Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0412177 · Quantum Information and Computation

The computational power of the W and GHZ states

Ellie D’Hondt, Prakash Panangaden

Published Mar 1, 2006• 124 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is well understood that the use of quantum entanglement significantly enhances the computational power of systems. Much of the attention has focused on Bell states and their multipartite generalizations. However, in the multipartite case it is known that there are several inequivalent classes of states, such as those represented by the W-state and the GHZ-state. Our main contribution is a demonstration of the special computational power of these states in the context of paradigmatic problems from classical distributed computing. Concretely, we show that the W-state is the only pure state that can be used to exactly solve the problem of leader election in anonymous quantum networks. Similarly we show that the GHZ-state is the only one that can be used to solve the problem of distributed consensus when no classical post-processing is considered. These results generalize to a family of W- and GHZ-like states. At the heart of the proofs of these impossibility results lie symmetry arguments.

DOI
10.26421/qic6.2-3

Related papers

Distributed quantum computing: a new frontier in distributed systems or science fiction?

Vasil S. Denchev, Gopal Pandurangan

Quantum computing and distributed systems may enter a mutually beneficial partnership in the future. On the one hand, it is much easier to build a number of small quantum computers rather than a single large one. On the other hand, the best results concerning some of the fundamental problems in distributed computing can potentially be dramatically improved upon by taking advantage of the superior resources and processing power that quantum mechanics offers. This survey has the purpose to highlight both of these benefits. We first review the current results regarding the implementation of arbitrary quantum algorithms on distributed hardware. We then discuss existing proposals for quantum solutions of leader election - a fundamental problem from distributed computing. Quantum mechanics allows leader election to be solved with no communication, provided that certain pre-shared entanglement is already in place. Further, an impossibility result from classical distributed computing is circumvented by the quantum solution of anonymous leader election - a unique leader is elected in finite time with certainty. Finally, we discuss the viability of these proposals from a practical perspective. Although, theoretically, distributed quantum computing looks promising, it is still unclear how to build quantum hardware and how to create and maintain robust large-scale entangled states. Moreover, it is not clear whether the costs of creating entangled states and working with them are smaller than the costs of existing classical solutions.

ACM SIGACT News•Sep 1, 2008•80 citations

Exact Quantum Algorithms for the Leader Election Problem

Seiichiro Tani, Hirotada Kobayashi, Keiji Matsumoto

This article gives a separation between quantum and classical models in pure (i.e., noncryptographic) computing abilities with no restriction on the amount of available computing resources, by considering the exact solvability of the leader election problem in anonymous networks, a celebrated unsolvable problem in classical distributed computing. The goal of the leader election problem is to elect a unique leader from among distributed parties. In an anonymous network, all parties with the same number of communication links are identical. It is well-known that no classical algorithm can exactly solve (i.e., in bounded time without error) the leader election problem in anonymous networks, even if the number of parties is given. This article devises a quantum algorithm that, if the number of parties is given, exactly solves the problem for any network topology in polynomial rounds with polynomial communication/time complexity with respect to the number of parties, when the parties are connected with quantum communication links and they have the ability of quantum computing. Our algorithm works even when only an upper bound of the number of parties is given. In such a case, no classical algorithm can solve the problem even under the zero-error setting, the setting in which error is not allowed but running time may be unbounded.

arXiv:0712.4213•ACM Transactions on Computation Theory•Mar 1, 2012•74 citations

Computing on Anonymous Quantum Network

Hirotada Kobayashi, Keiji Matsumoto, Seiichiro Tani

The anonymous network model was introduced by Angluin in [STOC '80, to understand the fundamental properties of distributed computing by examining how much each party in a network needs to know about its own identity and the identities of other parties.In this model, all parties with the same number of communication links are identical.When studying the model, the problem of electing a unique leader is the central problem in the sense that once a unique leader is elected, he can assign a unique identity to each party.It was proved in the literature, however, that it is impossible to deterministically solve the leader election problem with any finite amount of communication.This contrasts sharply with the situation in the quantum setting: the present authors gave quantum algorithms that exactly solve the problem on anonymous quantum networks, where quantum communication and computation can be performed [TOCT, vol.4,no.1, article 1].The core of their algorithm consists of somewhat tricky unitary operators, which eliminate the possibility of ties during (quantum) coin flipping and thereby reduce the number of leader candidates with certainty.This paper presents a new quantum leader election algorithm that is based on quantum reduction via exact amplitude amplification to a classically solvable problem, computing a certain symmetric function, which provides more intuitive reasoning behind the existence of exact quantum algorithms for leader election.The algorithm first achieves a round complexity that is linear in the number of parties, i.e., the largest possible diameter plus one of the underlying graph of the network.

arXiv:1001.5307•Chicago Journal of Theoretical Computer Science•Jan 1, 2014•8 citations

