Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0006063

Time operator for the quantum harmonic oscillator: resolution of an apparent paradox

Alex Granik, Harry R. Lewis

Published Jun 14, 2000• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An apparent paradox is resolved that concerns the existence of time operators which have been derived for the quantum harmonic oscillator. There is an apparent paradox because, although a time operator is canonically conjugate to the Hamiltonian, it has been asserted that no operator exists that is canonically conjugate to the Hamiltonian. In order to resolve the apparent paradox, we work in a representation where the phase operator is diagonal. The boundary condition on wave functions is such that they be periodic in the phase variable, which is related to the (continuous) eigenvalue of the time operator. Matrix elements of the commutator of the time operator with the Hamiltonian involve the phase variable itself in addition to periodic functions of the phase variable. The Hamiltonian is not hermitian when operating in space that includes the phase variable itself. The apparent paradox is resolved when this non-hermeticity is taken into account correctly in the evaluation of matrix elements of the commutation relation.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0006063

Related papers

Matrix representation of the time operator

Carl M. Bender, Mariagiovanna Gianfreda

In quantum mechanics the time operator Θ satisfies the commutation relation [Θ, H] = i, and thus it may be thought of as being formally canonically conjugate to the Hamiltonian H. The time operator associated with a given Hamiltonian H is not unique because one can replace Θ by Θ + Θhom, where Θhom satisfies the homogeneous condition [Θhom, H] = 0. To study this nonuniqueness the matrix elements of Θ for the harmonic-oscillator Hamiltonian are calculated in the eigenstate basis. This calculation requires the summation of divergent series, and the summation is accomplished by using zeta-summation techniques. It is shown that by including appropriate homogeneous contributions, the matrix elements of Θ simplify dramatically. However, it is still not clear whether there is an optimally simple representation of the time operator.

arXiv:1201.3838•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 2012•6 citations

Quantum Action-Angle Variables for the Harmonic Oscillator

Harry R. Lewis, W. E. Lawrence, Joseph David Harris

Operators conjugate to the Hamiltonian are constructed explicitly for the quantum harmonic oscillator by two approaches in the space spanned by the eigenstates of $q$ and the eigenstates of $p$. The operators are quantum analogs of a classical angle variable divided by the oscillator frequency. Matrix elements have been evaluated in the coherent state representation. Either conjugate operator can be used to construct an explicitly time-dependent operator invariant. It can be used as the starting point in a new perturbative procedure for constructing invariant operators for nonlinear, nonautonomous Hamiltonians.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 23, 1996•25 citations

Harmonic Oscillator

Ravinder Rupchand Puri

The physical quantum harmonic oscillator (h.o.) in one dimension is a linear combination of the operators and. Its properties are described by the wave function representing its state jxi in the position representation spanned by the eigenvectors. The energy eigenvalue problem of the h.o. in the position representation amounts to solving the second-order Schrödinger equation for x( x ). The solution of that equation has been derived in Section 11.2 as a special case of the general solution of exactly solvable potentials. Very often one encounters Hamiltonians which are linear combinations of operators and where and obey the same commutation relation as and but those operators do not act on fj x ig. We call them h.o. like Hamiltonians. In such cases, one cannot define ( x ) and consequently the eigenvalue problem of such Hamiltonians cannot be reduced to the one of solving Schrödinger's differential equation. The eigenvalue problem of h.o. like Hamiltonians therefore requires different approaches for its solution. This chapter discusses the method of solving that problem using only the commutation relation between, without reference to any representation. That approach proves useful even for the physical h.o. as it reduces its eigenvalue problem to the one of solving a simple first-order differential equation, a task arguably simpler than solving the second-order differential equation. The eigenvalue spectrum found by the two methods turns out to be the same. In general, the method of solving the eigenvalue problem by using only the commutation relations between the operators constituting the Hamiltonian is indispensable while dealing with Hamiltonians, such as the ones involving spin, which have no classical counterpart.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 17, 2017•0 citations

On the Canonical Transformation of Time-Dependent Harmonic Oscillator

Akpan N. Ikot, Louis E. Akpabio, Ita O. Akpan +3 more

We performed a two-variable canonical transformation on the time momentum operator, and without loss of generality we carried out a three-variable transformation on the coordinate and momentum space operators to trivialize the Hamiltonian operator of the system. Fortunately, this operation separates the time-coordinate and space coordinate naturally, and the wave function of the time-dependent Harmonic Oscillator is evaluated via the generator.

