Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0005127 · Physical Review A

Adiabatic elimination in compound quantum systems with feedback

Prahlad Warszawski, Howard M. Wiseman

Published Dec 5, 2000• 22 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Feedback in compound quantum systems is effected by using the output from one subsystem (``the system'') to control the evolution of a second subsystem (``the ancilla'') that is reversibly coupled to the system. In the limit where the ancilla responds to fluctuations on a much shorter time scale than does the system, we show that it can be adiabatically eliminated, yielding a master equation for the system alone. This is very significant as it decreases the necessary basis size for numerical simulation and allows the effect of the ancilla to be understood more easily. We consider two types of ancilla: a two-level ancilla (e.g., a two-level atom) and an infinite-level ancilla (e.g., an optical mode). For each, we consider two forms of feedback: coherent (for which a quantum-mechanical description of the feedback loop is required) and incoherent (for which a classical description is sufficient). We test the master equations we obtain using numerical simulation of the full dynamics of the compound system. For the system (a parametric oscillator) and feedback (intensity-dependent detuning) we choose, good agreement is found in the limit of heavy damping of the ancilla. We discuss the relation of our work to previous work on feedback in compound quantum systems, and also to previous work on adiabatic elimination in general.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.63.013803

Related papers

Deterministic Equations for Feedback Control of Open Quantum Systems

Alberto J. B. Rosal, Patrick P. Potts, Gabriel Teixeira Landi

Feedback control in open quantum dynamics is crucial for the advancement of various coherent platforms. However, currently only a handful of feedback master equations exist in the literature, which are restricted to specific types of feedback. In this letter we first introduce a unifying framework, based on a single general equation, that describes all possible feedback schemes in sequentially (and continuously) measured systems, and from which all previous results follow. Next, we specialize it to the case of quantum jumps and introduce a new type of feedback based on the channel of the last detected jump, as well as the time elapsed since it occurred. Our description is experimentally grounded, and naturally allows for the introduction of realistic effects, such as time-delays in the feedback loop. We illustrate our results with two time-dependent feedback protocols conditioned on quantum-jump detections: one achieving population inversion of a two-level system against a thermal bath, and another enabling real-time reversal of quantum transitions, both admitting steady-state solutions.

arXiv:2507.01934•Physical Review Letters•Jun 25, 2026•10 citations

Squeezing Enhancement and Adiabatic Elimination in Quantum Feedback Networks

Sebastian

Classical feedback control and system theory are playing an important role in modelling, controlling and analysing complex devices in many branches of engineering. Recent developments like quantum computers and miniaturisation of existing applications and devices are increasing the importance of the ability to control systems with quantum effects. Efforts have been made recently to extent the simplicity and power of the language of classical control theory to quantum mechanical systems. Within this framework of “Quantum Feedback Networks” we are investigating two problems. The first problem concerns the enhancement of squeezed states. It has been observed that the squeezing effect of squeezing devices can be enhancement by measurement based feedback techniques or use of optical cavities. We are investigating the possibility of feedback enhanced squeezing using coherent feedback control. Considered is a static ideal squeezing devices interacting with a single mode cavity undergoing coherent feedback using a beam splitter. We show that the overall squeezing of the output depends on the beam-splitter’s reflectivity and that we are thus able to enhance the squeezing by choosing an appropriate configuration of the beam-splitter. In the second part we investigate the question of compatibility of a rigorous approach to the adiabatic elimination of some degrees of freedom of a quantum mechanical systems and instantaneous feed-forward and feedback limits for quantum mechanical networks. The commutativity of both limits is not obvious but frequently assumed in quantum optics. We show that both limit procedures are instances of Schur complements and prove the commutativity of both limits by generalising a statement about successive Schur complements.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Adiabatic elimination for composite open quantum systems: Reduced-model formulation and numerical simulations

François-Marie Le Régent, Pierre Rouchon

A numerical method is proposed for simulation of composite open quantum systems. It is based on Lindblad master equations and adiabatic elimination. Each subsystem is assumed to converge exponentially towards a stationary subspace, slightly impacted by some decoherence channels and weakly coupled to the other subsystems. This numerical method is based on a perturbation analysis with an asymptotic expansion. It exploits the formulation of the slow dynamics with reduced dimension. It relies on the invariant operators of the local and nominal dissipative dynamics attached to each subsystem. Second-order expansion can be computed only with local numerical calculations. It avoids computations on the tensor-product Hilbert space attached to the full system. This numerical method is particularly well suited for autonomous quantum error correction schemes. Simulations of such reduced models agree with complete full model simulations for typical gates acting on one and two cat qubits (z, zz, and cnot) when the mean photon number of each cat qubit is less than eight. For larger mean photon numbers and gates with three cat qubits (zzz and ccnot), full model simulations are almost impossible whereas reduced model simulations remain accessible. In particular, one observes numerically the simultaneous capture of the dominant phase-flip error rate and of the very small bit-flip error rate with its exponential suppression versus the mean photon number.

