Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0008005 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

The classical limit of quantum mechanics and the Fejér sum of the Fourier series expansion of a classical quantity

Quanhui Liu

Published Jan 1, 1999• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum mechanics, the expectation value of a quantity on a quantum state, provided that the state itself gives in the classical limit a motion of a particle in a definite path, in the classical limit goes over to a Fourier series form of the classical quantity. In contrast to this widely accepted point of view, a rigorous calculation shows that the expectation value on such a state in the classical limit exactly gives the Fejér arithmetic mean of the partial sums of the Fourier series.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/32/4/003

Related papers

Classical Limit of Quantum Motion and Fejér Mean Value

Qi Wei

The rigorous calculation to quantum motion in one infinite potential square well shows that the expectation value of a quantum mechanical quantity on equally weighted wave packet in the classical limit tends to the Fejer mean value of the Fourier series of corresponding classical quantity,rather than Fourier series itself.Furthermore,when the number of eigenstates N equals to the square root of quantum number n ,the equally weighted wave packet minimizes the uncertainty relation.

Journal of Hunan University•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations

The Fejér average and the mean value of a quantity in a quasiclassical wave packet

Quanhui Liu, X. Wang, W. H. Qi +2 more

The mean value of a quantity in an equally weighted wave packet was recently found in the classical limit to be the Fejér average of partial sums of Fourier series expansion of the classical quantity, and the number of stationary states in it is equal to that of partial sums. The incompleteness of the Fejér average in representing a classical quantity enables us to define a classical uncertainty relation which turns out to be the counterpart of the quantum one. In this paper, two typical quantum systems, a harmonic oscillator and a particle in an infinite square well, are used to illustrate the above-mentioned points.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2002•6 citations

Does the Quantum Wavefunction Follow from a Fourier Series Treatment of the Classical Potential?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In classical physics, there is a potential V(r) for a conservative force and force is linked to changes in momentum through Newton’s second law. For the sake of argument, imagine one may write V(r) as a Fourier series i.e. Sum over k Vk exp(ikx) and attribute physical relevance to this series. In other words, V(r) is a kind of average of microscopic granular system in which each exp(ikx) can impart momentum on a quantum particle. In addition, the Fourier series seems to have the appearance of a vector with exp(ikx) as a basis. It may also be noted that exp(ikx)exp(ipx) = exp(i (k+p)x). Thus, the potential seems to consist of ‘particles’ represented by exp(ikx) which may merge with quantum particles represented by exp(ipx) to form a boosted quantum particle exp(i (p+k)x). At first, it may seem exp(i (p+k)x) represents increased kinetic energy, but actually this merge should create potential energy. This perhaps gives a microscopic picture of potential energy. Thus, a merge of a Fourier series of V(x) with an ensemble of quantum particles Sum over p fp exp(ipx) yields: V(x) Sum over p fp exp(ipx) ((1)) A point which arises, however, is that Sum over p fp exp(ipx) cannot represent physical density because it may be negative at certain x . Thus, ((1)) is a departure from classical physics in which the potential energy is V(x) for one particle or V(x) density(x). ((1)) represents a kind of potential energy interaction, but introduces a new ensemble object Sum over p fp exp(ipx) which does not seem to exist in classical physics. This ensemble also seems to be a vector. The objective of this note is to try to determine properties and conditions which arise from this merge. In particular, we wish to find an equation satisfied by W(x) and also see how the classical picture is linked to this alternative scenario.

•Nov 19, 2019•0 citations

Classical Limit of Quantum Mechanics

Xiang-You Huang

Because of the use of different limiting procedures, there are two conflict conclusions on wave function. One is that a wave function can describe a single particle and the other is that it can only describe an ensemble in the classical limit. In this paper the limiting procedures have been compared. We put the synthesized limit n→∞, →0 but keep E(n, ) to be the actual measured value of energy. Under this limit condition, we can not only prove that a wave function can only describe an ensemble, but also can make clear the dynamical behavior of the particles of the ensemble. Calculations show that the reason why quantum mechanics cannot describe a particle is not because of the motion equation but because of the definition of state for the particle.

Science in China Series A-Mathematics Physics Astronomy & Technological Science•Feb 20, 1993•1 citation

The Quantum Mechanical State

David Hodgson

In classical physics, the ‘state’ of a particle, at any particular time, is taken to involve a definite position in space and a definite motion; and the state of a system of particles is taken to involve a definite position in space and a definite motion for each of the particles. The situation in relation to quantum mechanics is completely different. As in classical physics, calculations can be made concerning the position and motion of a particle. However, this representation is not by means of symbols for scalar or vector quantities: it is by a more complex mathematical object. This quantum state does not indicate or represent position or motion in any direct way: what it does in substance is to enable calculation of the probability of the particle in question being found to have a position or momentum if an appropriate measurement is made.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Feb 4, 1993•0 citations

