Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0211165 · Physical Review A

Comment on “Some implications of the quantum nature of laser fields for quantum computations”

Wayne M. Itano

Published Oct 14, 2003• 28 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A recent discussion of quantum limitations to the fidelity with which superpositions of internal atomic energy levels can be generated by an applied, quantized, laser pulse, is shown to be based on unrealistic physical assumptions. This discussion assumed the validity of Jaynes-Cummings dynamics for an atom interacting with a laser field in free space, that is, when the atom is not surrounded by a resonant cavity. If the laser field is a multimode quantum coherent state, and the Rabi frequency is much greater than the spontaneous decay rate, then the total atomic decoherence rate is on the order of the spontaneous decay rate. With the use of a unitary transformation of the field states due to Mollow, it can be shown that the atomic decoherence rate is the same as if the laser field were treated classically, without any additional contribution due to the quantum nature of the laser field.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.68.046301

Related papers

Reply I to “Comment on ‘Some implications of the quantum nature of laser fields for quantum computations’ ”

S. J. van Enk, Harry J. Kimble

We show that Itano's arguments confirm our conclusion, that entanglement of the atom with the laser field contributes a small but nonzero amount to the total decoherence of an atom in a laser field. This small effect scales as $1/\mathrm{n\ifmmode \bar{}\else \={}\fi{}}$ with $\mathrm{n\ifmmode \bar{}\else \={}\fi{}}$ the average number of photons in the laser pulse.

arXiv:quant-ph/0212028•Physical Review A•Oct 14, 2003•12 citations

Atom–field interaction – quantum theory

Marlan O. Scully, Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

In the preceding chapters concerning the interaction of a radiation field with matter, we assumed the field to be classical. In many situations this assumption is valid. There are, however, many instances where a classical field fails to explain experimentally observed results and a quantized description of the field is required. This is, for example, true of spontaneous emission in an atomic system which was described phenomenologically in Chapter 5. For a rigorous treatment of the atomic level decay in free space, we need to consider the interaction of the atom with the vacuum modes of the universe. Even in the simplest system involving the interaction of a single-mode radiation field with a single two-level atom, the predictions for the dynamics of the atom are quite different in the semiclassical theory and the fully quantum theory. In the absence of the decay process, the semiclassical theory predicts Rabi oscillations for the atomic inversion whereas the quantum theory predicts certain collapse and revival phenomena due to the quantum aspects of the field. These interesting quantum field theoretical predictions have been experimentally verified.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 4, 1997•7 citations

Cavity QED beyond the Jaynes–Cummings model

Abeer Al Ghamdi, Gin Jose, Almut Beige

As atom-cavity systems are becoming more sophisticated, the limitations of the Jaynes-Cummings model are becoming more apparent. In this paper, we therefore take a more dynamical approach to the modelling of atom-cavity systems and do not reduce the electromagnetic field inside the resonator to a single mode. Our approach shows that the decay rate [Formula: see text] of an emitter inside a subwavelength cavity with metallic mirrors can be much larger than its free space decay rate [Formula: see text] due to constructive interference effects of the emitted light. In general, however, we find that [Formula: see text] to a very good approximation which might explain why atom-cavity experiments with planar mirrors have not been able to operate in the so-called strong coupling regime.

arXiv:2510.16634•Optical and Quantum Electronics•May 12, 2026•1 citation

Reply II to “Comment on ‘Some implications of the quantum nature of laser fields for quantum computations’ ”

Julio R. Gea-Banacloche

I show that there is no contradiction between the results in my original paper [Phys. Rev. A 65, 022308 (2002)] and Itano's claims in the previous Comment. The error probabilities I calculated from quantum field fluctuations can equivalently be obtained by considering the probability of spontaneous emission by the atom into the field modes that make up the laser pulse.

