Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0401121

Quantum entanglement, interaction, and the classical limit

Thomas Durt

Published Jan 1, 2004• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

PACS number: O3.65.Bz Abstract: Two or more quantum systems are said to be in an entangled or nonfactorisable state if their joint (supposedly pure) wave-function is not expressible as a product of individual wave functions but is instead a superposition of product states. It is only when the systems are in a factorisable state that they can be considered to be separated (in the sense of Bell). We show that whenever two quantum systems interact with each other, it is impossible that all factorisable states remain factorisable during the interaction unless the full Hamiltonian does not couple these systems so to say unless they do not really interact. We also present certain conditions under which particular factorisable states remain factorisable although they represent a bipartite system whose components mutually interact. We identify certain quasi-classical regimes that satisfy these conditions and show that they correspond to classical, pre-quantum, paradigms associated to the concept of particle

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0401121

Related papers

Characterisation of an entanglement-free evolution

Thomas Durt

Two or more quantum systems are said to be in an entangled or non-factorisable state if their joint (supposedly pure) wave-function is not expressible as a product of individual wave functions but is instead a superposition of product states. It is only when the systems are in a factorisable state that they can be considered to be separated (in the sense of Bell). We show that whenever two quantum systems interact with each other, it is impossible that all factorisable states remain factorisable during the interaction unless the full Hamiltonian does not couple these systems so to say unless they do not really interact. We also present certain conditions under which particular factorisable states remain factorisable although they represent a bipartite system whose components mutually interact and pay a particular attention to the case where the two particles interact mutually through an action at a distance in the three dimensional space.

arXiv:quant-ph/0109112•Sep 21, 2001•12 citations

Entangled states : Classical versus Quantum

S. Kanmani

Quantum mechanics of composite systems, gives rise to certain special states called entangled states. A physical system, that is in an entangled state displays an intricate correlation between its subsystems. There are also some composite quantum states (classically correlated states or separable states) that are not entangled. It is generally claimed, often without a rigorous proof to support, that these intricate correlations of an entangled state cannot occur in a classical system. This expository article, provides an elementary proof that entangled states cannot arise in the setting of classical mechanics. In addition, a detailed description of the origin of entanglement in quantum systems is included. The mathematical concepts that are necessary for this purpose are presented. The absence of entanglement in the classical setting is due to the fact that every pure classical state of a composite system is a product state, that is, a tensor product of two pure states of the subsystems. In contrast, there are pure composite quantum states that cannot be expressed in the form of a product state or even by a convex sum of product states. Roughly speaking, this is because classical states are positive valued functions on the phase-space while quantum states are positive linear operators. The structure of the tensor product between two commutative spaces of scalar valued functions is drastically different from that of the tensor product between two non-commutative spaces of linear operators. In other words, entanglement is a non-commutative phenomenon.

arXiv:0907.1784•Jul 10, 2009•1 citation

The classical-quantum limit considered from the point of view of entanglement: a survey

Thomas Durt

Three paradigms commonly used in classical, pre-quantum physics to describe particles (that is: the material point, the test-particle and the diluted particle (droplet model)) can be identified as limit-cases of a quantum regime in which pairs of particles interact without getting entangled with each other. This entanglement-free regime also provides a simplified model of what is called in the decoherence approach islands of classicality, that is, preferred bases that would be selected through evolution by a Darwinist mechanism that aims at optimising information. We show how, under very general conditions, coherent states are natural candidates for classical pointer states. This occurs essentially because, when a (supposedly bosonic) system coherently exchanges only one quantum at a time with the (supposedly bosonic) environment, coherent states of the system do not get entangled with the environment, due to the bosonic symmetry.

•Jun 25, 2012•0 citations

Classical states versus separable states

Nan Li, Shunlong Luo

A bipartite state is called classical (with regard to correlations) if it is left undisturbed by a certain local von Neumann measurement, and is called separable if it can be represented as a convex combination of product states. Due to the perfect distinguishability of orthogonal vectors, a classical state can essentially be identified with a convenient bivariate probability distribution, and moreover, it is separable, but not vice versa. The notion of separability plays a key role in quantum information theory because entanglement is defined via separability. However, the definition of separability is ad hoc and formal. In this paper, we present an intrinsic characterization of separable states via classical states from the measurement perspective: Separable states are precisely those states that are reductions of classical states in higher dimensions with the natural partitions. Consequently, entangled states are precisely those states that cannot be represented as such reductions of classical states. This observation highlights the hidden mutually exclusive and complementary relations between classicality and entanglement.

