Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0309219

Grandma's local realistic theory for the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm experiment

Boon Leong Lan

Published Sep 30, 2003• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A local realistic theory is presented for Mermin's special case of the EPRB experiment. The theory, which is readily extended to the general EPRB experiment, reproduces all the predictions of quantum theory. It also reveals that Bell, and also Hess and Philipp, had made an error in the mathematical formulation of Einstein's locality or no action at a distance principle.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0309219

Related papers

Grandma's local realistic theory for the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger experiment

Boon Leong Lan

A realistic theory is constructed for the GHZ experiment. It is shown that the theory is local and it reproduces all the probabilistic predictions of quantum theory. This local realistic theory shows that GHZ had formulated Einstein's locality or no-action-at-a-distance principle incorrectly in their local realistic theory for the experiment.

arXiv:quant-ph/0310119•Oct 20, 2003•1 citation

A realistic view of the canonical Einstein$ndash$Podolsky$ndash$Rosen$ndash$Bohm experiment based on quantum theory and its consequences

Boon Leong Lan

A realistic view of the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen–Bohm experiment with spins based on quantum theory is presented. This view implies that there is no action at a distance. It also implies that the measurement result A ( B ) for particle 1 (2) depends on both magnet angles, and hence the probability of obtaining the result A ( B ) also depends on both magnet angles. In the light of these realistic implications, it is clear that what is wrong at least with local realistic theory is not the locality or no-action-at-a-distance assumption itself but rather the formal implementation of that assumption.

arXiv:quant-ph/0202151•Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Aug 1, 2002•5 citations

On the problem of a local extension of the quantum formalism

Thomas D. Angelidis

The suggested impossibility of a consistent local extension of the quantum formalism is reviewed in the context of the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen–Bohm (EPRB) ideal experiment. A consistent local theory Th(𝒢) extending the quantum formalism is proposed. The postulates of Th(𝒢) stipulate a finer state specification than that given by the quantum state ‖γ1,γ2≳. This describes how the spontaneous annihilation process itself breaks the spherical symmetry of the singlet state ‖γ1,γ2≳ into a pair of back-to-back photons having only axial symmetry about the direction of their motion. The theory Th(𝒢) shows that local action suffices to explain all that the quantum formalism predicts for the EPRB ideal experiment as well as some other results.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1993•8 citations

A minimal local extension of the quantum formalism

Thomas D. Angelidis

We propose a consistent local theory Th(g) extending the quantum formalism. As a consequence, a realistic and local (“common cause”) interpretation of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm ideal experiment can now be given. The extended local theory Th(g) satisfies the Bell inequality τ. We call for an experiment to test the validity of τ∈Th(g) and submit it as a crucial test against the apparently false conjecture of nonlocality.

Mysteries, Puzzles, and Paradoxes in Quantum Mechanics•Jan 1, 1999•1 citation

New Slant on the EPR-Bell Experiment

P. W. Evans, Huw Price, K. B. Wharton

The best case for thinking that quantum mechanics is nonlocal rests on Bell's Theorem, and later results of the same kind. However, the correlations characteristic of Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR)–Bell (EPRB) experiments also arise in familiar cases elsewhere in quantum mechanics (QM), where the two measurements involved are timelike rather than spacelike separated; and in which the correlations are usually assumed to have a local causal explanation, requiring no action-at-a-distance (AAD). It is interesting to ask how this is possible, in the light of Bell's Theorem. We investigate this question, and present two options. Either (i) the new cases are nonlocal too, in which case AAD is more widespread in QM than has previously been appreciated (and does not depend on entanglement, as usually construed); or (ii) the means of avoiding AAD in the new cases extends in a natural way to EPRB, removing AAD in these cases too. There is a third option, viz., that the new cases are strongly disanalogous to EPRB. But this option requires an argument, so far missing, that the physical world breaks the symmetries which otherwise support the analogy. In the absence of such an argument, the orthodox combination of views—action-at-a-distance in EPRB, but local causality in its timelike analogue—is less well established than it is usually assumed to be. 1 Introduction 1.1 Background 1.2 Outline of the argument2 The Experiments 2.1 Standard EPRB 2.2 Sideways EPRB 2.3 Comparing the experiments 2.4 The need for beables3 The Symmetry Considerations 3.1 The action symmetry 3.2 Time-symmetry in SEPRB4 The Basic Trilemma 4.1 An intuitive defence of Option III?5 Avoiding the Trilemma?6 The Classical Objection7 Defending Option III 7.1 The free will argument 7.2 Independence and consistency8 Entanglement and Epistemic Perspective

arXiv:1001.5057•The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Jun 14, 2012•45 citations