Physics Research International•Dec 2, 2009•2 citations

Factorizing the time evolution operator

P. C. García Quijas, L. M. Arévalo, Aguilar Centro +4 more

There is a widespread belief in the quantum physical community, and in textbooks used to teach Quantum Mechanics, that it is a difficult task to apply the time evolution operator on an initial wave function. That is to say, because the hamiltonian operator generally is the sum of two operators, then it is a difficult task to apply the time evolution operator on an initial wave function, because it implies to apply terms like (A+B)^n. A possible solution of this problem is to factorize the time evolution operator and then apply successively the individual exponential operator on the initial wave function. However, the exponential operator does not directly factorize. In this work we present useful ways to factorizing the time evolution operator when the argument of the exponential is a sum of two operators which obey specific commutation relations. Then, we apply the exponential operator as an evolution operator for the case of elementary unidimensional potentials, like the harmonic oscillator. Also, we argue about an apparent paradox concerning the time evolution operator and non-spreading wave packets addressed in previous papers published in this Journal. Finally, we discuss the possible insight that can be learned using this approach in teaching Quantum Mechanics.

•Mar 28, 2006•15 citations

Pauli's theorem and quantum canonical pairs: the consistency of a bounded, self–adjoint time operator canonically conjugate to a Hamiltonian with non–empty point spectrum

Eric Galapon

In single Hilbert space, Pauli's well–known theorem implies that the existence of a self–adjoint time operator canonically conjugate to a given Hamiltonian requires the Hamiltonian to possess completely continuous spectra spanning the entire real line. Thus the conclusion that there exists no self–adjoint time operator conjugate to a semibounded or discrete Hamiltonian despite some well–known illustrative, implicit counterexamples. In this paper we evaluate Pauli's theorem against the single Hilbert space formulation of quantum mechanics, and consequently show the consistency of assuming a bounded, self–adjoint time operator canonically conjugate to a Hamiltonian with an unbounded, or semibounded, or finite point spectrum. We point out Pauli's implicit assumptions and show that they are not consistent. We demonstrate our analysis by giving two explicit examples. Moreover, we clarify issues surrounding the different solutions to the canonical commutation relations, and, consequently, expand the class of acceptable canonical pairs beyond the solutions required by Pauli's theorem.

