Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0503193 · Physical Review A

Simple formula for pooling knowledge about a quantum system

Kurt A. Jacobs

Published Oct 4, 2005• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

When various observers obtain information in an independent fashion about a classical system, there is a simple rule which allows them to pool their knowledge, and this requires only the states-of-knowledge of the respective observers. Here we derive an equivalent quantum formula. While its realm of applicability is necessarily more limited, it does apply to a large class of measurements, and we show explicitly for a single qubit that it satisfies the intuitive notions of what it means to pool knowledge about a quantum system. This analysis also provides a physical interpretation for the trace of the product of two density matrices.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.72.044101

Related papers

Pooling quantum states obtained by indirect measurements

Robert W. Spekkens, Howard M. Wiseman

We consider the pooling of quantum states when Alice and Bob both have one part of a tripartite system and, on the basis of measurements on their respective parts, each infers a quantum state for the third part $S$. We denote the conditioned states which Alice and Bob assign to $S$ by $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and $\ensuremath{\beta}$, respectively, while the unconditioned state of $S$ is $\ensuremath{\rho}$. The state assigned by an overseer, who has all the data available to Alice and Bob, is $\ensuremath{\omega}$. The pooler is told only $\ensuremath{\alpha}$, $\ensuremath{\beta}$, and $\ensuremath{\rho}$. We show that for certain classes of tripartite states, this information is enough for her to reconstruct $\ensuremath{\omega}$ by the formula $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\propto}\ensuremath{\alpha}{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\ensuremath{\beta}$. Specifically, we identify two classes of states for which this pooling formula works: (i) all pure states for which the rank of $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is equal to the product of the ranks of the states of Alice's and Bob's subsystems; (ii) all mixtures of tripartite product states that are mutually orthogonal on $S$.

arXiv:quant-ph/0612190•Physical Review A•Apr 11, 2007•9 citations

Quantum state reconstruction and optimal manipulations with quantum information (1996 IOC Prize Winner)

Vladimír Bužek

The concept of a quantum state represents one of the most fundamental pillars of the paradigm of quantum theory.'3 Contrary to its mathematical elegance and convenience in calculations, the physical interpretation of a quantum state is not so transparent. The problem is that the quantum state (described either by a state vector, or density operator or a phase-space probability density distribution) does not have a well defined objective status, i.e. a state vector is not an objective property of a particle. According to Peres (see,1 p. 374): "There is no physical evidence whatsoever that every physical system has at every instant a well defined state. .. In strict interpretation of quantum theory these mathematical symbols [i.e., state vectorsi represent statistical information enabling us to compute the probabilities of occurrence of specific events." Once this point of view is adopted then it becomes clear that any "measurement" or a reconstruction of a density operator (or its mathematical equivalent) can be understood exclusively as an expression of our knowledge about the quantum mechanical state based on a certain set of measured data. To be more specific, any quantum-mechanical reconstruction scheme is nothing more than an a posteriori estimation of the density operator of a quantum-mechanical (microscopic) system based on data obtained with the help of a macroscopic measurement apparatus.3 The quality of the reconstruction depends on the "quality" of the measured data and the efficiency of the reconstruction procedure with the help of which the data analysis is performed. In particular, we can specify three different situations. Firstly, when all system observables are precisely measured. In this case the complete reconstruction of an initially unknown state can be performed (we will call this the reconstruction on the complete observation level) . Secondly, when just part of the system observables is precisely measured then one cannot perform a complete reconstruction of the measured state. Nevertheless, the reconstructed density operator still uniquely determines mean values of the measured observables (we will denote this scheme as reconstruction on incomplete observation levels) . Finally, when measurement does not provide us with sufficient information to specify the exact mean values (or probability distributions) but only the frequencies of appearances of eigenstates of the measured observables, then one can perform an estimation (e.g. reconstruction based on quantum Bayesian inference) which is the "best" with respect to the given measured data and the a priori knowledge about the state of the measured system.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jul 19, 1999•0 citations

Contractions of Product Density Operators of Systems of Identical Fermions and Bosons

