Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0601065 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Black holes are almost optimal quantum cloners

Christoph Adami, Greg Ver Steeg

Published May 19, 2015• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

If black holes were able to clone quantum states, a number of paradoxes in black hole physics would disappear.However, the linearity of quantum mechanics forbids exact cloning of quantum states.Here we show that black holes indeed clone incoming quantum states with a fidelity that depends on the black hole's absorption coefficient, without violating the no-cloning theorem because the clones are only approximate.Perfectly reflecting black holes are optimal universal 'quantum cloning machines' and operate on the principle of stimulated emission, exactly as their quantum optical counterparts.In the limit of perfect absorption, the fidelity of clones is only equal to what can be obtained via quantum state estimation methods.But for any absorption probability less than one, the cloning fidelity is nearly optimal as long as ω ⩾ T 10, a common parameter for modest-sized black holes.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/48/23/23ft01

Related papers

Experimental Quantum Cloning of Single Photons

Antía Lamas-Linares, Christoph Simon, John C. Howell +1 more

Although perfect copying of unknown quantum systems is forbidden by the laws of quantum mechanics, approximate cloning is possible. A natural way of realizing quantum cloning of photons is by stimulated emission. In this context, the fundamental quantum limit to the quality of the clones is imposed by the unavoidable presence of spontaneous emission. In our experiment, a single input photon stimulates the emission of additional photons from a source on the basis of parametric down-conversion. This leads to the production of quantum clones with near-optimal fidelity. We also demonstrate universality of the copying procedure by showing that the same fidelity is achieved for arbitrary input states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0205149•Science•Apr 26, 2002•275 citations

Optimal universal and state-dependent quantum cloning

Dagmar Bruß, David Peter Divincenzo, ARTUR K. EKERT +3 more

We establish the best possible approximation to a perfect quantum cloning machine that produces two clones out of a single input. We analyze both universal and state-dependent cloners. The maximal fidelity of cloning is shown to be 5/6 for universal cloners. It can be achieved either by a special unitary evolution or by a teleportation scheme. We construct the optimal state-dependent cloners operating on any prescribed two nonorthogonal states and discuss their fidelities and the use of auxiliary physical resources in the process of cloning. The optimal universal cloners permit us to derive an upper bound on the quantum capacity of the depolarizing quantum channel.

arXiv:quant-ph/9705038•Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1998•556 citations

THE CAPACITY OF BLACK HOLES TO TRANSMIT QUANTUM INFORMATION

Bradler, Kamil, Christoph Adami

We study the properties of the quantum information transmission channel that emerges from the quantum dynamics of particles interacting with a black hole horizon. We calculate the quantum channel capacity in two limiting cases where a single-letter capacity is known to exist: the limit of perfectly reflecting and perfectly absorbing black holes. We find that the perfectly reflecting black hole channel is closely related to the Unruh channel and that its capacity is non-vanishing, allowing for the perfect reconstruction of quantum information outside of the black hole horizon. We also find that the complementary channel (transmitting entanglement behind the horizon) is entanglement-breaking in this case, with vanishing capacity. We then calculate the quantum capacity of the black hole channel in the limit of a perfectly absorbing black hole and find that this capacity vanishes, while the capacity of the complementary channel is non-vanishing instead. Rather than inviting a new crisis for quantum physics, this finding instead is in accordance with the quantum no-cloning theorem, because it guarantees that there are no space-like surfaces that contain both the sender’s quantum state and the receiver’s reconstructed quantum state.

