Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0209001 · Physical Review Letters

Experimental Investigation of Criteria for Continuous Variable Entanglement

Warwick P. Bowen, Roman Schnabel, Ping Koy Lam, Timothy C. Ralph

Published Jan 29, 2003• 257 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We generate a pair of entangled beams from the interference of two amplitude squeezed beams. The entanglement is quantified in terms of EPR paradox and inseparability criteria, with both results clearly beating the standard quantum limit. We experimentally analyze the effect of decoherence on each criterion and demonstrate qualitative differences. We also characterize the number of required and excess photons present in the entangled beams and provide contour plots of the efficacy of quantum information protocols in terms of these variables.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.90.043601

Related papers

An experimental investigation of criteria for continuous variable entanglement

Warwick P. Bowen, Roman Schnabel, Nicolas Treps +3 more

The criterion for Gaussian continuous variable entanglement is experimentally compare in the presence of loss, to a criterion for observation of the EPR-paradox and demonstrated qualitative and quantitative differences. The differences arise from the sensitivity of the EPR-paradox to state mixedness, a property that the inseparability criterion is entirely insensitive to. Entanglement on a diagram of the sideband photon number required to generate the entanglement - a property synonymous to inseparability - versus the excess sideband photons is presented. Efficacy contours of some common quantum information protocols on the diagram is displayed.

European Quantum Electronics Conference (EQEC)•Jan 1, 2003•6 citations

Experimental characterization of continuous-variable entanglement

Warwick P. Bowen, Roman Schnabel, Ping Koy Lam +1 more

We present an experimental analysis of quadrature entanglement produced from a pair of amplitude squeezed beams. The correlation matrix of the state is characterized within a set of reasonable assumptions, and the strength of the entanglement is gauged using measures of the degree of inseparability and the degree of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox. We introduce controlled decoherence in the form of optical loss to the entangled state, and demonstrate qualitative differences in the response of the degrees of inseparability and EPR paradox to this loss. The entanglement is represented on a photon number diagram that provides an intuitive and physically relevant description of the state. We calculate efficacy contours for several quantum information protocols on this diagram, and use them to predict the effectiveness of our entanglement in those protocols.

arXiv:quant-ph/0309013•Physical Review A•Jan 12, 2004•95 citations

Asymmetric EPR entanglement in continuous variable systems

K. Wagner, Jiří Janoušek, Seiji Armstrong +3 more

Continuous variable entanglement can be produced in nonlinear systems or via the interference of squeezed states. In many optical systems such as parametric down conversion, the production of two perfectly symmetric subsystems is usually assumed when demonstrating the existence of entanglement. This symmetry simplifies the description of entanglement. However, asymmetry in entanglement may arise naturally in a real experiment, or be intentionally introduced in a given quantum information protocol. These asymmetries can emerge from having the output beams experience different losses and environmental contamination, or from the availability of non-identical input quantum states in quantum communication protocols. In this paper, we present a visualization of entanglement using quadrature amplitude plots of the twin beams. We quantitatively discuss the strength of asymmetric entanglement using EPR and inseparability criteria and theoretically show that the optimal beamsplitter ratio for entanglement is dependent on the asymmetries and may not be 50 : 50. To support this theory, we present experimental results showing one particular asymmetric entanglement where a 78 : 22 beamsplitter is optimal for observing entanglement.

arXiv:1203.1980•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Nov 3, 2014•15 citations

PHOTON NUMBER DIAGRAM FOR CHARACTERIZING CONTINUOUS VARIABLE ENTANGLEMENT

Warwick P. Bowen, Magnus T. L. Hsu, Thomas Symul +7 more

We present an experimental analysis of continuous variable entanglement produced from a pair of amplitude squeezed beams. The correlation matrix of the entanglement is characterized within a set of assumptions. The entanglement is represented on a photon number diagram that provides an intuitive and physically relevant description of the state. We show efficacy contours for three quantum information protocols on this diagram, and use them to predict the effectiveness of our entanglement in those protocols.

Laser Spectroscopy•Feb 1, 2004•0 citations

Continuous variable polarization entanglement, experiment and analysis

Warwick P. Bowen, Nicolas Treps, Roman Schnabel +2 more

We generate and characterize continuous variable polarization entanglement between two optical beams. We first produce quadrature entanglement, and by performing local operations we transform it into a polarization basis. We extend two entanglement criteria, the inseparability criteria proposed by Duan et al (2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 84 2722) and the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) paradox criteria proposed by Reid and Drummond (1988 Phys. Rev. Lett. 60 2731), to Stokes operators; and use them to characterize the entanglement. Our results for the EPR paradox criteria are visualized in terms of uncertainty balls on the Poincaré sphere. We demonstrate theoretically that using two quadrature entangled pairs it is possible to entangle three orthogonal Stokes operators between a pair of beams, although with a bound √3 times more stringent than for the quadrature entanglement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0303180•Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Aug 1, 2003•15 citations

