Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:math-ph/0610023 · Reviews in Mathematical Physics

IONIZATION BY QUANTIZED ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS: THE PHOTOELECTRIC EFFECT

HERIBERT ZENK

Published May 1, 2008• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we explain the photoelectric effect in a variant of the standard model of non relativistic quantum electrodynamics, which is in some aspects more closely related to the physical picture, than the one studied in [5]. Now, we can apply our results to an electron with more than one bound state and to a larger class of electron-photon interactions. We will specify a situation, where the second order of ionization probability is a weighted sum of single photon terms. Furthermore, we will see that Einstein's equality [Formula: see text] for the maximal kinetic energy E kin of the electron, energy hν of the photon and ionization gap △E is the crucial condition, for these single photon terms to be nonzero.

DOI
10.1142/s0129055x08003316

Related papers

The Classical Electrodynamics Approach To Explain The Photoelectric Effect And The Photoelectric Emission

BingXin Gong

By re-analyzing the photoelectric effect, the limitations of Einstein’s photon hypothesis are identified and the relation between the photoelectron’s kinetic energy and the circular frequency of the incident light is reinterpreted using classical electrodynamics.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

One- and two-photon ionization

de Meijere, Jacob Louis Frederik

Detailed descriptions of one- and two-photon ionization are presented. We go beyond conventional perturbation theory to investigate the dynamics of both processes for a broad range of field intensities. The general theory of unstable decaying states is applied to the problem of one-photon ionization (the photoeffect). It is found that a non-trivial dependence of the transition dipole moment on the continuum state energy can lead to corrections to exponential decay, and even oscillations in the bound state population. As examples we consider the photoionization of hydrogen and atoms with autoionizing states. Only in the absence of autoionizing states corrections to exponential decay remain inconsequential for any experimentally relevant intensity. Our description of two-photon ionization is formulated in the Heisenberg picture. Besides the usual two-level atom projection operators we introduce explicitly the operators referring to the atomic continuum. By eliminating from the equations of motion the terms related to the electromagnetic self field as well as the terms referring to the continuum, transverse and longitudinal damping corresponding to spontaneous emission and photoionization is obtained. The use of field correlation functions allows us to account for the partial coherence of the applied field. We develop a technique to extract from the equations of motion a unique two-photon ionization rate. Such a characterization of the ionization process is not only instructive because of its simplicity, it is also in many cases completely satisfactory. The resulting general expression for the two-photon ionization rate is the central result of our treatment. From it we recover several familiar results in different limiting cases. In addition, our general rate expression provides the first description of the complete hierarchy of saturation effects that one should expect. We present a number of examples where we calculate the two-photon ionization rate as a function of the detuning, and where we emphasize the saturation and field correlation effects.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

The classical electrodynamics approach to explain the photoelectric effect and the photoelectric emission

BingXin Gong

By re-analyzing the photoelectric effect, the limitations of Einstein's photon hypothesis are identified and the relation between the photoelectron's kinetic energy and the circular frequency of the incident light is reinterpreted using classical electrodynamics. And it is realized that photoelectric emission is dependent on the incident light's circular frequency ω and the photon density of the incident light.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jan 31, 2006•0 citations

On the Correct Formulation of the Law of the External Photoelectric Effect

Temur Z. Kalanov

The critical and correct scientific analysis of the generally accepted theory of the external photoelectric effect is proposed. The methodological basis for the analysis is the unity of formal logic and of rational dialectics. It is shown that Einstein’s formulation of the law of the photoelectric effect is not free from the following objection. The terms of Einstein’s formula characterize the quantitative determinacy (i.e., energy) which belongs and is related to the different material objects: “photon”, “electron in metal”, and “electron not in metal”. This signifies that Einstein’s formula represents violation of the formal-logical laws of identity and absence (lack) of contradiction. The correct mathematical formulation of the law of the external photoelectric effect within the framework of the system approach is proposed. The correct formulation represents the proportion by relative increments of the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron. The proportion describes the linear relationship between the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Sep 14, 2016•10 citations

Basic Photon and Quantum Optics

Sofia E. Acosta-Ortiz

In 1905, Albert Einstein showed that the photoelectric effect could be explained by the hypothesis that the energy of a light beam was distributed in discrete bundles, later known as photons. Photon-counting experiments provide a fairly direct measurement of the photon probability distribution for all kinds of light embraced by the quantum theory. The field of quantum optics occupies a central position involving the interaction of atoms with the electromagnetic field. Young's experiment is one example of a phenomenon that can be explained by both classical and quantum theory. In Young's experiment, each photon must be capable of interfering with itself in such a way that its probability of striking the second screen at a particular point is proportional to the calculated intensity at that point. Multiphoton transitions are found whenever electrons bound in atoms or molecules interact with sufficiently intense electromagnetic radiation.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 22, 2017•0 citations

Comments on Einstein’s Explanation of Electrons, Photons, and the Photo-Electric Effect

Salama Abdelhady

According to an entropy approach and by reviewing the similarity between laws characterizing the flow of heat and electric charges, electric charges were defined as electromagnetic waves that possess an electrical potential or simply as ionized photons. Accordingly, the flow of electrons was defined as a simultaneous flow of particulate energy and wave energy. Such definitions led to clear the confusions of duality properties of electrons and light waves, conflicts in the SI system of units and to explain the difference between the calculated drift speed of electrons and the speed of electricity or charges in conductors. However, Einstein considered the electron to be a negative charge of unknown nature during his analysis of the photoelectric effect. Einstein presented his hypothesis that light may behave as a particle to find a plausible explanation of the photoelectric effect. He found the measured cutoff frequency of light below which light might not eject electrons from metal-surfaces in photocells regardless of how much light is shone on the surface as a proof of truth of his hypothesis. Such frequency may be explained also, according to the previously introduced definitions, as the minimum energy quanta that may gain a quantized potential in photocells. This explanation may find plausible explanations of the found measurements of the photoelectric effects for different metal surfaces, stopping voltages into photocells and the photoelectric effect of X-rays. Einstein’s hypothesis of the photoelectric effect failed to find plausible explanations of such measurement results. According to the principles of conservation of momentum, there is a minimum quantity of photons that may lead to bouncing an atomic electron out of its orbit. So, considering Einstein’s theory as a perfect hypothesis that explains the photoelectric effect may be a misconception.

