Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0408187 · Foundations of Physics

The Principle of Supplementarity: A Contextual Probabilistic Viewpoint to Complementarity, the Interference of Probabilities and Incompatibility of Variables in Quantum Mechanics

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Published Oct 1, 2005• 76 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1007/s10701-005-6511-z

Related papers

Reconstruction of quantum theory on the basis of the formula of total probability

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

The notion of context (complex of physical conditions) is basic in this paper. We show that the main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born’s rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the classical Kolmogorov probability model. However, this model should be considered as a calculus of contextual probabilities. In our approach it is forbidden to consider abstract context independent probabilities: “first context and then probability.” We start with the conventional formula of total probability for contextual (conditional) probabilities and then we rewrite it by eliminating combinations of incompatible contexts from consideration. In this way we obtain interference of probabilities without to appeal to the Hilbert space formalism or wave mechanics. However, we did not just reconstruct the probabilistic formalism of conventional quantum mechanics. Our contextual probabilistic model is essentially more general and, besides the projection to the complex Hilbert space, it has other projections. The most important new prediction is the possibility (at least theoretical) of appearance of hyperbolic interference. A projection of the classical contextual probabilistic model to the hyperbolic Hilbert space (a module over the commutative two dimensional Clifford algebra) has some similarities with the projection to the complex Hilbert space. However, in the hyperbolic quantum mechanics the principle of superposition is violated. Our realistic (but contextual!) approach to quantum mechanics does not contradict to various “no‐go theorems”, e.g., von Neumann, Bell, Kochen‐Specker. We emphasize that our projection of the classical probabilistic model to the complex Hilbert space is based on two incompatible observables (“reference observables”), e.g., the position and the momentum, or the position and the energy. Only these two observables can be considered as objective properties of quantum systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0302194•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2005•16 citations

I. Complementarity in Quantum Physics and its Philosophical Generalization

Adolf Grünbaum

The Journal of Philosophy•Jan 1, 1957•16 citations

Contextual Quantization and the Principle of Complementarity of Probabilities

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Sergei Vladimirovich Kozyrev

The contextual probabilistic quantization procedure is formulated. This approach to quantization has much broader field of applications, compared with the canonical quantization. The contextual probabilistic quantization procedure is based on the notions of probability context and the principle of complementarity of probabilities. The general definition of probability context is given. The principle of complementarity of probabilities, which combines the ideas of the Bohr complementarity principle and the technique of noncommutative probability, is introduced. The principle of complementarity of probabilities is the criterion of possibility of the contextual quantization.

arXiv:quant-ph/0310114•Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Aug 24, 2005•7 citations

Uncertainty principle and complementarity in axiomatic quantum mechanics

PEKKA J. LAHTI

Reports on Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1980•7 citations

On Quantum-Like Probabilistic Structure of Mental Information

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We describe methodology of cognitive experiments (based on interference of probabilities for mental observables) which could verify quantum-like structure of mental information, namely, interference of probabilities for incompatible observables. In principle, such experiments can be performed in psychology, cognitive, and social sciences. In fact, the general contextual probability theory predicts not only quantum-like trigonometric (cos θ) interference of probabilities, but also hyperbolic (cosh θ) interference of probabilities (as well as hyper-trigonometric). In principle, statistical data obtained in experiments with cognitive systems can produce hyperbolic (cosh θ) interference of probabilities. We introduce a wave function of (e.g., human) population. In general, we should not reject the possibility that cognitive functioning is neither quantum nor classical. We discuss the structure of state spaces for cognitive systems.

Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Sep 1, 2004•94 citations

Category-Theoretic Interpretative Framework of the Complementarity Principle in Quantum Mechanics

Elias Zafiris, Vassilios Karakostas

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Nov 13, 2019•2 citations
The notion of context (complex of physical conditions) is basic in this paper. We show that the main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born’s rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the classical Kolmogorov probability model. However, this model should be considered as a calculus of contextual probabilities. In our approach it is forbidden to consider abstract context independent probabilities: “first context and then probability.” We start with the conventional formula of total probability for contextual (conditional) probabilities and then we rewrite it by eliminating combinations of incompatible contexts from consideration. In this way we obtain interference of probabilities without to appeal to the Hilbert space formalism or wave mechanics. However, we did not just reconstruct the probabilistic formalism of conventional quantum mechanics. Our contextual probabilistic model is essentially more general and, besides the projection to the complex Hilbert space, it has other projections. The most important new prediction is the possibility (at least theoretical) of appearance of hyperbolic interference. A projection of the classical contextual probabilistic model to the hyperbolic Hilbert space (a module over the commutative two dimensional Clifford algebra) has some similarities with the projection to the complex Hilbert space. However, in the hyperbolic quantum mechanics the principle of superposition is violated. Our realistic (but contextual!) approach to quantum mechanics does not contradict to various “no‐go theorems”, e.g., von Neumann, Bell, Kochen‐Specker. We emphasize that our projection of the classical probabilistic model to the complex Hilbert space is based on two incompatible observables (“reference observables”), e.g., the position and the momentum, or the position and the energy. Only these two observables can be considered as objective properties of quantum systems.
The contextual probabilistic quantization procedure is formulated. This approach to quantization has much broader field of applications, compared with the canonical quantization. The contextual probabilistic quantization procedure is based on the notions of probability context and the principle of complementarity of probabilities. The general definition of probability context is given. The principle of complementarity of probabilities, which combines the ideas of the Bohr complementarity principle and the technique of noncommutative probability, is introduced. The principle of complementarity of probabilities is the criterion of possibility of the contextual quantization.
We describe methodology of cognitive experiments (based on interference of probabilities for mental observables) which could verify quantum-like structure of mental information, namely, interference of probabilities for incompatible observables. In principle, such experiments can be performed in psychology, cognitive, and social sciences. In fact, the general contextual probability theory predicts not only quantum-like trigonometric (cos θ) interference of probabilities, but also hyperbolic (cosh θ) interference of probabilities (as well as hyper-trigonometric). In principle, statistical data obtained in experiments with cognitive systems can produce hyperbolic (cosh θ) interference of probabilities. We introduce a wave function of (e.g., human) population. In general, we should not reject the possibility that cognitive functioning is neither quantum nor classical. We discuss the structure of state spaces for cognitive systems.