Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0206009

On a subject of diverse improvisations: The uncertainty relations on a circle

Spiridon Dumitru

Published Jun 3, 2002• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The disputed question of uncertainty relations (UR) on a circle is regarded as a particular element of a more general problem which refers to the quantum description of angular observables $L_z$ and $ϕ$. The improvised $L_z-ϕ$ UR are found to be affected by unsourmontable shortcomings. Also in contradiction with a largely accepted belief it is proved that the usual procedures of quantum mechanics are accurately applicable for the $L_z-ϕ$ pair. The applicability regards both the known circular motions and the less known non-circular rotational motions. The presented facts contribute as arguments to the following indubitable conclusions: (i) the traditional interpretation of UR must be denied as an incorrect doctrine, (ii) for a natural physical consideration of the the $L_z-ϕ$ pair the results from the usual quantum mechanics are sufficient while the improvised $L_z-ϕ$ UR must be rejected as senseless formulas and (iii) the descriptions of quantum measurements have to be done in a framework which is distinct and additional in respect with the usual quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0206009

Related papers

On the uncertainty relations for angular observables and beyond them

Spiridon Dumitru

For angular observables pairs (angular momentum-angle and number-phase) the adequate reference element of normality is not the Robertson-Schrödinger uncertainty relation but a Schwarz formula regarding the quantum fluctuations. Beyond such a fact the traditional interpretation of the uncertainty relations appears as an unjustified doctrine.

arXiv:quant-ph/0307007•Jul 1, 2003•1 citation

A survey on uncertainty relations and quantum measurements

Spiridon Dumitru

This survey tries to investigate the truths and deficiencies of prevalent philosophy about Uncertainty Relations (UR) and Quantum Measurements (QMS). The respective philosophy, known as being eclipsed by unfinished controversies, is revealed to be grounded on six basic precepts. But one finds that all the respective precepts are discredited by insurmountable deficiencies. So, in regard to UR, the alluded philosophy discloses oneself to be an unjustified mythology. Then UR appear either as short-lived historical conventions or as simple and limited mathematical formulas, without any essential significance for physics. Such a finding reinforces the Dirac's prediction that UR "`in their present form will not survive in the physics of future"'. The noted facets of UR motivate reconsiderations of associated debates on QMS. Mainly one reveals that, properly, UR have not any essential connection with genuine descriptions of QMS. For such descriptions, it is necessary that, mathematically, the quantum observables to be considered as random variables. The measuring scenarios with a single sampling, such are wave function collapse or Schrodinger's cat thought experiment, are revealed as being useless exercises. We propose to describe QMS as transmission processes for stochastic data. Note that the above-announced revaluation of UR and QMS philosophy does not disturb in any way the practical framework of the usual quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1205.3892•May 17, 2012•5 citations

On the uncertainty relations and quantum measurements: conventionalities, shortcomings, reconsiderations

Spiridon Dumitru

Unsolved controversies about uncertainty relations and quantum measurements still persists nowadays. They originate around the shortcomings regarding the conventional interpretation of uncertainty relations. Here we show that the respective shortcomings disclose veridic and unavoidable facts which require the abandonment of the mentioned interpretation. So the primitive uncertainty relations appear as being either thought fictions or fluctuations formulae. Subsequently we reveal that the conventional approaches of quantum measurements are grounded on incorrect premises. We propose a new approach in which : (i) the quantum observables are considered as generalized stochastic variables, (ii) the view is focused only on the pre-existent state of the measured system, without any interest for the collapse of the respective state, (iii) a measurement is described as an input-output transformation which modify the probability density and current but preserve the expressions of the operators. The measuring uncertainties are evaluated as changes in the probabilistic estimators of observables. Related to different observables we do not find reasons of principle neither for uncertainties-connections nor for measuring compatibility/incompatibility.

arXiv:quant-ph/0504058•Apr 8, 2005•2 citations

Topological Generalizations of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Relation

