Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0603151

Notes on optimality of direct characterisation of quantum dynamics

Mário Ziman

Published Mar 17, 2006• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We argue that the claimed optimality of a new process tomography method suggested in [quant-ph/0601033] and [quant-ph/0601034] is based on not completely fair comparison that does not take into account the available information in an equal way. We also argue that the method is not a new process tomography scheme, but rather represents an interesting modification of ancilla assisted process tomography method. In our opinion these modifications require deeper understanding and further investigation.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0603151

Related papers

Quantum-process tomography: Resource analysis of different strategies

Masoud Mohseni, A. T. Rezakhani, Daniel A. Lidar

Characterization of quantum dynamics is a fundamental problem in quantum physics and quantum-information science. Several methods are known which achieve this goal, namely standard quantum-process tomography (SQPT), ancilla-assisted process tomography, and the recently proposed scheme of direct characterization of quantum dynamics (DCQD). Here, we review these schemes and analyze them with respect to some of the physical resources they require. Although a reliable figure-of-merit for process characterization is not yet available, our analysis can provide a benchmark which is necessary for choosing the scheme that is the most appropriate in a given situation, with given resources. As a result, we conclude that for quantum systems where two-body interactions are not naturally available, SQPT is the most efficient scheme. However, for quantum systems with controllable two-body interactions, the DCQD scheme is more efficient than other known quantum-process tomography schemes in terms of the total number of required elementary quantum operations.

arXiv:quant-ph/0702131•Physical Review A•Mar 13, 2008•451 citations

Direct and Parallel Tomography of a Quantum Process

Yu-Xiang Zhang, Shengjun Wu, Zeng‐Bing Chen

As the method to completely characterize quantum dynamical processes, quantum process tomography (QPT) is vitally important for quantum information processing and quantum control, where the faithfulness of quantum devices plays an essential role. Here via weak measurements, we present a new QPT scheme characterized by its directness and parallelism. Comparing with the existing schemes, our scheme needs a simpler state preparation and much fewer experimental setups. Furthermore, each parameter of the quantum process is directly determined from only five experimental values in our scheme, meaning that our scheme is robust against the accumulation of errors.

arXiv:1309.5780•Sep 23, 2013•2 citations

Experimental Direct Characterization of a Quantum Process

Robert B. A. Adamson, Adam Michael Steinberg

We present the first experimental implementation of Direct Quantum Process Tomography. Direct tomography uses ideas from quantum error correction to reduce the number of experimental configurations required to characterize a quantum process.

International Conference on Quantum Information•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Reply to M. Ziman's "Notes on optimality of direct characterization of quantum dynamics"

Masoud Mohseni, Daniel A. Lidar

Recently M. Ziman [quant-ph/0603151] criticized our approach for quantifying the required physical resources in the theory of Direct Characterization of Quantum Dynamics (DCQD) [quant-ph/0601033, quant-ph/0601034] in comparison to other quantum process tomography (QPT) schemes. Here we argue that Ziman's comments regarding optimality, quantumness, and the novelty of DCQD are inaccurate. Specifically, we demonstrate that DCQD is optimal with respect to both the required number of experimental configurations and the number of possible outcomes over all known QPT schemes in the 2^{2n} dimensional Hilbert space of n system and n ancilla qubits. Moreover, we show DCQD is more efficient than all known QPT schemes in the sense of overall required number of quantum operations. Furthermore, we argue that DCQD is a new method for characterizing quantum dynamics and cannot be considered merely as a subclass of previously known QPT schemes.

arXiv:quant-ph/0604114•Apr 16, 2006•1 citation

Optimal estimation of quantum processes using incomplete information: variational quantum process tomography

Thiago O. Maciel, Reinaldo O. Vianna

We develop a quantum process tomography method, which variationally reconstruct the map of a process, using noisy and incomplete information about the dynamics. The new method encompasses the most common quantum process tomography schemes. It is based on the variational quantum tomography method (VQT) proposed by Maciel \emph{et al.} in arXiv:1001.1793[quant-ph] \cite{VQT}.

arXiv:1007.2395•Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2012•7 citations

