Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0608211 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

On the exactness of the semi-classical approximation for non-relativistic one-dimensional propagators

İbrahim Semiz, Koray Düztaş

Published Nov 8, 2006• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For one-dimensional non-relativistic quantum mechanical problems, we investigate the conditions for all the position dependence of the propagator to be in its phase, that is, for the semi-classical approximation to be exact. For velocity-independent potentials we find that: (i) the potential must be quadratic in space, but can have arbitrary time dependence, (ii) the phase may be made proportional to the classical action, and the magnitude (‘fluctuation factor’) can also be found from the classical solution and (iii) for the driven harmonic oscillator the fluctuation factor is independent of the driving term.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/39/47/011

Related papers

On the Space-Time Formulation of Non-Relativistic Quantum Mechanics

Izuru Fujiwara

For the case of the quantization of the usual non-relativistic classical Lagrangian function quadratic in the velocity the validity is demonstrated of the non-canonical space-time formulation of quantum mechanics proposed recently by the author, which aims to evaluate, without appealing to the Schrödinger equation, the transformation function K(x,t′;y,t′) in the space representation on the basis of the composition rule K(x, t″; y, t′) = ∫K(x, t″; z, t)dzK(z, t; y, t′) (1) coupled with the supposition that it is approximated to zeroth order in the quantum of action h by the so-called semi-classical kernel Ko(x, t″; y, t′) = [(i/h)∂2S/∂x∂y]1/2 exp [(i/ℏ) S(x,t″; y, t′] (2) written in terms of the classical action S(x, t″; y, t′) alone. In the first place the action function corresponding to the above Lagrangian is expanded in power of the interval of time T = t″ − t′. Then the deviation of the semi-classical kernel (2) from the unitary transformation function is shown to be of the third order in T, and the corresponding correction term is evaluated by solving the integral equation (1). It is also shown that the semi-classical kernel is unitary for a free motion of a particle with its mass being a function in the space coordinate.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jun 1, 1959•16 citations

Exact propagator for a time−dependent harmonic oscillator with and without a singular perturbation

Dinkar C. Khandekar, S. V. Lawande

By using Feynman’s definition of a path integral, exact propagators for a time−dependent harmonic oscillator with and without an inverse quadratic potential have been evaluated. It is shown that these propagators depend only on the solutions of the classical unperturbed oscillator. The relations between these propagators, the invariants, and the Schrödinger equation are also discussed.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1975•132 citations

A Non-relativistic Approach to Relativistic Quantum Mechanics: The Case of the Harmonic Oscillator

Luis A. Poveda, Luis Grave de Peralta, Jacob Pittman +1 more

Abstract A recently proposed approach to relativistic quantum mechanics (Grave de Peralta, Poveda, Poirier in Eur J Phys 42:055404, 2021) is applied to the problem of a particle in a quadratic potential. The methods, both exact and approximate, allow one to obtain eigenstate energy levels and wavefunctions, using conventional numerical eigensolvers applied to Schrödinger-like equations. Results are obtained over a nine-order-of-magnitude variation of system parameters, ranging from the non-relativistic to the ultrarelativistic limits. Various trends are analyzed and discussed—some of which might have been easily predicted, others which may be a bit more surprising.

Foundations of Physics•Feb 1, 2022•11 citations

The One-Dimensional, Non-Relativistic, Quanitum Morse Oscillator at the Classical Limit

G. A., M. Grado-Caffaro, www.sapienzastudies.com +2 more

The one-dimensional, non-relativistic, quantum Morse oscillator is studied at the classical limit.In fact, near the classical limit, the energy eigenvalues relative to the eigenstates of the nonrelativistic, time-independent, Schrödinger equation with Morse potential are negative and approximately proportional to the square of the corresponding vibrational quantum number.Within this framework, the mass of the oscillator in question is found to be negative.This can take place in certain particle phenomena and, in fact, occurs, for instance, in semiconductor superlattices.These cases are outlined very briefly in the present paper.

