Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0207124 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Classical three-box paradox

K A Kirkpatrick

Published Apr 14, 2003• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A simple classical probabilistic system (a simple card game) classically exemplifies Aharonov and Vaidman's ‘three-box ‘paradox’’ (1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24 2315 ), implying that the three-box example is neither quantal nor a paradox and leaving one with less difficulty to busy the interpreters of quantum mechanics. An ambiguity in the usual expression of the retrodiction formula is shown to have misled Albert et al (1985 Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 5) to a result not, in fact, ‘curious’; the discussion illustrates how to avoid this ambiguity.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/36/17/315

Related papers

The three-box paradox revisited

Tamar Ravon, Lev Vaidman A

The classical three-box paradox of Kirkpatrick ( 2003 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 36 4891 ) is compared to the original quantum three-box paradox of Aharonov and Vaidman ( 1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24 2315 ). It is argued that the quantum three-box experiment is a 'quantum paradox' in the sense that it is an example of a classical task which cannot be accomplished using classical means, but can be accomplished using quantum devices. It is shown that Kirkpatrick's card game is analogous to a different game with a particle in three boxes which does not contain paradoxical features.

arXiv:quant-ph/0606067•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 28, 2007•55 citations

Reply to ‘The three-box paradox revisited’ by T Ravon and L Vaidman

K A Kirkpatrick

I reply to Ravon and Vaidman's criticism ( 2007 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40 2873 (this issue)) of my classical implementation of a three-box system as a card-game.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703004•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 28, 2007•7 citations

Multi-agent paradoxes beyond quantum theory

V. Vilasini, Nuriya Nurgalieva, Lídia del Rio

Which theories lead to a contradiction between simple reasoning principles and modelling observers’ memories as physical systems? Frauchiger and Renner have shown that this is the case for quantum theory (Frauchiger and Renner 2018 Nat. Commun. 9 3711). Here we generalize the conditions of the Frauchiger–Renner result so that they can be applied to arbitrary physical theories, and in particular to those expressed as generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs) (Hardy 2001 arXiv: quant-ph/0101012 ; Barrett 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 032304). We then apply them to a particular GPT, box world, and find a deterministic contradiction in the case where agents may share a PR box (Popescu and Rohrlich 1994 Found. Phys. 24 379–85), which is stronger than the quantum paradox, in that it does not rely on post-selection. Obtaining an inconsistency for the framework of GPTs broadens the landscape of theories which are affected by the application of classical rules of reasoning to physical agents. In addition, we model how observers’ memories may evolve in box world, in a way consistent with Barrett’s criteria for allowed operations (Barrett 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 032304; Gross et al 2010 Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 080402). Ordinary readers, forgive my paradoxes: one must make them when one reflects; and whatever you may say, I prefer being a man with paradoxes than a man with prejudices. Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Emile or On Education

arXiv:1904.06247•New Journal of Physics•Oct 21, 2019•24 citations

Ambiguities in the derivation of retrodictive probability

Kirkpatrick, K. A.

The derivation of the quantum retrodictive probability formula involves an error, an ambiguity. The end result is correct because this error appears twice, in such a way as to cancel itself. In addition, however, the usual expression for the probability itself contains the same ambiguity; this may lead to errors in its application. A generally applicable method is given to avoid such ambiguities altogether.

arXiv:quant-ph/0207101•Jul 18, 2002•3 citations

Causal reappraisal of the quantum three-box paradox

Paweł Błasiak, Ewa Borsuk

The quantum three-box paradox is a prototypical example of some bizarre predictions for intermediate measurements made on pre- and postselected systems. Although in principle those effects can be explained by measurement disturbance, it is not clear what mechanisms are required to fully account for the observed correlations. In this paper, this paradox is scrutinized from the causal point of view. We consider an array of potential causal structures behind the experiment, eliminating those without enough explanatory power. A distinction is made between the propagation in the system of just the measurement outcome and the information about the full measurement context. We also discuss the consequences of the realist position in which preexisting values are revealed by measurements. Interestingly, the answers depend crucially on whether the original version of the paradox is considered or its extension where the third box is allowed for inspection too. This illustrates the richness of the paradox which is better appreciated from the causal perspective.