•May 21, 2014•23 citations

The capacity of black holes to transmit quantum information

Kamil Brádler, Christoph Adami

We study the properties of the quantum information transmission channel that emerges from the quantum dynamics of particles interacting with a black hole horizon. We calculate the quantum channel capacity in two limiting cases where a single-letter capacity is known to exist: the limit of perfectly reflecting and perfectly absorbing black holes. We find that the perfectly reflecting black hole channel is closely related to the Unruh channel and that its capacity is non-vanishing, allowing for the perfect reconstruction of quantum information outside of the black hole horizon. We also find that the complementary channel (transmitting entanglement behind the horizon) is entanglement-breaking in this case, with vanishing capacity. We then calculate the quantum capacity of the black hole channel in the limit of a perfectly absorbing black hole and find that this capacity vanishes, while the capacity of the complementary channel is non-vanishing instead. Rather than inviting a new crisis for quantum physics, this finding instead is in accordance with the quantum no-cloning theorem, because it guarantees that there are no space-like surfaces that contain both the sender’s quantum state and the receiver’s reconstructed quantum state.

arXiv:1310.7914•Journal of High Energy Physics•May 1, 2014•28 citations

Realization of the universal‐NOT gate and of the universal quantum cloning

Carlo Sias, Fabio Sciarrino, F. De Martini

Abstract An arbitrary quantum state cannot be “cloned” perfectly, i.e. reproduced with “fidelity” F = 1 into M > 1 states identical to the original by any conceivable physical device. The main root of this impossibility resides in the linearity of quantum mechanics. A second “quantum impossibility” process, based on the complete positivity character of any quantum operation and conceivably subtly related to the first one, forbids the realization of a universal NOT gate i.e. one that flips exactly any input qubit into an orthogonal one. A detailed investigation of these results, representing the most fundamental difference between classical and quantum information, indeed can reveal the detailed structure of the latter one. We report an experimental demonstration of the process of cloning of N = 1 input qubit into M = 2 output qubits by a quantum‐injected optical parametric amplifier OPA. By the same apparatus the realization of a universal NOT gate is also demonstrated. The two processes will be found to be “universal” and optimal, i.e. the measured fidelity of both processes F < 1 will be found close to the theoretical values.

Fortschritte der Physik•Apr 24, 2003•2 citations

Quantum cloning

Valerio Scarani, S. Iblisdir, Nicolas Gisin +1 more

The impossibility of perfectly copying (or cloning) an unknown quantum state is one of the basic rules governing the physics of quantum systems. The processes that perform the optimal approximate cloning have been found in many cases. These ``quantum cloning machines'' are important tools for studying a wide variety of tasks, e.g., state estimation and eavesdropping on quantum cryptography. This paper provides a comprehensive review of quantum cloning machines both for discrete-dimensional and for continuous-variable quantum systems. In addition, it presents the role of cloning in quantum cryptography, the link between optimal cloning and light amplification via stimulated emission, and the experimental demonstrations of optimal quantum cloning.

