Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0307018 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Ehrenfest theorem, Galilean invariance and nonlinear Schrödinger equations

German Kälbermann

Published Feb 11, 2004• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We prove that Galilean invariant Schrödinger equations derived from Lagrangian densities necessarily obey the Ehrenfest theorem for velocity-independent potentials. The conclusion holds as well for Lagrangians describing nonlinear self-interactions. An example of Doebner and Goldin motivates the result.
DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/37/8/011

Related papers

Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics and Locality

W. Lücke, P. Nattermann

It is shown that, in order to avoid unacceptable nonlocal effects, the free parameters of the general Doebner-Goldin equation have to be chosen such that this nonlinear Schrödinger equation becomes Galilean covariant.

arXiv:quant-ph/9707055•Jul 30, 1997•4 citations

Nonlinear Gauge Transformations and Exact Solutions of the Doebner-Goldin Equation

P. Nattermann, Wolfgang Scherer

Invariants of nonlinear gauge transformations of a family of nonlinear Schrödinger equations proposed by Doebner and Goldin are used to characterize the behaviour of exact solutions of these equations.

arXiv:quant-ph/9506033•Jun 21, 1995•9 citations

Properties of nonlinear Schrodinger equations associated with diffeomorphism group representations

H. D. Doebner, Gerald A. Goldin

The authors recently derived a family of nonlinear Schrodinger equations on R 3 from fundamental considerations of generalized symmetry: ih(cross) delta t psi =-(h(cross) 2 /2m) Del 2 psi +F( psi , psi ) psi +ih(cross)D( Del 2 psi +( mod Del psi mod 2 / mod psi mod 2 ) psi ), where F is an arbitrary real functional and D a real, continuous quantum number. These equations, descriptive of a quantum mechanical current that includes a diffusive term, correspond to unitary representations of the group Diff(M) parametrized by D, where M=R 3 is the physical space. In the present paper we explore the most natural ansatz for F, which is labelled by five real coefficients. We discuss the invariance properties, describe the stationary states and some non-stationary solutions, and determine the extra, dissipative terms that occur in the Ehrenfest theorem. We identify an interesting, Galilean-invariant subfamily whose properties we investigate, including the case where the dissipative terms vanish.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Mar 7, 1994•104 citations

The Galilean covariance of quantum mechanics in the case of external fields

Harvey R. Brown, Peter Holland

Textbook treatments of the Galilean covariance of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for a spinless particle seem invariably to cover the case of a free particle or one in the presence of a scalar potential. The principal objective of this paper is to examine the situation in the case of arbitrary forces, including the velocity-dependent variety resulting from a vector potential. To this end, we revisit the 1964 theorem of Jauch which purports to determine the most general form of the Hamiltonian consistent with “Galilean-invariance,” and argue that the proof is less than compelling. We then show systematically that the Schrödinger equation in the case of a Jauch-type Hamiltonian is Galilean covariant, so long as the vector and scalar potentials transform in a certain way. These transformations, which to our knowledge have appeared very rarely in the literature on quantum mechanics, correspond in the case of electrodynamical forces to the “magnetic” nonrelativistic limit of Maxwell’s equations in the sense of Le Bellac and Lévy-Leblond (1973). Finally, this Galilean covariant theory sheds light on Feynman’s “proof” of Maxwell’s equations, as reported by Dyson in 1990.

American Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 1999•70 citations

Nonlinear Phase Modification of the Schroedinger Equation

Waldemar Puszkarz

A nonlinear modification of the Schrödinger equation is proposed in which the Lagrangian density for the Schrödinger equation is extended by terms polynomial in $Δ^{m}\ln (Ψ^{*}/Ψ)$ multiplied by $Ψ^{*}Ψ$. This introduces a homogeneous nonlinearity in a Galilean invariant manner through the phase $S$ rather than the amplitude $R$ of the wave function $Ψ=R\exp (iS)$. From this general scheme we choose the simplest minimal model defined in some reasonable way. The model in question offers the simplest way to modify the Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics so as to allow a leading phase contribution to the quantum potential and a leading quantum contribution to the probability current removing asymmetries present in Bohm's original formulation. It preserves most of physically relevant properties of the Schrödinger equation including stationary states of quantum-mechanical systems. It can be thought of as the simplest model of nonlinear quantum mechanics of extended objects among other such models that also emerge within the general scheme proposed. The extensions of this model to $n$ particles and the question of separability of compound systems are studied. It is noted that there exists a weakly separable extension in addition to a strongly separable one. The place of the general modification scheme in a broader spectrum of nonlinear modifications of the Schrödinger equation is discussed. It is pointed out that the models it gives rise to have a unique definition of energy in that the field-theoretical energy functional coincides with the quantum-mechanical one. It is found that the Lagrangian for its simplest variant represents the Lagrangian for a restricted version of the Doebner-Goldin modification of this equation.

arXiv:quant-ph/9710010•Oct 2, 1997•3 citations

Introducing nonlinear gauge transformations in a family of nonlinear Schrödinger equations

