Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0112115 · Physical Review Letters

Inequivalence of Pure State Ensembles for Open Quantum Systems: The Preferred Ensembles Are Those That Are Physically Realizable

Howard M. Wiseman, John A. Vaccaro

Published Nov 20, 2001• 35 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An open quantum system in steady state ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ can be represented by a weighted ensemble of pure states ${\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{\mathrm{ss}}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\Sigma}{k}^{}{\ensuremath{\wp}}_{k}|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{k}〉〈{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{k}|$ in infinitely many ways. A physically realizable (PR) ensemble is one for which some continuous measurement of the environment will collapse the system into a pure state $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)〉$, stochastically evolving such that the proportion of time for which $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)〉\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{k}〉$ equals ${\ensuremath{\wp}}_{k}$. Some, but not all, ensembles are PR. This constitutes the preferred ensemble fact. We present the necessary and sufficient conditions for a given ensemble to be PR, and illustrate the method by showing that the coherent state ensemble is not PR for an atom laser.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.87.240402

Related papers

Atom lasers, coherent states, and coherence. I. Physically realizable ensembles of pure states

Howard M. Wiseman, John A. Vaccaro

A laser, be it an optical laser or an atom laser, is an open quantum system that produces a coherent beam of bosons (photons or atoms, respectively). Far above threshold, the stationary state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ of the laser mode is a mixture of coherent-field states with random phase, or, equivalently, a Poissonian mixture of number states. This paper answers the question: can descriptions such as these, of ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ as a stationary ensemble of pure states, be physically realized? Here physical realization is as defined previously by us [H. M. Wiseman and J. A. Vaccaro, Phys. Lett. A 250, 241 (1998)]: an ensemble of pure states for a particular system can be physically realized if, without changing the dynamics of the system, an experimenter can (in principle) know at any time that the system is in one of the pure-state members of the ensemble. Such knowledge can be obtained by monitoring the baths to which the system is coupled, provided that coupling is describable by a Markovian master equation. Using a family of master equations for the (atom) laser, we solve for the physically realizable (PR) ensembles. We find that for any finite self-energy $\ensuremath{\chi}$ of the bosons in the laser mode, the coherent-state ensemble is not PR; the closest one can come to it is an ensemble of squeezed states. This is particularly relevant for atom lasers, where the self-energy arising from elastic collisions is expected to be large. By contrast, the number-state ensemble is always PR. As the self-energy $\ensuremath{\chi}$ increases, the states in the PR ensemble closest to the coherent-state ensemble become increasingly squeezed. Nevertheless, there are values of $\ensuremath{\chi}$ for which states with well-defined coherent amplitudes are PR, even though the atom laser is not coherent (in the sense of having a Bose-degenerate output). We discuss the physical significance of this anomaly in terms of conditional coherence (and hence conditional Bose degeneracy).

arXiv:quant-ph/9906125•Physical Review A•Mar 20, 2002•10 citations

Atom lasers, coherent states, and coherence II. Maximally robust ensembles of pure states

Howard M. Wiseman, John A. Vaccaro

As discussed in the preceding paper [Wiseman and Vaccaro, preceding paper, Phys. Rev. A 65, 043605 (2002)], the stationary state of an optical or atom laser far above threshold is a mixture of coherent field states with random phase, or, equivalently, a Poissonian mixture of number states. We are interested in which, if either, of these descriptions of ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ as a stationary ensemble of pure states, is more natural. In the preceding paper we concentrated upon the question of whether descriptions such as these are physically realizable (PR). In this paper we investigate another relevant aspect of these ensembles, their robustness. A robust ensemble is one for which the pure states that comprise it survive relatively unchanged for a long time under the system evolution. We determine numerically the most robust ensembles as a function of the parameters in the laser model: the self-energy $\ensuremath{\chi}$ of the bosons in the laser mode, and the excess phase noise $\ensuremath{\nu}.$ We find that these most robust ensembles are PR ensembles, or similar to PR ensembles, for all values of these parameters. In the ideal laser limit $(\ensuremath{\nu}=\ensuremath{\chi}=0),$ the most robust states are coherent states. As the phase noise or phase dispersion is increased through $\ensuremath{\nu}$ or the self-interaction of the bosons $\ensuremath{\chi},$ respectively, the most robust states become more and more amplitude squeezed. We find scaling laws for these states, and give analytical derivations for them. As the phase diffusion or dispersion becomes so large that the laser output is no longer quantum coherent, the most robust states become so squeezed that they cease to have a well-defined coherent amplitude. That is, the quantum coherence of the laser output is manifest in the most robust PR ensemble being an ensemble of states with a well-defined coherent amplitude. This lends support to our approach of regarding robust PR ensembles as the most natural description of the state of the laser mode. It also has interesting implications for atom lasers in particular, for which phase dispersion due to self-interactions is expected to be large.

