Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0210141 · Contemporary mathematics - American Mathematical Society

A continuous variable Shor algorithm

Samuel J. Lomonaco, Louis Hirsch Kauffman

Published Jan 1, 2005• 26 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we use the methods found in quant-ph/0201095 to create a continuous variable analogue of Shor's quantum factoring algorithm. By this we mean a quantum hidden subgroup algorithm that finds the period P of a function F:R-->R from the reals R to the reals R, where F belongs to a very general class of functions, called the class of admissible functions. One objective in creating this continuous variable quantum algorithm was to make the structure of Shor's factoring algorithm more mathematically transparent, and thereby give some insight into the inner workings of Shor's original algorithm. This continuous quantum algorithm also gives some insight into the inner workings of Hallgren's Pell's equation algorithm. Two key questions remain unanswered. Is this quantum algorithm more efficient than its classical continuous variable counterpart? Is this quantum algorithm or some approximation of it implementable?

DOI
10.1090/conm/381/07093

Related papers

Quantum hidden subgroup algorithms: a mathematical perspective

Samuel J. Lomonaco, Louis Hirsch Kauffman

The ultimate objective of this paper is to create a stepping stone to the development of new quantum algorithms. The strategy chosen is to begin by focusing on the class of abelian quantum hidden subgroup algorithms, i.e., the class of abelian algorithms of the Shor/Simon genre. Our strategy is to make this class of algorithms as mathematically transparent as possible. By the phrase "mathematically transparent" we mean to expose, to bring to the surface, and to make explicit the concealed mathematical structures that are inherently and fundamentally a part of such algorithms. In so doing, we create symbolic abelian quantum hidden subgroup algorithms that are analogous to the those symbolic algorithms found within such software packages as Axiom, Cayley, Maple, Mathematica, and Magma. As a spin-off of this effort, we create three different generalizations of Shor's quantum factoring algorithm to free abelian groups of finite rank. We refer to these algorithms as wandering (or vintage Z_Q) Shor algorithms. They are essentially quantum algorithms on free abelian groups A of finite rank n which, with each iteration, first select a random cyclic direct summand Z of the group A and then apply one iteration of the standard Shor algorithm to produce a random character of the "approximating" finite group A=Z_Q, called the group probe. These characters are then in turn used to find either the order P of a maximal cyclic subgroup Z_P of the hidden quotient group H_phi, or the entire hidden quotient group H_phi. An integral part of these wandering quantum algorithms is the selection of a very special random transversal, which we refer to as a Shor transversal. The algorithmic time complexity of the first of these wandering Shor algorithms is found to be O(n^2(lgQ)^3(lglgQ)^(n+1)).

arXiv:quant-ph/0201095•Contemporary mathematics - American Mathematical Society•Jan 1, 2002•25 citations

Quantum Hidden Subgroup Algorithms: An Algorithmic Toolkit

Samuel J. Lomonaco, Louis H. Kauffman

One of the most promising and versatile approaches to creating new quantum algorithms is based on the quantum hidden subgroup (QHS) paradigm, originally suggested by Alexei Kitaev. This class of quantum algorithms encompasses the Deutsch-Jozsa, Simon, Shor algorithms, and many more. In this paper, our strategy for finding new quantum algorithms is to decompose Shor's quantum factoring algorithm into its basic primitives, then to generalize these primitives, and finally to show how to reassemble them into new QHS algorithms. Taking an "alphabetic building blocks approach," we use these primitives to form an "algorithmic toolkit" for the creation of new quantum algorithms, such as wandering Shor algorithms, continuous Shor algorithms, the quantum circle algorithm, the dual Shor algorithm, a QHS algorithm for Feynman integrals, free QHS algorithms, and more. Toward the end of this paper, we show how Grover's algorithm is most surprisingly "almost" a QHS algorithm, and how this result suggests the possibility of an even more complete "algorithmic tookit" beyond the QHS algorithms.

arXiv:quant-ph/0607046•Jul 6, 2006•1 citation

The Quantum Fourier Transform and Extensions of the Abelian Hidden Subgroup Problem

Lisa Hales

The quantum Fourier transform (QFT) has emerged as the primary tool in quantum algorithms which achieve exponential advantage over classical computation and lies at the heart of the solution to the abelian hidden subgroup problem, of which Shor's celebrated factoring and discrete log algorithms are a special case. We begin by addressing various computational issues surrounding the QFT and give improved parallel circuits for both the QFT over a power of 2 and the QFT over an arbitrary cyclic group. These circuits are based on new insight into the relationship between the discrete Fourier transform over different cyclic groups. We then exploit this insight to extend the class of hidden subgroup problems with efficient quantum solutions. First we relax the condition that the underlying hidden subgroup function be distinct on distinct cosets of the subgroup in question and show that this relaxation can be solved whenever G is a finitely-generated abelian group. We then extend this reasoning to the hidden cyclic subgroup problem over the reals, showing how to efficiently generate the bits of the period of any sufficiently piecewise-continuous function on R. Finally, we show that this problem of period-finding over R, viewed as an oracle promise problem, is strictly harder than its integral counterpart. In particular, period-finding over R lies outside the complexity class MA, a class which contains period-finding over the integers.