arXiv:quant-ph/0511088•Reviews of Modern Physics•Nov 8, 2005•636 citations
If black holes were able to clone quantum states, a number of paradoxes in black hole physics would disappear.However, the linearity of quantum mechanics forbids exact cloning of quantum states.Here we show that black holes indeed clone incoming quantum states with a fidelity that depends on the black hole's absorption coefficient, without violating the no-cloning theorem because the clones are only approximate.Perfectly reflecting black holes are optimal universal 'quantum cloning machines' and operate on the principle of stimulated emission, exactly as their quantum optical counterparts.In the limit of perfect absorption, the fidelity of clones is only equal to what can be obtained via quantum state estimation methods.But for any absorption probability less than one, the cloning fidelity is nearly optimal as long as ω ⩾ T 10, a common parameter for modest-sized black holes.
Although perfect copying of unknown quantum systems is forbidden by the laws of quantum mechanics, approximate cloning is possible. A natural way of realizing quantum cloning of photons is by stimulated emission. In this context, the fundamental quantum limit to the quality of the clones is imposed by the unavoidable presence of spontaneous emission. In our experiment, a single input photon stimulates the emission of additional photons from a source on the basis of parametric down-conversion. This leads to the production of quantum clones with near-optimal fidelity. We also demonstrate universality of the copying procedure by showing that the same fidelity is achieved for arbitrary input states.
We establish the best possible approximation to a perfect quantum cloning machine that produces two clones out of a single input. We analyze both universal and state-dependent cloners. The maximal fidelity of cloning is shown to be 5/6 for universal cloners. It can be achieved either by a special unitary evolution or by a teleportation scheme. We construct the optimal state-dependent cloners operating on any prescribed two nonorthogonal states and discuss their fidelities and the use of auxiliary physical resources in the process of cloning. The optimal universal cloners permit us to derive an upper bound on the quantum capacity of the depolarizing quantum channel.
We study the properties of the quantum information transmission channel that emerges from the quantum dynamics of particles interacting with a black hole horizon. We calculate the quantum channel capacity in two limiting cases where a single-letter capacity is known to exist: the limit of perfectly reflecting and perfectly absorbing black holes. We find that the perfectly reflecting black hole channel is closely related to the Unruh channel and that its capacity is non-vanishing, allowing for the perfect reconstruction of quantum information outside of the black hole horizon. We also find that the complementary channel (transmitting entanglement behind the horizon) is entanglement-breaking in this case, with vanishing capacity. We then calculate the quantum capacity of the black hole channel in the limit of a perfectly absorbing black hole and find that this capacity vanishes, while the capacity of the complementary channel is non-vanishing instead. Rather than inviting a new crisis for quantum physics, this finding instead is in accordance with the quantum no-cloning theorem, because it guarantees that there are no space-like surfaces that contain both the sender’s quantum state and the receiver’s reconstructed quantum state.
We study the properties of the quantum information transmission channel that emerges from the quantum dynamics of particles interacting with a black hole horizon. We calculate the quantum channel capacity in two limiting cases where a single-letter capacity is known to exist: the limit of perfectly reflecting and perfectly absorbing black holes. We find that the perfectly reflecting black hole channel is closely related to the Unruh channel and that its capacity is non-vanishing, allowing for the perfect reconstruction of quantum information outside of the black hole horizon. We also find that the complementary channel (transmitting entanglement behind the horizon) is entanglement-breaking in this case, with vanishing capacity. We then calculate the quantum capacity of the black hole channel in the limit of a perfectly absorbing black hole and find that this capacity vanishes, while the capacity of the complementary channel is non-vanishing instead. Rather than inviting a new crisis for quantum physics, this finding instead is in accordance with the quantum no-cloning theorem, because it guarantees that there are no space-like surfaces that contain both the sender’s quantum state and the receiver’s reconstructed quantum state.
Abstract An arbitrary quantum state cannot be “cloned” perfectly, i.e. reproduced with “fidelity” F = 1 into M > 1 states identical to the original by any conceivable physical device. The main root of this impossibility resides in the linearity of quantum mechanics. A second “quantum impossibility” process, based on the complete positivity character of any quantum operation and conceivably subtly related to the first one, forbids the realization of a universal NOT gate i.e. one that flips exactly any input qubit into an orthogonal one. A detailed investigation of these results, representing the most fundamental difference between classical and quantum information, indeed can reveal the detailed structure of the latter one. We report an experimental demonstration of the process of cloning of N = 1 input qubit into M = 2 output qubits by a quantum‐injected optical parametric amplifier OPA. By the same apparatus the realization of a universal NOT gate is also demonstrated. The two processes will be found to be “universal” and optimal, i.e. the measured fidelity of both processes F < 1 will be found close to the theoretical values.
The impossibility of perfectly copying (or cloning) an unknown quantum state is one of the basic rules governing the physics of quantum systems. The processes that perform the optimal approximate cloning have been found in many cases. These ``quantum cloning machines'' are important tools for studying a wide variety of tasks, e.g., state estimation and eavesdropping on quantum cryptography. This paper provides a comprehensive review of quantum cloning machines both for discrete-dimensional and for continuous-variable quantum systems. In addition, it presents the role of cloning in quantum cryptography, the link between optimal cloning and light amplification via stimulated emission, and the experimental demonstrations of optimal quantum cloning.