arXiv:quant-ph/0112145•Physical Review A•Mar 20, 2002•12 citations

Representation of a quantum ensemble as a minimal set of pure states

Thomas E. Skinner, Steffen J. Glaser

The density matrix $\ensuremath{\rho}$ for an n-level system is decomposed into the minimum number of pure states necessary to calculate physical observables. The corresponding physical system is first represented by a set $\mathcal{B}$ of n pure states $|{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{i}〉,$ together with their statistical weights. The time evolution of the system is therefore calculated as $\mathcal{B}(t)=U\mathcal{B}{(t}_{0}),$ with the propagator U operating on each member of the set, in contrast to the more laborious $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)=U\ensuremath{\rho}{(t}_{0}{)U}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}.$ At least one of the states can be eliminated from the set by reducing its weight to zero via a simple transformation of the density matrix. When there are degenerate weights, the transformation is applied using the weight with the largest degeneracy. Thus, even if none of the original statistical weights are equal to zero, so that $\mathrm{rank}(\ensuremath{\rho})=n,$ the system can be described by a set of m states with $m<n.$ The resulting minimal set provides a concommitant increase in calculational efficiency that depends on the fractional degeneracy. The independent evolution of the states comprising the set also provides an inherent parallelism that can be readily utilized in numerical computations. In addition to efficiency and conceptual simplification, this decomposition can provide physical insight, since the explicit contribution of each pure state to the dynamics of the system is readily apparent.

Physical Review A•Sep 25, 2002•5 citations

Quantum theory of open systems

Gennaro Auletta, Mauro Fortunato, Giorgio Parisi A

In this chapter we shall deal with the quantum dynamics of an open system. By open quantum system we mean here a system which interacts with an environment (see Sec. 9.4): since we are not interested in the dynamics of the environment, we shall have to describe the evolution of the system in some “effective” way. In particular, if we consider only the evolution of the system, it will be non-unitary, and this will represent the subject of this chapter. As we know, Hamiltonian quantum dynamics is unitary and changes pure states into pure states. On the other hand, non-unitary dynamics changes an initially pure state into a mixture, which must be described by a density matrix (see Ch. 5). In the case of macroscopic systems, the coupling with the environment may be arbitrarily reduced and therefore its influence can be made correspondingly small (see Sec. 1.1). Microscopic systems, however, always couple to the environment and this coupling cannot be considered negligible. This is the reason why the quantum theory of open systems is one of the most important and fundamental chapters of quantum mechanics that, though born in quantum optics, has many implications in almost all fields of physics. The present chapter can be seen as a further development of the measurement theory (see Ch. 9), as open systems manifest a decoherent dynamics (see in particular Sec. 9.4).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 16, 2009•33 citations

Stochastic feedback control of quantum transport to realize a dynamical ensemble of two nonorthogonal pure states

Shakib Daryanoosh, Howard M. Wiseman, Tobias Brandes

A Markovian open quantum system which relaxes to a unique steady state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ of finite rank can be decomposed into a finite physically realizable ensemble (PRE) of pure states. That is, as shown by R. I. Karasik and H. M. Wiseman [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 020406 (2011)], in principle there is a way to monitor the environment so that in the long-time limit the conditional state jumps between a finite number of possible pure states. In this paper we show how to apply this idea to the dynamics of a double quantum dot arising from the feedback control of quantum transport, as previously considered by C. P\"oltl, C. Emary, and T. Brandes [Phys. Rev. B 84, 085302 (2011)]. Specifically, we consider the limit where the system can be described as a qubit, and show that while the control scheme can always realize a two-state PRE, in the incoherent-tunneling regime there are infinitely many PREs compatible with the dynamics that cannot be so realized. For the two-state PREs that are realized, we calculate the counting statistics and see a clear distinction between the coherent and incoherent regimes.

arXiv:1510.05180•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 18, 2016•10 citations

Partial Collapse and Ensemble Invariance under Continuous Quantum Measurement

Shalender Singh, Santosh Kumar

Wavefunction collapse is commonly associated with unavoidable physical disturbance of the measured system. Here we show that in driven-dissipative quantum systems, continuous measurement can induce strong trajectory-level collapse while leaving the ensemble-averaged steady state strictly invariant. We identify measurement-invariant steady states whose unconditional density matrix remains unchanged under continuous monitoring, despite pronounced measurement-induced localization in conditioned quantum trajectories. This separation between trajectory-level collapse and ensemble invariance defines a regime of partial collapse, in which measurement-induced localization is continuously counteracted by dissipative dynamics. We derive a necessary and sufficient condition for steady-state invariance under continuous measurement and identify Liouvillian symmetry as a concrete dynamical mechanism enforcing it. Our results clarify the distinction between conditional collapse and physical disturbance in open quantum systems and provide a framework for non-invasive continuous monitoring in driven-dissipative settings.