EPR, Bell, and quantum locality

Robert B. Griffiths

Maudlin has claimed that no local theory can reproduce the predictions of standard quantum mechanics that violate Bell’s inequality for Bohm’s version (two spin-half particles in a singlet state) of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen problem. It is argued that, on the contrary, standard quantum mechanics itself is a counterexample to Maudlin’s claim, because it is local in the appropriate sense (measurements at one place do not influence what occurs elsewhere there) when formulated using consistent principles in place of the inconsistent appeals to “measurement” found in current textbooks. This argument sheds light on the claim of Blaylock that counterfactual definiteness is an essential ingredient in derivations of Bell’s inequality.

arXiv:1007.4281•American Journal of Physics•Aug 19, 2011•69 citations
A local realistic theory is presented for Mermin's special case of the EPRB experiment. The theory, which is readily extended to the general EPRB experiment, reproduces all the predictions of quantum theory. It also reveals that Bell, and also Hess and Philipp, had made an error in the mathematical formulation of Einstein's locality or no action at a distance principle.
A realistic view of the canonical EinsteinndashndashndashPodolskyndashndashndashRosenndashndashndashBohm experiment based on quantum theory and its consequences
A realistic view of the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen–Bohm experiment with spins based on quantum theory is presented. This view implies that there is no action at a distance. It also implies that the measurement result A ( B ) for particle 1 (2) depends on both magnet angles, and hence the probability of obtaining the result A ( B ) also depends on both magnet angles. In the light of these realistic implications, it is clear that what is wrong at least with local realistic theory is not the locality or no-action-at-a-distance assumption itself but rather the formal implementation of that assumption.
The suggested impossibility of a consistent local extension of the quantum formalism is reviewed in the context of the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen–Bohm (EPRB) ideal experiment. A consistent local theory Th(𝒢) extending the quantum formalism is proposed. The postulates of Th(𝒢) stipulate a finer state specification than that given by the quantum state ‖γ1,γ2≳. This describes how the spontaneous annihilation process itself breaks the spherical symmetry of the singlet state ‖γ1,γ2≳ into a pair of back-to-back photons having only axial symmetry about the direction of their motion. The theory Th(𝒢) shows that local action suffices to explain all that the quantum formalism predicts for the EPRB ideal experiment as well as some other results.
The best case for thinking that quantum mechanics is nonlocal rests on Bell's Theorem, and later results of the same kind. However, the correlations characteristic of Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR)–Bell (EPRB) experiments also arise in familiar cases elsewhere in quantum mechanics (QM), where the two measurements involved are timelike rather than spacelike separated; and in which the correlations are usually assumed to have a local causal explanation, requiring no action-at-a-distance (AAD). It is interesting to ask how this is possible, in the light of Bell's Theorem. We investigate this question, and present two options. Either (i) the new cases are nonlocal too, in which case AAD is more widespread in QM than has previously been appreciated (and does not depend on entanglement, as usually construed); or (ii) the means of avoiding AAD in the new cases extends in a natural way to EPRB, removing AAD in these cases too. There is a third option, viz., that the new cases are strongly disanalogous to EPRB. But this option requires an argument, so far missing, that the physical world breaks the symmetries which otherwise support the analogy. In the absence of such an argument, the orthodox combination of views—action-at-a-distance in EPRB, but local causality in its timelike analogue—is less well established than it is usually assumed to be. 1 Introduction 1.1 Background 1.2 Outline of the argument2 The Experiments 2.1 Standard EPRB 2.2 Sideways EPRB 2.3 Comparing the experiments 2.4 The need for beables3 The Symmetry Considerations 3.1 The action symmetry 3.2 Time-symmetry in SEPRB4 The Basic Trilemma 4.1 An intuitive defence of Option III?5 Avoiding the Trilemma?6 The Classical Objection7 Defending Option III 7.1 The free will argument 7.2 Independence and consistency8 Entanglement and Epistemic Perspective
Maudlin has claimed that no local theory can reproduce the predictions of standard quantum mechanics that violate Bell’s inequality for Bohm’s version (two spin-half particles in a singlet state) of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen problem. It is argued that, on the contrary, standard quantum mechanics itself is a counterexample to Maudlin’s claim, because it is local in the appropriate sense (measurements at one place do not influence what occurs elsewhere there) when formulated using consistent principles in place of the inconsistent appeals to “measurement” found in current textbooks. This argument sheds light on the claim of Blaylock that counterfactual definiteness is an essential ingredient in derivations of Bell’s inequality.