arXiv:2303.05089•Physical Review A•Mar 6, 2024•24 citations

Adiabatic elimination for open quantum systems with effective Lindblad master equations

Rémi Azouit, Alain Sarlette, Pierre Rouchon

We consider an open quantum system described by a Lindblad-type master equation with two time scales. The fast time scale is strongly dissipative and drives the system towards a low-dimensional decoherence-free space. To perform the adiabatic elimination of this fast relaxation, we propose a geometric asymptotic expansion based on the small positive parameter describing the time scale separation. This expansion exploits geometric singular perturbation theory and center-manifold techniques. We conjecture that, at any order, it provides an effective slow Lindblad master equation and a completely positive parameterization of the slow invariant sub-manifold associated to the low-dimensional decoherence-free space. By preserving complete positivity and trace, two important structural properties attached to open quantum dynamics, we obtain a reduced-order model that directly conveys a physical interpretation since it relies on effective Lindbladian descriptions of the slow evolution. At the first order, we derive simple formulae for the effective Lindblad master equation. For a specific type of fast dissipation, we show how any Hamiltonian perturbation yields Lindbladian second-order corrections to the first-order slow evolution governed by the Zeno-Hamiltonian. These results are illustrated on a composite system made of a strongly dissipative harmonic oscillator, the ancilla, weakly coupled to another quantum system.

arXiv:1603.04630•IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)•Dec 1, 2016•38 citations

Quantum theory of optical bistability without adiabatic elimination

M. D. Reid

A quantum theory describing N two-level atoms in a coherently driven single-mode optical ring cavity is presented. The usual approximation that one may adiabatically eliminate either the cavity or atomic variables is not made. Hence the results are valid for a range of relative cavity and atomic relaxation rates. The theory is based on the linearized equations derived in the positive P representation. A simple analytical solution is presented, including the effect of detunings, for the steady-state transmitted spectrum. The transmitted intensity and squeezing spectra are discussed.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1988•70 citations

Approximate master equations for atom optics

D. J. Atkins, Howard M. Wiseman, Prahlad Warszawski

In the field of atom optics, the basis of many experiments is a two-level atom coupled to a light field. The evolution of this system is governed by a master equation. The irreversible components of this master equation describe the spontaneous emission of photons from the atom. For many applications, it is necessary to minimize the effect of this irreversible evolution. This can be achieved by having a far detuned light field. The drawback of this regime is that making the detuning very large makes the time step required to solve the master equation very small, much smaller than the time scale of any significant evolution. This makes the problem very numerically intensive. For this reason, approximations are used to simulate the master equation, which are more numerically tractable to solve. This paper analyzes four approximations: The standard adiabatic approximation, a more sophisticated adiabatic approximation (not used before), a secular approximation, and a fully quantum dressed-state approximation. The advantages and disadvantages of each are investigated with respect to accuracy, complexity, and the resources required to simulate. In a parameter regime of particular experimental interest, only the sophisticated adiabatic and dressed-state approximations agree well with the exact evolution.