quant-pharXiv:2512.22235•Dec 24, 2025•0 citations
An open quantum system in steady state {\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{\mathrm{ss}} can be represented by a weighted ensemble of pure states {\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{\mathrm{ss}}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\Sigma}{k}^{}{\ensuremath{\wp}}_{k}|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{k}〉〈{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{k}| in infinitely many ways. A physically realizable (PR) ensemble is one for which some continuous measurement of the environment will collapse the system into a pure state ∣\ensuremathψ(t)〉|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)〉∣\ensuremathψ(t)〉, stochastically evolving such that the proportion of time for which ∣\ensuremathψ(t)〉=∣\ensuremathψk〉|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)〉\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{k}〉∣\ensuremathψ(t)〉=∣\ensuremathψk​〉 equals \ensuremath℘k{\ensuremath{\wp}}_{k}\ensuremath℘k​. Some, but not all, ensembles are PR. This constitutes the preferred ensemble fact. We present the necessary and sufficient conditions for a given ensemble to be PR, and illustrate the method by showing that the coherent state ensemble is not PR for an atom laser.
A laser, be it an optical laser or an atom laser, is an open quantum system that produces a coherent beam of bosons (photons or atoms, respectively). Far above threshold, the stationary state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ of the laser mode is a mixture of coherent-field states with random phase, or, equivalently, a Poissonian mixture of number states. This paper answers the question: can descriptions such as these, of ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ as a stationary ensemble of pure states, be physically realized? Here physical realization is as defined previously by us [H. M. Wiseman and J. A. Vaccaro, Phys. Lett. A 250, 241 (1998)]: an ensemble of pure states for a particular system can be physically realized if, without changing the dynamics of the system, an experimenter can (in principle) know at any time that the system is in one of the pure-state members of the ensemble. Such knowledge can be obtained by monitoring the baths to which the system is coupled, provided that coupling is describable by a Markovian master equation. Using a family of master equations for the (atom) laser, we solve for the physically realizable (PR) ensembles. We find that for any finite self-energy $\ensuremath{\chi}$ of the bosons in the laser mode, the coherent-state ensemble is not PR; the closest one can come to it is an ensemble of squeezed states. This is particularly relevant for atom lasers, where the self-energy arising from elastic collisions is expected to be large. By contrast, the number-state ensemble is always PR. As the self-energy $\ensuremath{\chi}$ increases, the states in the PR ensemble closest to the coherent-state ensemble become increasingly squeezed. Nevertheless, there are values of $\ensuremath{\chi}$ for which states with well-defined coherent amplitudes are PR, even though the atom laser is not coherent (in the sense of having a Bose-degenerate output). We discuss the physical significance of this anomaly in terms of conditional coherence (and hence conditional Bose degeneracy).
As discussed in the preceding paper [Wiseman and Vaccaro, preceding paper, Phys. Rev. A 65, 043605 (2002)], the stationary state of an optical or atom laser far above threshold is a mixture of coherent field states with random phase, or, equivalently, a Poissonian mixture of number states. We are interested in which, if either, of these descriptions of ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ as a stationary ensemble of pure states, is more natural. In the preceding paper we concentrated upon the question of whether descriptions such as these are physically realizable (PR). In this paper we investigate another relevant aspect of these ensembles, their robustness. A robust ensemble is one for which the pure states that comprise it survive relatively unchanged for a long time under the system evolution. We determine numerically the most robust ensembles as a function of the parameters in the laser model: the self-energy $\ensuremath{\chi}$ of the bosons in the laser mode, and the excess phase noise $\ensuremath{\nu}.$ We find that these most robust ensembles are PR ensembles, or similar to PR ensembles, for all values of these parameters. In the ideal laser limit $(\ensuremath{\nu}=\ensuremath{\chi}=0),$ the most robust states are coherent states. As the phase noise or phase dispersion is increased through $\ensuremath{\nu}$ or the self-interaction of the bosons $\ensuremath{\chi},$ respectively, the most robust states become more and more amplitude squeezed. We find scaling laws for these states, and give analytical derivations for them. As the phase diffusion or dispersion becomes so large that the laser output is no longer quantum coherent, the most robust states become so squeezed that they cease to have a well-defined coherent amplitude. That is, the quantum coherence of the laser output is manifest in the most robust PR ensemble being an ensemble of states with a well-defined coherent amplitude. This lends support to our approach of regarding robust PR ensembles as the most natural description of the state of the laser mode. It also has interesting implications for atom lasers in particular, for which phase dispersion due to self-interactions is expected to be large.
