Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0507151

On Entanglement with Vacuum

Marcin Pawłowski, Marek Czachor

Published Jul 16, 2005• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The so-called entanglement with vacuum is not a property of the Fock space, but of some rather pathological representations of CCR/CAR algebras. In some other Fock space representations the notion simply does not exist. We have checked all the main Gedanken experiments where the notion of entanglement with vacuum was used, and found that all the calculations could be performed at a representation-independent level. In particular any such experiment can be formulated in a Fock-space representation where the notion of entanglement with vacuum is meaningless. So, for the moment there is no single experiment where the notion is needed, and probably it is simply unphysical.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0507151

Related papers

Degree of entanglement as a physically ill-posed problem: The case of entanglement with vacuum

Marcin Pawłowski, Marek Czachor

We analyze an example of a photon in a superposition of different modes, and ask what is the degree of their entanglement with a vacuum. The problem turns out to be ill-posed since we do not know which representation of the algebra of canonical commutation relations (CCR) to choose for the field quantization. Once we make a choice, we can solve the question of entanglement unambiguously. So the difficulty is not with mathematics, but with physics of the problem. In order to make the discussion explicit we analyze from this perspective a popular argument based on a photon leaving a beam splitter and interacting with two two-level atoms. We first solve the problem algebraically in the Heisenberg picture, without any assumption about the form of representation of CCR. Then we take the $\ensuremath{\infty}$-representation and show in two ways that in two-mode states the modes are maximally entangled with the vacuum, but single-mode states are not entangled. Next we repeat the analysis in terms of the representation of CCR taken from Berezin's book and show that two-mode states do not involve the mode-vacuum entanglement. Finally, we switch to a family of reducible representations of CCR recently investigated in the context of field quantization, and show that the entanglement with the vacuum is present even for single-mode states. Still, the degree of entanglement here is difficult to estimate, mainly because there are $N+2$ subsystems, with $N$ unspecified and large.

arXiv:quant-ph/0512253•Physical Review A•Apr 21, 2006•24 citations

Orthogonal invariance of the CAR on Fock spaces

Jan Dereziński, Christian Gérard

Orthogonal invariance of the CAR on Fock spacesIn this chapter we continue our study of the orthogonal invariance of the CAR.This invariance was already investigated in Chap.14.However, whereas in Chap.14 we used the representation-independent framework of CAR algebras, in this chapter we will consider Fock CAR representations in any dimensions.Therefore, to some extent, this chapter can be viewed as a continuation of Chap.13 about Fock CAR representations.Note also that this chapter is parallel to Chap.11 about the symplectic invariance of the CCR on a Fock space.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 4, 2022•0 citations

Comment on “Single-particle entanglement”

Aurélien Drezet

We show that contrarily to what it is claimed in Phys. Rev. A 72, 064306 (2005) entanglement is not necessary for explaining experimental results associated with the ``single particle-vacuum'' state $\ensuremath{\mid}\ensuremath{\psi}⟩\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\mid}0{⟩}_{A}\ensuremath{\mid}1{⟩}_{B}+\ensuremath{\mid}1{⟩}_{A}\ensuremath{\mid}0{⟩}_{B}$.

Physical Review A•Aug 21, 2006•31 citations

Entanglement And The Special Theory Of Relativity

Ilija Barukčić

Abstract: The exact nature of non-locality and entanglement is still a matter of an ongoing controversy. Especially, the concept of non-locality as postulated by the orthodox Copenhagen quantum mechanics is claiming to reflect any non-locality in the quantum realm. Attention should be called to the obvious but very disconcerting fact that the concept of non-locality cannot contradict the theory of special relativity, as long as the same is not refuted theoretically or by experiments. Another way of expressing the peculiar situation is, under conditions of the special theory of relativity it remains rather discomforting to alter the properties of a distant system instantaneously (i. e. no light signal can travel) by acting on a local system. The purpose of this publication is to solve the problem of non-locality and entanglement from the standpoint of the special theory of relativity.

•Jun 1, 2015•0 citations

CAR on Fock spaces

Jan Dereziński, Christian Gérard

CAR on Fock spacesThis chapter is devoted to the study of Fock representations of the canonical anticommutation relations, a basic tool of quantum many-body theory and quantum field theory.It is parallel to Chap. 9, where Fock CCR representations were studied.The basic framework is almost the same as in Chap.9. Throughout this chapter Z is a Hilbert space, called the one-particle space.We will consider the Fock CAR representation acting on the fermionic Fock space Γ a (Z).As in Sect.1.3, we introduce the space Y = Re(Z ⊕ Z) := {(z, z) : z ∈ Z}, which will serve as the dual phase space of our system.Recall that in the bosonic case we equipped Y with the structure of the Kähler space consisting of the anti-involution j, the Euclidean scalar product • and the symplectic form ω: j(z, z) := (iz, iz), (13.1) (z, z) • (w, w) := 2Re(z|w), (13.2) (z, z)•ω(w, w) := 2Im(z|w) = -(z, z) • j(w, w).(13.3)In our presentation of the fermionic case, we will need the Kähler anti-involution j.The symplectic form ω will not be used.Instead of the scalar product (13.2) we will use another scalar product,Again we will avoid identifing Z with Y. CY is identified with Z ⊕ Z by the mapY # , the space dual to Y, is canonically identified with Re(Z ⊕ Z) by using the scalar product (9.2), and CY # is identified with Z ⊕ Z. Fock CAR representationConsider the fermionic Fock space Γ a (Z).Recall that, for z ∈ Z, a * (z), resp.a(z) denote the corresponding creation, resp.annihilation operators defined in Sect.3.4.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 4, 2022•0 citations

