Louis de Broglie's celebrated hypothesis transfers a problem of representation of optics to the quantum theories. Let us suppose that the fact that originated the problem in optics is the following, "The images obtained by optical instruments are limited by diffraction. Is the diffraction phenomenon exclusively restricting of the information contained in the image or does it have some physical meaning by itself?" This considered as a problem of measurement of the radiative field does not pose the question of tracing well-defined processes in the sense of the light quantum concept. Despite this the application thereto of quantum formalism makes the essentially inferring statistical nature of measurement forecasting most important. We suggest avoiding the probabilistic conception of measurement by replacing the wave-corpuscle dualistic principle with the duality one. The latter is a basic feature of projective geometry. Referring to it we shall try to include the diffraction in a geometrical model of optics and interpret in that coherent schema the point -plane "wave" dual solution. We show what experimental substantiation the proposed duality has. Lastly, we again discuss the experimental basis of wave-corpuscle dualism.
Louis de Broglie's celebrated hypothesis transfers a problem of representation of optics to the quantum theories. Let us suppose that the fact that originated the problem in optics is the following, "The images obtained by optical instruments are limited by diffraction. Is the diffraction phenomenon exclusively restricting of the information contained in the image or does it have some physical meaning by itself?" This considered as a problem of measurement of the radiative field does not pose the question of tracing well-defined processes in the sense of the light quantum concept. Despite this the application thereto of quantum formalism makes the essentially inferring statistical nature of measurement forecasting most important. We suggest avoiding the probabilistic conception of measurement by replacing the wave-corpuscle dualistic principle with the duality one. The latter is a basic feature of projective geometry. Referring to it we shall try to include the diffraction in a geometrical model of optics and interpret in that coherent schema the point -plane "wave" dual solution. We show what experimental substantiation the proposed duality has. Lastly, we again discuss the experimental basis of wave-corpuscle dualism.
Arguments about particles or waves gave way to a recognized need for both particles and waves in the description of radiation. The confusion over particle versus wave properties was resolved by Louis de Broglie. He postulated that since light has a dual wave–particle nature, matter also has this nature. The idea was to perform a diffraction experiment with electrons. An interference pattern was demonstrated not only with electrons, but also with many kinds of material particles like protons and neutrons. However, any attempt to observe an interference pattern with neutral atoms was found difficult by the fact that atoms carried no charge as electrons do and could not penetrate through condensate matter like neutrons. The de Broglie wavelength of an electron in the smallest orbit turns out to be exactly equal to the circumference of the orbit predicted by Bohr. The interpretation of the interference phenomenon becomes more subtle when the light beams are replaced by individual photons or particles.
Here, the concept of a wave-particle duality is questioned. First, the experimental proofs existing, respectively, for particles and waves are examined. In the case of particles, no experimental evidence can be found which establishes them; it seems that particles have always been taken for granted. In the case of waves, considerable evidence has accumulated with results on diffraction, interference, and self-interference of larger and larger objects. Then an important remark is made concerning the fact that unlike particles, waves are not observation-dependent: waves existed before observation otherwise the patterns of diffraction or interference would not have been appearing; the wave nature does not depend on the making of a measurement, there is no measurement problem for waves. Consequently, since waves are not observation-dependent, if the objects are demonstrated to be waves, they are only waves. This fact, along with some other evidence, disagrees with the current interpretation of the Wheeler-type delayed-choice experiments, where the absence of interference is interpreted as a particle behavior. Finally, recent works regarding the de Broglie‐Bohm theory are presented, which lead to suggest a new wave-only version of this theory. It is concluded that a wave-only view might be worth considering instead of the wave-particle duality view which has prevailed so far.
Louis de Broglie has the essential result of interpreting the physical optics based on diffraction phenomena without making any reference to the idea of harmonic oscillator and its classical dynamics in order to calculate the intensity of light. This chapter presents an equation, which shows that the density of the light particles classically conceived as material points or localized quanta, is proportional with the intensity of the classical theory of light. The effectively inadequate point of the de Broglie’s argument is in fact only the mathematical expression of his way to conclusions. de Broglie added an important attribute to the very classical notion of a light ray. However, his theory means in fact much more, far and beyond the physical theory of light. The de Broglie’s physical ray allows us to construct an interpretation based on the idea of adiabaticity.