Journal of Particle Physics•Jan 17, 2018•0 citations

Interpreting Bohm-like quantum potentials in "Computing quantum waves exactly from classical action"

Winfried Lohmiller, Jean-Jacques Slotine

Comment on arXiv:2605.02621 [23] and arXiv:2606.05197 [24]: In contrast to his earlier comment [23] on rspa.2025.0413 [12] and answered in arXiv:2605.20443 [11], the same author of [24] does not seem to dispute any longer that the use in [12] of tools from Feynman's [5] namely - the kernel approach, which computes a wave starting at a given initial position or momentum, and is a key element in [12] to ensure that the Bohm-like quantum potential vanishes. This is directly verified in all examples of [12] as well as in the Pauli, Dirac and Maxwell derivations from classical action. This approach is very different from the standard Bohm-Madelung potential on the overall wave, as illustrated in detail in [11] for the two-slit experiment. - for the harmonic oscillator, the kernel computation directly from a Taylor series expansion, which does not involve any circularity. His second post [24] now - criticizes the use in [12], [11] of Duru and Kleinert's time-independent eigenwave equivalence of the original and the time-scaled Schrödinger equations [4], confusing this standard result with a multivariable chain rule in the time-dependent kernel computation from action in [12]. - claims that "The mathematical framework presented by the authors remains identical to the well-established semiclassical Van Vleck propagator [sic]" which requires that the "Hamiltonian is at most quadratic in position and momentum [sic]". This confuses a quadratic action in the vector case with a harmonic propagated density based on the Laplacian of the action (with harmonicity always fulfilled e.g., for holomorphic complex functions [10]. In addition, it ignores the extension of a real position to a complex or quaternion position or spin, the key result on multi-valued action branches (which enables a classical derivation of quantum randomness) and the quantization of classical action in [12].

quant-pharXiv:2605.20443•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•May 21, 2026•6 citations

Exact quantum states of a general time-dependent quadratic system from classical action

Dae-Yup Song

A generalization of a driven harmonic oscillator with time-dependent mass and frequency, by adding total time-derivative terms to the Lagrangian, is considered. The generalization, which gives a general quadratic Hamiltonian system, does not change the classical equation of motion. Based on the observation by Feynman and Hibbs, the propagators (kernels) of the systems are calculated from the classical action, in terms of solutions of the classical equation of motion: two homogeneous solutions and one particular solution. The kernels are then used to find wave functions that satisfy the Schr\"odinger equation. One of the wave functions is shown to be that of a Gaussian pure state. In every case considered, we prove that the kernel does not depend on the way of choosing the classical solutions, while the wave functions depend on the choice. The generalization, which gives a rather complicated quadratic Hamiltonian, is simply interpreted as applying unitary transformation to the driven harmonic oscillator system in the Hamiltonian formulation.

