Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0312036

Uncertainties in the Measurement of the Momentum and Position of an Electron

Kirk T. McDonald

Published Dec 3, 2003• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It has been suggested that the uncertainty in the measurement of a particle's momentum could be made arbitrarily small by observing the particle at two ends of an arbitrarily long flight path. However, consideration of the nature of the detection process shows that the usual limits of the uncertainty principle hold independent of the length of the flight path.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0312036

Related papers

Confusion in our Understanding of Uncertainty Principle and Quantum Probability

Durgadas Datta.

Because the particles follow a wave pattern of probability prescribed by schrodinger equation and we are guided by uncertainty principles, we often wrongly interpret the nature of reality. Heisenberg only prescribes the measurement problems of very small due to limitations of wave length of the observing beam and that is the natural limitation but wrongly we say that nature is acting indeterministi. Thus we wrongly understand uncertainty principles connecting t to saying that nature can never be precisely defined in momentum and position.In the same way we measure time in relativity theory confusing the very notion of time.

Pure and applied physics•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

A thought experiment violating Heisenberg's uncertainty principle

M. C. Robinson

In principle, it is possible to make simultaneous and precise measurements of a particle's velocity using two different methods, which should give identical results. It is shown that these results permit the calculation of the particle's position and momentum with a combined error [Formula: see text] at every instant of time in an arbitrarily large interval. It is also shown that, in the special case considered, the statistical interpretation of the wave function is invalid.

Canadian Journal of Physics•May 1, 1969•12 citations

Uncertainty beyond the Uncertainty Principle

Charles Day

According to a new extension to an old theory, a particle's position cannot be measured precisely even if its momentum is not measured simultaneously.By Charles Day H eisenberg's uncertainty principle limits the precision with which two observables that do not commute with each other can be simultaneously measured.The Wigner-Araki-Yanase (WAY) theorem goes further.If observables A and B do not commute, and if observable A is conserved, observable B cannot be measured with arbitrary precision even if A is not measured at all.In its original 1960 formulation, the WAY theorem applied only to observables, such as spin, whose possible values are discrete and bounded.Now Yui Kuramochi of Kyushu University and Hiroyasu Tajima of the University of Electro-Communications-both in Japan-have proven that the WAY theorem also encompasses observables, such as position, that are continuous and unbounded [1].Besides resolving the decades-long problem of how to deal with such observables, the extension will likely find practical applications in quantum optics.The difficulty of extending the WAY theorem arose from how an

Physics•Nov 21, 2023•0 citations

Confidence uncertainty: position and momentum can be jointly determined with a guaranteed probability

Jia-Yi Lin, Xin-Yu Li, Wei Wang +1 more

Standard-deviation and entropic formulations of uncertainty principle capture the spread of the probability distribution but say little about the probability itself contained in a small region. We introduce the confidence uncertainty $Δ^{c}x(θ_x)$ as the minimal Lebesgue measure of the support set in which the particle is found with probability at least $θ_x$, and the companion interval confidence uncertainty $Δ^{I}x(θ_x)$ which restricts the support to a single interval. We prove two complementary uncertainty inequalities. (i) For $θ_x+θ_p\le 1$ both confidence uncertainties can be made arbitrarily small simultaneously, so that no nontrivial product bound holds; in particular, position and momentum can be jointly localised with probability at least~$50\%$. (ii) For $θ_x+θ_p>1$ a lower bound holds: combining Lenard's projection inequality with the Donoho--Stark operator-norm bound we obtain $Δ^{c}x\,Δ^{c}p\geq 2π\hbar\bigl(\sqrt{θ_xθ_p}-\sqrt{(1-θ_x)(1-θ_p)}\bigr)^{\!2}$, and for the interval version we obtain the sharp implicit Landau--Pollak bound $Δ^{I}x\,Δ^{I}p\geq 4\hbar\,λ_{0}^{-1}\!\bigl((\sqrt{θ_xθ_p}-\sqrt{(1-θ_x)(1-θ_p)})^{2}\bigr)$, where $λ_{0}(c)$ is the largest prolate-spheroidal eigenvalue. We support the analytical bounds with numerical evaluation of $λ_{0}(c)$, provide closed-form small-$c$ and large-$c$ asymptotics, compute the optimal Slepian-superposition states that saturate the interval bound, and compare the resulting product against the variance Heisenberg--Kennard, the Białynicki-Birula--Mycielski entropic, and the Donoho--Stark concentration bounds. The unified picture provides a complete phase diagram on $(θ_x,θ_p)\in[0,1]^{2}$.

quant-pharXiv:2605.04484•Physics Letters A•May 7, 2026•1 citation

Quantum Effects on the Accuracy of Momentum Measurements

C. H. Woo

It is shown in two examples that to measure the momentum of a particle with great accuracy, allowing for large uncertainties in the position, it is still necessary to consider additional quantum effects. For the case of measurements by electromagnetic means, the uncertainties in the measurability of field strengths and of charge-current densities should be considered. Within the framework of the Bohr-Rosenfeld analysis, uncertainties in the field measurements do not limit the accuracy of momentum measurements. What happens when the Bohr-Rosenfeld approximations are not made is an open question.

