Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0208047 · Journal of Mathematical Physics

Hilbert space structure in classical mechanics. II

E. Deotto, E. Gozzi, D. Mauro

Published Nov 22, 2003• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper we analyze two different functional formulations of classical mechanics. In the first one the Jacobi fields are represented by bosonic variables and belong to the vector (or its dual) representation of the symplectic group. In the second formulation the Jacobi fields are given as condensates of Grassmannian variables belonging to the spinor representation of the metaplectic group. For both formulations we shall show that, differently from what happens in the case presented in paper I, it is possible to endow the associated Hilbert space with a positive definite scalar product and to describe the dynamics via a Hermitian Hamiltonian. The drawback of this formulation is that higher forms do not appear automatically and that the description of chaotic systems may need a further extension of the Hilbert space.

DOI
10.1063/1.1623334

Related papers

Hilbert space structure in classical mechanics. I

E. Deotto, E. Gozzi, D. Mauro

In this paper we study the Hilbert space structure underlying the Koopman–von Neumann (KvN) operatorial formulation of classical mechanics. KvN limited themselves to study the Hilbert space of zero-forms that are the square integrable functions on phase space. They proved that in this Hilbert space the evolution is unitary for every system. In this paper we extend the KvN Hilbert space to higher forms which are basically functions of the phase space points and the differentials on phase space. We prove that if we equip this space with a positive definite scalar product the evolution can turn out to be nonunitary for some systems. Vice versa, if we insist in having a unitary evolution for every system then the scalar product cannot be positive definite. Identifying the one-forms with the Jacobi fields we provide a physical explanation of these phenomena. We also prove that the unitary/nonunitary character of the evolution is invariant under canonical transformations.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208046•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 22, 2003•37 citations

Quantum Mechanics associated with a Finite Group

Robert William Johnson

I describe, in the simplified context of finite groups and their representations, a mathematical model for a physical system that contains both its quantum and classical aspects. The physically observable system is associated with the space containing elements fxf for f an element in the regular representation of a given finite group G. The Hermitian portion of fxf is the Wigner distribution of f whose convolution with a test function leads to a mathematical description of the quantum measurement process. Starting with the Jacobi group that is formed from the semidirect product of the Heisenberg group with its automorphism group SL(2,F{N}) for N an odd prime number I show that the classical phase space is the first order term in a series of subspaces of the Hermitian portion of fxf that are stable under SL(2,F{N}). I define a derivative that is analogous to a pseudodifferential operator to enable a treatment that parallels the continuum case. I give a new derivation of the Schrodinger-Weil representation of the Jacobi group. Keywords: quantum mechanics, finite group, metaplectic. PACS: 03.65.Fd; 02.10.De; 03.65.Ta.

arXiv:quant-ph/0604153•Apr 20, 2006•1 citation

On obtaining classical mechanics from quantum mechanics

Ghanashyam Date

Constructing a classical mechanical system associated with a given quantum-mechanical one entails construction of a classical phase space and a corresponding Hamiltonian function from the available quantum structures and a notion of coarser observations. The Hilbert space of any quantum-mechanical system naturally has the structure of an infinite-dimensional symplectic manifold ('quantum phase space'). There is also a systematic, quotienting procedure which imparts a bundle structure to the quantum phase space and extracts a classical phase space as the base space. This works straightforwardly when the Hilbert space carries weakly continuous representation of the Heisenberg group and one recovers the linear classical phase space . We report on how the procedure also allows extraction of nonlinear classical phase spaces and illustrate it for Hilbert spaces being finite dimensional (spin- j systems), infinite dimensional but separable (particle on a circle) and infinite dimensional but non-separable (polymer quantization). To construct a corresponding classical dynamics, one needs to choose a suitable section and identify an effective Hamiltonian. The effective dynamics mirrors the quantum dynamics provided the section satisfies conditions of semiclassicality and tangentiality.

arXiv:gr-qc/0606078•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Dec 19, 2006•6 citations

Symplectic Field Theory of the Galilean Covariant Scalar and Spinor Representations

G. X. A. Petronilo, S. C. Ulhoa, A. E. Santana

We explore the concept of the extended Galilei group, a representation for the symplectic quantum mechanics in the manifold G, written in the light-cone of a five-dimensional de Sitter space-time in the phase space. The Hilbert space is constructed endowed with a symplectic structure. We study the unitary operators describing rotations and translations, whose generators satisfy the Lie algebra of G. This representation gives rise to the Schr¨odinger (Klein–Gordon-like) equation for the wave function in the phase space such that the dependent variables have the position and linear momentum contents. The wave functions are associated to the Wigner function through the Moyal product such that the wave functions represent a quasiamplitude of probability. We construct the Pauli–Schr¨odinger (Dirac-like) equation in the phase space in its explicitly covariant form. Finally, we show the equivalence between the five-dimensional formalism of the phase space with the usual formalism, proposing a solution that recovers the non-covariant form of the Pauli–Schr¨odinger equation in the phase space.

