Classical linear wave superposition produces the appearance of interference. This observation can be interpreted in two equivalent ways: one can assume that interference is an illusion because input components remain unperturbed, or that interference is real and input components undergo energy redistribution. Both interpretations entail the same observable consequences at the macroscopic level, but the first approach is considerably more popular. This preference was established before the emergence of quantum mechanics. Unfortunately, it requires a non-classical underlying mechanism and fails to explain well-known microscopic observations. Classical physics appears to collapse at the quantum level. On the other hand, quantum superposition can be described as a classical process if the second alternative is adopted. The gap between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics is an interpretive problem.
Classical linear wave superposition produces the appearance of interference. This observation can be interpreted in two equivalent ways: one can assume that interference is an illusion because input components remain unperturbed, or that interference is real and input components undergo energy redistribution. Both interpretations entail the same observable consequences at the macroscopic level, but the first approach is considerably more popular. This preference was established before the emergence of quantum mechanics. Unfortunately, it requires a non-classical underlying mechanism and fails to explain well-known microscopic observations. Classical physics appears to collapse at the quantum level. On the other hand, quantum superposition can be described as a classical process if the second alternative is adopted. The gap between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics is an interpretive problem.
A particle is described as a non-spreading wave packet satisfying a linear equation within the framework of special relativity. Young's and other interference experiments are explained with a hypothesis that there is a coupling interaction between the peaked and non-peaked pieces of the wave packet. This explanation of the interference experiments provides a realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics. The interpretation implies that there is physical reality of particles and no wave function collapse. It also implies that neither classical mechanics nor current quantum mechanics is a complete theory for describing physical reality and the Bell inequalities are not the proper touchstones for reality and locality. The problems of the boundary between the macro-world and micro-world and the de-coherence in the transition region (meso-world) between the two are discussed. The present interpretation of quantum mechanics is consistent with the physical aspects of the Copenhagen interpretation, such as, the superposition principle, Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and Born's probability interpretation, but does not favor its philosophical aspects, such as, non-reality, non-objectivity, non-causality and the complementary principle.
Quantum mechanics is based on Schrodinger’s wave function with linear superposition of vectors in a Hilbert space. Due to superposition, multiple physical states are considered simultaneously for the same time point, but when the corresponding quantum mechanical experiments are realized, there is only one outcome and not a superposition of pointer positions. This observation characterizes the quantum mechanical measurement problem, which for about a century found multiple interpretations, which can be classified as potentiality, as proposed by Heisenberg, or as real physical entities, for instance fields. Potentialities are yet inexistent in reality and unobservable in the present, since they represent a possible future. Thus, they can only be an intra-mental representation of a future process and not a physical extra-mental process ongoing in the present. There is coexistence of a physical object observable in reality and a mental prediction by an observer concerning the future behavior of this object. The characterization of quantum mechanical formalism by some physicists corresponds to a prediction and therefore to a mental representation of the future behavior of elementary particles and not to a description of an ongoing extra-mental process. Prediction in life and science has some characteristics, which resemble the measurement problem, since it undergoes a “multiple to one” reduction of mental potentialities to only one observable real outcome. Besides quantum mechanics, such reductions can also be found with many kinds of predictions, in classical physics for regular and irregular dynamical processes and in humans for programming future actions. Superposition in classical physics only concerns variable effects, but in quantum mechanics includes variable effects and non-localizable causes. Quantum mechanics, interpreted as prediction of future outcomes with multiple potentialities but only one realization, would resemble the general prediction problem in life and science and thereby loos its weird aspects.
The quasi-classical world of modern physics is a class of classical worlds superposed, literally a 'metaworld'. The measurement problem is itself evidence for the two different types of world, at the different levels of logical type. The enactment of linear dynamics in the classical worlds alters the class invariant, and thus induces physical collapse of the metaworld to a subclass. No new physics is required. The complex formalism that seems deeply counterintuitive is class arithmetic. Superposition and interference: properties of classes of worlds. Measurement: set-selection of a subclass compatible with the observed outcome. The uncertainty principle: incompatible set-selections. Fourier transforms: switching set-selection. Operators: enactment of set-selection. Decoherence: loss of coherence between worlds. Normalisation is required because all worlds are equally real, thus the probability of an outcome is essentially the proportion of worlds that instantiate it. True probability arises through phase, which is the degree to which the rest of each world aligns internally with this outcome. This is the second-logical-type phenomenon of interference: the degree to which worlds cohere in the classical actions that give rise to the outcome.This transforms the familiar structures of the formalism from postulates to inherent attributes of the class structure. The Born rule, unitary evolution, the complex structure of amplitudes, the probabilistic character of prediction, and the wave-mechanical form of the theory emerge as outputs of the ontology rather than independent axioms. The wavefunction is real. It is the ontological architecture of the metaworld and the reality of the quasi-classical world: this is the quantum realm. The classical world, quantum mechanics and relativistic physics are unified in logical types.
