Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:physics/0211102

On the concept of "efficiency loophole" and rejection of local realism

Mahdavi, M. R.

Published Nov 25, 2002• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper I shall demonstrate that an analysis of the concept of "efficiency loophole" leads to the conclusion that any type of charge carried by and elementary particle must be distributed on the surface of a non-spherical object. As a result I shall show that; for example, the eletrostatic field of an electron as seen by an observer, must be in the form of quantized superluminal pulses. Therefore, "efficiency loophole" cannot be used in support of local realistic models. In view of the available experimental results we conclude that a local realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics has now been empirically refuted. However, it can be shown that the inferred superluminal signals do not necessarily contradict the facts of Lorentz transormations and only introduce a weak non-locality into the laws of nature. For this reason we make a preliminary investigation about a possible connection between quantum mechanics and non-spherical charge distributions. We conclude that this idea deserves to be further investigated and its validity or otherwise can be verified experimentally.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.physics/0211102

Related papers

On the problem of detection efficiency in Bell-Type experiments

Mahdavi, M. R.

In this note we wish to demonstrate that the concept of efficiency loophole, as far as a local realistic model is concerned, is a self-defeating one since it implies that the static fields (for example, electric or gravitational) of and elementary particle must be in the form of quantized superluminal pulses. The Idea, however, may still be advocated by the proponents of non-local realistic models since it is shown that such superluminal pulses do not contradict the facts of Lorentz transformations. As an alternative to Bell-type experiments we propose an experiment by means of which one can directly verify the validity of otherwise of the concept of efficiency.

arXiv:physics/0109001•Sep 1, 2001•0 citations

Violation of Local Realism for Ququats

P. Traina

Conclusive experimental tests of local realism deserve a minimum quantum efficiency in order to close detection loophole. This efficiency depends on the considered observables, on the specific Bell inequality chosen and on the dimension of the quantum objects observed. In this paper, we numerically analyse some quantum mechanics predictions on local realism for qubits, qutrits and ququats and we suggest a system to produce ququats maximally violating Bell-CGLMP inequality.

Open Systems & Information Dynamics•May 31, 2007•2 citations

Information Field and Superluminal Communication

Valentine P. Oleinik

The field of scalar and vector potentials in electrodynamics is shown to represent an informational field capable of superluminally transmitting a signal (information) with no energy and momentum transfer. This conclusion strictly follows from Maxwell's equations for electromagnetic field interacting with electric charges and currents in vacuum, without resort to any additional hypotheses. That superluminal communication is possible is seen from the fact that the own field, generated by particles and inseparable from them, transforms the environment into a special physical medium which is capable to instantaneously transfer a signal (information) about any changes, happening to a particle in the region of its basic localization, to arbitrarily large distances. The phenomenon of superluminal communication is caused by the non-local connection of scalar and vector potentials with the electric and magnetic field strengths. The basis for the mechanism of superluminal communication considered in this work is the Aharonov-Bohm effect indicative of the field of electromagnetic potentials as a real physical field, which directly influences the behaviour of electron waves. The conclusion is made that in quantum systems superluminal signals occur constantly, in any quantum processes. The occurrence of superluminal signals is due to the space-time symmetry breaking of a special kind, consisting in that the equations for potentials do not possess relativistic invariance though Maxwell's equations for the field strengths are Lorentz-invariant. The results presented do not contradict the physical principles underlying special relativity and confirm the fundamental conclusion, made for the first time by de Broglie, that gauge invariance is not an absolute law in physics

arXiv:physics/0306073•Jun 9, 2003•6 citations

Realistic Aspects in the Standard Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Claudio Garola, Sandro Sozzo, Claudio Calosi

The belief that quantum mechanics (QM) does not admit a realistic interpretation is widespread. According to some scholars concerned with the foundations of QM all existing interpretations of this theory (except for the statistical interpretation) presuppose instead a form of realism which consists in assuming that QM deals with individual objects and their properties. We uphold in the present paper that the arguments supporting the contextuality and the nonlocality of QM are a significant clue to the implicit adoption of stronger forms of realism (realism of theoretical entities and realism of theories). If these kinds of realism are substituted by a simpler and more intuitive semantic realism one can contrive a noncontextual and local interpretation of the formalism of QM (SR interpretation). Moreover one can provide a model for such an interpretation (ESR model) in which local realism and QM do not conflict and some fundamental problems of the standard interpretation of QM are avoided.

Humana.mente•Jan 1, 2010•8 citations

THE CONJECTURE THAT LOCAL REALISM IS POSSIBLE

Emilio Santos

It is argued that local realism is a fundamental principle, which might be rejected only if experiments clearly show that it is untenable. Forty years after Bell's work no experiment has provided a valid, loophole-free, violation of local realism which, in my opinion, is thus reinforced. I study a simple, but wide, family of local realistic models and derive new inequalities almost insensitive to the detection loophole. I argue that quantum mechanics, with some change in the theory of measurement, might be compatible with local realism.

