Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0402094 · International Journal of Quantum Information

PROPER AND IMPROPER SEPARABILITY

Christopher G. Timpson, Harvey R. Brown

Published Dec 1, 2005• 25 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The distinction between proper and improper mixtures is a staple of the discussion of foundational questions in quantum mechanics. Here we note an analogous distinction in the context of the theory of entanglement. The terminology of "proper" versus "improper" separability is proposed to mark the distinction.
DOI
10.1142/s0219749905001493

Related papers

Proper and Improper Mixtures

Bernard d’Espagnat

Observable dynamical quantities are described by Hermitean operators, and in the early days of quantum mechanics the correspondence was believed to be one-to-one. It was assumed that (i) every observable can be related to some Hermitean operator and (ii) every Hermitean operator corresponds to one observable. The arguments concerning the difference between proper and improper mixtures are conceived of for the benefit of the physicists with a "realist" turn of mind who, prima facie, would tend to consider that, quite on the contrary, the statement in question is meaningful and true. Two ensembles are said to be different with respect to some observable A if the statistical frequencies of the prospective measurement outcomes on observable A are different on the two ensembles. Also, two ensembles are said to be different if there exists at least one observable A with respect to which they are different.

CRC Press eBooks•May 4, 2018•0 citations

Mixtures

Bernard d’Espagnat

The relevant mathematical theory was developed with regard to mixtures and their description. That theory could of course be expanded to a considerable degree. However, an abundant literature exists already on that subject. As a first, elementary way of clarifying them this chapter introduces an unconventional but useful distinction between improper mixtures and proper mixtures. It then investigates the question of the homogeneity or heterogeneity of ensembles, as well as two related questions, which bear on the measurability of the density matrix and on the relation between Hermitean operators and observables, respectively. More precisely, the assumptions were made that every observable can be related to some Hermitean operator, and every Hermitean operator corresponds to one observable. The chapter includes a discussion of the meaning that can be given to this sentence: "Such and such an observable has such and such a value on a system.".

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

All quantum mixtures are proper

Leonardo Castellani

It is argued that proper and improper quantum mixed states have no observable differences, and hence should not be distinguished. This has implications for subjective approaches to quantum mechanics, and invalidates one of the main motivations for relational interpretations.

arXiv:2201.04143•International Journal of Quantum Information•Mar 10, 2023•4 citations

Indistinguishability and improper mixtures

Kirkpatrick, K. A.

All quantum mixtures are what d'Espagnat has termed "improper." His "proper" mixture cannot be created -- if welcher weg, or distinguishing, information exists, an improper mixture results, while in the absence of such information, the resulting "mixture" is a pure state. D'Espagnat has claimed that an interpretation of the improper mixture in terms of subensembles leads to logical inconsistency; this claim is shown to be incorrect, as d'Espagnat's argument fails to account for the indistinguishability of the pure-state subensembles.

arXiv:quant-ph/0109146•Sep 27, 2001•16 citations

The Many Inconsistencies of the Purity-Mixture Distinction in Standard Quantum Mechanics

Christian DE RONDE, César Massri

The distinction between pure states and mixed states is a kernel ingredient of what is considered to be the standard formulation of quantum mechanics and plays today a kernel role in foundational debates about the meaning of quantum probability, the separability of quantum systems, the definition and measure of entanglement, etc. In this work we attempt to expose the many inconsistencies introduced by this distinction and the serious consequences this has for many ongoing research programs within quantum physics which apply these notions uncritically.

arXiv:2208.10574•Aug 22, 2022•3 citations

The modal interpretation of quantum mechanics and the distinction between proper and improper mixtures

Chunghyoung Lee

•Jun 1, 2011•1 citation
Observable dynamical quantities are described by Hermitean operators, and in the early days of quantum mechanics the correspondence was believed to be one-to-one. It was assumed that (i) every observable can be related to some Hermitean operator and (ii) every Hermitean operator corresponds to one observable. The arguments concerning the difference between proper and improper mixtures are conceived of for the benefit of the physicists with a "realist" turn of mind who, prima facie, would tend to consider that, quite on the contrary, the statement in question is meaningful and true. Two ensembles are said to be different with respect to some observable A if the statistical frequencies of the prospective measurement outcomes on observable A are different on the two ensembles. Also, two ensembles are said to be different if there exists at least one observable A with respect to which they are different.
The relevant mathematical theory was developed with regard to mixtures and their description. That theory could of course be expanded to a considerable degree. However, an abundant literature exists already on that subject. As a first, elementary way of clarifying them this chapter introduces an unconventional but useful distinction between improper mixtures and proper mixtures. It then investigates the question of the homogeneity or heterogeneity of ensembles, as well as two related questions, which bear on the measurability of the density matrix and on the relation between Hermitean operators and observables, respectively. More precisely, the assumptions were made that every observable can be related to some Hermitean operator, and every Hermitean operator corresponds to one observable. The chapter includes a discussion of the meaning that can be given to this sentence: "Such and such an observable has such and such a value on a system.".
All quantum mixtures are what d'Espagnat has termed "improper." His "proper" mixture cannot be created -- if welcher weg, or distinguishing, information exists, an improper mixture results, while in the absence of such information, the resulting "mixture" is a pure state. D'Espagnat has claimed that an interpretation of the improper mixture in terms of subensembles leads to logical inconsistency; this claim is shown to be incorrect, as d'Espagnat's argument fails to account for the indistinguishability of the pure-state subensembles.
The distinction between pure states and mixed states is a kernel ingredient of what is considered to be the standard formulation of quantum mechanics and plays today a kernel role in foundational debates about the meaning of quantum probability, the separability of quantum systems, the definition and measure of entanglement, etc. In this work we attempt to expose the many inconsistencies introduced by this distinction and the serious consequences this has for many ongoing research programs within quantum physics which apply these notions uncritically.