Practical Tomography of Multi-Time Processes

Abhinash Kumar Roy, Varun Srivastava, Christina Giarmatzi +1 more

Characterising multi-time quantum processes is essential for analysing temporally correlated noise and for designing effective control and mitigation strategies. A complete operational description through multi-time process tomography requires an informationally complete set of probes, which necessarily includes non-deterministic intermediate operations. On present-day quantum devices, such operations are commonly implemented using mid-circuit measurements and reset, which are technologically limited and can introduce noise and overhead in terms of ancilla requirement. In this work, we study the minimal ancillary dimension required for complete characterisation of multi-time processes. We show that sequential interactions with a single qubit ancilla can generate an informationally complete family of correlated probes for processes of arbitrary length, without requiring mid-circuit measurements or reset. Our result provides a resource-efficient route for complete multi-time process tomography and establishes that one qubit of coherent ancillary memory suffices for full reconstruction of arbitrary multi-time dynamics.

quant-pharXiv:2604.01482•Apr 3, 2026•2 citations
We argue that the claimed optimality of a new process tomography method suggested in [quant-ph/0601033] and [quant-ph/0601034] is based on not completely fair comparison that does not take into account the available information in an equal way. We also argue that the method is not a new process tomography scheme, but rather represents an interesting modification of ancilla assisted process tomography method. In our opinion these modifications require deeper understanding and further investigation.
Characterization of quantum dynamics is a fundamental problem in quantum physics and quantum-information science. Several methods are known which achieve this goal, namely standard quantum-process tomography (SQPT), ancilla-assisted process tomography, and the recently proposed scheme of direct characterization of quantum dynamics (DCQD). Here, we review these schemes and analyze them with respect to some of the physical resources they require. Although a reliable figure-of-merit for process characterization is not yet available, our analysis can provide a benchmark which is necessary for choosing the scheme that is the most appropriate in a given situation, with given resources. As a result, we conclude that for quantum systems where two-body interactions are not naturally available, SQPT is the most efficient scheme. However, for quantum systems with controllable two-body interactions, the DCQD scheme is more efficient than other known quantum-process tomography schemes in terms of the total number of required elementary quantum operations.
As the method to completely characterize quantum dynamical processes, quantum process tomography (QPT) is vitally important for quantum information processing and quantum control, where the faithfulness of quantum devices plays an essential role. Here via weak measurements, we present a new QPT scheme characterized by its directness and parallelism. Comparing with the existing schemes, our scheme needs a simpler state preparation and much fewer experimental setups. Furthermore, each parameter of the quantum process is directly determined from only five experimental values in our scheme, meaning that our scheme is robust against the accumulation of errors.
Recently M. Ziman [quant-ph/0603151] criticized our approach for quantifying the required physical resources in the theory of Direct Characterization of Quantum Dynamics (DCQD) [quant-ph/0601033, quant-ph/0601034] in comparison to other quantum process tomography (QPT) schemes. Here we argue that Ziman's comments regarding optimality, quantumness, and the novelty of DCQD are inaccurate. Specifically, we demonstrate that DCQD is optimal with respect to both the required number of experimental configurations and the number of possible outcomes over all known QPT schemes in the 2^{2n} dimensional Hilbert space of n system and n ancilla qubits. Moreover, we show DCQD is more efficient than all known QPT schemes in the sense of overall required number of quantum operations. Furthermore, we argue that DCQD is a new method for characterizing quantum dynamics and cannot be considered merely as a subclass of previously known QPT schemes.
Characterising multi-time quantum processes is essential for analysing temporally correlated noise and for designing effective control and mitigation strategies. A complete operational description through multi-time process tomography requires an informationally complete set of probes, which necessarily includes non-deterministic intermediate operations. On present-day quantum devices, such operations are commonly implemented using mid-circuit measurements and reset, which are technologically limited and can introduce noise and overhead in terms of ancilla requirement. In this work, we study the minimal ancillary dimension required for complete characterisation of multi-time processes. We show that sequential interactions with a single qubit ancilla can generate an informationally complete family of correlated probes for processes of arbitrary length, without requiring mid-circuit measurements or reset. Our result provides a resource-efficient route for complete multi-time process tomography and establishes that one qubit of coherent ancillary memory suffices for full reconstruction of arbitrary multi-time dynamics.