Once More About Quantum "Entanglement" (English Version)

V.A. Kasimov

During the conceptual design of the experimental results of Aspect one must speak the language of quantum mechanics, not the language Argo of the private insights. One of these insights is the concept of entanglement (of particles or states is unclear!) The language of quantum mechanics allows for a clear and unambiguous manner to give concrete content to the questions on this occasion. For the analysis of the proposed elementary model used in [1, 2].

•Jun 1, 2018•0 citations
The so-called entanglement with vacuum is not a property of the Fock space, but of some rather pathological representations of CCR/CAR algebras. In some other Fock space representations the notion simply does not exist. We have checked all the main Gedanken experiments where the notion of entanglement with vacuum was used, and found that all the calculations could be performed at a representation-independent level. In particular any such experiment can be formulated in a Fock-space representation where the notion of entanglement with vacuum is meaningless. So, for the moment there is no single experiment where the notion is needed, and probably it is simply unphysical.
We analyze an example of a photon in a superposition of different modes, and ask what is the degree of their entanglement with a vacuum. The problem turns out to be ill-posed since we do not know which representation of the algebra of canonical commutation relations (CCR) to choose for the field quantization. Once we make a choice, we can solve the question of entanglement unambiguously. So the difficulty is not with mathematics, but with physics of the problem. In order to make the discussion explicit we analyze from this perspective a popular argument based on a photon leaving a beam splitter and interacting with two two-level atoms. We first solve the problem algebraically in the Heisenberg picture, without any assumption about the form of representation of CCR. Then we take the $\ensuremath{\infty}$-representation and show in two ways that in two-mode states the modes are maximally entangled with the vacuum, but single-mode states are not entangled. Next we repeat the analysis in terms of the representation of CCR taken from Berezin's book and show that two-mode states do not involve the mode-vacuum entanglement. Finally, we switch to a family of reducible representations of CCR recently investigated in the context of field quantization, and show that the entanglement with the vacuum is present even for single-mode states. Still, the degree of entanglement here is difficult to estimate, mainly because there are N+2N+2N+2 subsystems, with NNN unspecified and large.
Orthogonal invariance of the CAR on Fock spacesIn this chapter we continue our study of the orthogonal invariance of the CAR.This invariance was already investigated in Chap.14.However, whereas in Chap.14 we used the representation-independent framework of CAR algebras, in this chapter we will consider Fock CAR representations in any dimensions.Therefore, to some extent, this chapter can be viewed as a continuation of Chap.13 about Fock CAR representations.Note also that this chapter is parallel to Chap.11 about the symplectic invariance of the CCR on a Fock space.
Abstract: The exact nature of non-locality and entanglement is still a matter of an ongoing controversy. Especially, the concept of non-locality as postulated by the orthodox Copenhagen quantum mechanics is claiming to reflect any non-locality in the quantum realm. Attention should be called to the obvious but very disconcerting fact that the concept of non-locality cannot contradict the theory of special relativity, as long as the same is not refuted theoretically or by experiments. Another way of expressing the peculiar situation is, under conditions of the special theory of relativity it remains rather discomforting to alter the properties of a distant system instantaneously (i. e. no light signal can travel) by acting on a local system. The purpose of this publication is to solve the problem of non-locality and entanglement from the standpoint of the special theory of relativity.
CAR on Fock spacesThis chapter is devoted to the study of Fock representations of the canonical anticommutation relations, a basic tool of quantum many-body theory and quantum field theory.It is parallel to Chap. 9, where Fock CCR representations were studied.The basic framework is almost the same as in Chap.9. Throughout this chapter Z is a Hilbert space, called the one-particle space.We will consider the Fock CAR representation acting on the fermionic Fock space Γ a (Z).As in Sect.1.3, we introduce the space Y = Re(Z ⊕ Z) := {(z, z) : z ∈ Z}, which will serve as the dual phase space of our system.Recall that in the bosonic case we equipped Y with the structure of the Kähler space consisting of the anti-involution j, the Euclidean scalar product • and the symplectic form ω: j(z, z) := (iz, iz), (13.1) (z, z) • (w, w) := 2Re(z|w), (13.2) (z, z)•ω(w, w) := 2Im(z|w) = -(z, z) • j(w, w).(13.3)In our presentation of the fermionic case, we will need the Kähler anti-involution j.The symplectic form ω will not be used.Instead of the scalar product (13.2) we will use another scalar product,Again we will avoid identifing Z with Y. CY is identified with Z ⊕ Z by the mapY # , the space dual to Y, is canonically identified with Re(Z ⊕ Z) by using the scalar product (9.2), and CY # is identified with Z ⊕ Z. Fock CAR representationConsider the fermionic Fock space Γ a (Z).Recall that, for z ∈ Z, a * (z), resp.a(z) denote the corresponding creation, resp.annihilation operators defined in Sect.3.4.