arXiv:quant-ph/9908033•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jan 8, 2002•152 citations
An apparent paradox is resolved that concerns the existence of time operators which have been derived for the quantum harmonic oscillator. There is an apparent paradox because, although a time operator is canonically conjugate to the Hamiltonian, it has been asserted that no operator exists that is canonically conjugate to the Hamiltonian. In order to resolve the apparent paradox, we work in a representation where the phase operator is diagonal. The boundary condition on wave functions is such that they be periodic in the phase variable, which is related to the (continuous) eigenvalue of the time operator. Matrix elements of the commutator of the time operator with the Hamiltonian involve the phase variable itself in addition to periodic functions of the phase variable. The Hamiltonian is not hermitian when operating in space that includes the phase variable itself. The apparent paradox is resolved when this non-hermeticity is taken into account correctly in the evaluation of matrix elements of the commutation relation.
In quantum mechanics the time operator Θ satisfies the commutation relation [Θ, H] = i, and thus it may be thought of as being formally canonically conjugate to the Hamiltonian H. The time operator associated with a given Hamiltonian H is not unique because one can replace Θ by Θ + Θhom, where Θhom satisfies the homogeneous condition [Θhom, H] = 0. To study this nonuniqueness the matrix elements of Θ for the harmonic-oscillator Hamiltonian are calculated in the eigenstate basis. This calculation requires the summation of divergent series, and the summation is accomplished by using zeta-summation techniques. It is shown that by including appropriate homogeneous contributions, the matrix elements of Θ simplify dramatically. However, it is still not clear whether there is an optimally simple representation of the time operator.
Operators conjugate to the Hamiltonian are constructed explicitly for the quantum harmonic oscillator by two approaches in the space spanned by the eigenstates of qqq and the eigenstates of ppp. The operators are quantum analogs of a classical angle variable divided by the oscillator frequency. Matrix elements have been evaluated in the coherent state representation. Either conjugate operator can be used to construct an explicitly time-dependent operator invariant. It can be used as the starting point in a new perturbative procedure for constructing invariant operators for nonlinear, nonautonomous Hamiltonians.
The physical quantum harmonic oscillator (h.o.) in one dimension is a linear combination of the operators and. Its properties are described by the wave function representing its state jxi in the position representation spanned by the eigenvectors. The energy eigenvalue problem of the h.o. in the position representation amounts to solving the second-order Schrödinger equation for x( x ). The solution of that equation has been derived in Section 11.2 as a special case of the general solution of exactly solvable potentials. Very often one encounters Hamiltonians which are linear combinations of operators and where and obey the same commutation relation as and but those operators do not act on fj x ig. We call them h.o. like Hamiltonians. In such cases, one cannot define ( x ) and consequently the eigenvalue problem of such Hamiltonians cannot be reduced to the one of solving Schrödinger's differential equation. The eigenvalue problem of h.o. like Hamiltonians therefore requires different approaches for its solution. This chapter discusses the method of solving that problem using only the commutation relation between, without reference to any representation. That approach proves useful even for the physical h.o. as it reduces its eigenvalue problem to the one of solving a simple first-order differential equation, a task arguably simpler than solving the second-order differential equation. The eigenvalue spectrum found by the two methods turns out to be the same. In general, the method of solving the eigenvalue problem by using only the commutation relations between the operators constituting the Hamiltonian is indispensable while dealing with Hamiltonians, such as the ones involving spin, which have no classical counterpart.
There is a widespread belief in the quantum physical community, and in textbooks used to teach Quantum Mechanics, that it is a difficult task to apply the time evolution operator on an initial wave function. That is to say, because the hamiltonian operator generally is the sum of two operators, then it is a difficult task to apply the time evolution operator on an initial wave function, because it implies to apply terms like (A+B)^n. A possible solution of this problem is to factorize the time evolution operator and then apply successively the individual exponential operator on the initial wave function. However, the exponential operator does not directly factorize. In this work we present useful ways to factorizing the time evolution operator when the argument of the exponential is a sum of two operators which obey specific commutation relations. Then, we apply the exponential operator as an evolution operator for the case of elementary unidimensional potentials, like the harmonic oscillator. Also, we argue about an apparent paradox concerning the time evolution operator and non-spreading wave packets addressed in previous papers published in this Journal. Finally, we discuss the possible insight that can be learned using this approach in teaching Quantum Mechanics.
In single Hilbert space, Pauli's well–known theorem implies that the existence of a self–adjoint time operator canonically conjugate to a given Hamiltonian requires the Hamiltonian to possess completely continuous spectra spanning the entire real line. Thus the conclusion that there exists no self–adjoint time operator conjugate to a semibounded or discrete Hamiltonian despite some well–known illustrative, implicit counterexamples. In this paper we evaluate Pauli's theorem against the single Hilbert space formulation of quantum mechanics, and consequently show the consistency of assuming a bounded, self–adjoint time operator canonically conjugate to a Hamiltonian with an unbounded, or semibounded, or finite point spectrum. We point out Pauli's implicit assumptions and show that they are not consistent. We demonstrate our analysis by giving two explicit examples. Moreover, we clarify issues surrounding the different solutions to the canonical commutation relations, and, consequently, expand the class of acceptable canonical pairs beyond the solutions required by Pauli's theorem.