arXiv:quant-ph/0212027•Physical Review A•Oct 14, 2003•17 citations

Wave packet analysis of the multimode Jaynes-Cummings model

Jonathan S. Parker, Carlos R. Stroud

A spontaneously decaying two-level atom in an evacuated high-Q cavity undergoes Rabi oscillations. This phenomenon has been observed experimentally as enhanced or inhibited spontaneous emission. In the standard Jaynes-Cummings model the atom is assumed to interact with only a single cavity mode. By retaining the infinite set of cavity modes the propagation of the spontaneously emitted radiation may be calculated. Such an analysis yields a clear physical picture of Rabi oscillations. These vacuum-field Rabi oscillations are compared with Rabi oscillations of a one-electron atom induced by coherent radiation. We show that the same wave packet analysis explains both types of Rabi oscillation. The limit in which a multimode cavity may be approximated as a single-mode cavity is discussed.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1986•0 citations

Some implications of the quantum nature of laser fields for quantum computations

Julio R. Gea-Banacloche

The quantum nature of the laser fields used in many proposed schemes for the manipulation of quantum information may have important consequences for some very large scale quantum computations. Some of these consequences are explored here, focusing especially on phase errors and their effects on error-correction schemes. Depending on the way the logical gates are performed, constraints are found on either the required number of photons per coherence time put out by the laser source, or the source's power

Physical Review A•Jan 4, 2002•61 citations
A recent discussion of quantum limitations to the fidelity with which superpositions of internal atomic energy levels can be generated by an applied, quantized, laser pulse, is shown to be based on unrealistic physical assumptions. This discussion assumed the validity of Jaynes-Cummings dynamics for an atom interacting with a laser field in free space, that is, when the atom is not surrounded by a resonant cavity. If the laser field is a multimode quantum coherent state, and the Rabi frequency is much greater than the spontaneous decay rate, then the total atomic decoherence rate is on the order of the spontaneous decay rate. With the use of a unitary transformation of the field states due to Mollow, it can be shown that the atomic decoherence rate is the same as if the laser field were treated classically, without any additional contribution due to the quantum nature of the laser field.
In the preceding chapters concerning the interaction of a radiation field with matter, we assumed the field to be classical. In many situations this assumption is valid. There are, however, many instances where a classical field fails to explain experimentally observed results and a quantized description of the field is required. This is, for example, true of spontaneous emission in an atomic system which was described phenomenologically in Chapter 5. For a rigorous treatment of the atomic level decay in free space, we need to consider the interaction of the atom with the vacuum modes of the universe. Even in the simplest system involving the interaction of a single-mode radiation field with a single two-level atom, the predictions for the dynamics of the atom are quite different in the semiclassical theory and the fully quantum theory. In the absence of the decay process, the semiclassical theory predicts Rabi oscillations for the atomic inversion whereas the quantum theory predicts certain collapse and revival phenomena due to the quantum aspects of the field. These interesting quantum field theoretical predictions have been experimentally verified.
As atom-cavity systems are becoming more sophisticated, the limitations of the Jaynes-Cummings model are becoming more apparent. In this paper, we therefore take a more dynamical approach to the modelling of atom-cavity systems and do not reduce the electromagnetic field inside the resonator to a single mode. Our approach shows that the decay rate [Formula: see text] of an emitter inside a subwavelength cavity with metallic mirrors can be much larger than its free space decay rate [Formula: see text] due to constructive interference effects of the emitted light. In general, however, we find that [Formula: see text] to a very good approximation which might explain why atom-cavity experiments with planar mirrors have not been able to operate in the so-called strong coupling regime.
A spontaneously decaying two-level atom in an evacuated high-Q cavity undergoes Rabi oscillations. This phenomenon has been observed experimentally as enhanced or inhibited spontaneous emission. In the standard Jaynes-Cummings model the atom is assumed to interact with only a single cavity mode. By retaining the infinite set of cavity modes the propagation of the spontaneously emitted radiation may be calculated. Such an analysis yields a clear physical picture of Rabi oscillations. These vacuum-field Rabi oscillations are compared with Rabi oscillations of a one-electron atom induced by coherent radiation. We show that the same wave packet analysis explains both types of Rabi oscillation. The limit in which a multimode cavity may be approximated as a single-mode cavity is discussed.
The quantum nature of the laser fields used in many proposed schemes for the manipulation of quantum information may have important consequences for some very large scale quantum computations. Some of these consequences are explored here, focusing especially on phase errors and their effects on error-correction schemes. Depending on the way the logical gates are performed, constraints are found on either the required number of photons per coherence time put out by the laser source, or the source's power