H. D. Doebner, Gerald A. Goldin

In earlier work we proposed a family of nonlinear time-evolution equations for quantum mechanics associated with certain unitary group representations [Doebner and Goldin, Phys. Lett. A 162, 397 (1992); J. Phys. A 27, 1771 (1994)]. Such nonlinear Schr\"odinger equations are expected to describe irreversible and dissipative quantum systems. Here we introduce and justify physically the group of nonlinear gauge transformations necessary to interpret our equations. We determine the parameters that are actually gauge invariant and describe some of their properties. Our conclusions contradict, at least in part, the view that any nonlinearity in quantum mechanics leads to unphysical predictions. We also show how time-dependent nonlinear gauge transformations connect our equations to those proposed by Kostin [J. Chem. Phys. 57, 3589 (1972)] and by Bialynicki-Birula and Mycielski [Ann. Phys. 100, 62 (1976)]. We believe our approach to be a fundamental generalization of the usual notions about gauge transformations in quantum mechanics. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1996•133 citations
The authors recently derived a family of nonlinear Schrodinger equations on R 3 from fundamental considerations of generalized symmetry: ih(cross) delta t psi =-(h(cross) 2 /2m) Del 2 psi +F( psi , psi ) psi +ih(cross)D( Del 2 psi +( mod Del psi mod 2 / mod psi mod 2 ) psi ), where F is an arbitrary real functional and D a real, continuous quantum number. These equations, descriptive of a quantum mechanical current that includes a diffusive term, correspond to unitary representations of the group Diff(M) parametrized by D, where M=R 3 is the physical space. In the present paper we explore the most natural ansatz for F, which is labelled by five real coefficients. We discuss the invariance properties, describe the stationary states and some non-stationary solutions, and determine the extra, dissipative terms that occur in the Ehrenfest theorem. We identify an interesting, Galilean-invariant subfamily whose properties we investigate, including the case where the dissipative terms vanish.
Textbook treatments of the Galilean covariance of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for a spinless particle seem invariably to cover the case of a free particle or one in the presence of a scalar potential. The principal objective of this paper is to examine the situation in the case of arbitrary forces, including the velocity-dependent variety resulting from a vector potential. To this end, we revisit the 1964 theorem of Jauch which purports to determine the most general form of the Hamiltonian consistent with “Galilean-invariance,” and argue that the proof is less than compelling. We then show systematically that the Schrödinger equation in the case of a Jauch-type Hamiltonian is Galilean covariant, so long as the vector and scalar potentials transform in a certain way. These transformations, which to our knowledge have appeared very rarely in the literature on quantum mechanics, correspond in the case of electrodynamical forces to the “magnetic” nonrelativistic limit of Maxwell’s equations in the sense of Le Bellac and Lévy-Leblond (1973). Finally, this Galilean covariant theory sheds light on Feynman’s “proof” of Maxwell’s equations, as reported by Dyson in 1990.
A nonlinear modification of the Schrödinger equation is proposed in which the Lagrangian density for the Schrödinger equation is extended by terms polynomial in Δmln⁡(Ψ∗/Ψ)Δ^{m}\ln (Ψ^{*}/Ψ)Δmln(Ψ∗/Ψ) multiplied by Ψ∗ΨΨ^{*}ΨΨ∗Ψ. This introduces a homogeneous nonlinearity in a Galilean invariant manner through the phase SSS rather than the amplitude RRR of the wave function Ψ=Rexp⁡(iS)Ψ=R\exp (iS)Ψ=Rexp(iS). From this general scheme we choose the simplest minimal model defined in some reasonable way. The model in question offers the simplest way to modify the Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics so as to allow a leading phase contribution to the quantum potential and a leading quantum contribution to the probability current removing asymmetries present in Bohm's original formulation. It preserves most of physically relevant properties of the Schrödinger equation including stationary states of quantum-mechanical systems. It can be thought of as the simplest model of nonlinear quantum mechanics of extended objects among other such models that also emerge within the general scheme proposed. The extensions of this model to nnn particles and the question of separability of compound systems are studied. It is noted that there exists a weakly separable extension in addition to a strongly separable one. The place of the general modification scheme in a broader spectrum of nonlinear modifications of the Schrödinger equation is discussed. It is pointed out that the models it gives rise to have a unique definition of energy in that the field-theoretical energy functional coincides with the quantum-mechanical one. It is found that the Lagrangian for its simplest variant represents the Lagrangian for a restricted version of the Doebner-Goldin modification of this equation.
In earlier work we proposed a family of nonlinear time-evolution equations for quantum mechanics associated with certain unitary group representations [Doebner and Goldin, Phys. Lett. A 162, 397 (1992); J. Phys. A 27, 1771 (1994)]. Such nonlinear Schr\"odinger equations are expected to describe irreversible and dissipative quantum systems. Here we introduce and justify physically the group of nonlinear gauge transformations necessary to interpret our equations. We determine the parameters that are actually gauge invariant and describe some of their properties. Our conclusions contradict, at least in part, the view that any nonlinearity in quantum mechanics leads to unphysical predictions. We also show how time-dependent nonlinear gauge transformations connect our equations to those proposed by Kostin [J. Chem. Phys. 57, 3589 (1972)] and by Bialynicki-Birula and Mycielski [Ann. Phys. 100, 62 (1976)]. We believe our approach to be a fundamental generalization of the usual notions about gauge transformations in quantum mechanics. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.