The density matrix $\ensuremath{\rho}$ for an n-level system is decomposed into the minimum number of pure states necessary to calculate physical observables. The corresponding physical system is first represented by a set B\mathcal{B}B of n pure states $|{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{i}〉,$ together with their statistical weights. The time evolution of the system is therefore calculated as B(t)=UB(t0),\mathcal{B}(t)=U\mathcal{B}{(t}_{0}),B(t)=UB(t0​), with the propagator U operating on each member of the set, in contrast to the more laborious $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)=U\ensuremath{\rho}{(t}_{0}{)U}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}.$ At least one of the states can be eliminated from the set by reducing its weight to zero via a simple transformation of the density matrix. When there are degenerate weights, the transformation is applied using the weight with the largest degeneracy. Thus, even if none of the original statistical weights are equal to zero, so that $\mathrm{rank}(\ensuremath{\rho})=n,$ the system can be described by a set of m states with m<n.m<n.m<n. The resulting minimal set provides a concommitant increase in calculational efficiency that depends on the fractional degeneracy. The independent evolution of the states comprising the set also provides an inherent parallelism that can be readily utilized in numerical computations. In addition to efficiency and conceptual simplification, this decomposition can provide physical insight, since the explicit contribution of each pure state to the dynamics of the system is readily apparent.
In this chapter we shall deal with the quantum dynamics of an open system. By open quantum system we mean here a system which interacts with an environment (see Sec. 9.4): since we are not interested in the dynamics of the environment, we shall have to describe the evolution of the system in some “effective” way. In particular, if we consider only the evolution of the system, it will be non-unitary, and this will represent the subject of this chapter. As we know, Hamiltonian quantum dynamics is unitary and changes pure states into pure states. On the other hand, non-unitary dynamics changes an initially pure state into a mixture, which must be described by a density matrix (see Ch. 5). In the case of macroscopic systems, the coupling with the environment may be arbitrarily reduced and therefore its influence can be made correspondingly small (see Sec. 1.1). Microscopic systems, however, always couple to the environment and this coupling cannot be considered negligible. This is the reason why the quantum theory of open systems is one of the most important and fundamental chapters of quantum mechanics that, though born in quantum optics, has many implications in almost all fields of physics. The present chapter can be seen as a further development of the measurement theory (see Ch. 9), as open systems manifest a decoherent dynamics (see in particular Sec. 9.4).
A Markovian open quantum system which relaxes to a unique steady state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{\mathrm{ss}}$ of finite rank can be decomposed into a finite physically realizable ensemble (PRE) of pure states. That is, as shown by R. I. Karasik and H. M. Wiseman [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 020406 (2011)], in principle there is a way to monitor the environment so that in the long-time limit the conditional state jumps between a finite number of possible pure states. In this paper we show how to apply this idea to the dynamics of a double quantum dot arising from the feedback control of quantum transport, as previously considered by C. P\"oltl, C. Emary, and T. Brandes [Phys. Rev. B 84, 085302 (2011)]. Specifically, we consider the limit where the system can be described as a qubit, and show that while the control scheme can always realize a two-state PRE, in the incoherent-tunneling regime there are infinitely many PREs compatible with the dynamics that cannot be so realized. For the two-state PREs that are realized, we calculate the counting statistics and see a clear distinction between the coherent and incoherent regimes.
Wavefunction collapse is commonly associated with unavoidable physical disturbance of the measured system. Here we show that in driven-dissipative quantum systems, continuous measurement can induce strong trajectory-level collapse while leaving the ensemble-averaged steady state strictly invariant. We identify measurement-invariant steady states whose unconditional density matrix remains unchanged under continuous monitoring, despite pronounced measurement-induced localization in conditioned quantum trajectories. This separation between trajectory-level collapse and ensemble invariance defines a regime of partial collapse, in which measurement-induced localization is continuously counteracted by dissipative dynamics. We derive a necessary and sufficient condition for steady-state invariance under continuous measurement and identify Liouvillian symmetry as a concrete dynamical mechanism enforcing it. Our results clarify the distinction between conditional collapse and physical disturbance in open quantum systems and provide a framework for non-invasive continuous monitoring in driven-dissipative settings.