Optical interference is regarded as a classical phenomenon and is usually completely described in classical terms, in which optical fields are represented by classical waves. Does it mean that optical interference, which is fundamentally ascribable to the phenomenon of a superposition of wave amplitudes, cannot be applied to test quantum phenomena? The superposition principle is at the heart of quantum physics and one could expect that it should distinguish the quantum nature of light from thewave nature. Our experience based on extensive theoretical analysis and experimental observations shows that classical and quantum theories of optical interference readily explain the presence of an interference pattern resulting from the first-order coherence. However, there are interference effects involving the higher order (second-order) coherence that distinguish the quantum (photon) nature of light from the wave nature. Quantum interference has recently returned to prominence because of its utility in manipulating spontaneous emission and other radiative properties of atomic systems. In this chapter, we present elementary concepts and definitions of both the classical and quantum theory of optical interference and discuss similarities and differences between these two approaches [80].
The framework of classical physics encompasses the well-established and complete Helmholtz wave equation. Capable of accurately describing the propagation, interference and diffraction of steady-state harmonic waves such as acoustic and electromagnetic waves at the macroscopic scale, this equation has been validated by centuries of experiments and is widely recognized as a definitive formula in fundamental physics. Nevertheless, conventional physics has long imposed a rigid scope of application. The academic community has always adopted one-dimensional real scalar coordinates for the Helmholtz equation, limiting its use to macroscopic material wave fields, while never attempting to apply it to the microscopic quantum realm or the underlying ontological structure of the universe. Meanwhile, starting from the microscopic mathematical characteristics, Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics derives the uncertainty principle based on the non-commutation relation of matrices. It directly proves that microscopic mechanical quantities cannot be fully represented by real scalars, and that the microscopic universe is inherently governed by matrix-dimensional structures. This is the fundamental reason why numerous paradoxes persist within quantum mechanics under the framework of real coordinates. Addressing the dual limitations of existing physical theories, this paper presents original research. While fully retaining the differential operators, wave constraints and steady-state solution rules of the classical Helmholtz equation, and introducing no new physical constants or artificial auxiliary hypotheses, this work merely replaces the real spatial coordinates X and Y in the equation with second-order two-dimensional linear matrix coordinates. On this basis, a novel theoretical system of two-dimensional linear waves tailored for the microscopic ontology of the universe is independently established. To clarify: classical physics only adopts the Helmholtz wave with real coordinates to interpret macroscopic wave motions. By contrast, the Helmholtz wave model built upon two-dimensional linear matrix coordinates is an exclusive original theory proposed in this paper. It forms a brand-new independent classical system for depicting the true microscopic essence of the universe. Employing rigorously verified classical mathematical and physical tools, including the classical Helmholtz wave principle, Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics, the uncertainty principle, the linear projection theorem and the wave field superposition principle, this paper systematically elaborates the mathematical structure, dimensional properties and evolutionary laws of two-dimensional linear waves. It further reveals the ultimate physical nature of quantum measurement collapse. All substances in the microscopic world exist inherently as two-dimensional linear Helmholtz waves. Human macroscopic perception and detection devices can only process one-dimensional real-valued information. Essentially, the act of observation is not the random collapse of the wave function as defined in standard quantum mechanics. Instead, the observing system actively extracts one degree of freedom from the two-dimensional matrix wave. The remaining single dimension undergoes dimensionality reduction and projection onto the one-dimensional real physical space, giving rise to the apparent phenomenon of localized particles. This original theory explains two core experimental puzzles that have perplexed quantum physics for a century, without logical contradictions or ad hoc supplements. First, continuous observation of the interference pattern in the double-slit experiment collects global steady-state information of the superimposed two-dimensional waves, and no dimensional extraction occurs, so no collapse takes place. Second, when a single photon reaches the human retina or a single-point detector conducts fixed-position detection, the observing system imposes localized boundary conditions to forcibly extract dimensions from the wave field. This projects the two-dimensional wave onto the one-dimensional physical space, which manifests macroscopically as wave function collapse. This research breaks down the barrier between macroscopic classical waves and microscopic quantum phenomena. The proposed original classical model provides a unified interpretation of microscopic effects including wave-particle duality and quantum measurement collapse, offering a new fundamental perspective for the research on the grand unification of fundamental physics.
Interpreting quantum mechanics is a hard problem basically because it means explaining why and how the mathematics exploited to formulate wave-particle duality are related to observations or reality in classical physics. Consequently, interpretation of quantum mechanics and its formalism should involve proper physical mathematics, physical logic and classical physics, which is not the case from the Copenhagen interpretation. Here, we shall revisit all the postulates of quantum mechanics with proper physics and physical logic and reconstruct them to establish the less-complex interpretation of quantum mechanics with additional new postulates from classical physics. A new quantum mechanical postulate (Postulate 9) is also introduced to understand the meaning of the forbidden gap between discrete energy levels and/or electron orbitals in atoms that is valid for molecules and condensed matter based on quantum mechanics that is technically well-defined and experimentally observable. Here, we tackle all the problems arise from the Copenhagen interpretation systematically by revising and/or extending them with proper classical and quantum physics without violating established experiments and without proposing ideas that violate physical reality.