Louis de Broglie explains that the photon is in fact both a particle and a wave, and that either aspect can be considered according to the practicality of the experiment or the calculation in question. By creating this wave-particle duality, which escapes the restriction of the preceding descriptions (in particular, their pseudo-incompatibility), Louis de Broglie demonstrated that all particles behave in this manner, even if the importance of their wave effect is often restricted and even forgotten or ignored. Living things always appear to us as being complex and mysterious, even almost more so than the quantum world in its probabilistic interpretation. The stability of the global living entity could be understood as a consequence of the phenomenon that is global quantification. This is what explains the appearance of the “individual”.
This chapter describes the dual nature of electron/de Broglie waves. de Broglie suggested that like light, an electron also behaves as both a particle and a wave. Based on this hypothesis, a relationship between wavelength of electrons (a particle) and momentum was developed. It opines that ‘wavelength of the particle is inversely proportional to momentum’. This is called the de Broglie relation. On the basis of the above facts, we have developed a relationship between wavelength and voltage applied and this relation may be stated as ‘the wavelength of a particle is inversely proportional to the square root of the voltage applied to the system’. This chapter also uses the Davisson and Germer experiment to show the wave nature of the particle, i.e., diffraction of electrons by crystal lattice. The experimental results were the same as found in the case of the diffraction of X-ray by crystals. This chapter also provides an idea on quantisation of angular momentum. It also discusses Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, phase velocity, group velocity, and uncertainty relation between energy and time. The chapter comprises the experimental evidence of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, such as by diffraction of electrons through a slit and gamma ray microscope thought experiment, which is shows the physical significance of the uncertainty principle. Sufficient references, solved problems, and questions on concepts have been provided at the end of chapter.
We have touched many times upon the problem of WP-Dualism. Now we shall analyse the problem, by starting with what is chronologically the first discussion about it. An organic answer to the problem came from de Broglie, but, for many reasons yet to be analysed in greater depth, it was not accepted by the majority of physicists. This theory was later included in the theoretical program of the Hidden-Variable theory by David Bohm, so that one normally speaks of the ‘de Broglie-Bohm Pilot wave’. However, de Broglie's proposal was directed more toward the problem of WP-Dualism as such, while Bohm's proposal was directed more toward the construction of a deterministic theory by contesting the completeness of QM — and here the point of departure is more Einstein's Ignorance interpretation [see proposition 6.3: p. 106] and the historical article of Einstein/Podolsky/Rosen [EINSTEIN et al . 1935]. As a consequence of the Hidden Variable theory the problem of non-locality was posed. The problem of the WP-Dualism and that of Hidden Variable theories (and non-locality) are theoretically different and hence they require different examinations. Therefore we divide all matter into three different parts: in this part we shall discuss de Broglie's theory and the problem of WP-Dualism; in part VIII, the problem of completeness and determinism (Bohm's Hidden Variable theory); in part IX the problem of separability and non locality. While part VIII, and especially chapter 33, is devoted to an interpretation of QM particles, we discuss in particular here what quantum waves are; if they are classical entities, if and how they can be ontologically interpreted, and what a quantum state is. We shall confirm our main distinction between states and observables. • We begin [in chapter 28 ] with the classical discussion stimulated by de Broglie with his proposal of the double solution theory — a proposal following which both particles and waves always exist together. Then more recent proposals concerning the nature of quantum waves and of quantum states are discussed (non-analytical solutions, empty waves, ontological interpretation of waves based on protective measurements). • Three-valued logic [ chapter 29 ] represents to a certain extent the opposite point of view relative to de Broglie's: the microentities are not determined in themselves (neither corpuscular nor wave-like), and, only under very specific circumstances (measurements), can the truth or falsehood of propositions about the values of observables be decided. Even if three-valued logic is chronological precedent to the matter of the precedent chapter, for systematical reasons it seemed better to discuss it after the latter. • Then in chapter 30 the relationship between which-path information and superposition is discussed, and very recent (proposed and performed) experiments are reported; finally we begin to discuss an ontological interpretation.