Physical Review•Aug 23, 1965•2 citations

Note on the Uncertainty Principle

Edward Fredkin

We describe a hypothetical apparatus for making arbitrarily accurate simultaneous successive measurements of a particle�s positions, momenta, energies and times.

•Jul 1, 2011•0 citations
It has been suggested that the uncertainty in the measurement of a particle's momentum could be made arbitrarily small by observing the particle at two ends of an arbitrarily long flight path. However, consideration of the nature of the detection process shows that the usual limits of the uncertainty principle hold independent of the length of the flight path.
Because the particles follow a wave pattern of probability prescribed by schrodinger equation and we are guided by uncertainty principles, we often wrongly interpret the nature of reality. Heisenberg only prescribes the measurement problems of very small due to limitations of wave length of the observing beam and that is the natural limitation but wrongly we say that nature is acting indeterministi. Thus we wrongly understand uncertainty principles connecting t to saying that nature can never be precisely defined in momentum and position.In the same way we measure time in relativity theory confusing the very notion of time.
According to a new extension to an old theory, a particle's position cannot be measured precisely even if its momentum is not measured simultaneously.By Charles Day H eisenberg's uncertainty principle limits the precision with which two observables that do not commute with each other can be simultaneously measured.The Wigner-Araki-Yanase (WAY) theorem goes further.If observables A and B do not commute, and if observable A is conserved, observable B cannot be measured with arbitrary precision even if A is not measured at all.In its original 1960 formulation, the WAY theorem applied only to observables, such as spin, whose possible values are discrete and bounded.Now Yui Kuramochi of Kyushu University and Hiroyasu Tajima of the University of Electro-Communications-both in Japan-have proven that the WAY theorem also encompasses observables, such as position, that are continuous and unbounded [1].Besides resolving the decades-long problem of how to deal with such observables, the extension will likely find practical applications in quantum optics.The difficulty of extending the WAY theorem arose from how an
Standard-deviation and entropic formulations of uncertainty principle capture the spread of the probability distribution but say little about the probability itself contained in a small region. We introduce the confidence uncertainty Δcx(θx)Δ^{c}x(θ_x)Δcx(θx​) as the minimal Lebesgue measure of the support set in which the particle is found with probability at least θxθ_xθx​, and the companion interval confidence uncertainty ΔIx(θx)Δ^{I}x(θ_x)ΔIx(θx​) which restricts the support to a single interval. We prove two complementary uncertainty inequalities. (i) For θx+θp≤1θ_x+θ_p\le 1θx​+θp​≤1 both confidence uncertainties can be made arbitrarily small simultaneously, so that no nontrivial product bound holds; in particular, position and momentum can be jointly localised with probability at least~50%50\%50%. (ii) For θx+θp>1θ_x+θ_p>1θx​+θp​>1 a lower bound holds: combining Lenard's projection inequality with the Donoho--Stark operator-norm bound we obtain Δcx Δcp≥2πℏ(θxθp−(1−θx)(1−θp)) ⁣2Δ^{c}x\,Δ^{c}p\geq 2π\hbar\bigl(\sqrt{θ_xθ_p}-\sqrt{(1-θ_x)(1-θ_p)}\bigr)^{\!2}ΔcxΔcp≥2πℏ(θx​θp​​−(1−θx​)(1−θp​)​)2, and for the interval version we obtain the sharp implicit Landau--Pollak bound ΔIx ΔIp≥4ℏ λ0−1 ⁣((θxθp−(1−θx)(1−θp))2)Δ^{I}x\,Δ^{I}p\geq 4\hbar\,λ_{0}^{-1}\!\bigl((\sqrt{θ_xθ_p}-\sqrt{(1-θ_x)(1-θ_p)})^{2}\bigr)ΔIxΔIp≥4ℏλ0−1​((θx​θp​​−(1−θx​)(1−θp​)​)2), where λ0(c)λ_{0}(c)λ0​(c) is the largest prolate-spheroidal eigenvalue. We support the analytical bounds with numerical evaluation of λ0(c)λ_{0}(c)λ0​(c), provide closed-form small-ccc and large-ccc asymptotics, compute the optimal Slepian-superposition states that saturate the interval bound, and compare the resulting product against the variance Heisenberg--Kennard, the Białynicki-Birula--Mycielski entropic, and the Donoho--Stark concentration bounds. The unified picture provides a complete phase diagram on (θx,θp)∈[0,1]2(θ_x,θ_p)\in[0,1]^{2}(θx​,θp​)∈[0,1]2.
It is shown in two examples that to measure the momentum of a particle with great accuracy, allowing for large uncertainties in the position, it is still necessary to consider additional quantum effects. For the case of measurements by electromagnetic means, the uncertainties in the measurability of field strengths and of charge-current densities should be considered. Within the framework of the Bohr-Rosenfeld analysis, uncertainties in the field measurements do not limit the accuracy of momentum measurements. What happens when the Bohr-Rosenfeld approximations are not made is an open question.