Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0210074 · Physical Review A

Comment on “Limits of the measurability of the local quantum electromagnetic-field amplitude”

Vladimir Hnizdo

Published Nov 1, 1999• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is argued that the findings of a recent reanalysis by Compagno and Persico [Phys. Rev. A 57, 1595 (1998)] of the Bohr-Rosenfeld procedure for the measurement of a single space-time-averaged component of the electromagnetic field are incorrect when the field measurement time is shorter than that required for light to traverse the measurement's test body. To this end, the time-averaged ``self-force'' on the test body, assumed for simplicity to be of a spherical shape, is evaluated in terms of a one-dimensional quadrature for the general trajectory allowed for the test body by Compagno and Persico, and in closed form for the limiting steplike trajectory used by Bohr and Rosenfeld.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.60.4191

Related papers

Reply to “Comment on ‘Limits of the measurability of the local quantum electromagnetic field amplitude’ ”

G. Compagno, Franco Persico

We argue that the criticism by Hnizdo [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 60, 4212 (1999)] of the results obtained by Compagno and Persico [Phys. Rev. A 57, 1595 (1998)] on the theory of measurement of the amplitude of the quantum electromagnetic field is unfounded. By a simple and direct approach we show that the quantities evaluated by Hnizdo in his Comment are incorrect and we present the correct results.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1999•9 citations

Limits of the measurability of the local quantum electromagnetic-field amplitude

G. Compagno, Franco Persico

The precision with which the amplitude of the free electromagnetic field can be measured locally in QED is evaluated by analyzing a well-known gedanken experiment originally proposed by Bohr and Rosenfeld (BR). The analysis is performed by applying standard theoretical techniques familiar in quantum optics. The main result obtained for the precision is significantly different from the generally accepted Bohr-Rosenfeld result. This leads to questioning the widely accepted notion of the compensating field, fostered by these authors. A misconception at the origin of this notion is pointed out by a careful investigation of the self-force acting on the apparatus designed to measure the field. The correct expression for this self-force is found to be at variance with that proposed by Bohr and Rosenfeld and generally accepted. It is argued that, as a consequence of this new expression and in contrast with the generally accepted view, no compensating force of nonelectromagnetic nature is required in order to perform measurements of the quantum field amplitude with any desired accuracy. It is shown that the only limitations to the precision of the measurement, in the BR gedanken experiment, arise from the time-energy uncertainty principle, as well as from the finite dimensions of the measuring apparatus.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1998•12 citations

Measurement of electrical field amplitude by a needle-like detector

G. Compagno

The Bohr-Rosenfeld measurement theory of the electromagnetic field amplitude is applied to a needle-like detector. The expression of the time average of the self-force due to the measurement process is explicitly obtained. It is shown that the appearance of divergences does not allow the approximations required by the Bohr-Rosenfeld theory.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations

Measurability of quantum fields and the energy-time uncertainty relation

Michael B. Mensky

Quantum restrictions on the measurability of an electromagnetic field strength and their relevance to the energy-time uncertainty relation are considered. The minimum errors in measuring electromagnetic field strengths, as they were estimated by the author (1988) in the framework of the phenomenological method of restricted path integral (RPI), are compared with the analogous estimates found by Landau and Peierls (1931) and by Bohr and Rosenfeld (1933) with the help of certain measurement setups. RPI-based restrictions, including those of Landau and Peierls as a special case, hold for any measuring schemes meeting the strict definition of measurement. Their fundamental nature is confirmed by the fact that their associated field detectability condition has the form of the energy-time uncertainty relation. The weaker restrictions suggested by Bohr and Rosenfeld rely on an extended definition of measurement. The energy?time uncertainty relation, which is the condition for the electromagnetic field to be detectable, is applied to the analysis of how the near-field scanning microscope works.

Physics-Uspekhi•May 31, 2011•6 citations

Is There a Flaw in the Seminal Bohr‐Rosenfeld Paper on the Measurement Problem of the Free Quantum Electromagnetic Field?

Luis Gerardo Pedraza Saavedra

In 1933, Bohr and Rosenfeld published a seminal paper in which they claimed to solve the measurement problem of the free quantum electromagnetic field. In 1951, however, Corinaldesi discovered, in the analysis of the above-mentioned authors, an error in the order of magnitude of a certain critical field. This paper shows, through a comparative analysis between the results of Bohr and Rosenfeld and Corinaldesi, that the error discovered by the latter does not affect the conclusions of the former. It is also possible to consider as a deficiency of their work the fact that Bohr and Rosenfeld never responded to the mistake found by Corinaldesi. It will be shown here that in fact Bohr and Rosenfeld studied a measurement situation, the problem of which was equal to the one that would be originated if the correction of Corinaldesi were taken into account.