Beyond the Quantum•Sep 1, 2007•0 citations

The "Chaotic Ball" model: local realism and the Bell test "detection loophole"

Caroline H. Thompson, H. Holstein

It has long been known that the "detection loophole", present when detector efficiencies are below a critical figure, could open the way for alternative "local realist" explanations for the violation of Bell tests. It has in recent years become common to assume the loophole can be ignored, regardless of which version of the Bell test is employed. A simple model is presented that illustrates that this may not be justified. Two of the versions -- the standard test of form -2 <= S <= 2 and the currently-popular "visibility" test -- are at grave risk of bias. Statements implying that experimental evidence "refutes local realism" or shows that the quantum world really is "weird" should be reviewed. The detection loophole is on its own unlikely to account for more than one or two test violations, but when taken in conjunction with other loopholes (briefly discussed) it is seen that the experiments refute only a narrow class of "local hidden variable" models, applicable to idealised situations, not to the real world. The full class of local realist models provides straightforward explanations not only for the publicised Bell-test violations but also for some lesser-known "anomalies".

•Oct 22, 2002•2 citations
In this paper I shall demonstrate that an analysis of the concept of "efficiency loophole" leads to the conclusion that any type of charge carried by and elementary particle must be distributed on the surface of a non-spherical object. As a result I shall show that; for example, the eletrostatic field of an electron as seen by an observer, must be in the form of quantized superluminal pulses. Therefore, "efficiency loophole" cannot be used in support of local realistic models. In view of the available experimental results we conclude that a local realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics has now been empirically refuted. However, it can be shown that the inferred superluminal signals do not necessarily contradict the facts of Lorentz transormations and only introduce a weak non-locality into the laws of nature. For this reason we make a preliminary investigation about a possible connection between quantum mechanics and non-spherical charge distributions. We conclude that this idea deserves to be further investigated and its validity or otherwise can be verified experimentally.
In this note we wish to demonstrate that the concept of efficiency loophole, as far as a local realistic model is concerned, is a self-defeating one since it implies that the static fields (for example, electric or gravitational) of and elementary particle must be in the form of quantized superluminal pulses. The Idea, however, may still be advocated by the proponents of non-local realistic models since it is shown that such superluminal pulses do not contradict the facts of Lorentz transformations. As an alternative to Bell-type experiments we propose an experiment by means of which one can directly verify the validity of otherwise of the concept of efficiency.
The field of scalar and vector potentials in electrodynamics is shown to represent an informational field capable of superluminally transmitting a signal (information) with no energy and momentum transfer. This conclusion strictly follows from Maxwell's equations for electromagnetic field interacting with electric charges and currents in vacuum, without resort to any additional hypotheses. That superluminal communication is possible is seen from the fact that the own field, generated by particles and inseparable from them, transforms the environment into a special physical medium which is capable to instantaneously transfer a signal (information) about any changes, happening to a particle in the region of its basic localization, to arbitrarily large distances. The phenomenon of superluminal communication is caused by the non-local connection of scalar and vector potentials with the electric and magnetic field strengths. The basis for the mechanism of superluminal communication considered in this work is the Aharonov-Bohm effect indicative of the field of electromagnetic potentials as a real physical field, which directly influences the behaviour of electron waves. The conclusion is made that in quantum systems superluminal signals occur constantly, in any quantum processes. The occurrence of superluminal signals is due to the space-time symmetry breaking of a special kind, consisting in that the equations for potentials do not possess relativistic invariance though Maxwell's equations for the field strengths are Lorentz-invariant. The results presented do not contradict the physical principles underlying special relativity and confirm the fundamental conclusion, made for the first time by de Broglie, that gauge invariance is not an absolute law in physics
The belief that quantum mechanics (QM) does not admit a realistic interpretation is widespread. According to some scholars concerned with the foundations of QM all existing interpretations of this theory (except for the statistical interpretation) presuppose instead a form of realism which consists in assuming that QM deals with individual objects and their properties. We uphold in the present paper that the arguments supporting the contextuality and the nonlocality of QM are a significant clue to the implicit adoption of stronger forms of realism (realism of theoretical entities and realism of theories). If these kinds of realism are substituted by a simpler and more intuitive semantic realism one can contrive a noncontextual and local interpretation of the formalism of QM (SR interpretation). Moreover one can provide a model for such an interpretation (ESR model) in which local realism and QM do not conflict and some fundamental problems of the standard interpretation of QM are avoided.
It is argued that local realism is a fundamental principle, which might be rejected only if experiments clearly show that it is untenable. Forty years after Bell's work no experiment has provided a valid, loophole-free, violation of local realism which, in my opinion, is thus reinforced. I study a simple, but wide, family of local realistic models and derive new inequalities almost insensitive to the detection loophole. I argue that quantum mechanics, with some change in the theory of measurement, might be compatible with local realism.
It has long been known that the "detection loophole", present when detector efficiencies are below a critical figure, could open the way for alternative "local realist" explanations for the violation of Bell tests. It has in recent years become common to assume the loophole can be ignored, regardless of which version of the Bell test is employed. A simple model is presented that illustrates that this may not be justified. Two of the versions -- the standard test of form -2 <= S <= 2 and the currently-popular "visibility" test -- are at grave risk of bias. Statements implying that experimental evidence "refutes local realism" or shows that the quantum world really is "weird" should be reviewed. The detection loophole is on its own unlikely to account for more than one or two test violations, but when taken in conjunction with other loopholes (briefly discussed) it is seen that the experiments refute only a narrow class of "local hidden variable" models, applicable to idealised situations, not to the real world. The full class of local realist models provides straightforward explanations not only for the publicised Bell-test violations but also for some lesser-known "anomalies".