Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0308108 · Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Comment on “Measurement of quantum states of neutrons in the Earth’s gravitational field”

Johan Hansson, David Olevik, C. Türk, Hanna Wiklund

Published Nov 18, 2003• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the paper by Nesvizhevsky et al. [Phys. Rev. D 67, 102002 (2003)], it is argued that the lowest quantum state of neutrons in the Earth's gravitational field has been experimentally identified. While this is most likely correct, it is imperative to investigate all alternative explanations of the result in order to close all loopholes, as it is the first experiment ever claimed to have observed gravitational quantum states. Here we show that geometrical effects in the experimental setup can mimic the results attributed to gravity. Modifications of the experimental setup to close these possible loopholes are suggested.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.68.108701

Related papers

Critique of an Experiment Regarding Quantum States in a Gravitational Field and Possible Geometrical Explanations

David Olevik, C. Türk, Hanna Wiklund +1 more

We discuss an experiment conducted by Nesvizhevsky et al. As it is the first experiment claimed to have observed gravitational quantum states, it is imperative to investigate all alternative explanations of the result. In a student project course in applied quantum mechanics, we consider the possibility of quantummechanical effects arising from the geometry of the experimental setup, due to the "cavity" formed. We try to reproduce the experimental result using geometrical arguments only. Due to the influence of several unknown parameters our result is still inconclusive.

arXiv:quant-ph/0206034•Jun 6, 2002•1 citation

Comment On "On observation of neutron quantum states in the Earth's gravitational field"

V. K. Ignatovich

It is shown that criticism in the paper: "On observation of neutron quantum states in the Earth's gravitational field." Phys.Rev.D {\bf 81} 052008 (2010) of the experiment with neutrons to observe bound levels in gravity field is not correct.

arXiv:1101.0888•Jan 5, 2011•0 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Measurement of quantum states of neutrons in the Earth’s gravitational field’ ”

V. V. Nesvizhevsky, A. Petoukhov, H. G. Börner +6 more

Possible false effects in the experiment on the measurement of quantum states of neutrons in the Earth's gravitational field are discussed. It is shown that the measured quantum states are defined mainly by a mirror and the gravitational field.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 18, 2003•21 citations

Quantization of neutron in Earth's gravity

Pulak Ranjan Giri

Gravity is the weakest of all four known forces in the universe. Quantum states of an elementary particle due to such a weak field is certainly very shallow and would therefore be an experimental challenge to detect. Recently an experimental attempt was made by V. V. Nesvizhevsky et al., Nature 415, 297 (2002), to measure the quantum states of a neutron, which shows that ground state and few excited states are \sim 10^{-12}eV. We show that the energy of the ground state of a neutron confined above Earth's surface should be \sim 10^{-37}eV. The experimentally observed energy levels are 10^{25} times deeper than the actual energy levels it should be and thus certainly not due to gravitational effect of Earth. Therefore the correct interpretation for the painstaking experimental results of Ref. \cite{nes1} is due to the confinement potential of a one dimensional box of length L \sim 50μm, generated from the experimental setup as commented before \cite{hansoon}. Our results thus creates a new challenge to the experimentalist to resolve the shallow energy levels of the neutron in Earth's gravitational field in future.

arXiv:0708.2649•Aug 20, 2007•0 citations

On observation of neutron quantum states in Earth gravitational field at Laue-Langevin Institute, Grenoble

Anatoli Vankov

The experiment performed with ultra-cold neutrons at the Laue-Langevin Institute, Grenoble, is analyzed in view of the claim that ``neutron quantum states in Earth gravitational field'' are observed. Our conclusion is that the above claim is neither theoretically nor experimentally substantiated. We also criticize the statement that ``observation of the gravitationally bound quantum states of neutrons and the related experimental techniques provide a unique tool for a broad range of investigations in fundamental physics of particles and fields''.