Simpler Exact Leader Election via Quantum Reduction

Hirotada Kobayashi, Keiji Matsumoto, Seiichiro Tani

The anonymous network model was introduced by Angluin in (STOC '80, pages 82-93) to understand the fundamental properties of distributed computing by examining how much each party in a network needs to know about its own identity and the identities of other parties. In this model, all parties with the same number of communication links are identical. When studying the model, the problem of electing a unique leader is the central problem in the sense that once a unique leader is elected, he can assign a unique identity to each party. It was proved in the literature, however, that it is impossible to deterministically solve the leader election problem with any finite amount of communication. This contrasts sharply with the situation in the quantum setting: the present authors gave quantum algorithms that exactly solve the problem on anonymous quantum networks, where quantum communication and computation can be performed (TOCT, vol.4, no.1, article 1). The core of their algorithm consists of somewhat tricky unitary operators, which eliminate the possibility of ties during (quantum) coin flipping and thereby reduce the number of leader candidates with certainty. This paper presents a new quantum leader election algorithm that is based on quantum reduction via exact amplitude amplification to a classically solvable problem, computing a certain symmetric function, which provides more intuitive reasoning behind the existence of exact quantum algorithms for leader election. The algorithm first achieves a round complexity that is linear in the number of parties, i.e., the largest possible diameter plus one of the underlying graph of the network.

Chicago Journal of Theoretical Computer Science•Jan 1, 2014•3 citations

Generation and Distribution of GHZ States in Quantum Networks

Mohammad Ghaderibaneh, Himanshu Gupta, C. R. Ramakrishnan

In quantum networks, multipartite entangled states distributed over the network are useful in implementing and supporting many quantum network applications for communications, sensing, and computing. The focus of our work is to de-velop techniques to efficiently generate distributed Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, a special class of multipartite entanglement states. Prior works on generating GHZ states have focused on the objective of minimizing the number of maximally entangled (bipartite) pairs (EPs), while ignoring the stochastic nature of quantum processes and assuming uniform network links for generating EPs. In contrast, in our work, we take into consideration the stochastic nature of quantum networks, and focus on maximizing the expected generated rate of the GHZ states under given fidelity constraints. In this context, we develop two efficient generation schemes, viz., Fusion - Retain - only and General Fusion, comprised of optimal or near-optimal sub-steps. Both schemes, at a high-level, first determine a way to “connect” the nodes over which the GHZ state is to distributed, and then, determine a sequence of fusion operations on the EPs created over the connections. Using extensive simulations over a quantum network simulator (NetSquid), we demonstrate the effectiveness of our developed techniques and show that our schemes outperform prior work as well as a simple centralized approach by up to orders of magnitude while generating GHZ states of tolerable fidelity.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 17, 2023•21 citations

Brief announcement

Hirotada Kobayashi, Keiji Matsumoto, Seiichiro Tani

This paper proves that, if quantum communication and computation are available and the number of parties is given, the leader election problem can exactly (i.e., without error in bounded time) be solved with at most the same complexity up to a constant factor as that of computing certain symmetric functions on an anonymous network of any unknown topology. Together with a novel quantum algorithm that computes a certain symmetric function, this characterization yields a quantum leader election algorithm that is more efficient than existing algorithms.