arXiv:quant-ph/0212002•Nov 30, 2002•28 citations

Continuous quantum hidden subgroup algorithms

Samuel J. Lomonaco, Louis Hirsch Kauffman

In this paper we show how to construct two continuous variable and one continuous functional quantum hidden subgroup (QHS) algorithms. These are respectively quantum algorithms on the additive group of reals R, the additive group R/Z of the reals R mod 1, i.e., the circle, and the additive group Paths of L2 paths x:[0,1] → Rn in real n-space Rn.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304084•Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 5, 2003•11 citations

Insights and Limitations of Shor’s Factorization Algorithm on IBM Real Quantum Computers

Camps Carmona, Adriano José, Manresa, Gerard De, Villarreal D’Angelo, Juan Manuel

Quantum Shor’s algorithm offers an exponential speedup over classical methods for integer factorization, a central problem to modern cryptography, and the implica- tions of Shor’s algorithm in factoring large numbers. The algorithm leverages on quantum parallelism to compute the period of a modular exponentiation function, employ- ing the Inverse Quantum Fourier Transform (IQFT) to extract periodicity, and classical post-processing to derive the factors. This final report of the Quantum Engineer- ing post-graduate course of the Fundacio Polit ́ enica de ` Catalunya, presents the main findings encountered in the implementation and benchmarking of Schor’s algorithm in real IBM quantum computers. To accomplish this, we created a command line tool made in Python, that allows the integration of the circuits implementing the Shor’s algorithm with the overall set of configuration parameters needed to perform the benchmark. In this report, we first provide an overview of the quantum factoring problem, followed by a detailed description of Shor’s algorithm, and its implementation using the Qiskit Python library. The circuit depth and noise effects are analyzed across different backend types, also different values for the optimization level and approximation degrees are configured when performing the circuit transpilation. As mentioned earlier different backend types were utilized for performance comparison, namely backend class with or without a noise model (AerSim), a fake backend class provided by the Qiskit library (fake provider), and the real quantum hardware (IBM Quantum Processing Units in January- June 2025).The study follows by analyzing the different error mitigation techniques: dynamic decoupling, Pauli twirling, the SABRE Optimization (Stochastic Algorithm for Quantum Boolean Optimization and Routing), and any combination of them. Once the optimum configuration is found, the maximum number that can be reasonably factorized with success is explored. Finally, the main conclusions, findings, and possible future research lines are presented, including the factorization of a N ≈ 1000 if appropriate parameters of the algorithm are selected.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Hidden Subgroup Algorithms: An Algorithmic Toolkit

Samuel J. Lomonaco, Louis H. Kauffman

Abstract One of the most promising and versatile approaches to creating new quantum algorithms is based on the quantum hidden subgroup (QHS) paradigm, originally suggested by Alexei Kitaev. This class of quantum algorithms encompasses the Deutsch-Jozsa, Simon, Shor algorithms, and many more.

