arXiv:quant-ph/0506159
Conditionalizing and commutativity: a note on Malley
Allen Stairs, Jeffrey Bub
Abstract
In a recent paper in this journal, James D. Malley has attempted to extend the uniqueness of quantum conditionalization to a result about hidden variable theories.If Malley is correct, then arguments such as those of Bell and Kochen and Specker prove only that the existence of hidden variables would require all quantum observables to commute.This would undermine the standard critiques of von Neumann's no hidden variable proof and would rob experimental violations of Bell-type inequalities of much of their interest.We demonstrate that there is a flaw in the proof of the theorem on which Malley relies.