Physical Review A•Aug 14, 2008•83 citations

Quantum sensing of even- versus odd-body interactions

Aparajita Bhattacharyya, Debarupa Saha, Ujjwal Sen

We analyze the scaling of quantum Fisher information with the number of system particles in the limit of large number of particles, as a function of the number of parties interacting with each other, for encoding Hamiltonians having arbitrary-body interactions. We find that estimation of coupling strength of such arbitrary-body encoding Hamiltonians provide a super-Heisenberg scaling that increases monotonically with an increase in the number of interacting particles, in the limit of large number of system particles. Moreover, we also find that the optimal probes corresponding to Hamiltonians that contain even-body interaction terms, may be entangled, but certainly not so in all bipartitions, and particularly, it is possible to attain optimal precision using asymmetric probes. Thereby we find a complementarity in the requirement of asymmetry and genuine entanglement in optimal probes for estimating strength of odd- and even-body interactions respectively. Additionally, we provide an upper bound on the number of parties up to which one can always obtain an asymmetric product state that gives the best metrological precision for even-body interactions. En route, we find the quantum Fisher information in closed form for two- and three-body interactions for arbitrary number of parties. We also provide an analysis of the case when the Hamiltonian contains local fields and up to k-body interaction terms, where the strength of interaction gradually decreases with an increase in the number of parties interacting with each other. Interestingly, we find a similar dichotomy in the nature of the optimal probe in this case as well. Further, we identify conditions on the local component of the Hamiltonian, for which this dichotomy is still shown to exist for two- and three-body encoding Hamiltonians with arbitrary local dimensions.

arXiv:2401.06729•Physical Review A•Sep 10, 2025•10 citations

An operational distinction between quantum entanglement and classical non-separability

Natalia Korolkova, Luis Lorenzo Sánchez-Soto, Gerd Leuchs

Quantum entanglement describes superposition states in multi-dimensional systems-at least two partite-which cannot be factorized and are thus non-separable. Non-separable states also exist in classical theories involving vector spaces. In both cases, it is possible to violate a Bell-like inequality. This has led to controversial discussions, which we resolve by identifying an operational distinction between the classical and quantum cases.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.