Applied Physics Research•Oct 30, 2011•13 citations
In this paper, we explain the photoelectric effect in a variant of the standard model of non relativistic quantum electrodynamics, which is in some aspects more closely related to the physical picture, than the one studied in [5]. Now, we can apply our results to an electron with more than one bound state and to a larger class of electron-photon interactions. We will specify a situation, where the second order of ionization probability is a weighted sum of single photon terms. Furthermore, we will see that Einstein's equality [Formula: see text] for the maximal kinetic energy E kin of the electron, energy hν of the photon and ionization gap △E is the crucial condition, for these single photon terms to be nonzero.
Detailed descriptions of one- and two-photon ionization are presented. We go beyond conventional perturbation theory to investigate the dynamics of both processes for a broad range of field intensities. The general theory of unstable decaying states is applied to the problem of one-photon ionization (the photoeffect). It is found that a non-trivial dependence of the transition dipole moment on the continuum state energy can lead to corrections to exponential decay, and even oscillations in the bound state population. As examples we consider the photoionization of hydrogen and atoms with autoionizing states. Only in the absence of autoionizing states corrections to exponential decay remain inconsequential for any experimentally relevant intensity. Our description of two-photon ionization is formulated in the Heisenberg picture. Besides the usual two-level atom projection operators we introduce explicitly the operators referring to the atomic continuum. By eliminating from the equations of motion the terms related to the electromagnetic self field as well as the terms referring to the continuum, transverse and longitudinal damping corresponding to spontaneous emission and photoionization is obtained. The use of field correlation functions allows us to account for the partial coherence of the applied field. We develop a technique to extract from the equations of motion a unique two-photon ionization rate. Such a characterization of the ionization process is not only instructive because of its simplicity, it is also in many cases completely satisfactory. The resulting general expression for the two-photon ionization rate is the central result of our treatment. From it we recover several familiar results in different limiting cases. In addition, our general rate expression provides the first description of the complete hierarchy of saturation effects that one should expect. We present a number of examples where we calculate the two-photon ionization rate as a function of the detuning, and where we emphasize the saturation and field correlation effects.
The critical and correct scientific analysis of the generally accepted theory of the external photoelectric effect is proposed. The methodological basis for the analysis is the unity of formal logic and of rational dialectics. It is shown that Einstein’s formulation of the law of the photoelectric effect is not free from the following objection. The terms of Einstein’s formula characterize the quantitative determinacy (i.e., energy) which belongs and is related to the different material objects: “photon”, “electron in metal”, and “electron not in metal”. This signifies that Einstein’s formula represents violation of the formal-logical laws of identity and absence (lack) of contradiction. The correct mathematical formulation of the law of the external photoelectric effect within the framework of the system approach is proposed. The correct formulation represents the proportion by relative increments of the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron. The proportion describes the linear relationship between the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron.
In 1905, Albert Einstein showed that the photoelectric effect could be explained by the hypothesis that the energy of a light beam was distributed in discrete bundles, later known as photons. Photon-counting experiments provide a fairly direct measurement of the photon probability distribution for all kinds of light embraced by the quantum theory. The field of quantum optics occupies a central position involving the interaction of atoms with the electromagnetic field. Young's experiment is one example of a phenomenon that can be explained by both classical and quantum theory. In Young's experiment, each photon must be capable of interfering with itself in such a way that its probability of striking the second screen at a particular point is proportional to the calculated intensity at that point. Multiphoton transitions are found whenever electrons bound in atoms or molecules interact with sufficiently intense electromagnetic radiation.
According to an entropy approach and by reviewing the similarity between laws characterizing the flow of heat and electric charges, electric charges were defined as electromagnetic waves that possess an electrical potential or simply as ionized photons. Accordingly, the flow of electrons was defined as a simultaneous flow of particulate energy and wave energy. Such definitions led to clear the confusions of duality properties of electrons and light waves, conflicts in the SI system of units and to explain the difference between the calculated drift speed of electrons and the speed of electricity or charges in conductors. However, Einstein considered the electron to be a negative charge of unknown nature during his analysis of the photoelectric effect. Einstein presented his hypothesis that light may behave as a particle to find a plausible explanation of the photoelectric effect. He found the measured cutoff frequency of light below which light might not eject electrons from metal-surfaces in photocells regardless of how much light is shone on the surface as a proof of truth of his hypothesis. Such frequency may be explained also, according to the previously introduced definitions, as the minimum energy quanta that may gain a quantized potential in photocells. This explanation may find plausible explanations of the found measurements of the photoelectric effects for different metal surfaces, stopping voltages into photocells and the photoelectric effect of X-rays. Einstein’s hypothesis of the photoelectric effect failed to find plausible explanations of such measurement results. According to the principles of conservation of momentum, there is a minimum quantity of photons that may lead to bouncing an atomic electron out of its orbit. So, considering Einstein’s theory as a perfect hypothesis that explains the photoelectric effect may be a misconception.