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Sep 19, 2007•5 citations
In this paper, we use the methods found in quant-ph/0201095 to create a continuous variable analogue of Shor's quantum factoring algorithm. By this we mean a quantum hidden subgroup algorithm that finds the period P of a function F:R-->R from the reals R to the reals R, where F belongs to a very general class of functions, called the class of admissible functions. One objective in creating this continuous variable quantum algorithm was to make the structure of Shor's factoring algorithm more mathematically transparent, and thereby give some insight into the inner workings of Shor's original algorithm. This continuous quantum algorithm also gives some insight into the inner workings of Hallgren's Pell's equation algorithm. Two key questions remain unanswered. Is this quantum algorithm more efficient than its classical continuous variable counterpart? Is this quantum algorithm or some approximation of it implementable?
The ultimate objective of this paper is to create a stepping stone to the development of new quantum algorithms. The strategy chosen is to begin by focusing on the class of abelian quantum hidden subgroup algorithms, i.e., the class of abelian algorithms of the Shor/Simon genre. Our strategy is to make this class of algorithms as mathematically transparent as possible. By the phrase "mathematically transparent" we mean to expose, to bring to the surface, and to make explicit the concealed mathematical structures that are inherently and fundamentally a part of such algorithms. In so doing, we create symbolic abelian quantum hidden subgroup algorithms that are analogous to the those symbolic algorithms found within such software packages as Axiom, Cayley, Maple, Mathematica, and Magma. As a spin-off of this effort, we create three different generalizations of Shor's quantum factoring algorithm to free abelian groups of finite rank. We refer to these algorithms as wandering (or vintage Z_Q) Shor algorithms. They are essentially quantum algorithms on free abelian groups A of finite rank n which, with each iteration, first select a random cyclic direct summand Z of the group A and then apply one iteration of the standard Shor algorithm to produce a random character of the "approximating" finite group A=Z_Q, called the group probe. These characters are then in turn used to find either the order P of a maximal cyclic subgroup Z_P of the hidden quotient group H_phi, or the entire hidden quotient group H_phi. An integral part of these wandering quantum algorithms is the selection of a very special random transversal, which we refer to as a Shor transversal. The algorithmic time complexity of the first of these wandering Shor algorithms is found to be O(n^2(lgQ)^3(lglgQ)^(n+1)).
One of the most promising and versatile approaches to creating new quantum algorithms is based on the quantum hidden subgroup (QHS) paradigm, originally suggested by Alexei Kitaev. This class of quantum algorithms encompasses the Deutsch-Jozsa, Simon, Shor algorithms, and many more. In this paper, our strategy for finding new quantum algorithms is to decompose Shor's quantum factoring algorithm into its basic primitives, then to generalize these primitives, and finally to show how to reassemble them into new QHS algorithms. Taking an "alphabetic building blocks approach," we use these primitives to form an "algorithmic toolkit" for the creation of new quantum algorithms, such as wandering Shor algorithms, continuous Shor algorithms, the quantum circle algorithm, the dual Shor algorithm, a QHS algorithm for Feynman integrals, free QHS algorithms, and more. Toward the end of this paper, we show how Grover's algorithm is most surprisingly "almost" a QHS algorithm, and how this result suggests the possibility of an even more complete "algorithmic tookit" beyond the QHS algorithms.
The quantum Fourier transform (QFT) has emerged as the primary tool in quantum algorithms which achieve exponential advantage over classical computation and lies at the heart of the solution to the abelian hidden subgroup problem, of which Shor's celebrated factoring and discrete log algorithms are a special case. We begin by addressing various computational issues surrounding the QFT and give improved parallel circuits for both the QFT over a power of 2 and the QFT over an arbitrary cyclic group. These circuits are based on new insight into the relationship between the discrete Fourier transform over different cyclic groups. We then exploit this insight to extend the class of hidden subgroup problems with efficient quantum solutions. First we relax the condition that the underlying hidden subgroup function be distinct on distinct cosets of the subgroup in question and show that this relaxation can be solved whenever G is a finitely-generated abelian group. We then extend this reasoning to the hidden cyclic subgroup problem over the reals, showing how to efficiently generate the bits of the period of any sufficiently piecewise-continuous function on R. Finally, we show that this problem of period-finding over R, viewed as an oracle promise problem, is strictly harder than its integral counterpart. In particular, period-finding over R lies outside the complexity class MA, a class which contains period-finding over the integers.
Quantum Shor’s algorithm offers an exponential speedup over classical methods for integer factorization, a central problem to modern cryptography, and the implica- tions of Shor’s algorithm in factoring large numbers. The algorithm leverages on quantum parallelism to compute the period of a modular exponentiation function, employ- ing the Inverse Quantum Fourier Transform (IQFT) to extract periodicity, and classical post-processing to derive the factors. This final report of the Quantum Engineer- ing post-graduate course of the Fundacio Polit ́ enica de ` Catalunya, presents the main findings encountered in the implementation and benchmarking of Schor’s algorithm in real IBM quantum computers. To accomplish this, we created a command line tool made in Python, that allows the integration of the circuits implementing the Shor’s algorithm with the overall set of configuration parameters needed to perform the benchmark. In this report, we first provide an overview of the quantum factoring problem, followed by a detailed description of Shor’s algorithm, and its implementation using the Qiskit Python library. The circuit depth and noise effects are analyzed across different backend types, also different values for the optimization level and approximation degrees are configured when performing the circuit transpilation. As mentioned earlier different backend types were utilized for performance comparison, namely backend class with or without a noise model (AerSim), a fake backend class provided by the Qiskit library (fake provider), and the real quantum hardware (IBM Quantum Processing Units in January- June 2025).The study follows by analyzing the different error mitigation techniques: dynamic decoupling, Pauli twirling, the SABRE Optimization (Stochastic Algorithm for Quantum Boolean Optimization and Routing), and any combination of them. Once the optimum configuration is found, the maximum number that can be reasonably factorized with success is explored. Finally, the main conclusions, findings, and possible future research lines are presented, including the factorization of a N ≈ 1000 if appropriate parameters of the algorithm are selected.