arXiv:2107.13937•Physical Review A•Jan 10, 2022•2 citations

A Classical and Quantum Mechanical Analog of Two Capacitors Paradox

Vladan Panković, D. Kapor

As it is well-known one of the most fascinating examples in remarkable discussion between Einstein and Bohr on the conceptual foundation of the quantum mechanics (Heisenberg energy-time uncertainty relation especially) was an experimental device representing a box hanged on an elastic spring. The pair of similar devices is used in this work for formulation of a classical and (implicitly) quantum mechanical analog of the famous two capacitors paradox. It admits a simple solution of the paradox since energy difference or seeming paradoxical "loss" can be explained by work of the elastic force for moving of the boxes in the gravitational field. (Obviously, original two capacitors paradox can be explained in the analogous way.)

arXiv:0912.4114•Dec 21, 2009•0 citations
A simple classical probabilistic system (a simple card game) classically exemplifies Aharonov and Vaidman's ‘three-box ‘paradox’’ (1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24 2315 ), implying that the three-box example is neither quantal nor a paradox and leaving one with less difficulty to busy the interpreters of quantum mechanics. An ambiguity in the usual expression of the retrodiction formula is shown to have misled Albert et al (1985 Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 5) to a result not, in fact, ‘curious’; the discussion illustrates how to avoid this ambiguity.
The classical three-box paradox of Kirkpatrick ( 2003 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 36 4891 ) is compared to the original quantum three-box paradox of Aharonov and Vaidman ( 1991 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24 2315 ). It is argued that the quantum three-box experiment is a 'quantum paradox' in the sense that it is an example of a classical task which cannot be accomplished using classical means, but can be accomplished using quantum devices. It is shown that Kirkpatrick's card game is analogous to a different game with a particle in three boxes which does not contain paradoxical features.
Which theories lead to a contradiction between simple reasoning principles and modelling observers’ memories as physical systems? Frauchiger and Renner have shown that this is the case for quantum theory (Frauchiger and Renner 2018 Nat. Commun. 9 3711). Here we generalize the conditions of the Frauchiger–Renner result so that they can be applied to arbitrary physical theories, and in particular to those expressed as generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs) (Hardy 2001 arXiv: quant-ph/0101012 ; Barrett 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 032304). We then apply them to a particular GPT, box world, and find a deterministic contradiction in the case where agents may share a PR box (Popescu and Rohrlich 1994 Found. Phys. 24 379–85), which is stronger than the quantum paradox, in that it does not rely on post-selection. Obtaining an inconsistency for the framework of GPTs broadens the landscape of theories which are affected by the application of classical rules of reasoning to physical agents. In addition, we model how observers’ memories may evolve in box world, in a way consistent with Barrett’s criteria for allowed operations (Barrett 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 032304; Gross et al 2010 Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 080402). Ordinary readers, forgive my paradoxes: one must make them when one reflects; and whatever you may say, I prefer being a man with paradoxes than a man with prejudices. Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Emile or On Education
The quantum three-box paradox is a prototypical example of some bizarre predictions for intermediate measurements made on pre- and postselected systems. Although in principle those effects can be explained by measurement disturbance, it is not clear what mechanisms are required to fully account for the observed correlations. In this paper, this paradox is scrutinized from the causal point of view. We consider an array of potential causal structures behind the experiment, eliminating those without enough explanatory power. A distinction is made between the propagation in the system of just the measurement outcome and the information about the full measurement context. We also discuss the consequences of the realist position in which preexisting values are revealed by measurements. Interestingly, the answers depend crucially on whether the original version of the paradox is considered or its extension where the third box is allowed for inspection too. This illustrates the richness of the paradox which is better appreciated from the causal perspective.
As it is well-known one of the most fascinating examples in remarkable discussion between Einstein and Bohr on the conceptual foundation of the quantum mechanics (Heisenberg energy-time uncertainty relation especially) was an experimental device representing a box hanged on an elastic spring. The pair of similar devices is used in this work for formulation of a classical and (implicitly) quantum mechanical analog of the famous two capacitors paradox. It admits a simple solution of the paradox since energy difference or seeming paradoxical "loss" can be explained by work of the elastic force for moving of the boxes in the gravitational field. (Obviously, original two capacitors paradox can be explained in the analogous way.)