arXiv:quant-ph/9810034•Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1999•39 citations
For one-dimensional non-relativistic quantum mechanical problems, we investigate the conditions for all the position dependence of the propagator to be in its phase, that is, for the semi-classical approximation to be exact. For velocity-independent potentials we find that: (i) the potential must be quadratic in space, but can have arbitrary time dependence, (ii) the phase may be made proportional to the classical action, and the magnitude (‘fluctuation factor’) can also be found from the classical solution and (iii) for the driven harmonic oscillator the fluctuation factor is independent of the driving term.
For the case of the quantization of the usual non-relativistic classical Lagrangian function quadratic in the velocity the validity is demonstrated of the non-canonical space-time formulation of quantum mechanics proposed recently by the author, which aims to evaluate, without appealing to the Schrödinger equation, the transformation function K(x,t′;y,t′) in the space representation on the basis of the composition rule K(x, t″; y, t′) = ∫K(x, t″; z, t)dzK(z, t; y, t′) (1) coupled with the supposition that it is approximated to zeroth order in the quantum of action h by the so-called semi-classical kernel Ko(x, t″; y, t′) = [(i/h)∂2S/∂x∂y]1/2 exp [(i/ℏ) S(x,t″; y, t′] (2) written in terms of the classical action S(x, t″; y, t′) alone. In the first place the action function corresponding to the above Lagrangian is expanded in power of the interval of time T = t″ − t′. Then the deviation of the semi-classical kernel (2) from the unitary transformation function is shown to be of the third order in T, and the corresponding correction term is evaluated by solving the integral equation (1). It is also shown that the semi-classical kernel is unitary for a free motion of a particle with its mass being a function in the space coordinate.
Abstract A recently proposed approach to relativistic quantum mechanics (Grave de Peralta, Poveda, Poirier in Eur J Phys 42:055404, 2021) is applied to the problem of a particle in a quadratic potential. The methods, both exact and approximate, allow one to obtain eigenstate energy levels and wavefunctions, using conventional numerical eigensolvers applied to Schrödinger-like equations. Results are obtained over a nine-order-of-magnitude variation of system parameters, ranging from the non-relativistic to the ultrarelativistic limits. Various trends are analyzed and discussed—some of which might have been easily predicted, others which may be a bit more surprising.
The one-dimensional, non-relativistic, quantum Morse oscillator is studied at the classical limit.In fact, near the classical limit, the energy eigenvalues relative to the eigenstates of the nonrelativistic, time-independent, Schrödinger equation with Morse potential are negative and approximately proportional to the square of the corresponding vibrational quantum number.Within this framework, the mass of the oscillator in question is found to be negative.This can take place in certain particle phenomena and, in fact, occurs, for instance, in semiconductor superlattices.These cases are outlined very briefly in the present paper.
Comment on arXiv:2605.02621 [23] and arXiv:2606.05197 [24]: In contrast to his earlier comment [23] on rspa.2025.0413 [12] and answered in arXiv:2605.20443 [11], the same author of [24] does not seem to dispute any longer that the use in [12] of tools from Feynman's [5] namely - the kernel approach, which computes a wave starting at a given initial position or momentum, and is a key element in [12] to ensure that the Bohm-like quantum potential vanishes. This is directly verified in all examples of [12] as well as in the Pauli, Dirac and Maxwell derivations from classical action. This approach is very different from the standard Bohm-Madelung potential on the overall wave, as illustrated in detail in [11] for the two-slit experiment. - for the harmonic oscillator, the kernel computation directly from a Taylor series expansion, which does not involve any circularity. His second post [24] now - criticizes the use in [12], [11] of Duru and Kleinert's time-independent eigenwave equivalence of the original and the time-scaled Schrödinger equations [4], confusing this standard result with a multivariable chain rule in the time-dependent kernel computation from action in [12]. - claims that "The mathematical framework presented by the authors remains identical to the well-established semiclassical Van Vleck propagator [sic]" which requires that the "Hamiltonian is at most quadratic in position and momentum [sic]". This confuses a quadratic action in the vector case with a harmonic propagated density based on the Laplacian of the action (with harmonicity always fulfilled e.g., for holomorphic complex functions [10]. In addition, it ignores the extension of a real position to a complex or quaternion position or spin, the key result on multi-valued action branches (which enables a classical derivation of quantum randomness) and the quantization of classical action in [12].
A generalization of a driven harmonic oscillator with time-dependent mass and frequency, by adding total time-derivative terms to the Lagrangian, is considered. The generalization, which gives a general quadratic Hamiltonian system, does not change the classical equation of motion. Based on the observation by Feynman and Hibbs, the propagators (kernels) of the systems are calculated from the classical action, in terms of solutions of the classical equation of motion: two homogeneous solutions and one particular solution. The kernels are then used to find wave functions that satisfy the Schr\"odinger equation. One of the wave functions is shown to be that of a Gaussian pure state. In every case considered, we prove that the kernel does not depend on the way of choosing the classical solutions, while the wave functions depend on the choice. The generalization, which gives a rather complicated quadratic Hamiltonian, is simply interpreted as applying unitary transformation to the driven harmonic oscillator system in the Hamiltonian formulation.