Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0204153

A stronger no-cloning theorem

Richard Jozsa

Published Apr 26, 2002• 42 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is well known that (non-orthogonal) pure states cannot be cloned so one may ask: how much or what kind of additional (quantum) information is needed to supplement one copy of a quantum state in order to be able to produce two copies of that state by a physical operation? For classical information, no supplementary information is required. However for pure quantum (non-orthogonal) states, we show that the supplementary information must always be as large as it can possibly be i.e. the clone must be able to be generated from the additional information alone, independently of the first (given) copy.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0204153

Related papers

Approximate cloning of structured pure states

Yaroslav Herasymenko, Junqiao Lin, Philip Verduyn Lunel +1 more

The no-cloning theorem is a cornerstone result in quantum mechanics that forbids copying of general quantum information. More quantitatively, even given $N$ copies of an unknown state, any channel producing an $(N+1)$-copy state incurs a nonzero trace-distance error on some inputs. Turning this around, one can ask about the sample complexity of approximate $N\rightarrow N+1$ cloning: for a desired small error $ε$, what $N$ suffices? For arbitrary pure states on a Hilbert space $H$, the answer is $N\simeq \dim H/ε$ - astronomically large for most $H$ of interest. What if the input is promised to lie in a structured family? We examine a range of families fundamental to many-body physics and quantum information: $n$-mode fermionic Gaussian and Slater states, $n$-mode bosonic Gaussian states, and qudit phase states. For fermions, we construct optimal cloning channels, reducing the complexity from exponential to polynomial in $n$. For bosonic Gaussian states, we construct an explicit cloner that certifies polynomial complexity, without any constraint on the energy of the state; this channel, however, is not optimal in general. The fermionic and bosonic results follow from a single representation-theoretic framework, which generalizes previous work by Werner and by Chiribella and Yang; it also yields the cloners' unitary implementation. Furthermore, we explain why for many families the cloning complexity is linear in the dimension of the family manifold, via a controlled saddle-point evaluation of the frame potential at high $N$. The same calculation accounts for the analogous scaling of tomography complexity. The above framework does not cover phase states; for these we give an independent construction of a channel with optimal cloning fidelity. Our work complements recent results on cloning stabilizer states.

quant-pharXiv:2610.06723•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Quantum cloning with nonlocal assistance: Complement of Jozsa's stronger no-cloning theorem

Koji Azuma, Masato Koashi, Hosho Katsura +1 more

We investigate the cases where a set $S$ of states $\{\ket{ψ_i} \}$ cannot be cloned by itself, but is clonable with the help of another system prepared in state $\hatρ_i$. When $S$ is pair-wise nonorthogonal, it is known that one can generate the copy from $\hatρ_i$ alone, with no interaction with the original system. Here we show that a set containing orthogonal pairs exhibits a property forming a striking contrast; For any such set, there is a choice of $\hatρ_i$ that enables cloning only when the two systems are interacted in a purely quantum manner that is not achievable via classical communication.

arXiv:quant-ph/0604009•Apr 3, 2006•1 citation

No-cloning with unitary scaling

Dafa Li

It is known that the classical information like strings of bits can be copied. In 1982, Wootters and Zurek proposed the quantum no-cloning principle. No-cloning principle says that it is impossible to make an identical copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution. In this paper, we call U $|ψ>$, where U is any unitary operator, a U-copy of the state $|ψ>$ and show it is impossible to make a U-copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution.

quant-pharXiv:2604.22960•Apr 28, 2026•0 citations

More Nonlocality with Less Purity

Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay

Quantum information is nonlocal in the sense that local measurements on a composite quantum system, prepared in one of many mutually orthogonal states, may not reveal in which state the system was prepared. It is shown that in the many copy limit this kind of nonlocality is fundamentally different for pure and mixed quantum states. In particular, orthogonal mixed states may not be distinguishable by local operations and classical communication, no matter how many copies are supplied, whereas any set of N orthogonal pure states can be perfectly discriminated with m copies, where m<N. Thus mixed quantum states can exhibit a new kind of nonlocality absent in pure states. We also argue that a set of orthogonal quantum states may be said to be maximally indistinguishable iff the set is not conclusively locally distinguishable with multiple copies.

arXiv:1106.0104•Physical Review Letters•May 25, 2011•66 citations

Test of Common Sense in Quantum Copying Process

Mi-Ra Hwang, Eylee Jung, Kap Soo Jang +5 more

It is believed that the more we have {\it a priori} information on input states, the better we can make the quality of clones in quantum cloning machines. This common sense idea was confirmed several years ago by analyzing a situation, where the input state is either one of two non-orthogonal states. If the {\it a priori} information is measured by the Shannon entropy, common sense predicts that the quality of the clone becomes poorer with increasing $N$, where $N$ is the number of possible input states. We show, however, that the {\it a priori} information measured by the Shannon entropy does not affect the quality of the clones. Instead the no-cloning theorem and `denseness' of the possible input states play important roles in determining the quality. Specifically, the factor `denseness' plays a more crucial role than the no-cloning theorem when $N \geq 3$.

arXiv:1012.0115•Dec 1, 2010•0 citations

Optimal universal quantum cloning

KayAlastair

We study the problem of universal quantum cloning - taking several identical copies of a pure but unknown quantum state and producing further copies. While it is well known that it is impossible to...