Wiktor Radzki

Recurrence and explicit formulae for contractions (partial traces) of antisymmetric and symmetric products of identical trace class operators are derived. Contractions of product density operators of systems of identical fermions and bosons are proved to be asymptotically equivalent to, respectively, antisymmetric and symmetric products of density operators of a single particle, multiplied by a normalization integer. The asymptotic equivalence relation is defined in terms of the thermodynamic limit of expectation values of observables in the states represented by given density operators. For some weaker relation of asymptotic equivalence, concerning the thermodynamic limit of expectation values of product observables, normalized antisymmetric and symmetric products of density operators of a single particle are shown to be equivalent to tensor products of density operators of a single particle.

arXiv:0809.0474•International Journal of Mathematics and Mathematical Sciences•Jan 1, 2010•2 citations

Compatibility of state assignments and pooling of information

Todd A. Brun, Min-Hsiu Hsieh, Christopher Perry

A measure for the compatibility of state assignments of independent observers of the same quantum system is proposed, and the possibility of arriving at a unique state assignment by pooling of information is investigated.

arXiv:1310.5325•Physical Review A•Jul 13, 2015•4 citations

On quantum information

Adam Paszkiewicz, Tomasz Sobieszek

We investigate the following generalisation of the entropy of quantum measurement. Let H be an infinite-dimensional separable Hilbert space with a 'density' operator ρ, tr ρ=1. Let I(P)\in R be defined for any partition P = (P_1,...,P_m), P_1+ ... +P_m=1_H, P_i \in proj H$ and let I(P_i Qj, i \leq m, j \leq n) = I(P) + I(Q) for Q =(Q_1,..., Q_n), \sum Q_j = 1_H and P_iQ_j = Q_j P_i, tr ρ P_iQ_j = tr ρ P_i tr ρ Q_j (P, Q are physically independent). Assuming some continuity properties we give a general form of generalised information I.

arXiv:1203.3329•Mar 15, 2012•1 citation

Multipartite entanglement measure for all discrete systems

Beatrix C. Hiesmayr, Marcus Huber

Via a multidimensional complementarity relation we derive an operational entanglement measure for any discrete quantum system, i.e., for any multidimensional and multipartite system. This measure admits a separation into different classes of entanglement obtained by using a flip operator $2,3,\dots{},n$ times, defining a $m$-flip concurrence. This operator sum has the practical feature to allow one to calculate for mixed states bounds on this $m$-flip concurrence. Moreover, the information content of an $n$-partite multidimensional system admits a simple and intuitive interpretation in terms of single particle obtainable information, entanglement, and information due to lack of classical knowledge of the quantum state under investigation. Explicitly, the three qubit system is analyzed and, e.g., the physical difference in entanglement of the W state, the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state, or a biseparable state is revealed.

