Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0306189

Reply to "No spin-statistics connection in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics"

Murray Peshkin

Published Jun 27, 2003• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a previous paper [quant-ph/0207017] I gave an elementary proof, starting from stated assumptions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, that identical spin-zero particles must be bosons. Since then it has been suggested that my proof assumed its conclusion, and that it is based on a theory "quite different from standard physics." [quant-ph/0304088] I show here that those two statements are incorrect.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0306189

Related papers

Reply to “Comment on ‘Spin and statistics in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics: The spin-zero case’ ”

Murray Peshkin

The preceding Comment states that I have assumed the conclusion in my proof from nonrelativistic quantum mechanics that spin-zero particles must be bosons, and that the theory presented is different from standard quantum mechanics. I show here that neither of those statements is true.

Physical Review A•Oct 14, 2003•12 citations

Reply to "Non-relativistic proofs of the spin-statistics connection," by Shaji and Sudarshan

Murray Peshkin

I earlier proved under stated assumptions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, that identical spin-zero particles with no internal degrees of freedom must be bosons. Shaji and Sudarshan have criticized that proof, asserting that it is "based on single-valuedness under rotation of the wave functions of systems of identical particles." No such assumption was used. Here, to remove all doubt, I exclude the fermion possibility through a proof in which even the existence of rotation is not used. Following that, I assume that the Hilbert space is invariant under rotation to exclude other symmetries which correspond neither to bosons nor to fermions. In that proof no issue of single-valuedness can arise.

arXiv:quant-ph/0402118•Feb 17, 2004•5 citations

Comment on “Spin and statistics in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics: The spin-zero case”

Roland E. Allen, Alfonso Mondragón

We emphasize that there is no spin-statistics connection in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. In several recent papers [including Phys. Rev. A 67, 042102 (2003)], quantum mechanics is modified so as to force a spin-statistics connection, but the resulting theory is quite different from standard physics.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304088•Physical Review A•Oct 14, 2003•18 citations

Spin and statistics in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics: The spin-zero case

Murray Peshkin

It is proved from stated assumptions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics based on the Schroedinger equation that identical spin-zero particles must obey symmetric statistics.

arXiv:quant-ph/0207017•Physical Review A•Apr 4, 2003•17 citations

On Spin and Statistics in Quantum Mechanics

Peshkin, M

It is proved from the assumptions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics that identical spin-zero particles must obey symmetric statistics.

•Jul 3, 2002•1 citation

Comments on Struyve and Baere's paper on experiments to distinguish Bohmian mechanics from quantum mechanics

Partha Ghose

It is shown in detail why the arguments put forward by Struyve and Baere (quant-ph/0108038) against my conclusions are incorrect.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208192•Aug 30, 2002•5 citations
In a previous paper [quant-ph/0207017] I gave an elementary proof, starting from stated assumptions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, that identical spin-zero particles must be bosons. Since then it has been suggested that my proof assumed its conclusion, and that it is based on a theory "quite different from standard physics." [quant-ph/0304088] I show here that those two statements are incorrect.
I earlier proved under stated assumptions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, that identical spin-zero particles with no internal degrees of freedom must be bosons. Shaji and Sudarshan have criticized that proof, asserting that it is "based on single-valuedness under rotation of the wave functions of systems of identical particles." No such assumption was used. Here, to remove all doubt, I exclude the fermion possibility through a proof in which even the existence of rotation is not used. Following that, I assume that the Hilbert space is invariant under rotation to exclude other symmetries which correspond neither to bosons nor to fermions. In that proof no issue of single-valuedness can arise.