Monitoring Beam Splitter Entanglement using Quantumness

Hua-Li Chen, Hsien-Yi Hsieh, Chien-Ming Wu +2 more

We report on an experiment in which two independent squeezed vacuum states get entangled by mixing them with a balanced beam splitter. We follow standard practice and use an inseparability criterion to quantify their entanglement. However, this only allows us to witness the entanglement, but not to determine the deleterious effects of experimental imperfections due to the beam splitter mixing and the associated mode-mismatch and detection imperfections. We therefore introduce an alternative framework suitable for continuous variable systems using the states' quantumness, $Ξ$. We show that, under ideal circumstances, $Ξ$ is a conserved quantity under beam mixing. This allows us to benchmark the experiment's performance by comparing the states' quantumness $Ξ$ after the beam splitter mixing with $Ξ$ before. Such a comparison is not possible with entanglement witnesses, as the input states are unentangled. This highlights the main strength of our approach: its ability to generally quantify the quantumness of multi-mode continuous variable states and use this to probe different stages in an experiment.

quant-pharXiv:2606.24242•Optica Quantum•Jun 24, 2026•2 citations
We generate a pair of entangled beams from the interference of two amplitude squeezed beams. The entanglement is quantified in terms of EPR paradox and inseparability criteria, with both results clearly beating the standard quantum limit. We experimentally analyze the effect of decoherence on each criterion and demonstrate qualitative differences. We also characterize the number of required and excess photons present in the entangled beams and provide contour plots of the efficacy of quantum information protocols in terms of these variables.
The criterion for Gaussian continuous variable entanglement is experimentally compare in the presence of loss, to a criterion for observation of the EPR-paradox and demonstrated qualitative and quantitative differences. The differences arise from the sensitivity of the EPR-paradox to state mixedness, a property that the inseparability criterion is entirely insensitive to. Entanglement on a diagram of the sideband photon number required to generate the entanglement - a property synonymous to inseparability - versus the excess sideband photons is presented. Efficacy contours of some common quantum information protocols on the diagram is displayed.
We present an experimental analysis of quadrature entanglement produced from a pair of amplitude squeezed beams. The correlation matrix of the state is characterized within a set of reasonable assumptions, and the strength of the entanglement is gauged using measures of the degree of inseparability and the degree of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox. We introduce controlled decoherence in the form of optical loss to the entangled state, and demonstrate qualitative differences in the response of the degrees of inseparability and EPR paradox to this loss. The entanglement is represented on a photon number diagram that provides an intuitive and physically relevant description of the state. We calculate efficacy contours for several quantum information protocols on this diagram, and use them to predict the effectiveness of our entanglement in those protocols.
Continuous variable entanglement can be produced in nonlinear systems or via the interference of squeezed states. In many optical systems such as parametric down conversion, the production of two perfectly symmetric subsystems is usually assumed when demonstrating the existence of entanglement. This symmetry simplifies the description of entanglement. However, asymmetry in entanglement may arise naturally in a real experiment, or be intentionally introduced in a given quantum information protocol. These asymmetries can emerge from having the output beams experience different losses and environmental contamination, or from the availability of non-identical input quantum states in quantum communication protocols. In this paper, we present a visualization of entanglement using quadrature amplitude plots of the twin beams. We quantitatively discuss the strength of asymmetric entanglement using EPR and inseparability criteria and theoretically show that the optimal beamsplitter ratio for entanglement is dependent on the asymmetries and may not be 50 : 50. To support this theory, we present experimental results showing one particular asymmetric entanglement where a 78 : 22 beamsplitter is optimal for observing entanglement.
We present an experimental analysis of continuous variable entanglement produced from a pair of amplitude squeezed beams. The correlation matrix of the entanglement is characterized within a set of assumptions. The entanglement is represented on a photon number diagram that provides an intuitive and physically relevant description of the state. We show efficacy contours for three quantum information protocols on this diagram, and use them to predict the effectiveness of our entanglement in those protocols.
We generate and characterize continuous variable polarization entanglement between two optical beams. We first produce quadrature entanglement, and by performing local operations we transform it into a polarization basis. We extend two entanglement criteria, the inseparability criteria proposed by Duan et al (2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 84 2722) and the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) paradox criteria proposed by Reid and Drummond (1988 Phys. Rev. Lett. 60 2731), to Stokes operators; and use them to characterize the entanglement. Our results for the EPR paradox criteria are visualized in terms of uncertainty balls on the Poincaré sphere. We demonstrate theoretically that using two quadrature entangled pairs it is possible to entangle three orthogonal Stokes operators between a pair of beams, although with a bound √3 times more stringent than for the quadrature entanglement.
We report on an experiment in which two independent squeezed vacuum states get entangled by mixing them with a balanced beam splitter. We follow standard practice and use an inseparability criterion to quantify their entanglement. However, this only allows us to witness the entanglement, but not to determine the deleterious effects of experimental imperfections due to the beam splitter mixing and the associated mode-mismatch and detection imperfections. We therefore introduce an alternative framework suitable for continuous variable systems using the states' quantumness, ΞΞΞ. We show that, under ideal circumstances, ΞΞΞ is a conserved quantity under beam mixing. This allows us to benchmark the experiment's performance by comparing the states' quantumness ΞΞΞ after the beam splitter mixing with ΞΞΞ before. Such a comparison is not possible with entanglement witnesses, as the input states are unentangled. This highlights the main strength of our approach: its ability to generally quantify the quantumness of multi-mode continuous variable states and use this to probe different stages in an experiment.