We consider two aspects of quantum game theory: the extent to which the quantum solution solves the original classical game, and to what extent the new solution can be obtained in a classical model.
Some basic knowledge of quantum mechanics is a necessary prerequisite for studying quantum games. The most fundamental facts are collected in Section 13.1 describing closed finite-dimensional systems and complemented by the rules of quantum measurements in Section 13.2. These facts are sufficient for the main trend of our introductory exposition. Essentially, they can be looked at as a linear algebra recast in physics terms and physics notations. However, for further developments of quantum games one needs some notions of open quantum systems. They are presented in Section 13.9, to which we refer occasionally, and which supplies the background that is necessary for reading modern research papers. The main Sections 13.3-13.7 build the foundations of quantum games. The main papers on this topic are written by physicists for physicists, and the inevitable exploitation of physics jargon may create difficulties for mathematicians or economists. Our main goal here is to make clear the physical content and to stress the new features of the games that may be revealed in their quantum versions, in particular, the new cooperative equilibria. We omit sometimes the lengthy calculations (referring to the original papers) once the physical part is sorted out and the problem is reformulated as pure game-theoretic problem of calculating the Nash or dominated equilibria. Section 13.8 is devoted to quantum games arising from the classical games with infinite state space (like the classical Cournot duopoly). Section 13.10 touches upon general theory of finite quantum static games. Further links and references are provided in Section 13.11.
In these lecture notes we investigate the implications of the identification of strategies with quantum operations in game theory beyond the results presented in [J. Eisert, M. Wilkens, and M. Lewenstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 3077 (1999)]. After introducing a general framework, we study quantum games with a classical analogue in order to flesh out the peculiarities of game theoretical settings in the quantum domain. Special emphasis is given to a detailed investigation of different sets of quantum strategies.
Quantum games have proposed a new point of view for the solution of the classical problems and dilemmas in game theory. Certain quantization relationships can be proposed with the objective that a game can be generalized into a quantum domain where the linear superposition of actions is allowed. This quantization let us describe and solution problems originated by conflicting or cooperative behaviors among the members of a system from the point of view of quantum mechanical interactions. This leads us to interesting aspects which only can be observed through the quantization of a game like the possibility of the entanglement between players, the definition of a socioeconomical temperature in a system, the collective welfare principle,the analysis of a game through elements of quantum information theory and the globalization process. The relationships between quantum mechanics and game theory are also studied and its shown how although both systems analyzed are described through two theories apparently different (quantum mechanics and game theory) both are analogous and thus exactly equivalents.
In game theory, a popular model of a struggle for survival among three competing agents is a truel, or three-person generalization of a duel. Adopting the ideas recently developed in quantum game theory, we present a quantum scheme for the problems of duels and truels. In the classical case, the outcome is sensitive to the precise rules under which the truel is performed and can be counterintuitive. These aspects carry over into our quantum scheme, but interference amongst the players' strategies can arise, leading to game equilibria different from the classical case.
N. Vyas and C. Benjamin (arXiv:1701.08573[quant-ph]) propose a new mixed strategy for the (quantum) Hawk-Dove and Prisoners' Dilemma games and argue that this strategy yields payoffs, which cannot be obtained in the corresponding classical games. They conclude that this refutes the earlier assertion by S.J. van Enk and R. Pike that the quantum equilibrium solution is present in a corresponding extended classical game. This paper argues that the scheme suggested by N. Vyas and C. Benjamin changes the rules of the original game, and hence it does not refute the argument put forward by van Enk and Pike.