Quantum Information and Computation•Sep 1, 2016•0 citations
It is well known that (non-orthogonal) pure states cannot be cloned so one may ask: how much or what kind of additional (quantum) information is needed to supplement one copy of a quantum state in order to be able to produce two copies of that state by a physical operation? For classical information, no supplementary information is required. However for pure quantum (non-orthogonal) states, we show that the supplementary information must always be as large as it can possibly be i.e. the clone must be able to be generated from the additional information alone, independently of the first (given) copy.
The no-cloning theorem is a cornerstone result in quantum mechanics that forbids copying of general quantum information. More quantitatively, even given NNN copies of an unknown state, any channel producing an (N+1)(N+1)(N+1)-copy state incurs a nonzero trace-distance error on some inputs. Turning this around, one can ask about the sample complexity of approximate N→N+1N\rightarrow N+1N→N+1 cloning: for a desired small error εεε, what NNN suffices? For arbitrary pure states on a Hilbert space HHH, the answer is N≃dim⁡H/εN\simeq \dim H/εN≃dimH/ε - astronomically large for most HHH of interest. What if the input is promised to lie in a structured family? We examine a range of families fundamental to many-body physics and quantum information: nnn-mode fermionic Gaussian and Slater states, nnn-mode bosonic Gaussian states, and qudit phase states. For fermions, we construct optimal cloning channels, reducing the complexity from exponential to polynomial in nnn. For bosonic Gaussian states, we construct an explicit cloner that certifies polynomial complexity, without any constraint on the energy of the state; this channel, however, is not optimal in general. The fermionic and bosonic results follow from a single representation-theoretic framework, which generalizes previous work by Werner and by Chiribella and Yang; it also yields the cloners' unitary implementation. Furthermore, we explain why for many families the cloning complexity is linear in the dimension of the family manifold, via a controlled saddle-point evaluation of the frame potential at high NNN. The same calculation accounts for the analogous scaling of tomography complexity. The above framework does not cover phase states; for these we give an independent construction of a channel with optimal cloning fidelity. Our work complements recent results on cloning stabilizer states.
We investigate the cases where a set SSS of states {∣ψi⟩}\{\ket{ψ_i} \}{∣ψi​⟩} cannot be cloned by itself, but is clonable with the help of another system prepared in state ρ^i\hatρ_iρ^​i​. When SSS is pair-wise nonorthogonal, it is known that one can generate the copy from ρ^i\hatρ_iρ^​i​ alone, with no interaction with the original system. Here we show that a set containing orthogonal pairs exhibits a property forming a striking contrast; For any such set, there is a choice of ρ^i\hatρ_iρ^​i​ that enables cloning only when the two systems are interacted in a purely quantum manner that is not achievable via classical communication.
It is known that the classical information like strings of bits can be copied. In 1982, Wootters and Zurek proposed the quantum no-cloning principle. No-cloning principle says that it is impossible to make an identical copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution. In this paper, we call U ∣ψ>|ψ>∣ψ>, where U is any unitary operator, a U-copy of the state ∣ψ>|ψ>∣ψ> and show it is impossible to make a U-copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum pure state by using unitary evolution.
Quantum information is nonlocal in the sense that local measurements on a composite quantum system, prepared in one of many mutually orthogonal states, may not reveal in which state the system was prepared. It is shown that in the many copy limit this kind of nonlocality is fundamentally different for pure and mixed quantum states. In particular, orthogonal mixed states may not be distinguishable by local operations and classical communication, no matter how many copies are supplied, whereas any set of N orthogonal pure states can be perfectly discriminated with m copies, where m<N. Thus mixed quantum states can exhibit a new kind of nonlocality absent in pure states. We also argue that a set of orthogonal quantum states may be said to be maximally indistinguishable iff the set is not conclusively locally distinguishable with multiple copies.
It is believed that the more we have {\it a priori} information on input states, the better we can make the quality of clones in quantum cloning machines. This common sense idea was confirmed several years ago by analyzing a situation, where the input state is either one of two non-orthogonal states. If the {\it a priori} information is measured by the Shannon entropy, common sense predicts that the quality of the clone becomes poorer with increasing NNN, where NNN is the number of possible input states. We show, however, that the {\it a priori} information measured by the Shannon entropy does not affect the quality of the clones. Instead the no-cloning theorem and `denseness' of the possible input states play important roles in determining the quality. Specifically, the factor `denseness' plays a more crucial role than the no-cloning theorem when N≥3N \geq 3N≥3.