ACM Symposium on Principles of Distributed Computing (PODC)•Aug 10, 2009•4 citations
It is well understood that the use of quantum entanglement significantly enhances the computational power of systems. Much of the attention has focused on Bell states and their multipartite generalizations. However, in the multipartite case it is known that there are several inequivalent classes of states, such as those represented by the W-state and the GHZ-state. Our main contribution is a demonstration of the special computational power of these states in the context of paradigmatic problems from classical distributed computing. Concretely, we show that the W-state is the only pure state that can be used to exactly solve the problem of leader election in anonymous quantum networks. Similarly we show that the GHZ-state is the only one that can be used to solve the problem of distributed consensus when no classical post-processing is considered. These results generalize to a family of W- and GHZ-like states. At the heart of the proofs of these impossibility results lie symmetry arguments.
Quantum computing and distributed systems may enter a mutually beneficial partnership in the future. On the one hand, it is much easier to build a number of small quantum computers rather than a single large one. On the other hand, the best results concerning some of the fundamental problems in distributed computing can potentially be dramatically improved upon by taking advantage of the superior resources and processing power that quantum mechanics offers. This survey has the purpose to highlight both of these benefits. We first review the current results regarding the implementation of arbitrary quantum algorithms on distributed hardware. We then discuss existing proposals for quantum solutions of leader election - a fundamental problem from distributed computing. Quantum mechanics allows leader election to be solved with no communication, provided that certain pre-shared entanglement is already in place. Further, an impossibility result from classical distributed computing is circumvented by the quantum solution of anonymous leader election - a unique leader is elected in finite time with certainty. Finally, we discuss the viability of these proposals from a practical perspective. Although, theoretically, distributed quantum computing looks promising, it is still unclear how to build quantum hardware and how to create and maintain robust large-scale entangled states. Moreover, it is not clear whether the costs of creating entangled states and working with them are smaller than the costs of existing classical solutions.
This article gives a separation between quantum and classical models in pure (i.e., noncryptographic) computing abilities with no restriction on the amount of available computing resources, by considering the exact solvability of the leader election problem in anonymous networks, a celebrated unsolvable problem in classical distributed computing. The goal of the leader election problem is to elect a unique leader from among distributed parties. In an anonymous network, all parties with the same number of communication links are identical. It is well-known that no classical algorithm can exactly solve (i.e., in bounded time without error) the leader election problem in anonymous networks, even if the number of parties is given. This article devises a quantum algorithm that, if the number of parties is given, exactly solves the problem for any network topology in polynomial rounds with polynomial communication/time complexity with respect to the number of parties, when the parties are connected with quantum communication links and they have the ability of quantum computing. Our algorithm works even when only an upper bound of the number of parties is given. In such a case, no classical algorithm can solve the problem even under the zero-error setting, the setting in which error is not allowed but running time may be unbounded.
The anonymous network model was introduced by Angluin in [STOC '80, to understand the fundamental properties of distributed computing by examining how much each party in a network needs to know about its own identity and the identities of other parties.In this model, all parties with the same number of communication links are identical.When studying the model, the problem of electing a unique leader is the central problem in the sense that once a unique leader is elected, he can assign a unique identity to each party.It was proved in the literature, however, that it is impossible to deterministically solve the leader election problem with any finite amount of communication.This contrasts sharply with the situation in the quantum setting: the present authors gave quantum algorithms that exactly solve the problem on anonymous quantum networks, where quantum communication and computation can be performed [TOCT, vol.4,no.1, article 1].The core of their algorithm consists of somewhat tricky unitary operators, which eliminate the possibility of ties during (quantum) coin flipping and thereby reduce the number of leader candidates with certainty.This paper presents a new quantum leader election algorithm that is based on quantum reduction via exact amplitude amplification to a classically solvable problem, computing a certain symmetric function, which provides more intuitive reasoning behind the existence of exact quantum algorithms for leader election.The algorithm first achieves a round complexity that is linear in the number of parties, i.e., the largest possible diameter plus one of the underlying graph of the network.
The anonymous network model was introduced by Angluin in (STOC '80, pages 82-93) to understand the fundamental properties of distributed computing by examining how much each party in a network needs to know about its own identity and the identities of other parties. In this model, all parties with the same number of communication links are identical. When studying the model, the problem of electing a unique leader is the central problem in the sense that once a unique leader is elected, he can assign a unique identity to each party. It was proved in the literature, however, that it is impossible to deterministically solve the leader election problem with any finite amount of communication. This contrasts sharply with the situation in the quantum setting: the present authors gave quantum algorithms that exactly solve the problem on anonymous quantum networks, where quantum communication and computation can be performed (TOCT, vol.4, no.1, article 1). The core of their algorithm consists of somewhat tricky unitary operators, which eliminate the possibility of ties during (quantum) coin flipping and thereby reduce the number of leader candidates with certainty. This paper presents a new quantum leader election algorithm that is based on quantum reduction via exact amplitude amplification to a classically solvable problem, computing a certain symmetric function, which provides more intuitive reasoning behind the existence of exact quantum algorithms for leader election. The algorithm first achieves a round complexity that is linear in the number of parties, i.e., the largest possible diameter plus one of the underlying graph of the network.
In quantum networks, multipartite entangled states distributed over the network are useful in implementing and supporting many quantum network applications for communications, sensing, and computing. The focus of our work is to de-velop techniques to efficiently generate distributed Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, a special class of multipartite entanglement states. Prior works on generating GHZ states have focused on the objective of minimizing the number of maximally entangled (bipartite) pairs (EPs), while ignoring the stochastic nature of quantum processes and assuming uniform network links for generating EPs. In contrast, in our work, we take into consideration the stochastic nature of quantum networks, and focus on maximizing the expected generated rate of the GHZ states under given fidelity constraints. In this context, we develop two efficient generation schemes, viz., Fusion - Retain - only and General Fusion, comprised of optimal or near-optimal sub-steps. Both schemes, at a high-level, first determine a way to “connect” the nodes over which the GHZ state is to distributed, and then, determine a sequence of fusion operations on the EPs created over the connections. Using extensive simulations over a quantum network simulator (NetSquid), we demonstrate the effectiveness of our developed techniques and show that our schemes outperform prior work as well as a simple centralized approach by up to orders of magnitude while generating GHZ states of tolerable fidelity.
This paper proves that, if quantum communication and computation are available and the number of parties is given, the leader election problem can exactly (i.e., without error in bounded time) be solved with at most the same complexity up to a constant factor as that of computing certain symmetric functions on an anonymous network of any unknown topology. Together with a novel quantum algorithm that computes a certain symmetric function, this characterization yields a quantum leader election algorithm that is more efficient than existing algorithms.