arXiv:1909.13737•Ukrainian Journal of Physics•Sep 18, 2019•2 citations

QUANTUM MECHANICS AS A GAUGE THEORY OF METAPLECTIC SPINOR FIELDS

M. REUTER

A hidden gauge theory structure of quantum mechanics which is invisible in its conventional formulation is uncovered. Quantum mechanics is shown to be equivalent to a certain Yang–Mills theory with an infinite-dimensional gauge group and a nondynamical connection. It is defined over an arbitrary symplectic manifold which constitutes the phase space of the system under consideration. The "matter fields" are local generalizations of states and observables; they assume values in a family of local Hilbert spaces (and their tensor products) which are attached to the points of phase space. Under local frame rotations they transform in the spinor representation of the metaplectic group Mp(2N), the double covering of Sp(2N). The rules of canonical quantization are replaced by two independent postulates with a simple group-theoretical and differential-geometrical interpretation. A novel background-quantum split symmetry plays a central role.

arXiv:hep-th/9804036•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Sep 10, 1998•18 citations

Structure and Some Properties and Applications of the Groups Sp(2n,ℝ)

Narasimhaiengar Mukunda, S. Chaturvedi

Classical mechanics in phase space involves the concepts of Poisson brackets and canonical transformations. In (nonrelativistic) quantum mechanics, based on fundamental Cartesian variables, the kinematics is expressed via the Heisenberg canonical commutation relations (CCR’s). One now has unitary transformations on wave functions in Hilbert space. In both cases, Hamiltonians quadratic in the canonical variables lead to linear equations of motion whose solutions are linear canonical transformations. In all this, the key role is played by the family of real symplectic groups Sp (2 n ,ℝ). They are the ‘noncompact’ versions of the classical compact Lie groups Cl = USp (2 l ) , and their defining representations are in real even dimensional vector spaces. In addition to their significance in the canonical formulation of classical mechanics and its counterpart in quantum mechanics, these groups are important in several specific quantum mechanical problems as well as in classical and quantum optics. We look at some aspects of these groups in this chapter. While we describe the main features, we will not present complete proofs of all statements made, but a motivated reader should be able to supply the details and proceed to make practical uses of these groups. In both classical and quantum mechanics we have in mind only Cartesian fundamental variables. So for n degrees of freedom, or n canonical pairs, the classical phase space is R 2 n , while in quantum mechanics we have the Hilbert space H = L 2(ℝ n ). Since the symplectic groups are somewhat unfamiliar to most students of physics, we study the case n = 1 to begin with, and later go on to general n . The Group Sp (2,ℝ) For one degree of freedom with Cartesian variables, in classical mechanics we have real canonical variables q and p , varying from −∞ to ∞, and the Poisson brackets (PB) {q, p} = 1, {q, q} = {p, p} = 0. (8.1) The phase space is the two dimensional plane ℝ 2 . For the corresponding system in quantum mechanics we have an irreducible pair of hermitian operators q , p obeying the Heisenberg CCR’s In the usual Schrödinger solution to these relations we have a Hilbert space H = L 2 (ℝ) with q , p acting as follows: (Strictly speaking, since q and p are unbounded operators, their domains should be carefully specified; we assume such precautions are implicitly observed.) Now consider linear homogeneous transformations on q , p which in the classical case preserve the PB's (8.1) and in the quantum case the CCR's (8.2).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 24, 2022•0 citations
In this paper we analyze two different functional formulations of classical mechanics. In the first one the Jacobi fields are represented by bosonic variables and belong to the vector (or its dual) representation of the symplectic group. In the second formulation the Jacobi fields are given as condensates of Grassmannian variables belonging to the spinor representation of the metaplectic group. For both formulations we shall show that, differently from what happens in the case presented in paper I, it is possible to endow the associated Hilbert space with a positive definite scalar product and to describe the dynamics via a Hermitian Hamiltonian. The drawback of this formulation is that higher forms do not appear automatically and that the description of chaotic systems may need a further extension of the Hilbert space.
In this paper we study the Hilbert space structure underlying the Koopman–von Neumann (KvN) operatorial formulation of classical mechanics. KvN limited themselves to study the Hilbert space of zero-forms that are the square integrable functions on phase space. They proved that in this Hilbert space the evolution is unitary for every system. In this paper we extend the KvN Hilbert space to higher forms which are basically functions of the phase space points and the differentials on phase space. We prove that if we equip this space with a positive definite scalar product the evolution can turn out to be nonunitary for some systems. Vice versa, if we insist in having a unitary evolution for every system then the scalar product cannot be positive definite. Identifying the one-forms with the Jacobi fields we provide a physical explanation of these phenomena. We also prove that the unitary/nonunitary character of the evolution is invariant under canonical transformations.
I describe, in the simplified context of finite groups and their representations, a mathematical model for a physical system that contains both its quantum and classical aspects. The physically observable system is associated with the space containing elements fxf for f an element in the regular representation of a given finite group G. The Hermitian portion of fxf is the Wigner distribution of f whose convolution with a test function leads to a mathematical description of the quantum measurement process. Starting with the Jacobi group that is formed from the semidirect product of the Heisenberg group with its automorphism group SL(2,F{N}) for N an odd prime number I show that the classical phase space is the first order term in a series of subspaces of the Hermitian portion of fxf that are stable under SL(2,F{N}). I define a derivative that is analogous to a pseudodifferential operator to enable a treatment that parallels the continuum case. I give a new derivation of the Schrodinger-Weil representation of the Jacobi group. Keywords: quantum mechanics, finite group, metaplectic. PACS: 03.65.Fd; 02.10.De; 03.65.Ta.
