Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0101022

Do Quantum Nonlocal Correlations Imply Information Transfer?- A Gedanken Experiment

R. Srikanth

Published Jan 4, 2001• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study a generalization of the original Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment. It is essentially a delayed choice experiment as applied to entangled particles. The basic idea is: given two observers sharing position-momentum entangled photons, one party chooses whether she measures position or momentum of her photons after the particles leave the source. The other party should infer her action by checking for the absence or presence of characteristic interference patterns after subjecting his particles to certain optical pre-processing. An occurance of apparent signaling is attributed to the difficulty in treating single photons simultaneously at a quantum mechanical and quantum electrodynamic level, as required by the experiment, and points to the need for a careful study of an aspect of the foundations of quantum mechanics and electrodynamics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0101022

Related papers

Do Quantum Nonlocal Correlations Imply Information Transfer?- A Simply Quantum Optical Test

R. Srikanth

In order to understand whether nonlocality implies information transfer, a quantum optical experimental test, well within the scope of current technology, is proposed. It is essentially a delayed choice experiment as applied to entangled particles. The basic idea is: given two observers sharing position-momentum entangled photons, one party chooses whether she measures position or momentum of her photons after the particles leave the source. The other party should infer her action by checking for the absence or presence of characteristic interference patterns after subjecting his particles to certain optical pre-processing. An occurance of signal transmission is attributed to the breakdown of complementarity in incomplete measurements. Since the result implies that the transferred information is classical, we discuss some propositions for safeguarding causality.

arXiv:quant-ph/0101023•Jan 4, 2001•5 citations

On the interpretation of Delayed Choice Quantum Experiments

Padmanabhan Murali

Experimental realization of Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics continue to suggest inferences of action at a distance, action into the future or past as reported in Delayed choice Quantum entanglement experiments recently by Ma et al (2012). Is it possible to read through this and investigate through simple logic and experiments whether control of the past or future is possible? A set of experiments are suggested here to do the same whose results may be interesting. Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics principles Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (Einstein et al, 1935) were the first to suggest a Gedanken experiment which would suggest instant communication over a distance between particles which was against the principle of Special

•Feb 1, 2015•0 citations

Optical Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen experiments

Harry Paul

Polarization entangled photon pairs Throughout his life, Albert Einstein was never reconciled to quantum theory being an essentially indeterministic description of natural processes, even though he himself contributed fundamental ideas to its development. “God does not play dice” was his inner conviction. In his opinion, quantum theory was only makeshift. His doubts about the completeness of the quantum mechanical description were expressed concisely in a paper published jointly with Podolsky and Rosen (Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen, 1935). This paper analyzes a sophisticated Gedanken experiment, now famous as the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox, which has excited theoreticians ever since. The Gedanken experiment was recently realized in a laboratory. The analyzed objects are photon pairs – and this is what has motivated us to dedicate a chapter to this problem which has bearing upon the foundations of quantum mechanics. The photon pairs are formed by two photons generated in sequence (in a so-called cascade transition, as shown in Fig. 11.1). Due to the validity of the angular momentum conservation law (discussed in Section 6.9) for the elementary emission process, the two photons exhibit specifically quantum mechanical correlations, which are incompatible with the classical reality concept, as will be discussed in detail below. How do the correlations appear in detail? Let us assume the initial state of the atom to be a state with angular momentum (spin) J = 0, the intermediate state to have angular momentum J = 1, and the final state to have again J = 0.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 20, 2004•0 citations

Two-particle interference

Kurt Gottfried

The superposition principle leads to coherence phenomena that have no counterpart in classical optics. A gedanken experiment, due to Horne and Zeilinger, provides an especially clear illustration of such phenomena, and is presented in a manner suitable to an introductory quantum mechanics course. The experiment displays an interference pattern in the correlation between two particles produced in a momentum-conserving decay, but no interference pattern when either particle is observed separately; it also has interesting Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen-type correlations.