arXiv:0712.0346•Physical Review A•Jul 22, 2008•43 citations
When various observers obtain information in an independent fashion about a classical system, there is a simple rule which allows them to pool their knowledge, and this requires only the states-of-knowledge of the respective observers. Here we derive an equivalent quantum formula. While its realm of applicability is necessarily more limited, it does apply to a large class of measurements, and we show explicitly for a single qubit that it satisfies the intuitive notions of what it means to pool knowledge about a quantum system. This analysis also provides a physical interpretation for the trace of the product of two density matrices.
We consider the pooling of quantum states when Alice and Bob both have one part of a tripartite system and, on the basis of measurements on their respective parts, each infers a quantum state for the third part SSS. We denote the conditioned states which Alice and Bob assign to SSS by $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and $\ensuremath{\beta}$, respectively, while the unconditioned state of SSS is $\ensuremath{\rho}$. The state assigned by an overseer, who has all the data available to Alice and Bob, is $\ensuremath{\omega}$. The pooler is told only $\ensuremath{\alpha}$, $\ensuremath{\beta}$, and $\ensuremath{\rho}$. We show that for certain classes of tripartite states, this information is enough for her to reconstruct $\ensuremath{\omega}$ by the formula $\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{\propto}\ensuremath{\alpha}{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\ensuremath{\beta}$. Specifically, we identify two classes of states for which this pooling formula works: (i) all pure states for which the rank of $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is equal to the product of the ranks of the states of Alice's and Bob's subsystems; (ii) all mixtures of tripartite product states that are mutually orthogonal on SSS.
The concept of a quantum state represents one of the most fundamental pillars of the paradigm of quantum theory.'3 Contrary to its mathematical elegance and convenience in calculations, the physical interpretation of a quantum state is not so transparent. The problem is that the quantum state (described either by a state vector, or density operator or a phase-space probability density distribution) does not have a well defined objective status, i.e. a state vector is not an objective property of a particle. According to Peres (see,1 p. 374): "There is no physical evidence whatsoever that every physical system has at every instant a well defined state. .. In strict interpretation of quantum theory these mathematical symbols [i.e., state vectorsi represent statistical information enabling us to compute the probabilities of occurrence of specific events." Once this point of view is adopted then it becomes clear that any "measurement" or a reconstruction of a density operator (or its mathematical equivalent) can be understood exclusively as an expression of our knowledge about the quantum mechanical state based on a certain set of measured data. To be more specific, any quantum-mechanical reconstruction scheme is nothing more than an a posteriori estimation of the density operator of a quantum-mechanical (microscopic) system based on data obtained with the help of a macroscopic measurement apparatus.3 The quality of the reconstruction depends on the "quality" of the measured data and the efficiency of the reconstruction procedure with the help of which the data analysis is performed. In particular, we can specify three different situations. Firstly, when all system observables are precisely measured. In this case the complete reconstruction of an initially unknown state can be performed (we will call this the reconstruction on the complete observation level) . Secondly, when just part of the system observables is precisely measured then one cannot perform a complete reconstruction of the measured state. Nevertheless, the reconstructed density operator still uniquely determines mean values of the measured observables (we will denote this scheme as reconstruction on incomplete observation levels) . Finally, when measurement does not provide us with sufficient information to specify the exact mean values (or probability distributions) but only the frequencies of appearances of eigenstates of the measured observables, then one can perform an estimation (e.g. reconstruction based on quantum Bayesian inference) which is the "best" with respect to the given measured data and the a priori knowledge about the state of the measured system.
Recurrence and explicit formulae for contractions (partial traces) of antisymmetric and symmetric products of identical trace class operators are derived. Contractions of product density operators of systems of identical fermions and bosons are proved to be asymptotically equivalent to, respectively, antisymmetric and symmetric products of density operators of a single particle, multiplied by a normalization integer. The asymptotic equivalence relation is defined in terms of the thermodynamic limit of expectation values of observables in the states represented by given density operators. For some weaker relation of asymptotic equivalence, concerning the thermodynamic limit of expectation values of product observables, normalized antisymmetric and symmetric products of density operators of a single particle are shown to be equivalent to tensor products of density operators of a single particle.
We investigate the following generalisation of the entropy of quantum measurement. Let H be an infinite-dimensional separable Hilbert space with a 'density' operator ρ, tr ρ=1. Let I(P)\in R be defined for any partition P = (P_1,...,P_m), P_1+ ... +P_m=1_H, P_i \in proj H$ and let I(P_i Qj, i \leq m, j \leq n) = I(P) + I(Q) for Q =(Q_1,..., Q_n), \sum Q_j = 1_H and P_iQ_j = Q_j P_i, tr ρ P_iQ_j = tr ρ P_i tr ρ Q_j (P, Q are physically independent). Assuming some continuity properties we give a general form of generalised information I.
Via a multidimensional complementarity relation we derive an operational entanglement measure for any discrete quantum system, i.e., for any multidimensional and multipartite system. This measure admits a separation into different classes of entanglement obtained by using a flip operator 2,3,…,n2,3,\dots{},n2,3,…,n times, defining a mmm-flip concurrence. This operator sum has the practical feature to allow one to calculate for mixed states bounds on this mmm-flip concurrence. Moreover, the information content of an nnn-partite multidimensional system admits a simple and intuitive interpretation in terms of single particle obtainable information, entanglement, and information due to lack of classical knowledge of the quantum state under investigation. Explicitly, the three qubit system is analyzed and, e.g., the physical difference in entanglement of the W state, the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state, or a biseparable state is revealed.