Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0603001

Does the wavefunction describe individual systems?

Antonio Di Lorenzo

Published Feb 28, 2006• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We analyze the issue of the interpretation of the wavefunction, namely whether it should be interpreted as describing individual systems or ensembles of identically prepared systems. We propose an experiment which can decide the issue, based on the simultaneous measurement of the same observable with different detectors, and we discuss the theoretical implications of the possible experimental outcomes.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0603001

Related papers

Single universe or multiple universes

Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

Abstract There is a consensus among physicists about the outcome of any experiment. However, there continues to be discussion about the interpretation of these results. At the heart of this discussion is the so-called measurement problem. The interaction of the particles with the measurement apparatus forms the measurement problem that has haunted physicists since the very early days of quantum mechanics. The problem is that quantum mechanics only describes the evolution of the wavefunction with time, but does not answer about the interaction with the measurement apparatus. These issues, related to the measurement problem, have led physicists to come up with different interpretations. Many possibilities are discussed. One of the most amazing resolutions of the measurement problem is via the possibility of the existence of multiple universes. This many-worlds approach is a desperate attempt to solve the measurement problem.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Alternative to the Orthodox Interpretation of Quantum Theory

Philip Pearle

An alternative calculational procedure for quantum theory is presented, employing three features which differ from the corresponding features of orthodox quantum theory. These are: (1) the state vector is never to be “reduced”; (2) quantum theory only makes predictions about ensembles of identical experiments (not about individual experiments); and (3) the measuring apparatus must always be included in the state vector. What is new about this alternative theory is the demonstration that Features 2 and 3 (which have hitherto been discussed separately) can be consistently combined to yield an interpretation of quantum theory which has the additional advantage of Feature 1. It is shown that alternative and orthodox theories yield identical predictions for any practical experiment. However, two classes of experiments (which are impractical) for which the orthodox and alternative theories yield different predictions are described. Therefore, it is, in principle, possible to decide which theory Nature has chosen to obey. It is concluded that there is no reason, based upon experimental evidence, for preferring one theory over the other.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1967•98 citations

Comment on ``Meaning of the Wave Function''

Samuel, J., Rajaram Nityananda

We draw attention to an elementary flaw in a recently proposed experiment to measure the wave function of a single quantum system.

arXiv:gr-qc/9404051•Apr 26, 1994•7 citations

Improving students’ understanding of quantum mechanics via the Stern–Gerlach experiment

Guangtian Zhu, Chandralekha Singh

The Stern–Gerlach experiment can play an important role in teaching the formalism of quantum mechanics. In the context of a finite-dimensional Hilbert space students can learn how to prepare a specific quantum state starting from an arbitrary state, issues related to the time evolution of the wave function and quantum measurement. The Stern–Gerlach experiment can also be used to teach the distinction between the physical space where the experiment is performed and the Hilbert space where the state of the system lies, and how information about the state of the system in the Hilbert space can be exploited to interpret the possible outcomes of the experiment in physical space. Students can learn the advantages of choosing an appropriate basis to make predictions about the outcomes of experiments with different arrangements of Stern–Gerlach devices. The latter can also help students understand that an ensemble of identically prepared systems is not the same as a mixture. We discuss student difficulties with the Stern–Gerlach experiment based on written tests and interviews with advanced undergraduate and graduate students in quantum mechanics courses. We also discuss preliminary data which suggest that the Quantum Interactive Learning Tutorial on the Stern–Gerlach experiment is helpful in improving student understanding of these concepts.

arXiv:1602.06367•American Journal of Physics•Apr 15, 2011•94 citations

Meaning of the wave function

Yakir Aharonov, J. Anandan, Lev Vaidman A

So far, the wave function has been interpreted as a probability amplitude, which is given physical meaning by ensemble averages of a large number of identical systems at a given time. We give an alternative interpretation of the wave function for a single system by means of a measurement which lasts a long time. This is a measurement on a single quantum system which determines the expectation values of (not necessarily commuting) observables while the wave function is protected from collapsing because it undergoes another suitably chosen interaction. This type of measurement enables the distinction between states which are not orthogonal, but are protected by a suitable interaction with the states of their environment, even for a single system. It therefore gives a different ontological meaning to the wave function. Several experiments in which such a measurement is realized, which can in principle be performed using electrons, neutrons, or atoms, are studied.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1993•298 citations