Sohang Gandhi

It is well known that the standard canonical uncertainty relation does not apply to the angular variable ? and its conjugate LZ. That is, the relation ? ø ? L Z > h/2 is false. The break down of the result has to do with difference in topology between the line and the circle. It is thus desirable to generalize the standard uncertainty relation topologically and find satisfactory results for the non-Euclidean spaces. This problem is intimately related to the issue of finding a consistent definition for quantum mechanics on "curved spaces". Just as the Heisenberg uncertainty relation was pivotal in understanding the basic structure of standard quantum mechanics, a solution to this problem should shine some light onto the proper conduct of quantum mechanics on general topological spaces. In this study we explore in detail how the standard uncertainty relation may breakdown. We also address the importance of topological considerations in quantum mechanics in general - we shall show how a change in topological character can change the nature of the quantum mechanics for a system and how the consideration of the topology of a system can greatly organize the solution of a problem and in some cases even be necessary for a. full understanding of the problem. We then discuss the derivation of satisfactory uncertainty relations for the compact, homogeneous spaces of the circle, the n-torus and the n-sphere. Finally, we draw out any implications to the issue of properly defining quantum mechanics on the non- Euclidean spaces.

Journal of International Crisis and Risk Communication Research•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Generalized uncertainty relations

Andrzej Herdegen, Piotr Ziobro

The standard uncertainty relations (UR) in quantum mechanics are typically used for unbounded operators (like the canonical pair). This implies the need for the control of the domain problems. On the other hand, the use of (possibly bounded) functions of basic observables usually leads to more complex and less readily interpretable relations. In addition, UR may turn trivial for certain states if the commutator of observables is not proportional to a positive operator. In this letter we consider a generalization of standard UR resulting from the use of two, instead of one, vector states. The possibility to link these states to each other in various ways adds additional flexibility to UR, which may compensate some of the above-mentioned drawbacks. We discuss applications of the general scheme, leading not only to technical improvements, but also to interesting new insight.

arXiv:1511.06589•Letters in Mathematical Physics•Nov 26, 2016•3 citations

On Quantum Uncertainty Relations and Uncertainty Regions

Paul Busch, Oliver Reardon-Smith

Given two or more non-commuting observables, it is generally not possible to simultaneously assign precise values to each. This quantum mechanical uncertainty principle is widely understood to be encapsulated by some form of uncertainty relation, expressing a trade-off between the standard deviations or other measures of uncertainty of two (or more) observables, resulting from their non-commutativity. Typically, such relations are coarse, and miss important features. It was not until very recently that a broader perspective on quantum uncertainty was envisaged and explored, one that utilises the notion of an uncertainty region. Here we review this new approach, illustrating it with pairs or triples of observables in the case of qubit and qutrit systems. We recall some of the shortcomings of traditional uncertainty relations, and highlight their inability to identify the full uncertainty region. These shortcomings suggest a precautionary note that, we surmise, ought to accompany the presentation of the uncertainty principle in introductory quantum mechanics courses.

