Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0506207

Comment on equivalence between quantum phase transition phenomena in radiation-matter and magnetic systems

J.G. Brankov, N. S. Tonchev, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

Published Jun 24, 2005• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this Comment we show that the temperature-dependent effective Hamiltonian derived by Reslen {\it et al} [Europhys. Lett., {\bf 69} (2005) 8] or that one by Liberti and Zaffino [arXiv:cond-mat/0503742] for the Dicke model cannot be correct for any temperature. They both violate a rigorous result. The former is correct only in the quantum (zero-temperature) limit while the last one only in the classical (infinite temperature) limit. The fact that the Dicke model belongs to the universality class of the infinitely coordinated transverse-field XY model is known for more then 30 years.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0506207

Related papers

Once more on the equivalence between quantum phase transition phenomena in radiation-matter and magnetic systems

J.G. Brankov, N. S. Tonchev, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

In answer to the replies of Reslen {\it et al} [arXiv: quant-ph/0507164 (2005)], and Liberti and Zaffino [arXiv:cond-mat/0507019, (2005)], we comment once more on the temperature-dependent effective Hamiltonians for the Dicke model derived by them in [Europhys. Lett., {\bf 69} (2005) 8] and [Eur. Phys. J., {\bf 44} (2005) 535], respectively. These approximate Hamiltonians cannot be correct for any finite nonzero temperature because they both violate a rigorous result. The fact that the Dicke model belongs to the universality class of, and its thermodynamics is described by the infinitely coordinated transverse-field XY model is known for more than 30 years.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508039•Aug 4, 2005•0 citations

Direct equivalence between quantum phase transition phenomena in radiation-matter and magnetic systems: Scaling of entanglement

Jose Reslen, Luis Quiroga, Neil F. Johnson

We show that the quantum phase transition arising in a standard radiation-matter model (Dicke model) belongs to the same universality class as the infinitely coordinated, transverse-field XY model. The effective qubit-qubit exchange interaction is shown to be proportional to the square of the qubit-radiation coupling. A universal finite-size scaling is derived for the corresponding two-qubit entanglement (concurrence) and a size-consistent effective Hamiltonian is proposed for the qubit subsystem.

arXiv:cond-mat/0406674•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Dec 7, 2004•75 citations

Comment on "Role of Matter Interactions in Superradiant Phenomena"

Max Hörmann, Anja Langheld, Jonas Leibig +2 more

Recently, Mendonça et al. [arXiv:2503.04961] investigated the Dicke-XXZ model and the Dicke-Ising model. For the latter model, their calculated quantum phase diagram contradicts claims about the existence of an intermediate phase with superradiant and antiferromagnetic order and the change in order of some phase transition lines, observed in other studies. In this comment we demonstrate that both features are indeed present in the Dicke-Ising model for the investigated parameter range in [arXiv:2503.04961].

quant-pharXiv:2511.08452•Physical Review Letters•Nov 12, 2025•5 citations

Comment on “Direct equivalence between quantum phase transition phenomena in radiation-matter and magnetic systems: Scaling of entanglement” by J. Reslen et al.

J.G. Brankov, N. S. Tonchev, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Aug 30, 2005•3 citations

Thermodynamics of the extended Dicke model

Philipp Pilar

The derivation of effective light-matter Hamiltonians in the context of cavity QED is revisited and the importance of making the correct choice of gauge is demonstrated. Controversies surrounding the quantum Rabi model as to whether the ultrastrong coupling regime can be reached are resolved and the adequacy of the effective models when applied to a superconducting circuit setup is shown. The effects of finite temperatures on the superradiant phase transition and the crossover to the subradiant phase in the extended Dicke model are exhibited. Applicability and limitations of the Holstein-Primakoff approximation as well as a mean field approach to the extended Dicke model are investigated. The heat capacity of the extended Dicke model is examined for a broad range of parameters.