The relevance of the preparation concept for the interpretation of quantum formalism

Miguel Ferrero, Víctor Gómez Pin, J. L. Sánchez‐Gómez

The preparation procedure, an undefined notion in quantum theory, has not had the relevance that it deserves in the interpretation of quantum mechanical formalism.Here we utilize the concepts of identical and similar preparation procedures to show the conceptual differences between the statistical and the conventional interpretation of quantum formalism.Although the statistical understanding, and its final logical consequence, hidden variables theories (this connexion being explained in the text), have a great intuitive appeal due to its fewer ontological difficulties, both recent experimental results and theoretical developments seem to support an epistemic alternative closer to the conventional one.Nevertheless, we must not rule out the possibility that new theorems or new explanatory principles may modify the reigning supremacy of this interpretation. 1.-Introduction.Although the conventional interpretation of the quantum mechanical formalism (CIQM), very close to the Copenhagen interpretation, is still dominant (is used in almost all textbooks), there are physical situations that ask for an interpretation of the quantum mechanical formalism (QMF) in terms of the Statistical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (SIQM) or even for hidden variables theories (HVT).The SIQM and HVT are different research programs, but they are closely related, as we will see further below.To introduce properly the distinctions between the three previous acronyms we will ask an old and apparently simple question.Is the wave function associated to an individual system or to a statistical ensemble?A first tentative answer could be formulated as follows.QMF introduces probabilities, and probabilities are related to statistical ensembles.Otherwise, the same concept of probability would lose its meaning.In QM, if it is said that you would get some concrete result with 0,63 probability it means that if the experiment is carried out 100 times, that concrete result would appear approximately 63 times.Hence, the obvious answer will be that the wave function should be related with statistical ensembles.However, despite its intuitiveness this idea does not capture completely what we want to express.The real problem to analyze could be best introduced with the following example.Imagine that we prepare identically two radioactive atoms with half-life of 30 minutes.By preparation we understand all those theoretical methods and physical procedures necessary to fully characterize the state of the system.It is, thus, a macroscopic reproducible act that lefts the system, without destroying it, in a concrete state after the procedure.In quantum theory, this preparation is represented by a vector state (or a density matrix).Identically in this context will mean identity of procedures, that is that the experimenter has repeated all previous operations, so that there is no difference whatsoever between them.Note, however, that identical preparations are not necessarily followed by identical results, so there is