arXiv:1901.03695•Jan 11, 2019•15 citations
The disputed question of uncertainty relations (UR) on a circle is regarded as a particular element of a more general problem which refers to the quantum description of angular observables LzL_zLz​ and ϕϕϕ. The improvised Lz−ϕL_z-ϕLz​−ϕ UR are found to be affected by unsourmontable shortcomings. Also in contradiction with a largely accepted belief it is proved that the usual procedures of quantum mechanics are accurately applicable for the Lz−ϕL_z-ϕLz​−ϕ pair. The applicability regards both the known circular motions and the less known non-circular rotational motions. The presented facts contribute as arguments to the following indubitable conclusions: (i) the traditional interpretation of UR must be denied as an incorrect doctrine, (ii) for a natural physical consideration of the the Lz−ϕL_z-ϕLz​−ϕ pair the results from the usual quantum mechanics are sufficient while the improvised Lz−ϕL_z-ϕLz​−ϕ UR must be rejected as senseless formulas and (iii) the descriptions of quantum measurements have to be done in a framework which is distinct and additional in respect with the usual quantum mechanics.
This survey tries to investigate the truths and deficiencies of prevalent philosophy about Uncertainty Relations (UR) and Quantum Measurements (QMS). The respective philosophy, known as being eclipsed by unfinished controversies, is revealed to be grounded on six basic precepts. But one finds that all the respective precepts are discredited by insurmountable deficiencies. So, in regard to UR, the alluded philosophy discloses oneself to be an unjustified mythology. Then UR appear either as short-lived historical conventions or as simple and limited mathematical formulas, without any essential significance for physics. Such a finding reinforces the Dirac's prediction that UR "`in their present form will not survive in the physics of future"'. The noted facets of UR motivate reconsiderations of associated debates on QMS. Mainly one reveals that, properly, UR have not any essential connection with genuine descriptions of QMS. For such descriptions, it is necessary that, mathematically, the quantum observables to be considered as random variables. The measuring scenarios with a single sampling, such are wave function collapse or Schrodinger's cat thought experiment, are revealed as being useless exercises. We propose to describe QMS as transmission processes for stochastic data. Note that the above-announced revaluation of UR and QMS philosophy does not disturb in any way the practical framework of the usual quantum mechanics.
Unsolved controversies about uncertainty relations and quantum measurements still persists nowadays. They originate around the shortcomings regarding the conventional interpretation of uncertainty relations. Here we show that the respective shortcomings disclose veridic and unavoidable facts which require the abandonment of the mentioned interpretation. So the primitive uncertainty relations appear as being either thought fictions or fluctuations formulae. Subsequently we reveal that the conventional approaches of quantum measurements are grounded on incorrect premises. We propose a new approach in which : (i) the quantum observables are considered as generalized stochastic variables, (ii) the view is focused only on the pre-existent state of the measured system, without any interest for the collapse of the respective state, (iii) a measurement is described as an input-output transformation which modify the probability density and current but preserve the expressions of the operators. The measuring uncertainties are evaluated as changes in the probabilistic estimators of observables. Related to different observables we do not find reasons of principle neither for uncertainties-connections nor for measuring compatibility/incompatibility.
It is well known that the standard canonical uncertainty relation does not apply to the angular variable ? and its conjugate LZ. That is, the relation ? ø ? L Z > h/2 is false. The break down of the result has to do with difference in topology between the line and the circle. It is thus desirable to generalize the standard uncertainty relation topologically and find satisfactory results for the non-Euclidean spaces. This problem is intimately related to the issue of finding a consistent definition for quantum mechanics on "curved spaces". Just as the Heisenberg uncertainty relation was pivotal in understanding the basic structure of standard quantum mechanics, a solution to this problem should shine some light onto the proper conduct of quantum mechanics on general topological spaces. In this study we explore in detail how the standard uncertainty relation may breakdown. We also address the importance of topological considerations in quantum mechanics in general - we shall show how a change in topological character can change the nature of the quantum mechanics for a system and how the consideration of the topology of a system can greatly organize the solution of a problem and in some cases even be necessary for a. full understanding of the problem. We then discuss the derivation of satisfactory uncertainty relations for the compact, homogeneous spaces of the circle, the n-torus and the n-sphere. Finally, we draw out any implications to the issue of properly defining quantum mechanics on the non- Euclidean spaces.
The standard uncertainty relations (UR) in quantum mechanics are typically used for unbounded operators (like the canonical pair). This implies the need for the control of the domain problems. On the other hand, the use of (possibly bounded) functions of basic observables usually leads to more complex and less readily interpretable relations. In addition, UR may turn trivial for certain states if the commutator of observables is not proportional to a positive operator. In this letter we consider a generalization of standard UR resulting from the use of two, instead of one, vector states. The possibility to link these states to each other in various ways adds additional flexibility to UR, which may compensate some of the above-mentioned drawbacks. We discuss applications of the general scheme, leading not only to technical improvements, but also to interesting new insight.
Given two or more non-commuting observables, it is generally not possible to simultaneously assign precise values to each. This quantum mechanical uncertainty principle is widely understood to be encapsulated by some form of uncertainty relation, expressing a trade-off between the standard deviations or other measures of uncertainty of two (or more) observables, resulting from their non-commutativity. Typically, such relations are coarse, and miss important features. It was not until very recently that a broader perspective on quantum uncertainty was envisaged and explored, one that utilises the notion of an uncertainty region. Here we review this new approach, illustrating it with pairs or triples of observables in the case of qubit and qutrit systems. We recall some of the shortcomings of traditional uncertainty relations, and highlight their inability to identify the full uncertainty region. These shortcomings suggest a precautionary note that, we surmise, ought to accompany the presentation of the uncertainty principle in introductory quantum mechanics courses.