arXiv:2405.15692•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 24, 2024•9 citations
PACS number: O3.65.Bz Abstract: Two or more quantum systems are said to be in an entangled or nonfactorisable state if their joint (supposedly pure) wave-function is not expressible as a product of individual wave functions but is instead a superposition of product states. It is only when the systems are in a factorisable state that they can be considered to be separated (in the sense of Bell). We show that whenever two quantum systems interact with each other, it is impossible that all factorisable states remain factorisable during the interaction unless the full Hamiltonian does not couple these systems so to say unless they do not really interact. We also present certain conditions under which particular factorisable states remain factorisable although they represent a bipartite system whose components mutually interact. We identify certain quasi-classical regimes that satisfy these conditions and show that they correspond to classical, pre-quantum, paradigms associated to the concept of particle
Two or more quantum systems are said to be in an entangled or non-factorisable state if their joint (supposedly pure) wave-function is not expressible as a product of individual wave functions but is instead a superposition of product states. It is only when the systems are in a factorisable state that they can be considered to be separated (in the sense of Bell). We show that whenever two quantum systems interact with each other, it is impossible that all factorisable states remain factorisable during the interaction unless the full Hamiltonian does not couple these systems so to say unless they do not really interact. We also present certain conditions under which particular factorisable states remain factorisable although they represent a bipartite system whose components mutually interact and pay a particular attention to the case where the two particles interact mutually through an action at a distance in the three dimensional space.
Quantum mechanics of composite systems, gives rise to certain special states called entangled states. A physical system, that is in an entangled state displays an intricate correlation between its subsystems. There are also some composite quantum states (classically correlated states or separable states) that are not entangled. It is generally claimed, often without a rigorous proof to support, that these intricate correlations of an entangled state cannot occur in a classical system. This expository article, provides an elementary proof that entangled states cannot arise in the setting of classical mechanics. In addition, a detailed description of the origin of entanglement in quantum systems is included. The mathematical concepts that are necessary for this purpose are presented. The absence of entanglement in the classical setting is due to the fact that every pure classical state of a composite system is a product state, that is, a tensor product of two pure states of the subsystems. In contrast, there are pure composite quantum states that cannot be expressed in the form of a product state or even by a convex sum of product states. Roughly speaking, this is because classical states are positive valued functions on the phase-space while quantum states are positive linear operators. The structure of the tensor product between two commutative spaces of scalar valued functions is drastically different from that of the tensor product between two non-commutative spaces of linear operators. In other words, entanglement is a non-commutative phenomenon.
Three paradigms commonly used in classical, pre-quantum physics to describe particles (that is: the material point, the test-particle and the diluted particle (droplet model)) can be identified as limit-cases of a quantum regime in which pairs of particles interact without getting entangled with each other. This entanglement-free regime also provides a simplified model of what is called in the decoherence approach islands of classicality, that is, preferred bases that would be selected through evolution by a Darwinist mechanism that aims at optimising information. We show how, under very general conditions, coherent states are natural candidates for classical pointer states. This occurs essentially because, when a (supposedly bosonic) system coherently exchanges only one quantum at a time with the (supposedly bosonic) environment, coherent states of the system do not get entangled with the environment, due to the bosonic symmetry.
A bipartite state is called classical (with regard to correlations) if it is left undisturbed by a certain local von Neumann measurement, and is called separable if it can be represented as a convex combination of product states. Due to the perfect distinguishability of orthogonal vectors, a classical state can essentially be identified with a convenient bivariate probability distribution, and moreover, it is separable, but not vice versa. The notion of separability plays a key role in quantum information theory because entanglement is defined via separability. However, the definition of separability is ad hoc and formal. In this paper, we present an intrinsic characterization of separable states via classical states from the measurement perspective: Separable states are precisely those states that are reductions of classical states in higher dimensions with the natural partitions. Consequently, entangled states are precisely those states that cannot be represented as such reductions of classical states. This observation highlights the hidden mutually exclusive and complementary relations between classicality and entanglement.
We analyze the scaling of quantum Fisher information with the number of system particles in the limit of large number of particles, as a function of the number of parties interacting with each other, for encoding Hamiltonians having arbitrary-body interactions. We find that estimation of coupling strength of such arbitrary-body encoding Hamiltonians provide a super-Heisenberg scaling that increases monotonically with an increase in the number of interacting particles, in the limit of large number of system particles. Moreover, we also find that the optimal probes corresponding to Hamiltonians that contain even-body interaction terms, may be entangled, but certainly not so in all bipartitions, and particularly, it is possible to attain optimal precision using asymmetric probes. Thereby we find a complementarity in the requirement of asymmetry and genuine entanglement in optimal probes for estimating strength of odd- and even-body interactions respectively. Additionally, we provide an upper bound on the number of parties up to which one can always obtain an asymmetric product state that gives the best metrological precision for even-body interactions. En route, we find the quantum Fisher information in closed form for two- and three-body interactions for arbitrary number of parties. We also provide an analysis of the case when the Hamiltonian contains local fields and up to k-body interaction terms, where the strength of interaction gradually decreases with an increase in the number of parties interacting with each other. Interestingly, we find a similar dichotomy in the nature of the optimal probe in this case as well. Further, we identify conditions on the local component of the Hamiltonian, for which this dichotomy is still shown to exist for two- and three-body encoding Hamiltonians with arbitrary local dimensions.
Quantum entanglement describes superposition states in multi-dimensional systems-at least two partite-which cannot be factorized and are thus non-separable. Non-separable states also exist in classical theories involving vector spaces. In both cases, it is possible to violate a Bell-like inequality. This has led to controversial discussions, which we resolve by identifying an operational distinction between the classical and quantum cases.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.