Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:physics/9704028

The third way to quantum mechanics is the forgotten first

S. Antoci, Dierck Ekkehard Liebscher

Published Apr 28, 1997• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum mechanics can be formulated in three ways, as Heisenberg, Schrödinger and Feynman did respectively. For the last way, an unknown (i.e. forgotten) forerunner exists, that we have found in a paper by Gregor Wentzel, published before the famous works by Heisenberg and Schrödinger, and contemporary with the fundamental works of L. de Broglie. In that paper, one can find the basic formulae and their interpretation as they were adopted by Feynman twenty years later. We believe that Wentzel's work was forgotten for several reasons: (I) Schrödinger's equation was much simpler to deal with (Wentzel himself contributed to its development in the same way as L.Brillouin and H.Kramers did). (II) The first application was rejected by Heisenberg and Kramers. (III) The approximation used by Wentzel was too na\"ıve and failed. Nevertheless, the foundation laid by Wentzel was sound, as it has been shown by Feynman's work. Therefore, Wentzel has to be considered as one of the founders of quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.physics/9704028

Related papers

Heisenberg and the early days of quantum mechanics

Felix Bloch

It is appropriate in this year, when we celebrate the 50th anniversary of quantum mechanics, and during which we have been saddened by the death of one of its leading founders, Werner Heisenberg, to reminisce about the formative years of the new mechanics. At the time when the foundations of physics were being replaced with totally new concepts I was a student of physics. I sat in the colloquium audience when Peter Debye made the suggestions to Erwin Schrödinger that started him on the study of de Broglie waves and the search for their wave equation. It was from Heisenberg, as his first doctorate student, that I caught the spirit of research, and that I received the encouragement to make my own contributions.

Physics Today•Dec 1, 1976•59 citations

Introduction

Richard A. Healey

In this monograph I present the basic structure of an interpretation of quantum mechanics. Chapter 1 outlines the central ideas behind the interpretation and illustrates them by means of examples: Subsequent chapters fill in the details of the interpretation. But it is important to begin by explaining what I take an interpretation of quantum mechanics to be, and why any further interpretation needs to be offered. After all, quantum mechanics (in some form) is by now both a foundation for much of contemporary physics and a veteran of more than sixty years of intermittent but sometimes intense reflection on its content and meaning. What more can be, or should be, said about the interpretation of this theory? Many physicists believe that no more needs to be said: that there is basically only one way of understanding quantum mechanics, due to Bohr, Heisenberg, Pauli, and others, and that the only remaining interpretative task is that of the physics teacher, who seeks to perfect ways of conveying this understanding to new generations of students. Sir Rudolf Peierls, one of the more lucid and distinguished of these physicists, even objects to the use of the familiar term ‘Copenhagen interpretation’ to refer to the way of understanding quantum mechanics due to Bohr, Heisenberg, Pauli, and others. Because this sounds as if there were several interpretations of quantum mechanics. There is only one. There is only one way in which you can understand quantum mechanics.[…]

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 24, 1989•0 citations

Quantum mechanics

Yutaka Toyozawa

Quantum mechanics was discovered in 1925 through groping efforts to compromise two apparently contradictory pictures on the fundamental entities in nature. One was the wave picture for light which was later extended to matter by de Broglie, another was the corpuscular picture of matter which was later extended to light by Einstein. Schrödinger's wave equation came as a natural development of the first stream, while Heisenberg's matrix mechanics was presented as a unique proposal from the second stream. In spite of completely different appearances, the two theories proved, within a couple of years after their discoveries, to be equivalent. This is a most beautiful example that the physical reality exists independent of the mathematical framework formulated for its description.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 9, 2003•0 citations

Chapter Seven

L I Ponomarev

Janos Bolyai (1802-1860), a Hungarian officer, developed non-Euclidian geometry at the age of twenty-three. He was quite pleased with his discovery until he found out that somewhere on the border between Europe and Asia one Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky (1793-1856) had published the same ideas several years earlier. Heisenberg was born in the year in which Planck published his celebrated work. De Broglie sincerely believed in the unity of nature, as all great scientists had believed before him. It is well known that when people strike a taut string, the sound it produces will depend on the tension and length of the string. The mechanism behind this is also well known: the vibration of the string is transmitted to the air, and people do not perceive the vibration of the string itself, but of the molecules of air. De Broglie wrote down his formulas in 1923, two years before the works of Heisenberg and Schrödinger.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 11, 2021•0 citations

Formulations of Quantum Mechanics

There have been two different approaches to quantum mechanics. The first follows its historical emergence and begins with the failure of classical mechanics in giving correct explanation to atomic and molecular phenomena such as atomic spectra, black-body radiation and photoelectric effect. In this way one appreciates the necessity of replacing the fundamental classical mechanical equations by the Schroedinger equation in wave mechanics leading to quantization of energy. In the second approach quantum mechanics is treated as a new subject with its own set of experimentally justifiable postulates. We follow this second approach.