Physics Essays•Mar 1, 2000•2 citations

Quantum Effects on the Accuracy of Momentum Measurements

C. H. Woo

It is shown in two examples that to measure the momentum of a particle with great accuracy, allowing for large uncertainties in the position, it is still necessary to consider additional quantum effects. For the case of measurements by electromagnetic means, the uncertainties in the measurability of field strengths and of charge-current densities should be considered. Within the framework of the Bohr-Rosenfeld analysis, uncertainties in the field measurements do not limit the accuracy of momentum measurements. What happens when the Bohr-Rosenfeld approximations are not made is an open question.

Physical Review•Aug 23, 1965•2 citations
It is argued that the findings of a recent reanalysis by Compagno and Persico [Phys. Rev. A 57, 1595 (1998)] of the Bohr-Rosenfeld procedure for the measurement of a single space-time-averaged component of the electromagnetic field are incorrect when the field measurement time is shorter than that required for light to traverse the measurement's test body. To this end, the time-averaged ``self-force'' on the test body, assumed for simplicity to be of a spherical shape, is evaluated in terms of a one-dimensional quadrature for the general trajectory allowed for the test body by Compagno and Persico, and in closed form for the limiting steplike trajectory used by Bohr and Rosenfeld.
The precision with which the amplitude of the free electromagnetic field can be measured locally in QED is evaluated by analyzing a well-known gedanken experiment originally proposed by Bohr and Rosenfeld (BR). The analysis is performed by applying standard theoretical techniques familiar in quantum optics. The main result obtained for the precision is significantly different from the generally accepted Bohr-Rosenfeld result. This leads to questioning the widely accepted notion of the compensating field, fostered by these authors. A misconception at the origin of this notion is pointed out by a careful investigation of the self-force acting on the apparatus designed to measure the field. The correct expression for this self-force is found to be at variance with that proposed by Bohr and Rosenfeld and generally accepted. It is argued that, as a consequence of this new expression and in contrast with the generally accepted view, no compensating force of nonelectromagnetic nature is required in order to perform measurements of the quantum field amplitude with any desired accuracy. It is shown that the only limitations to the precision of the measurement, in the BR gedanken experiment, arise from the time-energy uncertainty principle, as well as from the finite dimensions of the measuring apparatus.
Quantum restrictions on the measurability of an electromagnetic field strength and their relevance to the energy-time uncertainty relation are considered. The minimum errors in measuring electromagnetic field strengths, as they were estimated by the author (1988) in the framework of the phenomenological method of restricted path integral (RPI), are compared with the analogous estimates found by Landau and Peierls (1931) and by Bohr and Rosenfeld (1933) with the help of certain measurement setups. RPI-based restrictions, including those of Landau and Peierls as a special case, hold for any measuring schemes meeting the strict definition of measurement. Their fundamental nature is confirmed by the fact that their associated field detectability condition has the form of the energy-time uncertainty relation. The weaker restrictions suggested by Bohr and Rosenfeld rely on an extended definition of measurement. The energy?time uncertainty relation, which is the condition for the electromagnetic field to be detectable, is applied to the analysis of how the near-field scanning microscope works.
In 1933, Bohr and Rosenfeld published a seminal paper in which they claimed to solve the measurement problem of the free quantum electromagnetic field. In 1951, however, Corinaldesi discovered, in the analysis of the above-mentioned authors, an error in the order of magnitude of a certain critical field. This paper shows, through a comparative analysis between the results of Bohr and Rosenfeld and Corinaldesi, that the error discovered by the latter does not affect the conclusions of the former. It is also possible to consider as a deficiency of their work the fact that Bohr and Rosenfeld never responded to the mistake found by Corinaldesi. It will be shown here that in fact Bohr and Rosenfeld studied a measurement situation, the problem of which was equal to the one that would be originated if the correction of Corinaldesi were taken into account.
It is shown in two examples that to measure the momentum of a particle with great accuracy, allowing for large uncertainties in the position, it is still necessary to consider additional quantum effects. For the case of measurements by electromagnetic means, the uncertainties in the measurability of field strengths and of charge-current densities should be considered. Within the framework of the Bohr-Rosenfeld analysis, uncertainties in the field measurements do not limit the accuracy of momentum measurements. What happens when the Bohr-Rosenfeld approximations are not made is an open question.