arXiv:quant-ph/0204074•Physical Review A•Feb 6, 2003•15 citations
Feedback in compound quantum systems is effected by using the output from one subsystem (the system'') to control the evolution of a second subsystem (the ancilla'') that is reversibly coupled to the system. In the limit where the ancilla responds to fluctuations on a much shorter time scale than does the system, we show that it can be adiabatically eliminated, yielding a master equation for the system alone. This is very significant as it decreases the necessary basis size for numerical simulation and allows the effect of the ancilla to be understood more easily. We consider two types of ancilla: a two-level ancilla (e.g., a two-level atom) and an infinite-level ancilla (e.g., an optical mode). For each, we consider two forms of feedback: coherent (for which a quantum-mechanical description of the feedback loop is required) and incoherent (for which a classical description is sufficient). We test the master equations we obtain using numerical simulation of the full dynamics of the compound system. For the system (a parametric oscillator) and feedback (intensity-dependent detuning) we choose, good agreement is found in the limit of heavy damping of the ancilla. We discuss the relation of our work to previous work on feedback in compound quantum systems, and also to previous work on adiabatic elimination in general.
Feedback control in open quantum dynamics is crucial for the advancement of various coherent platforms. However, currently only a handful of feedback master equations exist in the literature, which are restricted to specific types of feedback. In this letter we first introduce a unifying framework, based on a single general equation, that describes all possible feedback schemes in sequentially (and continuously) measured systems, and from which all previous results follow. Next, we specialize it to the case of quantum jumps and introduce a new type of feedback based on the channel of the last detected jump, as well as the time elapsed since it occurred. Our description is experimentally grounded, and naturally allows for the introduction of realistic effects, such as time-delays in the feedback loop. We illustrate our results with two time-dependent feedback protocols conditioned on quantum-jump detections: one achieving population inversion of a two-level system against a thermal bath, and another enabling real-time reversal of quantum transitions, both admitting steady-state solutions.
Classical feedback control and system theory are playing an important role in modelling, controlling and analysing complex devices in many branches of engineering. Recent developments like quantum computers and miniaturisation of existing applications and devices are increasing the importance of the ability to control systems with quantum effects. Efforts have been made recently to extent the simplicity and power of the language of classical control theory to quantum mechanical systems. Within this framework of “Quantum Feedback Networks” we are investigating two problems. The first problem concerns the enhancement of squeezed states. It has been observed that the squeezing effect of squeezing devices can be enhancement by measurement based feedback techniques or use of optical cavities. We are investigating the possibility of feedback enhanced squeezing using coherent feedback control. Considered is a static ideal squeezing devices interacting with a single mode cavity undergoing coherent feedback using a beam splitter. We show that the overall squeezing of the output depends on the beam-splitter’s reflectivity and that we are thus able to enhance the squeezing by choosing an appropriate configuration of the beam-splitter. In the second part we investigate the question of compatibility of a rigorous approach to the adiabatic elimination of some degrees of freedom of a quantum mechanical systems and instantaneous feed-forward and feedback limits for quantum mechanical networks. The commutativity of both limits is not obvious but frequently assumed in quantum optics. We show that both limit procedures are instances of Schur complements and prove the commutativity of both limits by generalising a statement about successive Schur complements.
A numerical method is proposed for simulation of composite open quantum systems. It is based on Lindblad master equations and adiabatic elimination. Each subsystem is assumed to converge exponentially towards a stationary subspace, slightly impacted by some decoherence channels and weakly coupled to the other subsystems. This numerical method is based on a perturbation analysis with an asymptotic expansion. It exploits the formulation of the slow dynamics with reduced dimension. It relies on the invariant operators of the local and nominal dissipative dynamics attached to each subsystem. Second-order expansion can be computed only with local numerical calculations. It avoids computations on the tensor-product Hilbert space attached to the full system. This numerical method is particularly well suited for autonomous quantum error correction schemes. Simulations of such reduced models agree with complete full model simulations for typical gates acting on one and two cat qubits (z, zz, and cnot) when the mean photon number of each cat qubit is less than eight. For larger mean photon numbers and gates with three cat qubits (zzz and ccnot), full model simulations are almost impossible whereas reduced model simulations remain accessible. In particular, one observes numerically the simultaneous capture of the dominant phase-flip error rate and of the very small bit-flip error rate with its exponential suppression versus the mean photon number.
We consider an open quantum system described by a Lindblad-type master equation with two time scales. The fast time scale is strongly dissipative and drives the system towards a low-dimensional decoherence-free space. To perform the adiabatic elimination of this fast relaxation, we propose a geometric asymptotic expansion based on the small positive parameter describing the time scale separation. This expansion exploits geometric singular perturbation theory and center-manifold techniques. We conjecture that, at any order, it provides an effective slow Lindblad master equation and a completely positive parameterization of the slow invariant sub-manifold associated to the low-dimensional decoherence-free space. By preserving complete positivity and trace, two important structural properties attached to open quantum dynamics, we obtain a reduced-order model that directly conveys a physical interpretation since it relies on effective Lindbladian descriptions of the slow evolution. At the first order, we derive simple formulae for the effective Lindblad master equation. For a specific type of fast dissipation, we show how any Hamiltonian perturbation yields Lindbladian second-order corrections to the first-order slow evolution governed by the Zeno-Hamiltonian. These results are illustrated on a composite system made of a strongly dissipative harmonic oscillator, the ancilla, weakly coupled to another quantum system.
A quantum theory describing N two-level atoms in a coherently driven single-mode optical ring cavity is presented. The usual approximation that one may adiabatically eliminate either the cavity or atomic variables is not made. Hence the results are valid for a range of relative cavity and atomic relaxation rates. The theory is based on the linearized equations derived in the positive P representation. A simple analytical solution is presented, including the effect of detunings, for the steady-state transmitted spectrum. The transmitted intensity and squeezing spectra are discussed.
In the field of atom optics, the basis of many experiments is a two-level atom coupled to a light field. The evolution of this system is governed by a master equation. The irreversible components of this master equation describe the spontaneous emission of photons from the atom. For many applications, it is necessary to minimize the effect of this irreversible evolution. This can be achieved by having a far detuned light field. The drawback of this regime is that making the detuning very large makes the time step required to solve the master equation very small, much smaller than the time scale of any significant evolution. This makes the problem very numerically intensive. For this reason, approximations are used to simulate the master equation, which are more numerically tractable to solve. This paper analyzes four approximations: The standard adiabatic approximation, a more sophisticated adiabatic approximation (not used before), a secular approximation, and a fully quantum dressed-state approximation. The advantages and disadvantages of each are investigated with respect to accuracy, complexity, and the resources required to simulate. In a parameter regime of particular experimental interest, only the sophisticated adiabatic and dressed-state approximations agree well with the exact evolution.