•Feb 1, 2019•0 citations

Comment on “Revisiting the phase transitions of the Dicke model”

Ángel L. Corps, Armando Relaño

In the work of Das and Sharma [Phys. Rev. A 105, 033716 (2022)] the phase transitions of the Dicke model are studied. Its main result is that, besides the well-known quantum phase transition, excited-state quantum phase transition, and thermal phase transition exhibited by the model, there exists an upper bound energy ${E}_{*}$ beyond which the model ceases to exhibit quantum chaotic behavior and the structure of the eigenfunctions changes. Based on this finding, a number of well-established results about the Dicke model are called into question. We argue that this result and all its consequences are spurious numerical effects resulting from an improper truncation of the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space necessary for numerical diagonalization.

arXiv:2209.14660•Physical Review A•Oct 13, 2022•3 citations
In this Comment we show that the temperature-dependent effective Hamiltonian derived by Reslen {\it et al} [Europhys. Lett., {\bf 69} (2005) 8] or that one by Liberti and Zaffino [arXiv:cond-mat/0503742] for the Dicke model cannot be correct for any temperature. They both violate a rigorous result. The former is correct only in the quantum (zero-temperature) limit while the last one only in the classical (infinite temperature) limit. The fact that the Dicke model belongs to the universality class of the infinitely coordinated transverse-field XY model is known for more then 30 years.
In answer to the replies of Reslen {\it et al} [arXiv: quant-ph/0507164 (2005)], and Liberti and Zaffino [arXiv:cond-mat/0507019, (2005)], we comment once more on the temperature-dependent effective Hamiltonians for the Dicke model derived by them in [Europhys. Lett., {\bf 69} (2005) 8] and [Eur. Phys. J., {\bf 44} (2005) 535], respectively. These approximate Hamiltonians cannot be correct for any finite nonzero temperature because they both violate a rigorous result. The fact that the Dicke model belongs to the universality class of, and its thermodynamics is described by the infinitely coordinated transverse-field XY model is known for more than 30 years.
We show that the quantum phase transition arising in a standard radiation-matter model (Dicke model) belongs to the same universality class as the infinitely coordinated, transverse-field XY model. The effective qubit-qubit exchange interaction is shown to be proportional to the square of the qubit-radiation coupling. A universal finite-size scaling is derived for the corresponding two-qubit entanglement (concurrence) and a size-consistent effective Hamiltonian is proposed for the qubit subsystem.
Recently, Mendonça et al. [arXiv:2503.04961] investigated the Dicke-XXZ model and the Dicke-Ising model. For the latter model, their calculated quantum phase diagram contradicts claims about the existence of an intermediate phase with superradiant and antiferromagnetic order and the change in order of some phase transition lines, observed in other studies. In this comment we demonstrate that both features are indeed present in the Dicke-Ising model for the investigated parameter range in [arXiv:2503.04961].
The derivation of effective light-matter Hamiltonians in the context of cavity QED is revisited and the importance of making the correct choice of gauge is demonstrated. Controversies surrounding the quantum Rabi model as to whether the ultrastrong coupling regime can be reached are resolved and the adequacy of the effective models when applied to a superconducting circuit setup is shown. The effects of finite temperatures on the superradiant phase transition and the crossover to the subradiant phase in the extended Dicke model are exhibited. Applicability and limitations of the Holstein-Primakoff approximation as well as a mean field approach to the extended Dicke model are investigated. The heat capacity of the extended Dicke model is examined for a broad range of parameters.
In the work of Das and Sharma [Phys. Rev. A 105, 033716 (2022)] the phase transitions of the Dicke model are studied. Its main result is that, besides the well-known quantum phase transition, excited-state quantum phase transition, and thermal phase transition exhibited by the model, there exists an upper bound energy E∗{E}_{*}E∗​ beyond which the model ceases to exhibit quantum chaotic behavior and the structure of the eigenfunctions changes. Based on this finding, a number of well-established results about the Dicke model are called into question. We argue that this result and all its consequences are spurious numerical effects resulting from an improper truncation of the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space necessary for numerical diagonalization.