arXiv:0808.1362•Aug 9, 2008•0 citations

On observation of neutron quantum states in the Earth’s gravitational field

Anatoli Vankov

Observation of neutron gravitational quantum states ${E}_{n}=mg{z}_{n}$ in the peV energy range (${z}_{1}$ is about $10\text{ }\text{ }\ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{m}$ in the vertical direction) in the experiment conducted at Laue-Langevin Institute, Grenoble, with ultracold neutrons was recently reported in a series of publications. The purpose of the present work is to analyze the experiment. The experimental apparatus is designed to measure a transmission function $T({z}_{a})$, namely, a horizontal flux of relatively fast neutrons ($k\ensuremath{\gg}{k}_{z}$ in wavelength terms) passing through a slit of variable height ${z}_{a}$ of upper absorbing wall. The quantum states in question are defined by the so-called Airy functions, which are solutions to the stationary 1D equation for a neutron ``bouncing'' above the perfect mirror in a linear potential field. The Airy functions describe the quantum bouncer (QB), the concept of which is subject to theoretical study of toy 1D models of gravitationally bound particles in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (QM). This is essentially different from the 3D nonstationary QM object, ``the running QB,'' investigated in the experiment. The authors assume that there is a connection between $T({z}_{a})$ and the probability density distribution $P(z,{z}_{a})$ for QB states. They devised the ``phenomenological model,'' in which the quantum pattern should be visible in the transmission curve. We argue, however, that the measured curve $T({z}_{a})$ is not sensitive to QB states. Instead, it is sensitive to dynamics of neutron horizontal transport inside the absorbing slit for neutrons of energy values about ${10}^{5}$ times greater than eigenvalues ${E}_{n}$. The latter are related to the neutron transverse mode ${k}_{z}$ and cannot be termed ``energies of neutron gravitational quantum states.'' We conclude that the experiment setup and real conditions are not adequate to the claimed objective, and the methodology of measured data treatment is flawed. The authors' claim that ``neutron gravitational quantum states are observed'' is neither theoretically nor experimentally substantiated. Final, statistically significant results of the experiment are consistent with our physical reasoning that the experiment is not sensitive to ``neutron gravitational quantum states'' (in terms of Airy mode) and does not prove even their existence in rigorous quantum-mechanical terms.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Mar 24, 2010•1 citation
In the paper by Nesvizhevsky et al. [Phys. Rev. D 67, 102002 (2003)], it is argued that the lowest quantum state of neutrons in the Earth's gravitational field has been experimentally identified. While this is most likely correct, it is imperative to investigate all alternative explanations of the result in order to close all loopholes, as it is the first experiment ever claimed to have observed gravitational quantum states. Here we show that geometrical effects in the experimental setup can mimic the results attributed to gravity. Modifications of the experimental setup to close these possible loopholes are suggested.
We discuss an experiment conducted by Nesvizhevsky et al. As it is the first experiment claimed to have observed gravitational quantum states, it is imperative to investigate all alternative explanations of the result. In a student project course in applied quantum mechanics, we consider the possibility of quantummechanical effects arising from the geometry of the experimental setup, due to the "cavity" formed. We try to reproduce the experimental result using geometrical arguments only. Due to the influence of several unknown parameters our result is still inconclusive.
Gravity is the weakest of all four known forces in the universe. Quantum states of an elementary particle due to such a weak field is certainly very shallow and would therefore be an experimental challenge to detect. Recently an experimental attempt was made by V. V. Nesvizhevsky et al., Nature 415, 297 (2002), to measure the quantum states of a neutron, which shows that ground state and few excited states are \sim 10^{-12}eV. We show that the energy of the ground state of a neutron confined above Earth's surface should be \sim 10^{-37}eV. The experimentally observed energy levels are 10^{25} times deeper than the actual energy levels it should be and thus certainly not due to gravitational effect of Earth. Therefore the correct interpretation for the painstaking experimental results of Ref. \cite{nes1} is due to the confinement potential of a one dimensional box of length L \sim 50μm, generated from the experimental setup as commented before \cite{hansoon}. Our results thus creates a new challenge to the experimentalist to resolve the shallow energy levels of the neutron in Earth's gravitational field in future.
The experiment performed with ultra-cold neutrons at the Laue-Langevin Institute, Grenoble, is analyzed in view of the claim that ``neutron quantum states in Earth gravitational field'' are observed. Our conclusion is that the above claim is neither theoretically nor experimentally substantiated. We also criticize the statement that ``observation of the gravitationally bound quantum states of neutrons and the related experimental techniques provide a unique tool for a broad range of investigations in fundamental physics of particles and fields''.
Observation of neutron gravitational quantum states En=mgzn{E}_{n}=mg{z}_{n}En​=mgzn​ in the peV energy range (z1{z}_{1}z1​ is about $10\text{ }\text{ }\ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{m}$ in the vertical direction) in the experiment conducted at Laue-Langevin Institute, Grenoble, with ultracold neutrons was recently reported in a series of publications. The purpose of the present work is to analyze the experiment. The experimental apparatus is designed to measure a transmission function T(za)T({z}_{a})T(za​), namely, a horizontal flux of relatively fast neutrons ($k\ensuremath{\gg}{k}_{z}$ in wavelength terms) passing through a slit of variable height za{z}_{a}za​ of upper absorbing wall. The quantum states in question are defined by the so-called Airy functions, which are solutions to the stationary 1D equation for a neutron ``bouncing'' above the perfect mirror in a linear potential field. The Airy functions describe the quantum bouncer (QB), the concept of which is subject to theoretical study of toy 1D models of gravitationally bound particles in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (QM). This is essentially different from the 3D nonstationary QM object, ``the running QB,'' investigated in the experiment. The authors assume that there is a connection between T(za)T({z}_{a})T(za​) and the probability density distribution P(z,za)P(z,{z}_{a})P(z,za​) for QB states. They devised the ``phenomenological model,'' in which the quantum pattern should be visible in the transmission curve. We argue, however, that the measured curve T(za)T({z}_{a})T(za​) is not sensitive to QB states. Instead, it is sensitive to dynamics of neutron horizontal transport inside the absorbing slit for neutrons of energy values about 105{10}^{5}105 times greater than eigenvalues En{E}_{n}En​. The latter are related to the neutron transverse mode kz{k}_{z}kz​ and cannot be termed ``energies of neutron gravitational quantum states.'' We conclude that the experiment setup and real conditions are not adequate to the claimed objective, and the methodology of measured data treatment is flawed. The authors' claim that ``neutron gravitational quantum states are observed'' is neither theoretically nor experimentally substantiated. Final, statistically significant results of the experiment are consistent with our physical reasoning that the experiment is not sensitive to ``neutron gravitational quantum states'' (in terms of Airy mode) and does not prove even their existence in rigorous quantum-mechanical terms.