Classical Statistical Mechanics

Roland Kjellander

This chapter argues that the classical theory has conceptual difficulties that are resolved by quantum mechanics. Since the classical theory from a fundamental point of view is a special case of the quantum theory at large quantum numbers, it is very natural that there remains traces of the quantum treatment in the classical case. In classical mechanics, the Hamiltonian of a system is equal to the total energy, that is, the sum of the kinetic and potential energy of all particles in the system. Other thermodynamical quantities can also be expanded in a power series in density. The probability to observe a certain kinetic state of the system is completely independent of the interactions; it is the same for strongly interacting molecules in a liquid as it is for a thin gas of the same molecules at the same temperature.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 30, 2019•1 citation
In quantum mechanics, the expectation value of a quantity on a quantum state, provided that the state itself gives in the classical limit a motion of a particle in a definite path, in the classical limit goes over to a Fourier series form of the classical quantity. In contrast to this widely accepted point of view, a rigorous calculation shows that the expectation value on such a state in the classical limit exactly gives the Fejér arithmetic mean of the partial sums of the Fourier series.
The mean value of a quantity in an equally weighted wave packet was recently found in the classical limit to be the Fejér average of partial sums of Fourier series expansion of the classical quantity, and the number of stationary states in it is equal to that of partial sums. The incompleteness of the Fejér average in representing a classical quantity enables us to define a classical uncertainty relation which turns out to be the counterpart of the quantum one. In this paper, two typical quantum systems, a harmonic oscillator and a particle in an infinite square well, are used to illustrate the above-mentioned points.
In classical physics, there is a potential V(r) for a conservative force and force is linked to changes in momentum through Newton’s second law. For the sake of argument, imagine one may write V(r) as a Fourier series i.e. Sum over k Vk exp(ikx) and attribute physical relevance to this series. In other words, V(r) is a kind of average of microscopic granular system in which each exp(ikx) can impart momentum on a quantum particle. In addition, the Fourier series seems to have the appearance of a vector with exp(ikx) as a basis. It may also be noted that exp(ikx)exp(ipx) = exp(i (k+p)x). Thus, the potential seems to consist of ‘particles’ represented by exp(ikx) which may merge with quantum particles represented by exp(ipx) to form a boosted quantum particle exp(i (p+k)x). At first, it may seem exp(i (p+k)x) represents increased kinetic energy, but actually this merge should create potential energy. This perhaps gives a microscopic picture of potential energy. Thus, a merge of a Fourier series of V(x) with an ensemble of quantum particles Sum over p fp exp(ipx) yields: V(x) Sum over p fp exp(ipx) ((1)) A point which arises, however, is that Sum over p fp exp(ipx) cannot represent physical density because it may be negative at certain x . Thus, ((1)) is a departure from classical physics in which the potential energy is V(x) for one particle or V(x) density(x). ((1)) represents a kind of potential energy interaction, but introduces a new ensemble object Sum over p fp exp(ipx) which does not seem to exist in classical physics. This ensemble also seems to be a vector. The objective of this note is to try to determine properties and conditions which arise from this merge. In particular, we wish to find an equation satisfied by W(x) and also see how the classical picture is linked to this alternative scenario.
Because of the use of different limiting procedures, there are two conflict conclusions on wave function. One is that a wave function can describe a single particle and the other is that it can only describe an ensemble in the classical limit. In this paper the limiting procedures have been compared. We put the synthesized limit n→∞, →0 but keep E(n, ) to be the actual measured value of energy. Under this limit condition, we can not only prove that a wave function can only describe an ensemble, but also can make clear the dynamical behavior of the particles of the ensemble. Calculations show that the reason why quantum mechanics cannot describe a particle is not because of the motion equation but because of the definition of state for the particle.
In classical physics, the ‘state’ of a particle, at any particular time, is taken to involve a definite position in space and a definite motion; and the state of a system of particles is taken to involve a definite position in space and a definite motion for each of the particles. The situation in relation to quantum mechanics is completely different. As in classical physics, calculations can be made concerning the position and motion of a particle. However, this representation is not by means of symbols for scalar or vector quantities: it is by a more complex mathematical object. This quantum state does not indicate or represent position or motion in any direct way: what it does in substance is to enable calculation of the probability of the particle in question being found to have a position or momentum if an appropriate measurement is made.
This chapter argues that the classical theory has conceptual difficulties that are resolved by quantum mechanics. Since the classical theory from a fundamental point of view is a special case of the quantum theory at large quantum numbers, it is very natural that there remains traces of the quantum treatment in the classical case. In classical mechanics, the Hamiltonian of a system is equal to the total energy, that is, the sum of the kinetic and potential energy of all particles in the system. Other thermodynamical quantities can also be expanded in a power series in density. The probability to observe a certain kinetic state of the system is completely independent of the interactions; it is the same for strongly interacting molecules in a liquid as it is for a thin gas of the same molecules at the same temperature.