impossible to encode an arbitrary input state into a larger bipartite entangled state such that the full information is stored in the correlation but the individual subsystems have no information about the input state. Here, we ask the question: Is it possible to mask an observable such that the information about the observable is available in the joint system, but individual subsystems reveal nothing about the imprints of the observable? This generalizes the notion of masking to observables. We show that a universal unitary that can mask an arbitrary observable in any dimension does not exist. For a qubit system, we show that the masking operation for a given observable is locally unitarily connected to the swap operation. This suggests a conservation law for information content of observables that goes beyond the conservation laws under symmetry operations. Furthermore, we prove that the unconditional no-bit commitment result follows from the no-masking theorem for observables. Our results can have important applications in quantum information and quantum communication where we encode information not in states but in observables.

arXiv:2209.12261•Physical Review A•Aug 15, 2024•3 citations
In this work we show that the most general class of anti-unitary operators are nonphysical in nature through the existence of incomparable pure bipartite entangled states. It is also shown that a large class of inner-product-preserving operations defined only on the three qubits having spin-directions along x,y and z are impossible. If we perform such an operation locally on a particular pure bipartite state then it will exactly transform to another pure bipartite state that is incomparable with the original one. As subcases of the above results we find the nonphysical nature of universal exact flipping operation and existence of universal Hadamard gate. Beyond the information conservation in terms of entanglement, this work shows how an impossible local operation evolve with the joint system in a nonphysical way.
We present here a scheme that relates seemingly two different kinds of physical impossibilities of quantum information processing. We derive, exact flipping of three arbitrary states not lying in one great circle is not possible with certainty, by using the existence of incomparable states which are not interconvertible deterministically by local operations and classical communications. In contrast, considering the nonexistence of exact universal flipper, the incomparability of a pair of bipartite pure entangled states can be established.
The work is intended to represent some interesting and apparently peculiar features of entangled system in both pure as well as mixed states level. In the pure state level, we are largely concerned about the existence and characteristics of bipartite incomparable pair of states. We have found some schemes for local transformation of one pure bipartite state to another, incomparable in nature, by exploiting free unpreserved entanglement. Also, we observed that different incomparable pair of states in 3×33\times 33×3 may co-operate with each other to cross the barrier of incomparability. Our next goal was to probe critically the roots of the existence of incomparable states. We have succeeded in connecting incomparability with some famous no-go theorems of quantum mechanics. We have established it with no-flipping principle, general anti-unitary operators and lastly with inner product preserving operations. Thus we are able to pose incomparability as a good detector of some non-physical operations. In the next part, we provide a new class of multipartite bound entanglement in mixed state level. The class of states are activable bound entangled. There are exactly four orthogonal activable bound entangled states in any even number of qubit system. They have some interesting features like Bell correlation, permutation symmetry, local Pauli connection, non-compatibility, etc. Apart from those properties, the class of bound entangled states have the remarkable feature of local indistinguishability in quantum systems.
Incomparability of pure bipartite entangled states under deterministic LOCC is a very strange phenomena. We find two possible ways of getting our desired pure entangled state which is incomparable with the given input state, by collective LOCC with certainty. The first one is by providing some pure entanglement through the lower dimensional maximally-entangled states or using further less amount of entanglement and the next one is by collective operation on two pairs which are individually incomparable. It is quite surprising that we are able to achieve maximally entangled states of any Schmidt rank from a finite number of 2x2 pure entangled states only by deterministic LOCC. We provide general theory for the case of 3x3 system of incomparable states by the above processes where incomparability seems to be the most hardest one.
We introduce the general catalysts for pure entanglement transformations under local operations and classical communications in such a way that we disregard the profit and loss of entanglement of the catalysts per se. As such, the possibilities of pure entanglement transformations are greatly expanded. Remarkably, we find an interesting phenomenon that, in some situations, incomparable pairs ${| ψ> ,| ϕ> \} $ and ${| χ> ,| χ^{\prime}> \} $ can assist each other mutually so as to realize the transformation ∣ψ>∣χ>→∣ϕ>∣χ′>| ψ> | χ> \to| ϕ> | χ^{\prime}>∣ψ>∣χ>→∣ϕ>∣χ′>. We also design an efficient algorithm to detect whether a k×kk\times kk×k general catalyst exists for a given entanglement transformation. This algorithm can as well be exploited to witness the existence of standard catalysts.
Entanglement theory is formulated as a quantum resource theory in which the free operations are local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This defines a partial order among bipartite pure states that makes it possible to identify a maximally entangled state, which turns out to be the most relevant state in applications. However, the situation changes drastically in the multipartite regime. Not only do there exist inequivalent forms of entanglement forbidding the existence of a unique maximally entangled state, but recent results have shown that LOCC induces a trivial ordering: almost all pure entangled multipartite states are incomparable (i.e., LOCC transformations among them are almost never possible). In order to cope with this problem we consider alternative resource theories in which we relax the class of LOCC to operations that do not create entanglement. We consider two possible theories depending on whether resources correspond to multipartite entangled or genuinely multipartite entangled (GME) states and we show that they are both nontrivial: no inequivalent forms of entanglement exist in them and they induce a meaningful partial order (i.e., every pure state is transformable to more weakly entangled pure states). Moreover, we prove that the resource theory of GME that we formulate here has a unique maximally entangled state, the generalized GHZ state, which can be transformed to any other state by the allowed free operations.
The no-masking theorem for quantum information proves that it is impossible to encode an arbitrary input state into a larger bipartite entangled state such that the full information is stored in the correlation but the individual subsystems have no information about the input state. Here, we ask the question: Is it possible to mask an observable such that the information about the observable is available in the joint system, but individual subsystems reveal nothing about the imprints of the observable? This generalizes the notion of masking to observables. We show that a universal unitary that can mask an arbitrary observable in any dimension does not exist. For a qubit system, we show that the masking operation for a given observable is locally unitarily connected to the swap operation. This suggests a conservation law for information content of observables that goes beyond the conservation laws under symmetry operations. Furthermore, we prove that the unconditional no-bit commitment result follows from the no-masking theorem for observables. Our results can have important applications in quantum information and quantum communication where we encode information not in states but in observables.