American Journal of Physics•Feb 1, 2000•54 citations

On the Correlations between the Particles in the EPR‐Paradoxon

H.‐J. Treder

Abstract The Einstein‐Podolsky‐Rosen “gedanken‐experiment” does not imply non‐local interactions or an “action‐at‐a‐distance”. Contrary, the EPR proves the measurements at one particle does not have influences at canonical variables of the other particles if the quantum‐mechanical commutation relations are true. But, the EPR implices correlations between the particles which come in by “subjective knowledge”. These correlations are a priori informations about the relative motion or, complementarily, about the motion of the center of mass. The impression of an action‐at‐a‐distance is produced by the use of usual particle coordinates in the EPR‐arrangements. The discussion of the Einstein‐Podolsky‐Rosen “gedanken‐experiment” (EPR) has been going on over fifty years. EINSTEIN, PODOLSKY, and ROSEN formulated their famous paradox in 1935, and in the discussion between N. BOHR (1935, 1949) and A. EINSTEIN (1936, 1948); A. EINSTEIN (1948) made his point that the EPR implied an “action‐at‐a‐distance” for quantum‐mechanical particles (without obvious classical interactions). His argument is the starting point for the recent discussion about EPR and causality (see A. Aspect, 1981).

Annalen der Physik•Jan 1, 1983•2 citations

Quantum correlations from local amplitudes and the resolution of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen nonlocality puzzle

C. S. Unnikrishnan

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) nonlocality puzzle has been recognized as one of the most important unresolved issues in the foundational aspects of quantum mechanics. We show that the problem is more or less entirely resolved, if the quantum correlations are calculated directly from local quantities, which preserve the phase information in the quantum system. We assume strict locality for the probability amplitudes instead of local realism for the outcomes and calculate an amplitude correlation function. Then the experimentally observed correlation of outcomes is calculated from the square of the amplitude correlation function. Locality of amplitudes implies that measurement on one particle does not collapse the companion particle to a definite state. Apart from resolving the EPR puzzle, this approach shows that the physical interpretation of apparently “nonlocal” effects, such as quantum teleportation and entanglement swapping, are different from what is usually assumed. Bell-type measurements do not change distant states. Yet the correlations are correctly reproduced, when measured, if complex probability amplitudes are treated as the basic local quantities. As examples, we derive the quantum correlations of two-particle maximally entangled states and the three-particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger entangled state.