World Scientific series in contemporary chemical physics•Jul 1, 1996•0 citations

The mathematical structure of quantum theory

Keith Hannabuss

Abstract We have already mentioned that Schriöidinger’s formulation of quantum mechanics was slightly preceded by a totally different algebraic formulation proposed by Heisenberg. Although Schriöidinger’s methods were so much simpler that they were generally preferred, both approaches seemed to give the same answers, so it was natural to ask how they were related. This was particularly important because some features of quantum theory were easier to understand in Heisenberg’s formalism. In fact, as we have already noted, Schriöidinger was able to show that the two methods were essentially equivalent. Soon mathematicians like Hermann Weyland John von Neumann were able to find a general mathematical scheme that encompassed both approaches, and it is this that we shall now describe.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 20, 1997•0 citations
Quantum mechanics can be formulated in three ways, as Heisenberg, Schrödinger and Feynman did respectively. For the last way, an unknown (i.e. forgotten) forerunner exists, that we have found in a paper by Gregor Wentzel, published before the famous works by Heisenberg and Schrödinger, and contemporary with the fundamental works of L. de Broglie. In that paper, one can find the basic formulae and their interpretation as they were adopted by Feynman twenty years later. We believe that Wentzel's work was forgotten for several reasons: (I) Schrödinger's equation was much simpler to deal with (Wentzel himself contributed to its development in the same way as L.Brillouin and H.Kramers did). (II) The first application was rejected by Heisenberg and Kramers. (III) The approximation used by Wentzel was too na"ıve and failed. Nevertheless, the foundation laid by Wentzel was sound, as it has been shown by Feynman's work. Therefore, Wentzel has to be considered as one of the founders of quantum mechanics.
It is appropriate in this year, when we celebrate the 50th anniversary of quantum mechanics, and during which we have been saddened by the death of one of its leading founders, Werner Heisenberg, to reminisce about the formative years of the new mechanics. At the time when the foundations of physics were being replaced with totally new concepts I was a student of physics. I sat in the colloquium audience when Peter Debye made the suggestions to Erwin Schrödinger that started him on the study of de Broglie waves and the search for their wave equation. It was from Heisenberg, as his first doctorate student, that I caught the spirit of research, and that I received the encouragement to make my own contributions.
In this monograph I present the basic structure of an interpretation of quantum mechanics. Chapter 1 outlines the central ideas behind the interpretation and illustrates them by means of examples: Subsequent chapters fill in the details of the interpretation. But it is important to begin by explaining what I take an interpretation of quantum mechanics to be, and why any further interpretation needs to be offered. After all, quantum mechanics (in some form) is by now both a foundation for much of contemporary physics and a veteran of more than sixty years of intermittent but sometimes intense reflection on its content and meaning. What more can be, or should be, said about the interpretation of this theory? Many physicists believe that no more needs to be said: that there is basically only one way of understanding quantum mechanics, due to Bohr, Heisenberg, Pauli, and others, and that the only remaining interpretative task is that of the physics teacher, who seeks to perfect ways of conveying this understanding to new generations of students. Sir Rudolf Peierls, one of the more lucid and distinguished of these physicists, even objects to the use of the familiar term ‘Copenhagen interpretation’ to refer to the way of understanding quantum mechanics due to Bohr, Heisenberg, Pauli, and others. Because this sounds as if there were several interpretations of quantum mechanics. There is only one. There is only one way in which you can understand quantum mechanics.[…]
Quantum mechanics was discovered in 1925 through groping efforts to compromise two apparently contradictory pictures on the fundamental entities in nature. One was the wave picture for light which was later extended to matter by de Broglie, another was the corpuscular picture of matter which was later extended to light by Einstein. Schrödinger's wave equation came as a natural development of the first stream, while Heisenberg's matrix mechanics was presented as a unique proposal from the second stream. In spite of completely different appearances, the two theories proved, within a couple of years after their discoveries, to be equivalent. This is a most beautiful example that the physical reality exists independent of the mathematical framework formulated for its description.
Janos Bolyai (1802-1860), a Hungarian officer, developed non-Euclidian geometry at the age of twenty-three. He was quite pleased with his discovery until he found out that somewhere on the border between Europe and Asia one Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky (1793-1856) had published the same ideas several years earlier. Heisenberg was born in the year in which Planck published his celebrated work. De Broglie sincerely believed in the unity of nature, as all great scientists had believed before him. It is well known that when people strike a taut string, the sound it produces will depend on the tension and length of the string. The mechanism behind this is also well known: the vibration of the string is transmitted to the air, and people do not perceive the vibration of the string itself, but of the molecules of air. De Broglie wrote down his formulas in 1923, two years before the works of Heisenberg and Schrödinger.
There have been two different approaches to quantum mechanics. The first follows its historical emergence and begins with the failure of classical mechanics in giving correct explanation to atomic and molecular phenomena such as atomic spectra, black-body radiation and photoelectric effect. In this way one appreciates the necessity of replacing the fundamental classical mechanical equations by the Schroedinger equation in wave mechanics leading to quantization of energy. In the second approach quantum mechanics is treated as a new subject with its own set of experimentally justifiable postulates. We follow this second approach.
Abstract We have already mentioned that Schriöidinger’s formulation of quantum mechanics was slightly preceded by a totally different algebraic formulation proposed by Heisenberg. Although Schriöidinger’s methods were so much simpler that they were generally preferred, both approaches seemed to give the same answers, so it was natural to ask how they were related. This was particularly important because some features of quantum theory were easier to understand in Heisenberg’s formalism. In fact, as we have already noted, Schriöidinger was able to show that the two methods were essentially equivalent. Soon mathematicians like Hermann Weyland John von Neumann were able to find a general mathematical scheme that encompassed both approaches, and it is this that we shall now describe.