Constructing a classical mechanical system associated with a given quantum-mechanical one entails construction of a classical phase space and a corresponding Hamiltonian function from the available quantum structures and a notion of coarser observations. The Hilbert space of any quantum-mechanical system naturally has the structure of an infinite-dimensional symplectic manifold ('quantum phase space'). There is also a systematic, quotienting procedure which imparts a bundle structure to the quantum phase space and extracts a classical phase space as the base space. This works straightforwardly when the Hilbert space carries weakly continuous representation of the Heisenberg group and one recovers the linear classical phase space . We report on how the procedure also allows extraction of nonlinear classical phase spaces and illustrate it for Hilbert spaces being finite dimensional (spin- j systems), infinite dimensional but separable (particle on a circle) and infinite dimensional but non-separable (polymer quantization). To construct a corresponding classical dynamics, one needs to choose a suitable section and identify an effective Hamiltonian. The effective dynamics mirrors the quantum dynamics provided the section satisfies conditions of semiclassicality and tangentiality.
We explore the concept of the extended Galilei group, a representation for the symplectic quantum mechanics in the manifold G, written in the light-cone of a five-dimensional de Sitter space-time in the phase space. The Hilbert space is constructed endowed with a symplectic structure. We study the unitary operators describing rotations and translations, whose generators satisfy the Lie algebra of G. This representation gives rise to the Schr¨odinger (Klein–Gordon-like) equation for the wave function in the phase space such that the dependent variables have the position and linear momentum contents. The wave functions are associated to the Wigner function through the Moyal product such that the wave functions represent a quasiamplitude of probability. We construct the Pauli–Schr¨odinger (Dirac-like) equation in the phase space in its explicitly covariant form. Finally, we show the equivalence between the five-dimensional formalism of the phase space with the usual formalism, proposing a solution that recovers the non-covariant form of the Pauli–Schr¨odinger equation in the phase space.
A hidden gauge theory structure of quantum mechanics which is invisible in its conventional formulation is uncovered. Quantum mechanics is shown to be equivalent to a certain Yang–Mills theory with an infinite-dimensional gauge group and a nondynamical connection. It is defined over an arbitrary symplectic manifold which constitutes the phase space of the system under consideration. The "matter fields" are local generalizations of states and observables; they assume values in a family of local Hilbert spaces (and their tensor products) which are attached to the points of phase space. Under local frame rotations they transform in the spinor representation of the metaplectic group Mp(2N), the double covering of Sp(2N). The rules of canonical quantization are replaced by two independent postulates with a simple group-theoretical and differential-geometrical interpretation. A novel background-quantum split symmetry plays a central role.
Classical mechanics in phase space involves the concepts of Poisson brackets and canonical transformations. In (nonrelativistic) quantum mechanics, based on fundamental Cartesian variables, the kinematics is expressed via the Heisenberg canonical commutation relations (CCR’s). One now has unitary transformations on wave functions in Hilbert space. In both cases, Hamiltonians quadratic in the canonical variables lead to linear equations of motion whose solutions are linear canonical transformations. In all this, the key role is played by the family of real symplectic groups Sp (2 n ,ℝ). They are the ‘noncompact’ versions of the classical compact Lie groups Cl = USp (2 l ) , and their defining representations are in real even dimensional vector spaces. In addition to their significance in the canonical formulation of classical mechanics and its counterpart in quantum mechanics, these groups are important in several specific quantum mechanical problems as well as in classical and quantum optics. We look at some aspects of these groups in this chapter. While we describe the main features, we will not present complete proofs of all statements made, but a motivated reader should be able to supply the details and proceed to make practical uses of these groups. In both classical and quantum mechanics we have in mind only Cartesian fundamental variables. So for n degrees of freedom, or n canonical pairs, the classical phase space is R 2 n , while in quantum mechanics we have the Hilbert space H = L 2(ℝ n ). Since the symplectic groups are somewhat unfamiliar to most students of physics, we study the case n = 1 to begin with, and later go on to general n . The Group Sp (2,ℝ) For one degree of freedom with Cartesian variables, in classical mechanics we have real canonical variables q and p , varying from −∞ to ∞, and the Poisson brackets (PB) {q, p} = 1, {q, q} = {p, p} = 0. (8.1) The phase space is the two dimensional plane ℝ 2 . For the corresponding system in quantum mechanics we have an irreducible pair of hermitian operators q , p obeying the Heisenberg CCR’s In the usual Schrödinger solution to these relations we have a Hilbert space H = L 2 (ℝ) with q , p acting as follows: (Strictly speaking, since q and p are unbounded operators, their domains should be carefully specified; we assume such precautions are implicitly observed.) Now consider linear homogeneous transformations on q , p which in the classical case preserve the PB's (8.1) and in the quantum case the CCR's (8.2).