arXiv:quant-ph/0005103•Optics and Spectroscopy•Sep 1, 2001•1 citation
We study a generalization of the original Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment. It is essentially a delayed choice experiment as applied to entangled particles. The basic idea is: given two observers sharing position-momentum entangled photons, one party chooses whether she measures position or momentum of her photons after the particles leave the source. The other party should infer her action by checking for the absence or presence of characteristic interference patterns after subjecting his particles to certain optical pre-processing. An occurance of apparent signaling is attributed to the difficulty in treating single photons simultaneously at a quantum mechanical and quantum electrodynamic level, as required by the experiment, and points to the need for a careful study of an aspect of the foundations of quantum mechanics and electrodynamics.
In order to understand whether nonlocality implies information transfer, a quantum optical experimental test, well within the scope of current technology, is proposed. It is essentially a delayed choice experiment as applied to entangled particles. The basic idea is: given two observers sharing position-momentum entangled photons, one party chooses whether she measures position or momentum of her photons after the particles leave the source. The other party should infer her action by checking for the absence or presence of characteristic interference patterns after subjecting his particles to certain optical pre-processing. An occurance of signal transmission is attributed to the breakdown of complementarity in incomplete measurements. Since the result implies that the transferred information is classical, we discuss some propositions for safeguarding causality.
Experimental realization of Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics continue to suggest inferences of action at a distance, action into the future or past as reported in Delayed choice Quantum entanglement experiments recently by Ma et al (2012). Is it possible to read through this and investigate through simple logic and experiments whether control of the past or future is possible? A set of experiments are suggested here to do the same whose results may be interesting. Gedanken experiments on Quantum Mechanics principles Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (Einstein et al, 1935) were the first to suggest a Gedanken experiment which would suggest instant communication over a distance between particles which was against the principle of Special
Polarization entangled photon pairs Throughout his life, Albert Einstein was never reconciled to quantum theory being an essentially indeterministic description of natural processes, even though he himself contributed fundamental ideas to its development. “God does not play dice” was his inner conviction. In his opinion, quantum theory was only makeshift. His doubts about the completeness of the quantum mechanical description were expressed concisely in a paper published jointly with Podolsky and Rosen (Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen, 1935). This paper analyzes a sophisticated Gedanken experiment, now famous as the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox, which has excited theoreticians ever since. The Gedanken experiment was recently realized in a laboratory. The analyzed objects are photon pairs – and this is what has motivated us to dedicate a chapter to this problem which has bearing upon the foundations of quantum mechanics. The photon pairs are formed by two photons generated in sequence (in a so-called cascade transition, as shown in Fig. 11.1). Due to the validity of the angular momentum conservation law (discussed in Section 6.9) for the elementary emission process, the two photons exhibit specifically quantum mechanical correlations, which are incompatible with the classical reality concept, as will be discussed in detail below. How do the correlations appear in detail? Let us assume the initial state of the atom to be a state with angular momentum (spin) J = 0, the intermediate state to have angular momentum J = 1, and the final state to have again J = 0.
The superposition principle leads to coherence phenomena that have no counterpart in classical optics. A gedanken experiment, due to Horne and Zeilinger, provides an especially clear illustration of such phenomena, and is presented in a manner suitable to an introductory quantum mechanics course. The experiment displays an interference pattern in the correlation between two particles produced in a momentum-conserving decay, but no interference pattern when either particle is observed separately; it also has interesting Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen-type correlations.
Abstract The Einstein‐Podolsky‐Rosen “gedanken‐experiment” does not imply non‐local interactions or an “action‐at‐a‐distance”. Contrary, the EPR proves the measurements at one particle does not have influences at canonical variables of the other particles if the quantum‐mechanical commutation relations are true. But, the EPR implices correlations between the particles which come in by “subjective knowledge”. These correlations are a priori informations about the relative motion or, complementarily, about the motion of the center of mass. The impression of an action‐at‐a‐distance is produced by the use of usual particle coordinates in the EPR‐arrangements. The discussion of the Einstein‐Podolsky‐Rosen “gedanken‐experiment” (EPR) has been going on over fifty years. EINSTEIN, PODOLSKY, and ROSEN formulated their famous paradox in 1935, and in the discussion between N. BOHR (1935, 1949) and A. EINSTEIN (1936, 1948); A. EINSTEIN (1948) made his point that the EPR implied an “action‐at‐a‐distance” for quantum‐mechanical particles (without obvious classical interactions). His argument is the starting point for the recent discussion about EPR and causality (see A. Aspect, 1981).
The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) nonlocality puzzle has been recognized as one of the most important unresolved issues in the foundational aspects of quantum mechanics. We show that the problem is more or less entirely resolved, if the quantum correlations are calculated directly from local quantities, which preserve the phase information in the quantum system. We assume strict locality for the probability amplitudes instead of local realism for the outcomes and calculate an amplitude correlation function. Then the experimentally observed correlation of outcomes is calculated from the square of the amplitude correlation function. Locality of amplitudes implies that measurement on one particle does not collapse the companion particle to a definite state. Apart from resolving the EPR puzzle, this approach shows that the physical interpretation of apparently “nonlocal” effects, such as quantum teleportation and entanglement swapping, are different from what is usually assumed. Bell-type measurements do not change distant states. Yet the correlations are correctly reproduced, when measured, if complex probability amplitudes are treated as the basic local quantities. As examples, we derive the quantum correlations of two-particle maximally entangled states and the three-particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger entangled state.