EPISTEMOLOGIA•Jul 1, 2014•1 citation
We analyze the issue of the interpretation of the wavefunction, namely whether it should be interpreted as describing individual systems or ensembles of identically prepared systems. We propose an experiment which can decide the issue, based on the simultaneous measurement of the same observable with different detectors, and we discuss the theoretical implications of the possible experimental outcomes.
Abstract There is a consensus among physicists about the outcome of any experiment. However, there continues to be discussion about the interpretation of these results. At the heart of this discussion is the so-called measurement problem. The interaction of the particles with the measurement apparatus forms the measurement problem that has haunted physicists since the very early days of quantum mechanics. The problem is that quantum mechanics only describes the evolution of the wavefunction with time, but does not answer about the interaction with the measurement apparatus. These issues, related to the measurement problem, have led physicists to come up with different interpretations. Many possibilities are discussed. One of the most amazing resolutions of the measurement problem is via the possibility of the existence of multiple universes. This many-worlds approach is a desperate attempt to solve the measurement problem.
An alternative calculational procedure for quantum theory is presented, employing three features which differ from the corresponding features of orthodox quantum theory. These are: (1) the state vector is never to be “reduced”; (2) quantum theory only makes predictions about ensembles of identical experiments (not about individual experiments); and (3) the measuring apparatus must always be included in the state vector. What is new about this alternative theory is the demonstration that Features 2 and 3 (which have hitherto been discussed separately) can be consistently combined to yield an interpretation of quantum theory which has the additional advantage of Feature 1. It is shown that alternative and orthodox theories yield identical predictions for any practical experiment. However, two classes of experiments (which are impractical) for which the orthodox and alternative theories yield different predictions are described. Therefore, it is, in principle, possible to decide which theory Nature has chosen to obey. It is concluded that there is no reason, based upon experimental evidence, for preferring one theory over the other.
The Stern–Gerlach experiment can play an important role in teaching the formalism of quantum mechanics. In the context of a finite-dimensional Hilbert space students can learn how to prepare a specific quantum state starting from an arbitrary state, issues related to the time evolution of the wave function and quantum measurement. The Stern–Gerlach experiment can also be used to teach the distinction between the physical space where the experiment is performed and the Hilbert space where the state of the system lies, and how information about the state of the system in the Hilbert space can be exploited to interpret the possible outcomes of the experiment in physical space. Students can learn the advantages of choosing an appropriate basis to make predictions about the outcomes of experiments with different arrangements of Stern–Gerlach devices. The latter can also help students understand that an ensemble of identically prepared systems is not the same as a mixture. We discuss student difficulties with the Stern–Gerlach experiment based on written tests and interviews with advanced undergraduate and graduate students in quantum mechanics courses. We also discuss preliminary data which suggest that the Quantum Interactive Learning Tutorial on the Stern–Gerlach experiment is helpful in improving student understanding of these concepts.
So far, the wave function has been interpreted as a probability amplitude, which is given physical meaning by ensemble averages of a large number of identical systems at a given time. We give an alternative interpretation of the wave function for a single system by means of a measurement which lasts a long time. This is a measurement on a single quantum system which determines the expectation values of (not necessarily commuting) observables while the wave function is protected from collapsing because it undergoes another suitably chosen interaction. This type of measurement enables the distinction between states which are not orthogonal, but are protected by a suitable interaction with the states of their environment, even for a single system. It therefore gives a different ontological meaning to the wave function. Several experiments in which such a measurement is realized, which can in principle be performed using electrons, neutrons, or atoms, are studied.
The preparation procedure, an undefined notion in quantum theory, has not had the relevance that it deserves in the interpretation of quantum mechanical formalism.Here we utilize the concepts of identical and similar preparation procedures to show the conceptual differences between the statistical and the conventional interpretation of quantum formalism.Although the statistical understanding, and its final logical consequence, hidden variables theories (this connexion being explained in the text), have a great intuitive appeal due to its fewer ontological difficulties, both recent experimental results and theoretical developments seem to support an epistemic alternative closer to the conventional one.Nevertheless, we must not rule out the possibility that new theorems or new explanatory principles may modify the reigning supremacy of this interpretation. 1.-Introduction.Although the conventional interpretation of the quantum mechanical formalism (CIQM), very close to the Copenhagen interpretation, is still dominant (is used in almost all textbooks), there are physical situations that ask for an interpretation of the quantum mechanical formalism (QMF) in terms of the Statistical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (SIQM) or even for hidden variables theories (HVT).The SIQM and HVT are different research programs, but they are closely related, as we will see further below.To introduce properly the distinctions between the three previous acronyms we will ask an old and apparently simple question.Is the wave function associated to an individual system or to a statistical ensemble?A first tentative answer could be formulated as follows.QMF introduces probabilities, and probabilities are related to statistical ensembles.Otherwise, the same concept of probability would lose its meaning.In QM, if it is said that you would get some concrete result with 0,63 probability it means that if the experiment is carried out 100 times, that concrete result would appear approximately 63 times.Hence, the obvious answer will be that the wave function should be related with statistical ensembles.However, despite its intuitiveness this idea does not capture completely what we want to express.The real problem to analyze could be best introduced with the following example.Imagine that we prepare identically two radioactive atoms with half-life of 30 minutes.By preparation we understand all those theoretical methods and physical procedures necessary to fully characterize the state of the system.It is, thus, a macroscopic reproducible act that lefts the system, without destroying it, in a concrete state after the procedure.In quantum theory, this preparation is represented by a vector state (or a density matrix).Identically in this context will mean identity of procedures, that is that the experimenter has repeated all previous operations, so that there is no difference whatsoever between them.Note, however, that identical preparations are not necessarily followed by identical results, so there is