Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0509130

Comment on ''Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Is Incorrect''

Markus Bier

Published Sep 20, 2005• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is shown that ''Theorem 1'' of the article ''Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Is Incorrect'' by G.-L. Li and V.O.K. Li (see quant-ph/0509089) is false. Therefore the assertion expressed in the title of that article is untenable.
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0509130

Related papers

Comments on Struyve and Baere's paper on experiments to distinguish Bohmian mechanics from quantum mechanics

Partha Ghose

It is shown in detail why the arguments put forward by Struyve and Baere (quant-ph/0108038) against my conclusions are incorrect.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208192•Aug 30, 2002•5 citations

Incorrect Mathematical Operators in a Two-Dimensional Quantum Problem

Ranjan Das

Comment in which the author agrees with the difficulties in the teaching–learning process of quantum mechanics and discusses some basic problems in the quantum mechanical treatment as presented in an earlier article.

Journal of Chemical Education•Dec 1, 2009•1 citation

Reply to comment by D.L. Khokhlov on my paper "INCOMPATIBILITY OF THE COPENHAGEN INTERPRETATION WITH QUANTUM MECHANICS FORMALISM"

Yuri A. Rylov

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Is Incorrect

Guang-Liang Li, Victor O. K. Li

(A point-by-point response to a comment (quant-ph/0509130) on our paper (quant-ph/0509089) is added as Appendix C. We find the comment incorrect.) Einstein's criticism of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics is an important part of his legacy. Although most physicists consider Einstein's criticism technically unfounded, we show that the Copenhagen interpretation is actually incorrect, since Born's probability explanation of the wave function is incorrect due to a false assumption on "continuous probabilities" in modern probability theory. "Continuous probability" means a "probability measure" that can take every value in a subinterval of the unit interval (0, 1). We prove that such "continuous probabilities" are invalid. Since Bell's inequality also assumes "continuous probabilities", the result of the experimental test of Bell's inequality is not evidence supporting the Copenhagen interpretation. Although successful applications of quantum mechanics and explanation of quantum phenomena do not necessarily rely on the Copenhagen interpretation, the question asked by Einstein 70 years ago, i.e., whether a complete description of reality exists, still remains open.

arXiv:quant-ph/0509089•Sep 13, 2005•0 citations

Comment on ``Quantum Entanglement and the Nonexistence of Superluminal Signals''

Vladimir S. Mashkevich

We argue that the claim given in quant-ph/9801014 is untenable. The fallacy in the proof is a misinterpretation of the no-cloning theorem, which does not allow quantum jumps, specifically measurements.

arXiv:quant-ph/9801062•Jan 27, 1998•4 citations

Comment on the deformation of quantum mechanics

Ki-Soo Chung, Won-Sang Chung

For original paper see Li et al., ibid, vol.25, p.6779 (1992) In this comment we point out a serious mistake in a recent paper by Li and Sheng and present the correct version for q-deformed quantum mechanics.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 21, 1994•3 citations
(A point-by-point response to a comment (quant-ph/0509130) on our paper (quant-ph/0509089) is added as Appendix C. We find the comment incorrect.) Einstein's criticism of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics is an important part of his legacy. Although most physicists consider Einstein's criticism technically unfounded, we show that the Copenhagen interpretation is actually incorrect, since Born's probability explanation of the wave function is incorrect due to a false assumption on "continuous probabilities" in modern probability theory. "Continuous probability" means a "probability measure" that can take every value in a subinterval of the unit interval (0, 1). We prove that such "continuous probabilities" are invalid. Since Bell's inequality also assumes "continuous probabilities", the result of the experimental test of Bell's inequality is not evidence supporting the Copenhagen interpretation. Although successful applications of quantum mechanics and explanation of quantum phenomena do not necessarily rely on the Copenhagen interpretation, the question asked by Einstein 70 years ago, i.e., whether a complete description of reality exists, still remains open.